{"schemaVersion":"2026-08-28.107","dataset":"claims","description":"Entry-scoped reviewed ancestry claims and their canonical-edge mappings.","totalRows":1152,"license":null,"licenseNote":"Reuse terms for SET-U editorial data are not yet declared. Source works retain their own rights.","data":[{"cursor":1,"id":1,"entryId":1,"entrySlug":"love","childFormId":1,"parentFormId":2,"canonicalEdgeId":1,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Spelling stabilized around love while the short stressed vowel continued into modern English.","semanticChange":"Inherited noun and verb expanded into preference, devotion, and address.","scholar":"OED · Merriam-Webster","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":2,"id":2,"entryId":1,"entrySlug":"love","childFormId":2,"parentFormId":3,"canonicalEdgeId":2,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Final unstressed -u was lost; Old English intervocalic ⟨f⟩ had a voiced realization [v].","semanticChange":"Religious, familial, erotic, and social senses continued.","scholar":"Middle English Dictionary editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":3,"id":3,"entryId":1,"entrySlug":"love","childFormId":3,"parentFormId":4,"canonicalEdgeId":3,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"West Germanic medial /b/ developed a fricative realization represented by Old English ⟨f⟩.","semanticChange":"The affective core remained stable.","scholar":"Kroonen · comparative Germanic evidence","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Exact intermediate phonetic detail depends on reconstruction.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":4,"id":4,"entryId":1,"entrySlug":"love","childFormId":4,"parentFormId":5,"canonicalEdgeId":4,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"A regular West Germanic continuation with final-vowel and inflectional reshaping.","semanticChange":"The central sense remained stable.","scholar":"Kroonen 2013","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":5,"id":5,"entryId":1,"entrySlug":"love","childFormId":5,"parentFormId":6,"canonicalEdgeId":5,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Germanic reflects the inherited root with regular treatment of PIE *bʰ and a different vowel grade.","semanticChange":"Desire, approval, care, and affection overlap across daughter languages.","scholar":"Pokorny · Mallory & Adams","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The breadth of the reconstructed gloss is debated.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":6,"id":6,"entryId":1,"entrySlug":"love","childFormId":6,"parentFormId":7,"canonicalEdgeId":6,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The comparative method has reached its evidentiary horizon.","semanticChange":"Anything deeper would exceed the securely recoverable record.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":7,"id":7,"entryId":2,"entrySlug":"etymology","childFormId":8,"parentFormId":9,"canonicalEdgeId":7,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English adapted the learned French form and later aligned spelling with the classical model.","semanticChange":"The technical term broadened into the modern historical discipline.","scholar":"OED · historical lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":8,"id":8,"entryId":2,"entrySlug":"etymology","childFormId":9,"parentFormId":10,"canonicalEdgeId":8,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French transmitted the learned Latin form.","semanticChange":"Scholarly explanation of a word’s origin continued.","scholar":"French historical lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":9,"id":9,"entryId":2,"entrySlug":"etymology","childFormId":10,"parentFormId":11,"canonicalEdgeId":9,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin borrowed Greek ἐτυμολογία.","semanticChange":"A Greek technical concept entered Latin grammatical tradition.","scholar":"Latin and Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":10,"id":10,"entryId":2,"entrySlug":"etymology","childFormId":11,"parentFormId":12,"canonicalEdgeId":10,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The compound joins ἔτυμος “true, real” and -λογία “account, study.”","semanticChange":"A word’s “true sense” becomes an object of analysis.","scholar":"Ancient Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":11,"id":11,"entryId":2,"entrySlug":"etymology","childFormId":12,"parentFormId":13,"canonicalEdgeId":11,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The attested Greek adjective is analyzed through an earlier *setu-mo- formation; initial *s is lost in the proposed path.","semanticChange":"Truth, actuality, and proper order form the reconstructed semantic field.","scholar":"Beekes 2010 · Pinault · de Lamberterie","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The exact morphology and wider family have competing analyses.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":12,"id":12,"entryId":2,"entrySlug":"etymology","childFormId":13,"parentFormId":14,"canonicalEdgeId":12,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form commands secure consensus.","semanticChange":"The brand preserves this uncertainty instead of erasing it.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":13,"id":13,"entryId":3,"entrySlug":"salary","childFormId":15,"parentFormId":16,"canonicalEdgeId":13,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French stress and vowels were adapted into English.","semanticChange":"The word narrowed toward fixed regular compensation.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":14,"id":14,"entryId":3,"entrySlug":"salary","childFormId":16,"parentFormId":17,"canonicalEdgeId":14,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"A regular Romance continuation of Latin salārium.","semanticChange":"Official payment became general compensation.","scholar":"Romance historical lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":15,"id":15,"entryId":3,"entrySlug":"salary","childFormId":17,"parentFormId":18,"canonicalEdgeId":15,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"salārium is morphologically related to salārius “pertaining to salt,” from sāl.","semanticChange":"The precise bridge from salt to official compensation is not preserved.","scholar":"Latin lexicography · Pliny","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Morphology is secure; the historical motivation is not.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":16,"id":16,"entryId":3,"entrySlug":"salary","childFormId":18,"parentFormId":19,"canonicalEdgeId":16,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin sāl continues the inherited salt word through Italic development.","semanticChange":"Material salt; no wage sense is reconstructed at this stage.","scholar":"Mallory & Adams","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":17,"id":17,"entryId":3,"entrySlug":"salary","childFormId":19,"parentFormId":20,"canonicalEdgeId":17,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The trail ends beyond the reconstructable salt root.","semanticChange":"The salt-to-pay semantic bridge also remains partly unknown.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":18,"id":18,"entryId":4,"entrySlug":"sincere","childFormId":21,"parentFormId":22,"canonicalEdgeId":18,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English borrowed the learned French adjective with later vowel development.","semanticChange":"Material purity shifted toward honesty of feeling and expression.","scholar":"OED editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":19,"id":19,"entryId":4,"entrySlug":"sincere","childFormId":22,"parentFormId":23,"canonicalEdgeId":19,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French borrowed Latin sincerus.","semanticChange":"Physical intactness and moral genuineness continued together.","scholar":"French and Latin historical lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":20,"id":20,"entryId":4,"entrySlug":"sincere","childFormId":23,"parentFormId":24,"canonicalEdgeId":20,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"sine cera cannot regularly yield sincerus and lacks documentary support.","semanticChange":"“Without wax” is a later folk story, not an ancestor.","scholar":"OED · Ernout & Meillet","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Alternative Latin analyses remain proposed, not settled.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":21,"id":21,"entryId":5,"entrySlug":"clue","childFormId":25,"parentFormId":26,"canonicalEdgeId":21,"relationType":"semantic_specialization","soundChange":"The spelling clue became standard for the figurative sense while clew remained literal.","semanticChange":"A guiding thread became a fact that guides reasoning.","scholar":"OED editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":22,"id":22,"entryId":5,"entrySlug":"clue","childFormId":26,"parentFormId":27,"canonicalEdgeId":22,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English vowel sequence and inflection simplified in Middle English.","semanticChange":"A concrete ball or wound thread was retained.","scholar":"Bosworth–Toller · historical lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":23,"id":23,"entryId":5,"entrySlug":"clue","childFormId":27,"parentFormId":28,"canonicalEdgeId":23,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"Competing remote Germanic reconstructions are withheld.","semanticChange":"The site stops before false certainty begins.","scholar":"Editorial evidence boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":24,"id":24,"entryId":6,"entrySlug":"disaster","childFormId":29,"parentFormId":30,"canonicalEdgeId":24,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English adapted the French form, including stress and final syllable.","semanticChange":"The inherited calamity sense became the general modern category of disaster.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"English first known use: 1567.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":25,"id":25,"entryId":6,"entrySlug":"disaster","childFormId":30,"parentFormId":31,"canonicalEdgeId":25,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French désastre and Italian disastro belong to the same Romance formation and transmission history.","semanticChange":"Astrologically unfavorable influence generalized to severe misfortune.","scholar":"Romance historical lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The exact immediate donor sequence is represented cautiously.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":26,"id":26,"entryId":6,"entrySlug":"disaster","childFormId":31,"parentFormId":32,"canonicalEdgeId":26,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Italian disastro combines the negative prefix dis- with astro “star.”","semanticChange":"An unfavorable star or astral influence became calamity.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":27,"id":27,"entryId":6,"entrySlug":"disaster","childFormId":32,"parentFormId":33,"canonicalEdgeId":27,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Italian astro continues Latin astrum through regular Romance development.","semanticChange":"The celestial-body meaning remains stable.","scholar":"Latin and Romance lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":28,"id":28,"entryId":6,"entrySlug":"disaster","childFormId":33,"parentFormId":34,"canonicalEdgeId":28,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin astrum belongs to the inherited Indo-European star family; details of formation and Greek contact require care.","semanticChange":"The referent remains a star or celestial body.","scholar":"Comparative Indo-European lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The graph does not collapse every ancient star-form into one undifferentiated route.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":29,"id":29,"entryId":6,"entrySlug":"disaster","childFormId":34,"parentFormId":35,"canonicalEdgeId":29,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"Comparative reconstruction reaches its stated horizon.","semanticChange":"Anything deeper would exceed the reviewed evidence.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":30,"id":30,"entryId":7,"entrySlug":"candidate","childFormId":36,"parentFormId":37,"canonicalEdgeId":30,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English borrowed the learned Latin office term with regular adaptation of ending and stress.","semanticChange":"An office-seeker remained an office-seeker, later broadening to any person under selection.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · CNRTL editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"English evidence begins around 1600.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":31,"id":31,"entryId":7,"entrySlug":"candidate","childFormId":37,"parentFormId":38,"canonicalEdgeId":31,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin candidātus is built from candidus and identifies the person clothed in shining white.","semanticChange":"The white-clad Roman office-seeker became the lexical category for a person seeking office.","scholar":"Corpus of Latin Dictionaries editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":32,"id":32,"entryId":7,"entrySlug":"candidate","childFormId":38,"parentFormId":39,"canonicalEdgeId":32,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"candidus belongs to the candēre family of shining and whiteness.","semanticChange":"Physical brightness and whiteness extended to clarity and unblemished quality.","scholar":"Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":33,"id":33,"entryId":7,"entrySlug":"candidate","childFormId":39,"parentFormId":40,"canonicalEdgeId":33,"relationType":"proposed_inheritance","soundChange":"The Latin shining family has been compared with a reconstructed *kand- root.","semanticChange":"Shining and glowing remain the proposed semantic core.","scholar":"Indo-European etymological tradition","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Published analyses differ on the deeper formation and cognate set.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":34,"id":34,"entryId":7,"entrySlug":"candidate","childFormId":40,"parentFormId":41,"canonicalEdgeId":34,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond proposal status.","semanticChange":"The trail stops where comparative agreement stops.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":35,"id":35,"entryId":8,"entrySlug":"quarantine","childFormId":42,"parentFormId":43,"canonicalEdgeId":35,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English quarantine reflects a French and Italian Romance transmission with adapted spelling and stress.","semanticChange":"A defined period of isolation became the general act or state of protective isolation.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"References weight French and Italian stages differently.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":36,"id":36,"entryId":8,"entrySlug":"quarantine","childFormId":43,"parentFormId":44,"canonicalEdgeId":36,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French quarantaine and Italian quarantena are parallel Romance formations around forty.","semanticChange":"A group or period of forty specialized as a disease-control interval.","scholar":"French and Italian historical lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The health sense developed within Mediterranean practice, not in a single clean handoff.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":37,"id":37,"entryId":8,"entrySlug":"quarantine","childFormId":44,"parentFormId":45,"canonicalEdgeId":37,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"quarantena is transparently built on the Italian numeral quaranta.","semanticChange":"Forty becomes a conventional duration, then names the isolation itself.","scholar":"CDC · Oxford historical accounts","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The forty-day practice followed an earlier thirty-day regime.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":38,"id":38,"entryId":8,"entrySlug":"quarantine","childFormId":45,"parentFormId":46,"canonicalEdgeId":38,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Italian quaranta regularly continues Latin quadrāgintā.","semanticChange":"The numeral meaning remains forty.","scholar":"Romance and Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":39,"id":39,"entryId":8,"entrySlug":"quarantine","childFormId":46,"parentFormId":47,"canonicalEdgeId":39,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin quadrāgintā is the inherited decimal formation based on four.","semanticChange":"Four is multiplied into the decade numeral forty.","scholar":"Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":40,"id":40,"entryId":8,"entrySlug":"quarantine","childFormId":47,"parentFormId":48,"canonicalEdgeId":40,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin quattuor continues the Proto-Indo-European four numeral through Italic sound change.","semanticChange":"The numeral meaning remains four.","scholar":"Comparative Indo-European lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":41,"id":41,"entryId":8,"entrySlug":"quarantine","childFormId":48,"parentFormId":49,"canonicalEdgeId":41,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The reviewed numeral lineage reaches its stated reconstruction boundary.","semanticChange":"Anything deeper is outside the present secure graph.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":42,"id":42,"entryId":9,"entrySlug":"logic","childFormId":50,"parentFormId":51,"canonicalEdgeId":42,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English final consonant and vowel pattern stabilized as modern logic with later pronunciation change.","semanticChange":"The technical discipline broadened into everyday “reasoning” and, later, computational circuitry.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":43,"id":43,"entryId":9,"entrySlug":"logic","childFormId":51,"parentFormId":52,"canonicalEdgeId":43,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English adapted the Anglo-French form and spelling.","semanticChange":"The scholastic discipline retained its core reference.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":44,"id":44,"entryId":9,"entrySlug":"logic","childFormId":52,"parentFormId":53,"canonicalEdgeId":44,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French transmitted the learned Latin form with Romance phonology.","semanticChange":"The name of the rational art remained technical.","scholar":"French and Latin historical lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":45,"id":45,"entryId":9,"entrySlug":"logic","childFormId":53,"parentFormId":54,"canonicalEdgeId":45,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin logica borrowed and adapted Greek λογική.","semanticChange":"The Greek “logical art” became the Latin discipline.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":46,"id":46,"entryId":9,"entrySlug":"logic","childFormId":54,"parentFormId":55,"canonicalEdgeId":46,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Greek λογική is the substantivized feminine of λογικός, conventionally with an understood noun such as τέχνη.","semanticChange":"“Pertaining to reasoning” becomes the name of the art itself.","scholar":"Ancient Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":47,"id":47,"entryId":9,"entrySlug":"logic","childFormId":55,"parentFormId":56,"canonicalEdgeId":47,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"λογικός is formed on λόγος with the adjectival suffix -ικός.","semanticChange":"The broad λόγος family narrows to what pertains to account, reason, or discourse.","scholar":"Ancient Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":48,"id":48,"entryId":9,"entrySlug":"logic","childFormId":56,"parentFormId":57,"canonicalEdgeId":48,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"λόγος is a verbal noun in the λέγω family, with an o-grade formation represented in traditional analysis.","semanticChange":"Gathering, counting, recounting, speech, account, and reason form a historically layered semantic network.","scholar":"Logeion · comparative Greek lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The semantic sequence should not be reduced to a single just-so story.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":49,"id":49,"entryId":9,"entrySlug":"logic","childFormId":57,"parentFormId":58,"canonicalEdgeId":49,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Greek λέγω is traditionally derived from PIE *leǵ-; some scholarship argues that an initial *s should be reconstructed.","semanticChange":"The daughter evidence spans collecting and speaking, but the exact semantic path remains reconstructed.","scholar":"UT Austin LRC · IE-CoR · Kaczyńska","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The competing *sleǵ- analysis prevents an unqualified grade.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":50,"id":50,"entryId":9,"entrySlug":"logic","childFormId":58,"parentFormId":59,"canonicalEdgeId":50,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops rather than laundering a contested root into certainty.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":51,"id":51,"entryId":10,"entrySlug":"legal","childFormId":60,"parentFormId":61,"canonicalEdgeId":52,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English preserved the learned form with later English vowel and stress development.","semanticChange":"The adjective broadened from juridical status to rule-conformity more generally.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known English use: 15th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":52,"id":52,"entryId":10,"entrySlug":"legal","childFormId":61,"parentFormId":62,"canonicalEdgeId":53,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French borrowed Latin lēgālis through regular Romance adaptation.","semanticChange":"Pertaining to law remained the core sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":53,"id":53,"entryId":10,"entrySlug":"legal","childFormId":62,"parentFormId":63,"canonicalEdgeId":54,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin lēgālis is formed on lēx, leg- “law.”","semanticChange":"The law noun becomes a relational adjective.","scholar":"Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":54,"id":54,"entryId":10,"entrySlug":"legal","childFormId":63,"parentFormId":64,"canonicalEdgeId":55,"relationType":"proposed_inheritance","soundChange":"Latin lēx has traditionally been connected with the gather / collect family; published work argues for a root with initial *s.","semanticChange":"A collection or selection of rules is a proposed semantic bridge, not an uncontested fact.","scholar":"Kaczyńska · Indo-European lexicography","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Both the root shape and exact semantic derivation remain disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":55,"id":55,"entryId":10,"entrySlug":"legal","childFormId":64,"parentFormId":65,"canonicalEdgeId":56,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the live reconstruction dispute.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":56,"id":56,"entryId":11,"entrySlug":"lecture","childFormId":66,"parentFormId":67,"canonicalEdgeId":57,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English adapted Late Latin lectūra through the medieval learned tradition.","semanticChange":"An act of reading became an instructional discourse and later a scolding.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known English use: 15th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":57,"id":57,"entryId":11,"entrySlug":"lecture","childFormId":67,"parentFormId":68,"canonicalEdgeId":58,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"lectūra is a deverbal noun built from the participial stem lēct-.","semanticChange":"Reading is nominalized as an act or practice.","scholar":"Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":58,"id":58,"entryId":11,"entrySlug":"lecture","childFormId":68,"parentFormId":69,"canonicalEdgeId":59,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"lēctus is the suppletive-looking past participle used with legere.","semanticChange":"What has been gathered or selected becomes what has been read.","scholar":"Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":59,"id":59,"entryId":11,"entrySlug":"lecture","childFormId":69,"parentFormId":70,"canonicalEdgeId":60,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin legere is traditionally assigned to the *leǵ- family; *sleǵ- remains a published alternative.","semanticChange":"Gathering and selecting extend into reading.","scholar":"Indo-European lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Root shape is disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":60,"id":60,"entryId":11,"entrySlug":"lecture","childFormId":70,"parentFormId":71,"canonicalEdgeId":61,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the live reconstruction dispute.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":61,"id":61,"entryId":12,"entrySlug":"legend","childFormId":72,"parentFormId":73,"canonicalEdgeId":62,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Final unstressed -e was lost and spelling stabilized as legend.","semanticChange":"Saintly reading matter expanded to inherited story, inscription, and explanatory key.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known use for the inscription sense: c. 1500.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":62,"id":62,"entryId":12,"entrySlug":"legend","childFormId":73,"parentFormId":74,"canonicalEdgeId":63,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English adapted the Anglo-French form.","semanticChange":"The reading and saint’s-life senses continued.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":63,"id":63,"entryId":12,"entrySlug":"legend","childFormId":74,"parentFormId":75,"canonicalEdgeId":64,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French transmitted Medieval Latin legenda.","semanticChange":"Materials appointed for reading became a category of devotional narrative.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":64,"id":64,"entryId":12,"entrySlug":"legend","childFormId":75,"parentFormId":76,"canonicalEdgeId":65,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"legenda is the feminine singular or neuter plural gerundive formation represented in medieval use.","semanticChange":"“Things to be read” becomes a lexical category.","scholar":"Latin and medieval lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":65,"id":65,"entryId":12,"entrySlug":"legend","childFormId":76,"parentFormId":77,"canonicalEdgeId":66,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"legendus is the gerundive of legere.","semanticChange":"Obligation or appointment to read supplies the literal formation.","scholar":"Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":66,"id":66,"entryId":12,"entrySlug":"legend","childFormId":77,"parentFormId":78,"canonicalEdgeId":60,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin legere is traditionally assigned to the *leǵ- family; *sleǵ- remains a published alternative.","semanticChange":"Gathering and selecting extend into reading.","scholar":"Indo-European lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Root shape is disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":67,"id":67,"entryId":12,"entrySlug":"legend","childFormId":78,"parentFormId":79,"canonicalEdgeId":68,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the live reconstruction dispute.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":68,"id":68,"entryId":13,"entrySlug":"intelligence","childFormId":80,"parentFormId":81,"canonicalEdgeId":69,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English borrowed the French abstract noun with later pronunciation change.","semanticChange":"Understanding expands into news, strategic information, and the organizations that obtain it.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known English use: 14th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":69,"id":69,"entryId":13,"entrySlug":"intelligence","childFormId":81,"parentFormId":82,"canonicalEdgeId":70,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French transmitted Latin intelligentia.","semanticChange":"Understanding and discernment remain central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":70,"id":70,"entryId":13,"entrySlug":"intelligence","childFormId":82,"parentFormId":83,"canonicalEdgeId":71,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The abstract noun intelligentia is formed on the participial stem intelligent-.","semanticChange":"A discerning or understanding quality becomes an abstract capacity.","scholar":"Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":71,"id":71,"entryId":13,"entrySlug":"intelligence","childFormId":83,"parentFormId":84,"canonicalEdgeId":72,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"intelligēns is the present participial formation of intellegere / intelligere.","semanticChange":"The one understanding supplies the adjective and abstract noun family.","scholar":"Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":72,"id":72,"entryId":13,"entrySlug":"intelligence","childFormId":84,"parentFormId":85,"canonicalEdgeId":73,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin intellegere is traditionally analyzed as inter- plus legere, with phonological assimilation.","semanticChange":"Selecting or discerning among becomes understanding; the exact semantic bridge should not be over-literalized.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Latin lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The morphology is strong; a slogan such as “choose between” is not a full semantic history.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":73,"id":73,"entryId":13,"entrySlug":"intelligence","childFormId":85,"parentFormId":86,"canonicalEdgeId":60,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin legere is traditionally assigned to the *leǵ- family; *sleǵ- remains a published alternative.","semanticChange":"Gathering and selecting extend into reading.","scholar":"Indo-European lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Root shape is disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":74,"id":74,"entryId":13,"entrySlug":"intelligence","childFormId":86,"parentFormId":87,"canonicalEdgeId":75,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the live reconstruction dispute.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":75,"id":75,"entryId":14,"entrySlug":"collect","childFormId":88,"parentFormId":89,"canonicalEdgeId":76,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English inflection was lost and the learned spelling stabilized.","semanticChange":"Accumulating and inferring broadened into the modern family of gathering, receiving, and regaining control.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The prayer noun has an earlier English record than the verb.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":76,"id":76,"entryId":14,"entrySlug":"collect","childFormId":89,"parentFormId":90,"canonicalEdgeId":77,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English borrowed the Anglo-French verb.","semanticChange":"Accumulating, inferring, and calculating are recorded early senses.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":77,"id":77,"entryId":14,"entrySlug":"collect","childFormId":90,"parentFormId":91,"canonicalEdgeId":78,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French transmitted the Latin participial stem.","semanticChange":"The gathered-together sense remains transparent.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":78,"id":78,"entryId":14,"entrySlug":"collect","childFormId":91,"parentFormId":92,"canonicalEdgeId":79,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"collēctus is the past participle of colligere.","semanticChange":"A completed gathering becomes the collected state.","scholar":"Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":79,"id":79,"entryId":14,"entrySlug":"collect","childFormId":92,"parentFormId":93,"canonicalEdgeId":80,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"colligere combines the assimilated com- / col- “together” prefix with legere.","semanticChange":"Gathering becomes explicitly gathering together.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":80,"id":80,"entryId":14,"entrySlug":"collect","childFormId":93,"parentFormId":94,"canonicalEdgeId":60,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin legere is traditionally assigned to the *leǵ- family; *sleǵ- remains a published alternative.","semanticChange":"Gathering and selecting extend into reading.","scholar":"Indo-European lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Root shape is disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":81,"id":81,"entryId":14,"entrySlug":"collect","childFormId":94,"parentFormId":95,"canonicalEdgeId":82,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the live reconstruction dispute.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":82,"id":82,"entryId":15,"entrySlug":"algorithm","childFormId":96,"parentFormId":97,"canonicalEdgeId":83,"relationType":"alteration","soundChange":"The older ending -ism was reshaped to -ithm, commonly explained through association with Greek arithmos “number.”","semanticChange":"Arithmetic or numeral procedure narrowed and generalized into a finite stepwise procedure.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · MacTutor editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The descent from algorism is secure; the exact force of Greek influence is reported rather than independently demonstrated here.","chronologyNote":"The spelling is reported in 1699; Merriam-Webster dates its currently defined technical sense to 1926.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":83,"id":83,"entryId":15,"entrySlug":"algorithm","childFormId":97,"parentFormId":98,"canonicalEdgeId":84,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English and French forms adapted Medieval Latin algorismus with variable vowels and endings.","semanticChange":"The art of reckoning with Hindu-Arabic numerals remained central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Algorism is recorded in English in the 14th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":84,"id":84,"entryId":15,"entrySlug":"algorithm","childFormId":98,"parentFormId":99,"canonicalEdgeId":85,"relationType":"eponymic_borrowing","soundChange":"The Arabic name al-Khwārizmī was heavily Latinized as Algoritmi / algorismus; the initial article was absorbed into the form.","semanticChange":"A scholar's geographic name came to denote the arithmetic associated with transmitted texts.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · MacTutor editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Latin arithmetic texts circulated from the 12th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":85,"id":85,"entryId":15,"entrySlug":"algorithm","childFormId":99,"parentFormId":100,"canonicalEdgeId":86,"relationType":"nisba_derivation","soundChange":"Arabic al- plus Khwārizm plus the relational suffix -ī forms “the Khwārizmian.”","semanticChange":"A place of origin becomes a personal identifier.","scholar":"Arabic onomastic analysis · Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Name attested for the 9th-century scholar.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":86,"id":86,"entryId":15,"entrySlug":"algorithm","childFormId":100,"parentFormId":101,"canonicalEdgeId":87,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper analysis of the toponym is promoted without dedicated Iranian and Central Asian onomastic review.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the geographic name rather than inventing a lexical root.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":87,"id":87,"entryId":16,"entrySlug":"algebra","childFormId":102,"parentFormId":103,"canonicalEdgeId":88,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English borrowed the learned form through Medieval Latin and Romance channels, with stress and vowel adaptation.","semanticChange":"A named mathematical art developed into the broad modern discipline.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Oxford editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known English mathematical use: 1551.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":88,"id":88,"entryId":16,"entrySlug":"algebra","childFormId":103,"parentFormId":104,"canonicalEdgeId":89,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Arabic al-jabr was adapted into Medieval Latin algebra, retaining the article as part of the word.","semanticChange":"An operation of restoring a subtracted term—and a title phrase—came to name the mathematical discipline; a bone-setting sense also circulated.","scholar":"Oxford · MacTutor editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Latin translations circulated from the 12th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":89,"id":89,"entryId":16,"entrySlug":"algebra","childFormId":104,"parentFormId":105,"canonicalEdgeId":90,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The Arabic verbal noun jabr is derived from jabara; the definite article al- is prefixed.","semanticChange":"Restoring, reuniting, or mending is specialized as a mathematical operation.","scholar":"Oxford University Press editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The term appears in al-Khwārizmī's 9th-century title.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":90,"id":90,"entryId":16,"entrySlug":"algebra","childFormId":105,"parentFormId":106,"canonicalEdgeId":91,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"This dossier does not promote a deeper Semitic reconstruction without a reviewed specialist source.","semanticChange":"The attested Arabic verb is the current evidentiary horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":91,"id":91,"entryId":17,"entrySlug":"calculate","childFormId":107,"parentFormId":108,"canonicalEdgeId":92,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English borrowed the learned participial stem with regular English stress and suffix treatment.","semanticChange":"Counting and reckoning broadened into estimation, intention, and deliberate planning.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known English use: 1542.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":92,"id":92,"entryId":17,"entrySlug":"calculate","childFormId":108,"parentFormId":109,"canonicalEdgeId":93,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"Calculātus is the past participle of calculāre.","semanticChange":"The completed act of reckoning supplies the borrowed form.","scholar":"Latin morphology · Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":93,"id":93,"entryId":17,"entrySlug":"calculate","childFormId":109,"parentFormId":110,"canonicalEdgeId":94,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Calculāre is derived from calculus.","semanticChange":"Manipulating counting pebbles becomes the general act of computation.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":94,"id":94,"entryId":17,"entrySlug":"calculate","childFormId":110,"parentFormId":111,"canonicalEdgeId":95,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"Calculus has traditionally been treated as an irregular diminutive of calx, but the phonology and meanings are problematic and a shared non-Indo-European source with a Greek stone-word has been proposed.","semanticChange":"A small stone or pebble may connect to lime or limestone; the route is unsettled.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors summarizing Festus and Beekes","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The calculus-to-calx derivation is not secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":95,"id":95,"entryId":17,"entrySlug":"calculate","childFormId":111,"parentFormId":112,"canonicalEdgeId":96,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The traditional limestone route and substrate alternatives do not yield a single secure deeper chain.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the live etymological dispute.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":96,"id":96,"entryId":18,"entrySlug":"robot","childFormId":113,"parentFormId":114,"canonicalEdgeId":97,"relationType":"creative_coinage","soundChange":"Josef Čapek suggested robot from Czech robota; English received the coined form through Karel Čapek's R.U.R. and its translation.","semanticChange":"Compulsory human labor was reassigned to artificial workers, then generalized to automatic machines.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"R.U.R. appeared in 1920; English first known use is 1922.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":97,"id":97,"entryId":18,"entrySlug":"robot","childFormId":114,"parentFormId":115,"canonicalEdgeId":98,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Czech robota continues the reconstructed Slavic form with loss of the initial vowel and regular West Slavic development.","semanticChange":"Obligatory work and drudgery preserve the inherited labor field.","scholar":"Slavic etymological lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Slavic form is reconstructed from multiple Slavic languages.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":98,"id":98,"entryId":18,"entrySlug":"robot","childFormId":115,"parentFormId":116,"canonicalEdgeId":99,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Proto-Slavic *orbota is analyzed within the *orb- family with an abstract noun suffix; comparison reaches the Indo-European *h₃orbʰ- family.","semanticChange":"Transfer of social status, dependency, bereavement, slavery, and obligatory labor form a reconstructed semantic network—not a single literal definition.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Slavic etymological lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The family connection is strong; individual semantic bridges remain reconstructed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":99,"id":99,"entryId":18,"entrySlug":"robot","childFormId":116,"parentFormId":117,"canonicalEdgeId":100,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted beyond the proposed Indo-European base.","semanticChange":"The graph stops where the comparative evidence currently stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":100,"id":100,"entryId":19,"entrySlug":"muscle","childFormId":118,"parentFormId":119,"canonicalEdgeId":101,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English muscle continued into modern English with regular orthographic and phonological development.","semanticChange":"The anatomical meaning remained central and later extended to strength and coercive power.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports English muscle from the 14th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":101,"id":101,"entryId":19,"entrySlug":"muscle","childFormId":119,"parentFormId":120,"canonicalEdgeId":102,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English muscle borrowed the Old French form with English pronunciation and spelling adaptation.","semanticChange":"The anatomical name remained a muscle term.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Borrowing belongs to the Middle English period.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":102,"id":102,"entryId":19,"entrySlug":"muscle","childFormId":120,"parentFormId":121,"canonicalEdgeId":103,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French muscle continues Latin musculus through the Romance transmission channel.","semanticChange":"The Latin anatomical name remained a muscle term.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":103,"id":103,"entryId":19,"entrySlug":"muscle","childFormId":121,"parentFormId":122,"canonicalEdgeId":104,"relationType":"diminutive_derivation","soundChange":"Latin musculus is the diminutive formation built from mūs with the suffix -culus.","semanticChange":"“Little mouse” named a muscle and also supplied a Latin name for the mussel; the anatomical resemblance mechanism is not fixed here.","scholar":"American Heritage · Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The morphological derivation is secure; the precise resemblance that motivated the anatomical sense remains uncertain.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":104,"id":104,"entryId":19,"entrySlug":"muscle","childFormId":122,"parentFormId":123,"canonicalEdgeId":105,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin mūs continues the Indo-European *mūs- mouse word; the family also includes Germanic *mūs- and Greek mūs.","semanticChange":"The inherited mouse word also generated specialized muscle and mussel terms in Latin.","scholar":"American Heritage Indo-European Roots · University of Texas LRC","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Indo-European form is reconstructed from cross-branch comparison.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":105,"id":105,"entryId":19,"entrySlug":"muscle","childFormId":123,"parentFormId":124,"canonicalEdgeId":106,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted beyond the reviewed Indo-European *mūs- reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops rather than fabricating an ancestor for the mouse word.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":106,"id":106,"entryId":20,"entrySlug":"mussel","childFormId":125,"parentFormId":126,"canonicalEdgeId":107,"relationType":"alteration","soundChange":"Modern mussel replaces Middle English muscle; American Heritage says the current spelling was perhaps influenced by Dutch mossel.","semanticChange":"The mollusk meaning remained stable while spelling separated it from anatomical muscle.","scholar":"American Heritage · Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Descent from Middle English muscle is secure; Dutch influence on the modern spelling is possible rather than established.","chronologyNote":"The changed spelling is post-Middle English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":107,"id":107,"entryId":20,"entrySlug":"mussel","childFormId":126,"parentFormId":127,"canonicalEdgeId":108,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English muscle continues Old English muscelle with reduction and remodeling of the final syllables.","semanticChange":"The word continues to denote the bivalve mollusk.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":108,"id":108,"entryId":20,"entrySlug":"mussel","childFormId":127,"parentFormId":128,"canonicalEdgeId":109,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old English muscelle was borrowed from the Latin mussel form represented as Medieval Latin mūscula or Vulgar Latin *muscula.","semanticChange":"The Latin mollusk name entered Old English without a major semantic change.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The borrowing is secure; the sources differ on whether to label the immediate Latin register Medieval or Vulgar Latin.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":109,"id":109,"entryId":20,"entrySlug":"mussel","childFormId":128,"parentFormId":129,"canonicalEdgeId":110,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Medieval or Vulgar Latin mūscula is the feminine variant of Latin musculus.","semanticChange":"The mouse-derived Latin word was used as a name for the bivalve mollusk.","scholar":"American Heritage · Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The exact chronological register of mūscula is source-dependent.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":110,"id":110,"entryId":20,"entrySlug":"mussel","childFormId":129,"parentFormId":130,"canonicalEdgeId":104,"relationType":"diminutive_derivation","soundChange":"Latin musculus is the diminutive formation built from mūs with the suffix -culus.","semanticChange":"“Little mouse” named a muscle and also supplied a Latin name for the mussel; the anatomical resemblance mechanism is not fixed here.","scholar":"American Heritage · Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The morphological derivation is secure; the precise resemblance that motivated the anatomical sense remains uncertain.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":111,"id":111,"entryId":20,"entrySlug":"mussel","childFormId":130,"parentFormId":131,"canonicalEdgeId":105,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin mūs continues the Indo-European *mūs- mouse word; the family also includes Germanic *mūs- and Greek mūs.","semanticChange":"The inherited mouse word also generated specialized muscle and mussel terms in Latin.","scholar":"American Heritage Indo-European Roots · University of Texas LRC","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Indo-European form is reconstructed from cross-branch comparison.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":112,"id":112,"entryId":20,"entrySlug":"mussel","childFormId":131,"parentFormId":132,"canonicalEdgeId":113,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted beyond the reviewed Indo-European *mūs- reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops rather than fabricating an ancestor for the mouse word.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":113,"id":113,"entryId":21,"entrySlug":"mouse","childFormId":133,"parentFormId":134,"canonicalEdgeId":114,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English mous developed into modern mouse with the later spelling convention marking the diphthong.","semanticChange":"The central rodent meaning remained stable while transferred senses accumulated.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports first known use before the 12th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":114,"id":114,"entryId":21,"entrySlug":"mouse","childFormId":134,"parentFormId":135,"canonicalEdgeId":115,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English mous continues Old English mūs.","semanticChange":"The inherited word retained the meaning “mouse.”","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":115,"id":115,"entryId":21,"entrySlug":"mouse","childFormId":135,"parentFormId":136,"canonicalEdgeId":116,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English mūs continues reconstructed Proto-Germanic *mūs, with cognates including German Maus and Dutch muis.","semanticChange":"The rodent meaning remained stable across the Germanic branch.","scholar":"American Heritage Indo-European Roots · University of Texas LRC","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Proto-Germanic *mūs is reconstructed from the attested Germanic forms.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":116,"id":116,"entryId":21,"entrySlug":"mouse","childFormId":136,"parentFormId":137,"canonicalEdgeId":117,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *mūs continues Proto-Indo-European *mūs-, reconstructed from Germanic, Latin, Greek, and other comparanda.","semanticChange":"The inherited meaning remains “mouse.”","scholar":"American Heritage Indo-European Roots · University of Texas LRC","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Both endpoints are reconstructed; the cross-branch comparison supports the deeper form.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":117,"id":117,"entryId":21,"entrySlug":"mouse","childFormId":137,"parentFormId":138,"canonicalEdgeId":118,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted beyond the reviewed Indo-European *mūs- reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops rather than fabricating an ancestor for the mouse word.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":118,"id":118,"entryId":22,"entrySlug":"host","childFormId":139,"parentFormId":140,"canonicalEdgeId":119,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English ost / host continued into modern host with loss of the unstressed variant and stabilization of initial h.","semanticChange":"The reversible host-or-guest role narrowed in English toward the person receiving others, then expanded into event, media, biological, and computing roles.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Hospitality sense recorded from the 14th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":119,"id":119,"entryId":22,"entrySlug":"host","childFormId":140,"parentFormId":141,"canonicalEdgeId":120,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English borrowed Anglo-French oste / hoste with ordinary spelling variation around initial h.","semanticChange":"The host-or-guest hospitality role was retained.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":120,"id":120,"entryId":22,"entrySlug":"host","childFormId":141,"parentFormId":142,"canonicalEdgeId":121,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French oste / hoste continues Latin hospes through Romance sound reduction and adaptation.","semanticChange":"Latin's reciprocal host-or-guest role remained available in the French and early English forms.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":121,"id":121,"entryId":22,"entrySlug":"host","childFormId":142,"parentFormId":143,"canonicalEdgeId":122,"relationType":"compound_reflex","soundChange":"Latin hospes (stem hospit-) is analyzed as a reduced reflex of the compound *ghos-pot-, with substantial phonetic reduction acknowledged by the sources.","semanticChange":"A “guest-master” encoded the reciprocal role in which the same person could be guest on one occasion and host on another.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The host/guest reciprocity is well supported; Merriam-Webster notes that the degree of phonetic reduction has led some scholars to question the precise compound etymology.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":122,"id":122,"entryId":22,"entrySlug":"host","childFormId":143,"parentFormId":144,"canonicalEdgeId":123,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"The first member *ghos- of *ghos-pot- continues the *ghos-ti- guest/stranger base; the compound also contains *pot- “master.”","semanticChange":"The reciprocal outsider becomes the “guest-master,” the person who stands for mutual duties of hospitality.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The compound analysis is reconstructed and has a separate *pot- component edge in the canonical graph.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":123,"id":123,"entryId":22,"entrySlug":"host","childFormId":144,"parentFormId":145,"canonicalEdgeId":124,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted as a secure ancestor of *ghos-ti-.","semanticChange":"The graph preserves a hypothetical exchange-root analysis as proposed evidence, not as the single established continuation.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":124,"id":124,"entryId":23,"entrySlug":"guest","childFormId":146,"parentFormId":147,"canonicalEdgeId":125,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English gest and related variants developed into modern guest; the modern spelling distinguishes the hard initial consonant without changing the inherited base.","semanticChange":"The visitor receiving hospitality remained the central sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known use: 13th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":125,"id":125,"entryId":23,"entrySlug":"guest","childFormId":147,"parentFormId":148,"canonicalEdgeId":126,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English forms continue Old English giest / gyst / gest / gæst; Merriam-Webster notes that Middle English g may partly reflect Old Norse gestr.","semanticChange":"Guest, visitor, and stranger remain within the inherited semantic field.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Direct Old English inheritance is secure; the degree of Norse reinforcement in the Middle English forms is not fixed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":126,"id":126,"entryId":23,"entrySlug":"guest","childFormId":148,"parentFormId":149,"canonicalEdgeId":127,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English guest forms continue reconstructed Germanic *gastiz / *gasti-, alongside Old Saxon and Old High German gast, Old Norse gestr, and Gothic gasts.","semanticChange":"The Germanic family preserves guest and stranger senses.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage · University of Texas LRC","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic form is reconstructed and notation varies slightly by source.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":127,"id":127,"entryId":23,"entrySlug":"guest","childFormId":149,"parentFormId":150,"canonicalEdgeId":128,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Germanic *gastiz continues *ghos-ti-, with the Germanic reflex showing the inherited consonant and vowel developments represented across the cognate set.","semanticChange":"A reciprocal outsider or stranger specializes as the guest.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots · University of Texas LRC","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Indo-European form is reconstructed from a geographically limited set of branches.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":128,"id":128,"entryId":23,"entrySlug":"guest","childFormId":150,"parentFormId":151,"canonicalEdgeId":129,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted as a secure ancestor of *ghos-ti-.","semanticChange":"The graph preserves a hypothetical exchange-root analysis as proposed evidence, not as the single established continuation.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":129,"id":129,"entryId":24,"entrySlug":"hostile","childFormId":152,"parentFormId":153,"canonicalEdgeId":130,"relationType":"mixed_borrowing","soundChange":"English hostile was borrowed through Middle French while also drawing directly on Latin hostīlis.","semanticChange":"The enemy-related adjective entered English without a major semantic shift.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The source identifies both Middle French and Latin; the displayed route preserves French transmission without excluding learned Latin influence.","chronologyNote":"First known use: 1580.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":130,"id":130,"entryId":24,"entrySlug":"hostile","childFormId":153,"parentFormId":154,"canonicalEdgeId":131,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle French hostile was borrowed from Latin hostīlis with minimal learned-form adaptation.","semanticChange":"The meaning remained “of or characteristic of an enemy.”","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":131,"id":131,"entryId":24,"entrySlug":"hostile","childFormId":154,"parentFormId":155,"canonicalEdgeId":132,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin hostīlis is formed from hostis with the relational adjective suffix -īlis.","semanticChange":"The noun “enemy” becomes the adjective “enemy-like” or hostile.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":132,"id":132,"entryId":24,"entrySlug":"hostile","childFormId":155,"parentFormId":156,"canonicalEdgeId":133,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin hostis continues *ghos-ti-; the inherited word first denoted a foreigner or stranger and later narrowed to an enemy.","semanticChange":"The reciprocal or legally recognized outsider becomes the hostile outsider and enemy as Roman usage changes.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots · University of Texas LRC","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The family connection is strong; the semantic narrowing unfolded historically rather than at one recoverable moment.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":133,"id":133,"entryId":24,"entrySlug":"hostile","childFormId":156,"parentFormId":157,"canonicalEdgeId":134,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted as a secure ancestor of *ghos-ti-.","semanticChange":"The graph preserves a hypothetical exchange-root analysis as proposed evidence, not as the single established continuation.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":134,"id":134,"entryId":25,"entrySlug":"hospital","childFormId":158,"parentFormId":159,"canonicalEdgeId":135,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English hospital / ospitale continued into modern hospital with spelling and stress stabilization.","semanticChange":"Guest accommodation and charitable residence developed into the institution for medical care familiar today.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The medical sense developed in the 15th century after the 14th-century English borrowing.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":135,"id":135,"entryId":25,"entrySlug":"hospital","childFormId":159,"parentFormId":160,"canonicalEdgeId":136,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English borrowed Anglo-French hospital, with an ospitale variant reflecting the same learned lodging term.","semanticChange":"Residence for travelers and charitable care remained central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":136,"id":136,"entryId":25,"entrySlug":"hospital","childFormId":160,"parentFormId":161,"canonicalEdgeId":137,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French hospital continues Medieval Latin hospitāle with Romance adaptation.","semanticChange":"Guest accommodation becomes a named charitable lodging institution.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Merriam-Webster historical essay","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":137,"id":137,"entryId":25,"entrySlug":"hospital","childFormId":161,"parentFormId":162,"canonicalEdgeId":138,"relationType":"substantivization","soundChange":"Medieval Latin hospitāle is the neuter substantivization of Latin hospitālis, “of a guest; hospitable.”","semanticChange":"An adjective about guests came to name guest accommodations and then institutions of lodging and care.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":138,"id":138,"entryId":25,"entrySlug":"hospital","childFormId":162,"parentFormId":163,"canonicalEdgeId":139,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin hospitālis is formed from the stem hospit- of hospes with the adjective suffix -ālis.","semanticChange":"The host/guest relationship becomes the quality of being for guests or hospitable.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":139,"id":139,"entryId":25,"entrySlug":"hospital","childFormId":163,"parentFormId":164,"canonicalEdgeId":122,"relationType":"compound_reflex","soundChange":"Latin hospes (stem hospit-) is analyzed as a reduced reflex of the compound *ghos-pot-, with substantial phonetic reduction acknowledged by the sources.","semanticChange":"A “guest-master” encoded the reciprocal role in which the same person could be guest on one occasion and host on another.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The host/guest reciprocity is well supported; Merriam-Webster notes that the degree of phonetic reduction has led some scholars to question the precise compound etymology.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":140,"id":140,"entryId":25,"entrySlug":"hospital","childFormId":164,"parentFormId":165,"canonicalEdgeId":123,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"The first member *ghos- of *ghos-pot- continues the *ghos-ti- guest/stranger base; the compound also contains *pot- “master.”","semanticChange":"The reciprocal outsider becomes the “guest-master,” the person who stands for mutual duties of hospitality.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The compound analysis is reconstructed and has a separate *pot- component edge in the canonical graph.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":141,"id":141,"entryId":25,"entrySlug":"hospital","childFormId":165,"parentFormId":166,"canonicalEdgeId":142,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted as a secure ancestor of *ghos-ti-.","semanticChange":"The graph preserves a hypothetical exchange-root analysis as proposed evidence, not as the single established continuation.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":142,"id":142,"entryId":26,"entrySlug":"hotel","childFormId":167,"parentFormId":168,"canonicalEdgeId":143,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English borrowed French hôtel, anglicizing the accent and pronunciation.","semanticChange":"The lodging-establishment sense was retained and generalized in English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known use: 1687.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":143,"id":143,"entryId":26,"entrySlug":"hotel","childFormId":168,"parentFormId":169,"canonicalEdgeId":144,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"French hôtel continues Old French hostel / ostel; loss of s before the consonant is reflected by the circumflex in the modern French spelling.","semanticChange":"Lodging and accommodation remain central, with French also developing a mansion sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":144,"id":144,"entryId":26,"entrySlug":"hotel","childFormId":169,"parentFormId":170,"canonicalEdgeId":145,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French hostel / ostel continues the Medieval Latin guest-accommodation term hospitāle through Romance sound and spelling change.","semanticChange":"A guest room or lodging becomes an inn-like place for travelers.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster historical essay","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":145,"id":145,"entryId":26,"entrySlug":"hotel","childFormId":170,"parentFormId":171,"canonicalEdgeId":138,"relationType":"substantivization","soundChange":"Medieval Latin hospitāle is the neuter substantivization of Latin hospitālis, “of a guest; hospitable.”","semanticChange":"An adjective about guests came to name guest accommodations and then institutions of lodging and care.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":146,"id":146,"entryId":26,"entrySlug":"hotel","childFormId":171,"parentFormId":172,"canonicalEdgeId":139,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin hospitālis is formed from the stem hospit- of hospes with the adjective suffix -ālis.","semanticChange":"The host/guest relationship becomes the quality of being for guests or hospitable.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":147,"id":147,"entryId":26,"entrySlug":"hotel","childFormId":172,"parentFormId":173,"canonicalEdgeId":122,"relationType":"compound_reflex","soundChange":"Latin hospes (stem hospit-) is analyzed as a reduced reflex of the compound *ghos-pot-, with substantial phonetic reduction acknowledged by the sources.","semanticChange":"A “guest-master” encoded the reciprocal role in which the same person could be guest on one occasion and host on another.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The host/guest reciprocity is well supported; Merriam-Webster notes that the degree of phonetic reduction has led some scholars to question the precise compound etymology.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":148,"id":148,"entryId":26,"entrySlug":"hotel","childFormId":173,"parentFormId":174,"canonicalEdgeId":123,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"The first member *ghos- of *ghos-pot- continues the *ghos-ti- guest/stranger base; the compound also contains *pot- “master.”","semanticChange":"The reciprocal outsider becomes the “guest-master,” the person who stands for mutual duties of hospitality.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The compound analysis is reconstructed and has a separate *pot- component edge in the canonical graph.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":149,"id":149,"entryId":26,"entrySlug":"hotel","childFormId":174,"parentFormId":175,"canonicalEdgeId":150,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted as a secure ancestor of *ghos-ti-.","semanticChange":"The graph preserves a hypothetical exchange-root analysis as proposed evidence, not as the single established continuation.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":150,"id":150,"entryId":27,"entrySlug":"nice","childFormId":176,"parentFormId":177,"canonicalEdgeId":155,"relationType":"semantic_continuation","soundChange":"The inherited spelling and /aɪ/ pronunciation remain stable as the modern sense profile settles.","semanticChange":"Foolish, wanton, and fastidious senses move through precise and discriminating toward pleasant, agreeable, and kind.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The semantic history is multiply attested; no claim is made that one instantaneous shift produced the modern sense.","chronologyNote":"Positive pleasant/agreeable senses become prominent in the nineteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":151,"id":151,"entryId":27,"entrySlug":"nice","childFormId":177,"parentFormId":178,"canonicalEdgeId":156,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French nice enters Middle English with spelling preserved and pronunciation adapted to English.","semanticChange":"Silly or simple expands into foolish, wanton, coy, fastidious, and precise senses.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Borrowed in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":152,"id":152,"entryId":27,"entrySlug":"nice","childFormId":178,"parentFormId":179,"canonicalEdgeId":157,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin nescius passes through Romance without preserving the full Latin ending.","semanticChange":"Ignorance becomes foolishness or simplicity in the French adjective.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":153,"id":153,"entryId":27,"entrySlug":"nice","childFormId":179,"parentFormId":180,"canonicalEdgeId":158,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The adjective nescius is built within the nescīre “not know” family.","semanticChange":"Not knowing is lexicalized as ignorant.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":154,"id":154,"entryId":27,"entrySlug":"nice","childFormId":180,"parentFormId":181,"canonicalEdgeId":159,"relationType":"negative_compound","soundChange":"Latin nescīre contains the negative element ne- plus scīre “to know.”","semanticChange":"Knowing is negated: “know” becomes “not know, be unfamiliar with.”","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The internal Latin negative relationship is secure even though the deeper prehistory of scīre is disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":155,"id":155,"entryId":27,"entrySlug":"nice","childFormId":181,"parentFormId":182,"canonicalEdgeId":160,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"Latin scīre has been compared with an Indo-European cutting/separating base; the exact formation and even the semantic bridge remain disputed.","semanticChange":"A proposed development moves from cutting or separating to distinguishing and then knowing.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · de Vaan · Ernout and Meillet · American Heritage","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster records competing morphological analyses and calls the semantic progression questionable; Ernout and Meillet call the comparison uncertain.","chronologyNote":"The comparison belongs to prehistory, not a directly attested change.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":156,"id":156,"entryId":27,"entrySlug":"nice","childFormId":182,"parentFormId":183,"canonicalEdgeId":161,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed *skei- comparison.","semanticChange":"The graph stops where the reviewed comparative analysis stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":157,"id":157,"entryId":28,"entrySlug":"science","childFormId":184,"parentFormId":411,"canonicalEdgeId":162,"relationType":"semantic_specialization","soundChange":"The Early Modern spelling science continues as modern /ˈsaɪəns/ with pronunciation stabilization.","semanticChange":"An organized branch or body of knowledge narrows in prominent modern use toward systematic and especially natural knowledge tested through scientific method.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Older general and branch-of-knowledge senses remain available; specialization is not total replacement.","chronologyNote":"The natural-science center becomes dominant in the modern period.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":158,"id":158,"entryId":28,"entrySlug":"science","childFormId":185,"parentFormId":186,"canonicalEdgeId":163,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French science/cience is adopted into Middle English learned vocabulary.","semanticChange":"The broad knowledge and learning senses remain central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First-known English use is reported in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":159,"id":159,"entryId":28,"entrySlug":"science","childFormId":186,"parentFormId":187,"canonicalEdgeId":164,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin scientia passes into Anglo-French with regular Romance phonological development.","semanticChange":"Knowledge, awareness, and a branch of learning remain the core meanings.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":160,"id":160,"entryId":28,"entrySlug":"science","childFormId":187,"parentFormId":188,"canonicalEdgeId":165,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The noun scientia is formed from the participial stem scient- / sciens.","semanticChange":"A knowing person/state supplies an abstract noun for knowledge.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":161,"id":161,"entryId":28,"entrySlug":"science","childFormId":188,"parentFormId":189,"canonicalEdgeId":166,"relationType":"inflectional_derivation","soundChange":"Sciens is the present participle of sciō, scīre.","semanticChange":"The activity of knowing is expressed as “knowing.”","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":162,"id":162,"entryId":28,"entrySlug":"science","childFormId":189,"parentFormId":190,"canonicalEdgeId":160,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"Latin scīre has been compared with an Indo-European cutting/separating base; the exact formation and even the semantic bridge remain disputed.","semanticChange":"A proposed development moves from cutting or separating to distinguishing and then knowing.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · de Vaan · Ernout and Meillet · American Heritage","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster records competing morphological analyses and calls the semantic progression questionable; Ernout and Meillet call the comparison uncertain.","chronologyNote":"The comparison belongs to prehistory, not a directly attested change.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":163,"id":163,"entryId":28,"entrySlug":"science","childFormId":190,"parentFormId":191,"canonicalEdgeId":168,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed *skei- comparison.","semanticChange":"The graph stops where the reviewed comparative analysis stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":164,"id":164,"entryId":29,"entrySlug":"decimate","childFormId":192,"parentFormId":193,"canonicalEdgeId":169,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English decimate is formed on the Latin past-participial stem decimāt-.","semanticChange":"The exact selection or taxation of a tenth broadens within English to drastic reduction or destruction.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The broader sense is established English usage, not an etymological error.","chronologyNote":"First-known English use is reported in 1660; broader use follows within decades.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":165,"id":165,"entryId":29,"entrySlug":"decimate","childFormId":193,"parentFormId":194,"canonicalEdgeId":170,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin decimāre is derived from the tenth/ordinal family.","semanticChange":"“Tenth” becomes the action “take or select a tenth.”","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":166,"id":166,"entryId":29,"entrySlug":"decimate","childFormId":194,"parentFormId":195,"canonicalEdgeId":171,"relationType":"ordinal_derivation","soundChange":"Latin decimus is the ordinal formation corresponding to decem.","semanticChange":"The cardinal “ten” becomes ordinal “tenth.”","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":167,"id":167,"entryId":29,"entrySlug":"decimate","childFormId":195,"parentFormId":196,"canonicalEdgeId":172,"relationType":"inherited","soundChange":"Latin decem regularly continues the centum-language form of Indo-European *dekm̥.","semanticChange":"The numeral meaning “ten” remains stable.","scholar":"American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The Latin and Indo-European numeral relationship is securely comparative.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European prehistory to attested Latin.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":168,"id":168,"entryId":29,"entrySlug":"decimate","childFormId":196,"parentFormId":197,"canonicalEdgeId":173,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper numeral form is asserted beyond *dekm̥.","semanticChange":"The reviewed trail ends at the published Indo-European root.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":169,"id":169,"entryId":30,"entrySlug":"decimal","childFormId":198,"parentFormId":199,"canonicalEdgeId":174,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French décimal is adapted into English as decimal.","semanticChange":"The “of tenths/base ten” meaning remains transparent.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"English adjective reported from 1608; noun from 1623.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":170,"id":170,"entryId":30,"entrySlug":"decimal","childFormId":199,"parentFormId":200,"canonicalEdgeId":175,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Medieval Latin decimālis passes into French décimal with Romance sound development.","semanticChange":"The learned mathematical and proportional sense remains tied to tenths.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":171,"id":171,"entryId":30,"entrySlug":"decimal","childFormId":200,"parentFormId":201,"canonicalEdgeId":176,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Medieval Latin decimālis is formed from Latin decima with an adjectival suffix.","semanticChange":"A tenth part or tithe becomes “pertaining to tenths.”","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":172,"id":172,"entryId":30,"entrySlug":"decimal","childFormId":201,"parentFormId":202,"canonicalEdgeId":177,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin decima is a substantivized feminine form in the decimus/decem family.","semanticChange":"The cardinal “ten” supplies a named tenth part or tithe.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":173,"id":173,"entryId":30,"entrySlug":"decimal","childFormId":202,"parentFormId":203,"canonicalEdgeId":172,"relationType":"inherited","soundChange":"Latin decem regularly continues the centum-language form of Indo-European *dekm̥.","semanticChange":"The numeral meaning “ten” remains stable.","scholar":"American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The Latin and Indo-European numeral relationship is securely comparative.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European prehistory to attested Latin.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":174,"id":174,"entryId":30,"entrySlug":"decimal","childFormId":203,"parentFormId":204,"canonicalEdgeId":179,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper numeral form is asserted beyond *dekm̥.","semanticChange":"The reviewed trail ends at the published Indo-European root.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":175,"id":175,"entryId":31,"entrySlug":"december","childFormId":205,"parentFormId":206,"canonicalEdgeId":180,"relationType":"orthographic_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English Decembre is respelled December under renewed Latin influence and standardized capitalization.","semanticChange":"The month identity remains while its calendar position is twelfth.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Modern spelling follows the medieval transmission.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":176,"id":176,"entryId":31,"entrySlug":"december","childFormId":206,"parentFormId":207,"canonicalEdgeId":181,"relationType":"borrowing_via_competing_routes","soundChange":"The Latin month name reaches Middle English through Old English or Anglo-French transmission; the exact route is not resolved by the reviewed source.","semanticChange":"The named tenth month is retained as the last/twelfth month after calendar reordering.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly gives Old English or Anglo-French as alternatives rather than selecting one.","chronologyNote":"Middle English period.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":177,"id":177,"entryId":31,"entrySlug":"december","childFormId":207,"parentFormId":208,"canonicalEdgeId":182,"relationType":"compound_derivation","soundChange":"Latin December is formed on decem “ten” as a month name.","semanticChange":"The numeral ten identifies the tenth month in the early Roman year.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The name predates its later position as month twelve.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":178,"id":178,"entryId":31,"entrySlug":"december","childFormId":208,"parentFormId":209,"canonicalEdgeId":172,"relationType":"inherited","soundChange":"Latin decem regularly continues the centum-language form of Indo-European *dekm̥.","semanticChange":"The numeral meaning “ten” remains stable.","scholar":"American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The Latin and Indo-European numeral relationship is securely comparative.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European prehistory to attested Latin.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":179,"id":179,"entryId":31,"entrySlug":"december","childFormId":209,"parentFormId":210,"canonicalEdgeId":184,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper numeral form is asserted beyond *dekm̥.","semanticChange":"The reviewed trail ends at the published Indo-European root.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":180,"id":180,"entryId":32,"entrySlug":"check","childFormId":211,"parentFormId":212,"canonicalEdgeId":185,"relationType":"semantic_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English chek stabilizes as check; the core consonants remain while spelling standardizes.","semanticChange":"A chess attack produces stop and restraint, then verification, marks, tokens, and the anti-forgery counterfoil behind the bank sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The semantic ordering is explicit in Merriam-Webster; several modern branches coexist rather than replacing one another.","chronologyNote":"Chess and restraint senses are medieval; banking and verification branches develop later.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":181,"id":181,"entryId":32,"entrySlug":"check","childFormId":212,"parentFormId":213,"canonicalEdgeId":186,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French eschec loses its initial unstressed vowel as it enters Middle English chek.","semanticChange":"The chess warning expands toward assault, obstruction, and adverse event.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Borrowed in the Middle English period.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":182,"id":182,"entryId":32,"entrySlug":"check","childFormId":213,"parentFormId":214,"canonicalEdgeId":187,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Anglo-French eschec continues continental Old French eschac / eschés with vowel leveling.","semanticChange":"The king-in-danger chess call remains the core sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The exact Old French vowel history may reflect homonym association or ordinary raising.","chronologyNote":"Old and Anglo-French period.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":183,"id":183,"entryId":32,"entrySlug":"check","childFormId":214,"parentFormId":215,"canonicalEdgeId":188,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Arabic /ʃ/ is adapted as Old French /tʃ/ with an added initial vowel; direct borrowing versus Spanish mediation remains uncertain.","semanticChange":"The word “king” is reinterpreted as the chess warning or the pieces/game surrounding that warning.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly leaves direct Arabic transmission versus Spanish jaque mediation unresolved.","chronologyNote":"Arabic-to-Romance chess contact before the Middle English borrowing.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":184,"id":184,"entryId":32,"entrySlug":"check","childFormId":215,"parentFormId":216,"canonicalEdgeId":189,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Persian šāh is borrowed into Arabic chess vocabulary with the initial /ʃ/ and long vowel substantially retained.","semanticChange":"The sovereign title is specialized as the chess call naming the threatened king.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The borrowing direction is supported by Persian predominance in the chess terminology.","chronologyNote":"Persian chess vocabulary enters Arabic in the early Islamic period.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":185,"id":185,"entryId":32,"entrySlug":"check","childFormId":216,"parentFormId":217,"canonicalEdgeId":190,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"New Persian šāh continues Middle Persian šāh with the long vowel and final consonant retained.","semanticChange":"The title “king” remains stable across the Iranian language stages.","scholar":"Rüdiger Schmitt · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Encyclopaedia Iranica explicitly identifies Middle and New Persian šāh as continuations of the Old Persian title.","chronologyNote":"Middle Persian to New Persian.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":186,"id":186,"entryId":32,"entrySlug":"check","childFormId":217,"parentFormId":218,"canonicalEdgeId":191,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"The substantially shorter Middle Persian šāh continues Old Persian xšāyaθiyā; the reviewed record does not invent every unattested intermediate sound change.","semanticChange":"The meaning “king, sovereign” remains stable.","scholar":"Rüdiger Schmitt · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The continuation is explicit, while the internal contraction history is not overstated.","chronologyNote":"Achaemenid Old Persian to Middle Persian.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":187,"id":187,"entryId":32,"entrySlug":"check","childFormId":218,"parentFormId":219,"canonicalEdgeId":192,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"Old Persian xšāyaθiyā is analyzed through xšāy- “rule, have power, possess” and compared with dialectal Indo-European *tkeH-.","semanticChange":"Rule or possession supplies the base for a sovereign title.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster also records a materially different Lexikon der indogermanischen Verben analysis from *h₃ekʷ-; neither is promoted as consensus.","chronologyNote":"The comparison belongs to Indo-European prehistory.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":188,"id":188,"entryId":32,"entrySlug":"check","childFormId":219,"parentFormId":220,"canonicalEdgeId":193,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the competing proposed reconstructions.","semanticChange":"The reviewed trail ends at a disputed root comparison.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":189,"id":189,"entryId":33,"entrySlug":"chess","childFormId":221,"parentFormId":222,"canonicalEdgeId":194,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English chesse / ches stabilizes as modern chess with final spelling simplification.","semanticChange":"The board-game meaning remains stable.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Fourteenth century to modern English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":190,"id":190,"entryId":33,"entrySlug":"chess","childFormId":222,"parentFormId":223,"canonicalEdgeId":195,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French escheks / eschez enters Middle English as chesse, ches, and esches.","semanticChange":"The formally plural French game name becomes an English mass/singular game name.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Borrowed in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":191,"id":191,"entryId":33,"entrySlug":"chess","childFormId":223,"parentFormId":224,"canonicalEdgeId":196,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Anglo-French plural forms continue continental Old French eschés with dialectal spelling differences.","semanticChange":"Chess pieces or checks become the name of the game as a whole.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Old French to Anglo-French.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":192,"id":192,"entryId":33,"entrySlug":"chess","childFormId":224,"parentFormId":225,"canonicalEdgeId":197,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Arabic /ʃ/ is adapted as Old French /tʃ/ with an added initial vowel; an alternate šatranj route remains separately graphed.","semanticChange":"The chess “king” call becomes a plural name for pieces and then the game.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster routes the word through šāh; Encyclopaedia Iranica groups English chess with descendants of the traveling game-name šatranj.","chronologyNote":"Medieval Arabic-to-Romance chess transmission.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":193,"id":193,"entryId":33,"entrySlug":"chess","childFormId":225,"parentFormId":226,"canonicalEdgeId":189,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Persian šāh is borrowed into Arabic chess vocabulary with the initial /ʃ/ and long vowel substantially retained.","semanticChange":"The sovereign title is specialized as the chess call naming the threatened king.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The borrowing direction is supported by Persian predominance in the chess terminology.","chronologyNote":"Persian chess vocabulary enters Arabic in the early Islamic period.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":194,"id":194,"entryId":33,"entrySlug":"chess","childFormId":226,"parentFormId":227,"canonicalEdgeId":190,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"New Persian šāh continues Middle Persian šāh with the long vowel and final consonant retained.","semanticChange":"The title “king” remains stable across the Iranian language stages.","scholar":"Rüdiger Schmitt · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Encyclopaedia Iranica explicitly identifies Middle and New Persian šāh as continuations of the Old Persian title.","chronologyNote":"Middle Persian to New Persian.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":195,"id":195,"entryId":33,"entrySlug":"chess","childFormId":227,"parentFormId":228,"canonicalEdgeId":191,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"The substantially shorter Middle Persian šāh continues Old Persian xšāyaθiyā; the reviewed record does not invent every unattested intermediate sound change.","semanticChange":"The meaning “king, sovereign” remains stable.","scholar":"Rüdiger Schmitt · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The continuation is explicit, while the internal contraction history is not overstated.","chronologyNote":"Achaemenid Old Persian to Middle Persian.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":196,"id":196,"entryId":33,"entrySlug":"chess","childFormId":228,"parentFormId":229,"canonicalEdgeId":192,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"Old Persian xšāyaθiyā is analyzed through xšāy- “rule, have power, possess” and compared with dialectal Indo-European *tkeH-.","semanticChange":"Rule or possession supplies the base for a sovereign title.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster also records a materially different Lexikon der indogermanischen Verben analysis from *h₃ekʷ-; neither is promoted as consensus.","chronologyNote":"The comparison belongs to Indo-European prehistory.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":197,"id":197,"entryId":33,"entrySlug":"chess","childFormId":229,"parentFormId":230,"canonicalEdgeId":202,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the competing proposed reconstructions.","semanticChange":"The reviewed trail ends at a disputed root comparison.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":198,"id":198,"entryId":34,"entrySlug":"checkmate","childFormId":231,"parentFormId":232,"canonicalEdgeId":203,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English chekmaten / chekmat stabilizes as modern checkmate.","semanticChange":"Chess defeat and complete frustration continue together into modern English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster records frustrate alongside the chess meaning already in Middle English.","chronologyNote":"Fourteenth century to modern English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":199,"id":199,"entryId":34,"entrySlug":"checkmate","childFormId":232,"parentFormId":233,"canonicalEdgeId":204,"relationType":"borrowing_and_derivation","soundChange":"Anglo-French eschec mat is borrowed as Middle English chek mat and supplies the derived verb chekmaten.","semanticChange":"The announcement that a king cannot escape becomes both a chess result and complete frustration.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Middle English borrowing and derivation.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":200,"id":200,"entryId":34,"entrySlug":"checkmate","childFormId":233,"parentFormId":234,"canonicalEdgeId":205,"relationType":"compound_member","soundChange":"The second member mat continues Arabic māt with little phonological change in French.","semanticChange":"A state of helplessness or defeat supplies the result component of the compound.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Bo Utas","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Persian helpless analysis is favored, but the Arabic “has died” analysis remains a recorded competitor.","chronologyNote":"Persian and Arabic chess terminology passes through French before English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":201,"id":201,"entryId":34,"entrySlug":"checkmate","childFormId":234,"parentFormId":235,"canonicalEdgeId":206,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Persian mānd is borrowed into Arabic chess usage as māt, with final consonant adaptation.","semanticChange":"Left or helpless is specialized as the state of a trapped king.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Bo Utas","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The alternative reading as native Arabic māt “has died” is explicitly preserved as a dispute.","chronologyNote":"Early Islamic chess vocabulary.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":202,"id":202,"entryId":34,"entrySlug":"checkmate","childFormId":235,"parentFormId":236,"canonicalEdgeId":207,"relationType":"inflectional_derivation","soundChange":"Persian mānd is the verbal adjective associated with māndan.","semanticChange":"The action “remain” yields the state “left, at a loss, helpless.”","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Persian.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":203,"id":203,"entryId":34,"entrySlug":"checkmate","childFormId":236,"parentFormId":237,"canonicalEdgeId":208,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Persian māndan continues the earlier Iranian base mān- with an infinitival ending.","semanticChange":"The meaning “remain, wait” continues.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Middle to New Persian.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":204,"id":204,"entryId":34,"entrySlug":"checkmate","childFormId":237,"parentFormId":238,"canonicalEdgeId":209,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle Persian mān- continues the Old Persian verbal base evidenced in amānaya.","semanticChange":"Remain or wait stays stable.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The source supplies the Old Persian comparison but not a complete paradigm.","chronologyNote":"Old to Middle Persian.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":205,"id":205,"entryId":34,"entrySlug":"checkmate","childFormId":238,"parentFormId":239,"canonicalEdgeId":210,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is asserted beyond the reviewed Old Persian evidence.","semanticChange":"The trail ends instead of importing an uncited reconstruction.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":206,"id":206,"entryId":35,"entrySlug":"shah","childFormId":240,"parentFormId":241,"canonicalEdgeId":211,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Persian šāh is borrowed into English as shah with its pronunciation approximated and transliteration simplified.","semanticChange":"The sovereign title remains a sovereign title.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First-known English use is reported in 1566.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":207,"id":207,"entryId":35,"entrySlug":"shah","childFormId":241,"parentFormId":242,"canonicalEdgeId":190,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"New Persian šāh continues Middle Persian šāh with the long vowel and final consonant retained.","semanticChange":"The title “king” remains stable across the Iranian language stages.","scholar":"Rüdiger Schmitt · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Encyclopaedia Iranica explicitly identifies Middle and New Persian šāh as continuations of the Old Persian title.","chronologyNote":"Middle Persian to New Persian.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":208,"id":208,"entryId":35,"entrySlug":"shah","childFormId":242,"parentFormId":243,"canonicalEdgeId":191,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"The substantially shorter Middle Persian šāh continues Old Persian xšāyaθiyā; the reviewed record does not invent every unattested intermediate sound change.","semanticChange":"The meaning “king, sovereign” remains stable.","scholar":"Rüdiger Schmitt · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The continuation is explicit, while the internal contraction history is not overstated.","chronologyNote":"Achaemenid Old Persian to Middle Persian.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":209,"id":209,"entryId":35,"entrySlug":"shah","childFormId":243,"parentFormId":244,"canonicalEdgeId":192,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"Old Persian xšāyaθiyā is analyzed through xšāy- “rule, have power, possess” and compared with dialectal Indo-European *tkeH-.","semanticChange":"Rule or possession supplies the base for a sovereign title.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster also records a materially different Lexikon der indogermanischen Verben analysis from *h₃ekʷ-; neither is promoted as consensus.","chronologyNote":"The comparison belongs to Indo-European prehistory.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":210,"id":210,"entryId":35,"entrySlug":"shah","childFormId":244,"parentFormId":245,"canonicalEdgeId":215,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the competing proposed reconstructions.","semanticChange":"The reviewed trail ends at a disputed root comparison.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":211,"id":211,"entryId":36,"entrySlug":"tea","childFormId":246,"parentFormId":247,"canonicalEdgeId":224,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English tea reflects the Dutch thee-type form; the modern /iː/ follows the wider English raising of earlier /eː/.","semanticChange":"The plant and beverage senses were retained, then English developed additional meal, social-event, infusion, and slang branches.","scholar":"Östen Dahl","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"WALS describes Dutch-mediated European diffusion, while Merriam-Webster compresses the etymology to borrowing from Xiamen Chinese. The Dutch stage is therefore shown but disputed.","chronologyNote":"English is recorded from 1655; Dutch maritime diffusion belongs to the seventeenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":212,"id":212,"entryId":36,"entrySlug":"tea","childFormId":247,"parentFormId":248,"canonicalEdgeId":225,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Dutch thee adapts the Southern Min te-type pronunciation with Dutch spelling conventions.","semanticChange":"The meaning remains tea.","scholar":"Östen Dahl","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"WALS explicitly connects Dutch contacts at Amoy/Xiamen with Dutch thee.","chronologyNote":"Dutch commercial contact with Xiamen and wider Asian maritime trade intensified in the seventeenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":213,"id":213,"entryId":36,"entrySlug":"tea","childFormId":248,"parentFormId":249,"canonicalEdgeId":226,"relationType":"sinitic_reflex","soundChange":"Southern Min te is treated as a divergent Sinitic reflex of the word reconstructed by Baxter and Sagart as Old Chinese *lˤra; the exact sound history is not reduced here to one uncontroversial rule.","semanticChange":"The plant or beverage meaning remains tea.","scholar":"Östen Dahl · William H. Baxter · Laurent Sagart","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"WALS establishes the Min Nan te family; Baxter and Sagart establish the reviewed Old Chinese reconstruction. The Min branch is not falsely routed through the later Middle Chinese *drae reading.","chronologyNote":"Old Chinese reconstruction to the historically documented Southern Min form.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":214,"id":214,"entryId":36,"entrySlug":"tea","childFormId":249,"parentFormId":250,"canonicalEdgeId":227,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond Baxter and Sagart’s *lˤra in this reviewed path.","semanticChange":"The plant-name history reaches the present editorial evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"This is a boundary of the selected evidence, not proof that no deeper proposal has ever been published.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":215,"id":215,"entryId":37,"entrySlug":"chai","childFormId":251,"parentFormId":252,"canonicalEdgeId":228,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English chai adapts the chay/cāy form as /tʃaɪ/.","semanticChange":"A general word for tea specializes in English toward South Asian-style spiced tea.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster names Hindi and Urdu among several source-language forms without selecting a single donor; the displayed Hindustani stage is representative rather than exclusive.","chronologyNote":"First known use of the modern English culinary sense: 1984.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":216,"id":216,"entryId":37,"entrySlug":"chai","childFormId":252,"parentFormId":253,"canonicalEdgeId":229,"relationType":"overland_borrowing_route","soundChange":"Hindustani cāy belongs to the cha/chay family derived from Chinese chá; the final glide and exact sequence of intermediaries are not treated as one settled sound law.","semanticChange":"The core meaning remains tea, while preparation traditions vary across receiving languages.","scholar":"Östen Dahl · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"WALS supports a broad overland cha/chai pattern, and Merriam-Webster lists multiple intermediate language forms. This edge represents the family route, not a claim of direct Hindi–Mandarin contact.","chronologyNote":"Overland transmission preceded the modern English borrowing; individual regional dates vary.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":217,"id":217,"entryId":37,"entrySlug":"chai","childFormId":253,"parentFormId":254,"canonicalEdgeId":230,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Modern Mandarin chá continues the Chinese word represented by reconstructed Middle Chinese *drae, with the onset and vowel changes summarized by the Baxter–Sagart correspondence table.","semanticChange":"The tea meaning remains stable.","scholar":"William H. Baxter · Laurent Sagart","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The modern form is attested, while the Middle Chinese phonological value is reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Middle Chinese to modern Mandarin.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":218,"id":218,"entryId":37,"entrySlug":"chai","childFormId":254,"parentFormId":255,"canonicalEdgeId":231,"relationType":"historical_reconstruction","soundChange":"Baxter and Sagart reconstruct Middle Chinese drae from Old Chinese *lˤra for the same character 茶.","semanticChange":"The gloss remains a plant name associated with tea.","scholar":"William H. Baxter · Laurent Sagart","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Both phonological stages are scholarly reconstructions even though the character and lexical tradition are historically attested.","chronologyNote":"Old Chinese to Middle Chinese.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":219,"id":219,"entryId":37,"entrySlug":"chai","childFormId":255,"parentFormId":256,"canonicalEdgeId":232,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond Baxter and Sagart’s *lˤra in this reviewed path.","semanticChange":"The plant-name history reaches the present editorial evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"This is a boundary of the selected evidence, not proof that no deeper proposal has ever been published.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":220,"id":220,"entryId":38,"entrySlug":"ten","childFormId":257,"parentFormId":258,"canonicalEdgeId":234,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Modern English ten continues the Middle English spelling with ordinary phonological stabilization.","semanticChange":"The cardinal value remains ten while later noun, rating, money, and idiomatic senses branch from it.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The English continuity and historical forms are directly reported.","chronologyNote":"Middle English to modern English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":221,"id":221,"entryId":38,"entrySlug":"ten","childFormId":258,"parentFormId":259,"canonicalEdgeId":235,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English ten continues Old English tīen and tēn with vowel shortening and spelling convergence.","semanticChange":"The cardinal meaning remains ten.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The entry explicitly supplies the Old and Middle English lineage.","chronologyNote":"Old English to Middle English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":222,"id":222,"entryId":38,"entrySlug":"ten","childFormId":259,"parentFormId":260,"canonicalEdgeId":236,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English tīen and tēn continue Germanic *tehun through West Germanic consonant loss and vowel development.","semanticChange":"The numeral meaning remains ten.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Germanic and Old English forms are given, while this edge summarizes multiple regular developments rather than one spelling substitution.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic to Old English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":223,"id":223,"entryId":38,"entrySlug":"ten","childFormId":260,"parentFormId":261,"canonicalEdgeId":237,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Germanic *tehun continues Indo-European *deḱm̥ with the initial stop shift and branch-specific treatment of the following consonant cluster.","semanticChange":"The numeral meaning remains ten.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Both references connect the Germanic and wider Indo-European numeral family; notation varies between *deḱm̥ and *dekm̥.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European to Proto-Germanic.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":224,"id":224,"entryId":38,"entrySlug":"ten","childFormId":261,"parentFormId":262,"canonicalEdgeId":238,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed Indo-European numeral.","semanticChange":"The numeral history reaches the present evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"This is an evidence boundary, not a metaphysical claim that no deeper history existed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":225,"id":225,"entryId":39,"entrySlug":"dime","childFormId":263,"parentFormId":264,"canonicalEdgeId":239,"relationType":"semantic_specialization","soundChange":"Modern dime preserves the older spelling while English pronunciation developed to /daɪm/.","semanticChange":"A general tenth-part or tithe word is applied specifically to a coin worth one tenth of a dollar.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster supplies both the older tenth-part meaning and the 1786 coin use.","chronologyNote":"Middle English ancestry; United States coin sense reported from 1786.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":226,"id":226,"entryId":39,"entrySlug":"dime","childFormId":264,"parentFormId":265,"canonicalEdgeId":240,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English dime adapts Anglo-French disme or dime, including loss of the written consonant in the simplified form.","semanticChange":"The meaning remains a tenth part or tithe.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The borrowing route is explicit in the source.","chronologyNote":"Anglo-French to Middle English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":227,"id":227,"entryId":39,"entrySlug":"dime","childFormId":265,"parentFormId":266,"canonicalEdgeId":241,"relationType":"romance_development","soundChange":"Anglo-French disme and dime continue Latin decima through regular Romance reduction and spelling change.","semanticChange":"The tenth-part and tithe meaning remains central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The source directly traces the French forms to Latin decima.","chronologyNote":"Latin to Anglo-French.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":228,"id":228,"entryId":39,"entrySlug":"dime","childFormId":266,"parentFormId":267,"canonicalEdgeId":242,"relationType":"inflectional_derivation","soundChange":"Latin decima is the feminine form of decimus.","semanticChange":"The ordinal adjective “tenth” is substantivized as a tenth part or tithe.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly identifies decima as feminine of decimus.","chronologyNote":"Latin derivation.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":229,"id":229,"entryId":39,"entrySlug":"dime","childFormId":267,"parentFormId":268,"canonicalEdgeId":171,"relationType":"ordinal_derivation","soundChange":"Latin decimus is the ordinal formation corresponding to decem.","semanticChange":"The cardinal “ten” becomes ordinal “tenth.”","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":230,"id":230,"entryId":39,"entrySlug":"dime","childFormId":268,"parentFormId":269,"canonicalEdgeId":172,"relationType":"inherited","soundChange":"Latin decem regularly continues the centum-language form of Indo-European *dekm̥.","semanticChange":"The numeral meaning “ten” remains stable.","scholar":"American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The Latin and Indo-European numeral relationship is securely comparative.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European prehistory to attested Latin.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":231,"id":231,"entryId":39,"entrySlug":"dime","childFormId":269,"parentFormId":270,"canonicalEdgeId":245,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed Indo-European numeral.","semanticChange":"The tenth-word history reaches the present evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The stop records the current evidence limit.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":232,"id":232,"entryId":40,"entrySlug":"hostel","childFormId":271,"parentFormId":272,"canonicalEdgeId":246,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Modern hostel continues the Middle English form, including its revived use after a period of reduced currency.","semanticChange":"A general inn or lodging word specializes toward inexpensive, communal, youth, and institutional accommodation.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The dictionary and family history support the medieval word and modern lodging senses.","chronologyNote":"Medieval English origin with later revival and specialization.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":233,"id":233,"entryId":40,"entrySlug":"hostel","childFormId":272,"parentFormId":273,"canonicalEdgeId":247,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English hostel borrows Anglo-French ostel or hostel with close preservation of the form.","semanticChange":"The lodging meaning remains stable.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The borrowing is directly stated.","chronologyNote":"Anglo-French to Middle English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":234,"id":234,"entryId":40,"entrySlug":"hostel","childFormId":273,"parentFormId":274,"canonicalEdgeId":248,"relationType":"romance_development","soundChange":"Anglo-French ostel or hostel continues Latin hospitāle with loss and reduction around the initial consonant cluster.","semanticChange":"Guest accommodation remains the core meaning.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The source directly gives Latin hospitāle as the predecessor.","chronologyNote":"Latin to Gallo-Romance and Anglo-French.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":235,"id":235,"entryId":40,"entrySlug":"hostel","childFormId":274,"parentFormId":275,"canonicalEdgeId":138,"relationType":"substantivization","soundChange":"Medieval Latin hospitāle is the neuter substantivization of Latin hospitālis, “of a guest; hospitable.”","semanticChange":"An adjective about guests came to name guest accommodations and then institutions of lodging and care.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":236,"id":236,"entryId":40,"entrySlug":"hostel","childFormId":275,"parentFormId":276,"canonicalEdgeId":139,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin hospitālis is formed from the stem hospit- of hospes with the adjective suffix -ālis.","semanticChange":"The host/guest relationship becomes the quality of being for guests or hospitable.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":237,"id":237,"entryId":40,"entrySlug":"hostel","childFormId":276,"parentFormId":277,"canonicalEdgeId":122,"relationType":"compound_reflex","soundChange":"Latin hospes (stem hospit-) is analyzed as a reduced reflex of the compound *ghos-pot-, with substantial phonetic reduction acknowledged by the sources.","semanticChange":"A “guest-master” encoded the reciprocal role in which the same person could be guest on one occasion and host on another.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The host/guest reciprocity is well supported; Merriam-Webster notes that the degree of phonetic reduction has led some scholars to question the precise compound etymology.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":238,"id":238,"entryId":40,"entrySlug":"hostel","childFormId":277,"parentFormId":278,"canonicalEdgeId":123,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"The first member *ghos- of *ghos-pot- continues the *ghos-ti- guest/stranger base; the compound also contains *pot- “master.”","semanticChange":"The reciprocal outsider becomes the “guest-master,” the person who stands for mutual duties of hospitality.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The compound analysis is reconstructed and has a separate *pot- component edge in the canonical graph.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":239,"id":239,"entryId":40,"entrySlug":"hostel","childFormId":278,"parentFormId":279,"canonicalEdgeId":253,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No single deeper ancestor of *ghos-ti- is selected for this dossier.","semanticChange":"The hospitality lineage reaches an explicit evidence boundary.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"A proposed *ǵhes- analysis remains a competing branch elsewhere in the graph.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":240,"id":240,"entryId":41,"entrySlug":"hospice","childFormId":280,"parentFormId":281,"canonicalEdgeId":254,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English hospice adapts French hospice with English pronunciation.","semanticChange":"A religious or charitable lodging develops toward institutional palliative care and support.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The French borrowing, 1818 first use, and older lodging sense are directly reported.","chronologyNote":"Middle French to English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":241,"id":241,"entryId":41,"entrySlug":"hospice","childFormId":281,"parentFormId":282,"canonicalEdgeId":255,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle French hospise or hospice adapts Medieval Latin hospitium, including the ending that becomes French -ce.","semanticChange":"Hospitality, lodging, and shelter remain central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The source explicitly describes the Medieval Latin borrowing and French ending.","chronologyNote":"Medieval Latin to Middle French.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":242,"id":242,"entryId":41,"entrySlug":"hospice","childFormId":282,"parentFormId":283,"canonicalEdgeId":256,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Medieval Latin hospitium is built on the hospit- stem of hospes with a denominal suffix.","semanticChange":"The host-or-guest role becomes accommodation, hospitality, or shelter.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The derivation is explicit in the hospice entry.","chronologyNote":"Latin and Medieval Latin derivation.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":243,"id":243,"entryId":41,"entrySlug":"hospice","childFormId":283,"parentFormId":284,"canonicalEdgeId":122,"relationType":"compound_reflex","soundChange":"Latin hospes (stem hospit-) is analyzed as a reduced reflex of the compound *ghos-pot-, with substantial phonetic reduction acknowledged by the sources.","semanticChange":"A “guest-master” encoded the reciprocal role in which the same person could be guest on one occasion and host on another.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The host/guest reciprocity is well supported; Merriam-Webster notes that the degree of phonetic reduction has led some scholars to question the precise compound etymology.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":244,"id":244,"entryId":41,"entrySlug":"hospice","childFormId":284,"parentFormId":285,"canonicalEdgeId":123,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"The first member *ghos- of *ghos-pot- continues the *ghos-ti- guest/stranger base; the compound also contains *pot- “master.”","semanticChange":"The reciprocal outsider becomes the “guest-master,” the person who stands for mutual duties of hospitality.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The compound analysis is reconstructed and has a separate *pot- component edge in the canonical graph.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":245,"id":245,"entryId":41,"entrySlug":"hospice","childFormId":285,"parentFormId":286,"canonicalEdgeId":259,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No single deeper ancestor of *ghos-ti- is selected for this dossier.","semanticChange":"The hospice lineage reaches an explicit evidence boundary.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Competing deeper proposals remain separate rather than silently merged.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":246,"id":246,"entryId":42,"entrySlug":"lesson","childFormId":287,"parentFormId":288,"canonicalEdgeId":260,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Modern lesson continues the Middle English form with spelling stabilization.","semanticChange":"A reading or assigned text expands into instruction and then something learned from experience.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The historical and current senses are documented in the entry.","chronologyNote":"Middle English to modern English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":247,"id":247,"entryId":42,"entrySlug":"lesson","childFormId":288,"parentFormId":289,"canonicalEdgeId":261,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English lesson or lessoun adapts Anglo-French leçon.","semanticChange":"The reading and instructional senses remain connected.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The Anglo-French borrowing is directly reported.","chronologyNote":"Anglo-French to Middle English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":248,"id":248,"entryId":42,"entrySlug":"lesson","childFormId":289,"parentFormId":290,"canonicalEdgeId":262,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French leçon continues Late Latin lectiō through regular Romance sound and spelling development.","semanticChange":"An act or selection of reading remains the source of the lesson sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The source gives Late Latin lection-, lectio as the French source.","chronologyNote":"Late Latin to Anglo-French.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":249,"id":249,"entryId":42,"entrySlug":"lesson","childFormId":290,"parentFormId":291,"canonicalEdgeId":263,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin lectiō is formed from the reading stem associated with legere.","semanticChange":"The act of gathering or selecting develops into reading, then a reading passage.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The derivation from Latin legere “to read” is explicit.","chronologyNote":"Latin derivation.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":250,"id":250,"entryId":42,"entrySlug":"lesson","childFormId":291,"parentFormId":292,"canonicalEdgeId":60,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin legere is traditionally assigned to the *leǵ- family; *sleǵ- remains a published alternative.","semanticChange":"Gathering and selecting extend into reading.","scholar":"Indo-European lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Root shape is disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":251,"id":251,"entryId":42,"entrySlug":"lesson","childFormId":292,"parentFormId":293,"canonicalEdgeId":265,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper ancestor is promoted beyond *leǵ-.","semanticChange":"The reading-and-instruction path reaches its reviewed horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary preserves uncertainty rather than naming a speculative predecessor.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":252,"id":252,"entryId":43,"entrySlug":"select","childFormId":294,"parentFormId":295,"canonicalEdgeId":266,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English select borrows Latin selectus with minor English phonological adaptation.","semanticChange":"The Latin “chosen apart” sense becomes English adjectival and verbal selection.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The source explicitly gives Latin selectus as the English source.","chronologyNote":"English adjective reported from 1565 and verb from 1566.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":253,"id":253,"entryId":43,"entrySlug":"select","childFormId":295,"parentFormId":296,"canonicalEdgeId":267,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"Latin selectus is the past participle of seligere.","semanticChange":"The action “choose apart” becomes the result “chosen.”","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The inflectional relation is explicit in the entry.","chronologyNote":"Latin morphology.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":254,"id":254,"entryId":43,"entrySlug":"select","childFormId":296,"parentFormId":297,"canonicalEdgeId":268,"relationType":"prefixed_derivation","soundChange":"Latin seligere combines se- “apart” with legere “gather, select.”","semanticChange":"Gathering becomes discriminating choice by adding the apart element.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The source explicitly decomposes se- plus legere.","chronologyNote":"Latin derivation.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":255,"id":255,"entryId":43,"entrySlug":"select","childFormId":297,"parentFormId":298,"canonicalEdgeId":60,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin legere is traditionally assigned to the *leǵ- family; *sleǵ- remains a published alternative.","semanticChange":"Gathering and selecting extend into reading.","scholar":"Indo-European lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Root shape is disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":256,"id":256,"entryId":43,"entrySlug":"select","childFormId":298,"parentFormId":299,"canonicalEdgeId":270,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper ancestor is promoted beyond *leǵ-.","semanticChange":"The gathering-and-selection path reaches its reviewed horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary prevents a decorative but uncited deeper root.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":257,"id":257,"entryId":44,"entrySlug":"hostis","childFormId":300,"parentFormId":301,"canonicalEdgeId":133,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin hostis continues *ghos-ti-; the inherited word first denoted a foreigner or stranger and later narrowed to an enemy.","semanticChange":"The reciprocal or legally recognized outsider becomes the hostile outsider and enemy as Roman usage changes.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots · University of Texas LRC","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The family connection is strong; the semantic narrowing unfolded historically rather than at one recoverable moment.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":258,"id":258,"entryId":44,"entrySlug":"hostis","childFormId":301,"parentFormId":302,"canonicalEdgeId":272,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *ghos-ti- reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The outsider history reaches the present evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"A proposed deeper *ǵhes- analysis remains separately labeled proposed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":259,"id":259,"entryId":45,"entrySlug":"mys","childFormId":303,"parentFormId":304,"canonicalEdgeId":273,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Ancient long /yː/ develops through Greek iotacism to Modern Greek /i/, while polytonic μῦς is written monotonic μυς.","semanticChange":"The anatomical muscle sense becomes the ordinary modern center; the mouse sense survives as learned vocabulary while everyday Greek normally uses another rodent word.","scholar":"Centre for the Greek Language editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Both the modern anatomical entry and its Ancient Greek source are directly documented.","chronologyNote":"Ancient Greek to Modern Greek.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":260,"id":260,"entryId":45,"entrySlug":"mys","childFormId":304,"parentFormId":305,"canonicalEdgeId":274,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Greek μῦς preserves the inherited long-vowel mouse stem represented by reconstructed *mūs-; the inflected stem appears as μυ-.","semanticChange":"The inherited mouse word also acquires the anatomical muscle sense within Greek.","scholar":"Liddell and Scott · American Heritage Dictionary Editors · University of Texas LRC","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Greek form and polysemy are attested; the Indo-European ancestor is reconstructed by cross-branch comparison.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European prehistory to attested Ancient Greek.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":261,"id":261,"entryId":45,"entrySlug":"mys","childFormId":305,"parentFormId":306,"canonicalEdgeId":275,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed Indo-European *mūs- reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The mouse-and-muscle history reaches the present evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"This is an evidence boundary, not a claim that no deeper proposal exists.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":262,"id":262,"entryId":46,"entrySlug":"nescience","childFormId":307,"parentFormId":308,"canonicalEdgeId":276,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Late Latin nescientia is adapted into English nescience with loss of the Latin ending and English stress and consonant development.","semanticChange":"The abstract meaning remains lack of knowledge or awareness.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The borrowing path and 1612 English record are directly reported.","chronologyNote":"Late Latin to English by 1612.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":263,"id":263,"entryId":46,"entrySlug":"nescience","childFormId":308,"parentFormId":309,"canonicalEdgeId":277,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Late Latin nescientia is built on the present-participial stem nescient- of nesciens.","semanticChange":"A not-knowing person or state supplies the abstract noun for ignorance.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The morphological sequence is explicit in the etymology.","chronologyNote":"Late Latin derivation.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":264,"id":264,"entryId":46,"entrySlug":"nescience","childFormId":309,"parentFormId":310,"canonicalEdgeId":278,"relationType":"inflectional_derivation","soundChange":"Latin nesciens is the present participle of nescīre.","semanticChange":"The activity or state of not knowing is expressed as “not knowing.”","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The participial relationship is explicit in the etymology.","chronologyNote":"Latin derivation.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":265,"id":265,"entryId":46,"entrySlug":"nescience","childFormId":310,"parentFormId":311,"canonicalEdgeId":159,"relationType":"negative_compound","soundChange":"Latin nescīre contains the negative element ne- plus scīre “to know.”","semanticChange":"Knowing is negated: “know” becomes “not know, be unfamiliar with.”","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The internal Latin negative relationship is secure even though the deeper prehistory of scīre is disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":266,"id":266,"entryId":46,"entrySlug":"nescience","childFormId":311,"parentFormId":312,"canonicalEdgeId":160,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"Latin scīre has been compared with an Indo-European cutting/separating base; the exact formation and even the semantic bridge remain disputed.","semanticChange":"A proposed development moves from cutting or separating to distinguishing and then knowing.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · de Vaan · Ernout and Meillet · American Heritage","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster records competing morphological analyses and calls the semantic progression questionable; Ernout and Meillet call the comparison uncertain.","chronologyNote":"The comparison belongs to prehistory, not a directly attested change.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":267,"id":267,"entryId":46,"entrySlug":"nescience","childFormId":312,"parentFormId":313,"canonicalEdgeId":281,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed *skei- comparison.","semanticChange":"The negative-knowing history reaches the present evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary preserves the difference between a proposed reconstruction and a securely attested ancestor.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":268,"id":268,"entryId":47,"entrySlug":"liebe","childFormId":314,"parentFormId":315,"canonicalEdgeId":282,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle High German liebe continues into modern German Liebe with capitalization of the noun and standardization of spelling and pronunciation.","semanticChange":"The inherited abstract noun remains centered on affection while broadening across personal, religious, and object-directed uses.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The immediate Middle High German stage is explicit in the modern dictionary.","chronologyNote":"Middle High German to present-day German.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":269,"id":269,"entryId":47,"entrySlug":"liebe","childFormId":315,"parentFormId":316,"canonicalEdgeId":283,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old High German liubī develops into Middle High German liebe through regular High German vowel and ending development.","semanticChange":"Love, favor, pleasure, and affection remain overlapping parts of the semantic field.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion · Rosemarie Lühr","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Both historical stages and their continuity are directly reported.","chronologyNote":"Old High German to Middle High German.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":270,"id":270,"entryId":47,"entrySlug":"liebe","childFormId":316,"parentFormId":317,"canonicalEdgeId":284,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old High German liubī reflects the reconstructed Germanic feminine abstract formation *leubīn, with inherited diphthong and later High German reshaping.","semanticChange":"The abstract meaning remains love, affection, esteem, or pleasure.","scholar":"Rosemarie Lühr","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Old High German form is attested; the Germanic parent is reconstructed from comparative morphology.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic prehistory to Old High German records from the tenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":271,"id":271,"entryId":47,"entrySlug":"liebe","childFormId":317,"parentFormId":318,"canonicalEdgeId":285,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Germanic *leubīn is an abstract-noun formation within the *lewbʰ- desire-and-care family.","semanticChange":"A broad root meaning care for, desire, or love yields a noun for affection and pleasure.","scholar":"Rosemarie Lühr · Guus Kroonen · University of Texas LRC","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The morphological comparison is published, but the parent root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European to Proto-Germanic prehistory.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":272,"id":272,"entryId":47,"entrySlug":"liebe","childFormId":318,"parentFormId":319,"canonicalEdgeId":286,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *lewbʰ- reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The German love-noun history reaches the current secure evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"This is an explicit knowledge boundary, not a claim that no deeper proposal has ever been made.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":273,"id":273,"entryId":48,"entrySlug":"lief","childFormId":320,"parentFormId":321,"canonicalEdgeId":287,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle Dutch lief continues into modern Dutch lief with stable spelling and later standardization of pronunciation and inflection.","semanticChange":"Dear, beloved, pleasant, and kind remain within the inherited adjective’s semantic range.","scholar":"Instituut voor de Nederlandse Taal editors · N. van Wijk","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Modern grammar and the historical form are directly documented.","chronologyNote":"Middle Dutch to present-day Dutch.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":274,"id":274,"entryId":48,"entrySlug":"lief","childFormId":321,"parentFormId":322,"canonicalEdgeId":288,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle Dutch lief reflects the West Germanic continuation of reconstructed *leubaz, including the diphthong history represented by Dutch ie and final f.","semanticChange":"The adjective preserves the sense dear, beloved, or pleasing.","scholar":"N. van Wijk · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Dutch form is attested; the Proto-Germanic parent and exact sound stages are comparative reconstructions.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic prehistory to Middle Dutch.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":275,"id":275,"entryId":48,"entrySlug":"lief","childFormId":322,"parentFormId":323,"canonicalEdgeId":289,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *leubaz continues the *lewbʰ- family with Germanic *b corresponding to Indo-European *bʰ and adjective-stem formation.","semanticChange":"A broad field of caring, desiring, and loving develops the adjective sense dear, beloved, or pleasing.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen · University of Texas LRC","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The cross-branch comparison is strong, while both parent forms are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European to Proto-Germanic prehistory.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":276,"id":276,"entryId":48,"entrySlug":"lief","childFormId":323,"parentFormId":324,"canonicalEdgeId":290,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *lewbʰ- reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The Dutch adjective history reaches the current secure evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary preserves the difference between reviewed reconstruction and unknown deeper prehistory.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":277,"id":277,"entryId":49,"entrySlug":"liufs","childFormId":325,"parentFormId":326,"canonicalEdgeId":291,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *eu is reflected as Gothic iu; the stem-final fricative appears as f in the normalized nominative liufs and as b in manuscript inflections such as liuba and liubans.","semanticChange":"The sense dear or beloved remains stable in the surviving biblical uses.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen · Wilhelm Streitberg · Project Wulfila editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The inflectional alternation is manuscript-attested; the Proto-Germanic parent and phonological staging are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic prehistory to the fourth-century Gothic translation tradition and early-sixth-century manuscript.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":278,"id":278,"entryId":49,"entrySlug":"liufs","childFormId":326,"parentFormId":327,"canonicalEdgeId":289,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *leubaz continues the *lewbʰ- family with Germanic *b corresponding to Indo-European *bʰ and adjective-stem formation.","semanticChange":"A broad field of caring, desiring, and loving develops the adjective sense dear, beloved, or pleasing.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen · University of Texas LRC","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The cross-branch comparison is strong, while both parent forms are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European to Proto-Germanic prehistory.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":279,"id":279,"entryId":49,"entrySlug":"liufs","childFormId":327,"parentFormId":328,"canonicalEdgeId":293,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *lewbʰ- reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The Gothic adjective history reaches the current secure evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary keeps the attested Gothic lexeme separate from unknown deeper prehistory.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":280,"id":280,"entryId":50,"entrySlug":"lieb","childFormId":329,"parentFormId":330,"canonicalEdgeId":294,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle High German liep continues into modern German lieb through regular final devoicing in pronunciation and later spelling standardization.","semanticChange":"The inherited field of dear, beloved, pleasing, and welcome remains productive, with later kind or well-behaved uses in particular contexts.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Duden explicitly supplies the Middle High German form and the modern adjective’s living senses.","chronologyNote":"Middle High German to present-day German.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":281,"id":281,"entryId":50,"entrySlug":"lieb","childFormId":330,"parentFormId":331,"canonicalEdgeId":295,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old High German liob develops into Middle High German liep with the inherited diphthong and High German obstruent pattern reflected in the historical spellings.","semanticChange":"The adjective remains centered on what is dear, beloved, or pleasing.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Duden publishes the immediate Old High German and Middle High German sequence.","chronologyNote":"Old High German to Middle High German.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":282,"id":282,"entryId":50,"entrySlug":"lieb","childFormId":331,"parentFormId":332,"canonicalEdgeId":296,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old High German liob reflects the West Germanic continuation of reconstructed *leubaz, with the inherited diphthong and consonant represented in the daughter form.","semanticChange":"The adjective preserves the sense dear, beloved, or pleasing.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Old High German form is attested; its Proto-Germanic parent and precise phonological staging are comparative reconstructions.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic prehistory to the Old High German textual period.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":283,"id":283,"entryId":50,"entrySlug":"lieb","childFormId":332,"parentFormId":333,"canonicalEdgeId":289,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *leubaz continues the *lewbʰ- family with Germanic *b corresponding to Indo-European *bʰ and adjective-stem formation.","semanticChange":"A broad field of caring, desiring, and loving develops the adjective sense dear, beloved, or pleasing.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen · University of Texas LRC","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The cross-branch comparison is strong, while both parent forms are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European to Proto-Germanic prehistory.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":284,"id":284,"entryId":50,"entrySlug":"lieb","childFormId":333,"parentFormId":334,"canonicalEdgeId":298,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *lewbʰ- reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The German adjective history reaches the current secure evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary preserves the distinction between reviewed reconstruction and unknown deeper prehistory.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":285,"id":285,"entryId":51,"entrySlug":"emoji","childFormId":335,"parentFormId":336,"canonicalEdgeId":299,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Japanese emoji was romanized and adapted to English phonology without treating its spelling as an English compound.","semanticChange":"Japanese “picture character” entered English as the name for the digital symbols.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Unicode Consortium","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Both sources explicitly identify the Japanese word and its two components.","chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports English use by 1997.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":286,"id":286,"entryId":51,"entrySlug":"emoji","childFormId":336,"parentFormId":337,"canonicalEdgeId":300,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No single predecessor form is asserted because 絵文字 is synchronically analyzable as a two-component Japanese compound.","semanticChange":"The whole-word lineage stops while the canonical graph branches into “picture” and “written character.”","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Unicode Consortium","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"This is a topology boundary, not a claim that the Japanese components have no histories of their own.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":287,"id":287,"entryId":52,"entrySlug":"sauna","childFormId":338,"parentFormId":339,"canonicalEdgeId":301,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Finnish sauna entered English with only modest adaptation to English pronunciation.","semanticChange":"The Finnish bath and bathhouse word retained its central referent in English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly gives Finnish as the source language.","chronologyNote":"English first known use is reported as 1881.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":288,"id":288,"entryId":52,"entrySlug":"sauna","childFormId":339,"parentFormId":340,"canonicalEdgeId":302,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Modern Finnish sauna continues reconstructed Proto-Finnic *sakna through Finnic sound development; the intermediate changes are not over-specified here.","semanticChange":"The sauna or bath-building sense continues, while an earlier stove reference remains tied to the deeper proposal.","scholar":"Petri Kallio · Kotus editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Finnish form is attested and the Proto-Finnic form is comparative reconstruction.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Finnic prehistory to attested Finnish.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":289,"id":289,"entryId":52,"entrySlug":"sauna","childFormId":340,"parentFormId":341,"canonicalEdgeId":303,"relationType":"proposed_borrowing","soundChange":"Kallio compares Proto-Finnic *sakna with Palaeo-Germanic *stagh-ná- as an ancient borrowing adapted to Finnic phonotactics.","semanticChange":"A Germanic pile or stack term is proposed to have named a stone-pile stove, then the sauna containing it.","scholar":"Petri Kallio · Jussi Ylikoski","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Kotus says the Germanic proposal has gained support; Ylikoski also records explicit scholarly skepticism.","chronologyNote":"Proposed prehistoric borrowing before attested Finnish.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":290,"id":290,"entryId":52,"entrySlug":"sauna","childFormId":341,"parentFormId":342,"canonicalEdgeId":304,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted beyond the disputed Palaeo-Germanic reconstruction in this dossier.","semanticChange":"The dossier reaches the current reviewed proposal and stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"A proposed donor form is not converted into a certain ancestral chain.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":291,"id":291,"entryId":53,"entrySlug":"ubuntu","childFormId":343,"parentFormId":344,"canonicalEdgeId":305,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"The Nguni form was adopted into South African English with the source-language spelling substantially preserved.","semanticChange":"A word for humanity or goodness became an English philosophical and ethical term.","scholar":"Dictionary of South African English Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The dictionary names both isiXhosa and isiZulu; the dossier uses isiZulu as one representative route while the canonical graph preserves isiXhosa as a parallel competing donor.","chronologyNote":"The English record is attested by 1926.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":292,"id":292,"entryId":53,"entrySlug":"ubuntu","childFormId":344,"parentFormId":345,"canonicalEdgeId":306,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No single whole-word predecessor is asserted because ubuntu is morphologically analyzable and the source-language route is not uniquely isolated.","semanticChange":"The whole-word lineage stops while the graph exposes the abstract prefix and human stem.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Praeg and Magadla","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary prevents a productive Bantu noun-class formation from being flattened into one fictional lexical parent.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":293,"id":293,"entryId":54,"entrySlug":"taboo","childFormId":346,"parentFormId":347,"canonicalEdgeId":312,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Tongan tabu was adapted to the English spelling taboo and English phonology.","semanticChange":"A Polynesian field joining sacredness and prohibition became an English noun, adjective, and verb for prohibited things and acts.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · POLLEX editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly identifies Tongan tabu; POLLEX documents the Tongan forms and semantic range.","chronologyNote":"English record by 1777.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":294,"id":294,"entryId":54,"entrySlug":"taboo","childFormId":347,"parentFormId":348,"canonicalEdgeId":313,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"POLLEX compares Tongan tapu with Proto-Oceanic *tampu; intermediate Polynesian developments are not over-specified here.","semanticChange":"The sacred, prohibited, and ritual-restriction field remains continuous across the comparison.","scholar":"POLLEX editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The modern form is attested while the Proto-Oceanic form is a comparative reconstruction.","chronologyNote":"Reconstructed Oceanic prehistory to attested Tongan.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":295,"id":295,"entryId":54,"entrySlug":"taboo","childFormId":348,"parentFormId":349,"canonicalEdgeId":314,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted beyond the Proto-Oceanic reconstruction in the reviewed comparative entry.","semanticChange":"The dossier reaches the current reviewed reconstruction and stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · POLLEX editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"This is an evidence boundary, not a universal claim that no deeper comparison could ever be proposed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":296,"id":296,"entryId":55,"entrySlug":"kayak","childFormId":350,"parentFormId":351,"canonicalEdgeId":315,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Inuit qayaq was adapted to the English spelling kayak and English pronunciation.","semanticChange":"The Indigenous Arctic watercraft name retained its central referent in English and later expanded to modern recreational craft.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly gives Inuit qayaq, but does not identify one source variety.","chronologyNote":"English record by 1757.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":297,"id":297,"entryId":55,"entrySlug":"kayak","childFormId":351,"parentFormId":352,"canonicalEdgeId":316,"relationType":"proposed_inheritance","soundChange":"The broad Inuit qayaq form is compared with Proto-Eskimo *qan-yaq; the notation is source-dependent and does not identify one modern donor variety.","semanticChange":"The kayak or skin-boat referent remains central across the comparison.","scholar":"José Andrés Alonso de la Fuente","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"A specialist philological analysis supports a distinct Eskimo reconstruction, while the English dictionary supplies only the broad label Inuit.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Eskimo reconstruction precedes attested Inuit forms.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":298,"id":298,"entryId":56,"entrySlug":"hammock","childFormId":353,"parentFormId":354,"canonicalEdgeId":317,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Spanish hamaca was adapted to English hammock with final consonant and vowel changes reflected in English spelling and pronunciation.","semanticChange":"The suspended sleeping net or bed retained its core function in English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly gives Spanish hamaca as the immediate source.","chronologyNote":"English suspended-bed sense recorded by 1626.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":299,"id":299,"entryId":56,"entrySlug":"hammock","childFormId":354,"parentFormId":355,"canonicalEdgeId":318,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Spanish retained the Taíno form hamaca with little visible adaptation in the spelling reported by the RAE.","semanticChange":"The Indigenous Caribbean suspended-bed referent continued in Spanish.","scholar":"RAE · ASALE editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The RAE explicitly derives Spanish hamaca from Taíno hamaca.","chronologyNote":"Colonial-era transfer into Spanish; no invented exact year.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":300,"id":300,"entryId":56,"entrySlug":"hammock","childFormId":355,"parentFormId":356,"canonicalEdgeId":319,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted beyond Taíno hamaca in the reviewed dictionaries.","semanticChange":"The lexical route reaches the Indigenous Caribbean source and stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · RAE · ASALE editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The absence of a deeper promoted form is disclosed rather than filled with a speculative reconstruction.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":301,"id":301,"entryId":57,"entrySlug":"avocado","childFormId":357,"parentFormId":358,"canonicalEdgeId":320,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English avocado reshaped Spanish aguacate, changing both consonants and the ending in the adopted form.","semanticChange":"The fruit and tree senses continued into English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly calls avocado a modification of Spanish aguacate.","chronologyNote":"English record by 1696.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":302,"id":302,"entryId":57,"entrySlug":"avocado","childFormId":358,"parentFormId":359,"canonicalEdgeId":321,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Spanish aguacate adapted Nahuatl āhuacatl to Spanish phonology and spelling.","semanticChange":"The avocado sense was carried into Spanish, while the source word’s testicle sense did not become the ordinary Spanish fruit meaning.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · RAE · ASALE editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Both dictionaries explicitly give Nahuatl āhuacatl or ahuacatl and document its avocado and testicle senses.","chronologyNote":"Colonial-era transfer into Spanish; no invented exact year.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":303,"id":303,"entryId":57,"entrySlug":"avocado","childFormId":359,"parentFormId":360,"canonicalEdgeId":322,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form or direction of derivation between the two Nahuatl senses is promoted from the reviewed sources.","semanticChange":"The dossier preserves the attested polysemy and stops before an unsupported origin story.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Merriam-Webster Editors · RAE · ASALE editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"A source word having two senses does not by itself establish which sense motivated the other.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":304,"id":304,"entryId":58,"entrySlug":"boomerang","childFormId":361,"parentFormId":362,"canonicalEdgeId":323,"relationType":"proposed_borrowing","soundChange":"English boomerang is compared with Dharug bumarin, with substantial early spelling variation in colonial records.","semanticChange":"An Aboriginal Australian name for a missile or club became the international English object name and later a recoil metaphor.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Australian National Dictionary Centre","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster assigns Dharug; ANU says the exact Aboriginal source language is still uncertain.","chronologyNote":"English record by 1824; early colonial borrowing in the Sydney region.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":305,"id":305,"entryId":58,"entrySlug":"boomerang","childFormId":362,"parentFormId":363,"canonicalEdgeId":324,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The linear dossier stops because neither one donor language nor a deeper ancestor is securely established by the reviewed evidence.","semanticChange":"The source attribution remains open rather than being flattened into one definitive lineage.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Australian National Dictionary Centre","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The canonical graph retains a competing Dharawal candidate and citations on both paths.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":306,"id":306,"entryId":59,"entrySlug":"mango","childFormId":364,"parentFormId":365,"canonicalEdgeId":326,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Portuguese manga was adapted with the English ending and vowel represented by mango.","semanticChange":"The fruit and tree referent remained central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly identifies Portuguese manga as the immediate source.","chronologyNote":"English record by 1582.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":307,"id":307,"entryId":59,"entrySlug":"mango","childFormId":365,"parentFormId":366,"canonicalEdgeId":327,"relationType":"proposed_borrowing","soundChange":"Portuguese manga closely reflects Malayalam māṅṅa; the nasal and final vowel were accommodated in Portuguese spelling.","semanticChange":"The mango-fruit referent remained stable.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Hermann Gundert","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “probably from Malayalam”; Gundert independently attests the Malayalam form.","chronologyNote":"Indian Ocean contact before the English record; no invented transfer year.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":308,"id":308,"entryId":59,"entrySlug":"mango","childFormId":366,"parentFormId":367,"canonicalEdgeId":328,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper Dravidian reconstruction is promoted from the reviewed sources.","semanticChange":"The reviewed route reaches Malayalam and stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary distinguishes an attested source word from deeper comparisons not reviewed in this tranche.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":309,"id":309,"entryId":60,"entrySlug":"jaguar","childFormId":368,"parentFormId":369,"canonicalEdgeId":329,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Portuguese jaguar entered English with pronunciation adapted to English patterns.","semanticChange":"The large-cat referent continued into English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly gives Portuguese as the immediate source.","chronologyNote":"English record by 1604.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":310,"id":310,"entryId":60,"entrySlug":"jaguar","childFormId":369,"parentFormId":370,"canonicalEdgeId":330,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Portuguese jaguar reflects Tupi jawára or jaguara with adaptation to Portuguese spelling.","semanticChange":"A broader Tupi large-carnivore name became specialized as the jaguar species name in European languages.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · CNRTL editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly gives Tupi jawára and its broad gloss; CNRTL documents historical variants and specialization.","chronologyNote":"Colonial-era Brazilian transmission; no invented exact year.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":311,"id":311,"entryId":60,"entrySlug":"jaguar","childFormId":370,"parentFormId":371,"canonicalEdgeId":331,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper ancestor is promoted beyond the attested Tupi source.","semanticChange":"The lexical path reaches the Indigenous Brazilian form and stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reviewed sources do not establish a deeper form.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":312,"id":312,"entryId":61,"entrySlug":"moose","childFormId":372,"parentFormId":373,"canonicalEdgeId":332,"relationType":"proposed_borrowing","soundChange":"English moose reflects a closely matching Eastern Algonquian animal name such as moos or mos.","semanticChange":"The animal referent remained stable.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Canadian Language Museum","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Algonquian origin is secure, but the exact donor variety is not uniquely established in the reviewed evidence.","chronologyNote":"English record by 1603.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":313,"id":313,"entryId":61,"entrySlug":"moose","childFormId":373,"parentFormId":374,"canonicalEdgeId":333,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The donor variety and deeper reconstructed path are not promoted beyond the evidence reviewed here.","semanticChange":"The route stops rather than converting cognates into a false direct lineage.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Massachusett and Eastern Abenaki forms support the family attribution without uniquely identifying the borrowing event.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":314,"id":314,"entryId":62,"entrySlug":"bayou","childFormId":375,"parentFormId":376,"canonicalEdgeId":334,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Louisiana French bayouque was shortened and anglicized as bayou.","semanticChange":"The watercourse sense continued and broadened in English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly identifies Louisiana French bayouque.","chronologyNote":"Louisiana French record in 1723; English first-known use in 1763.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":315,"id":315,"entryId":62,"entrySlug":"bayou","childFormId":376,"parentFormId":377,"canonicalEdgeId":335,"relationType":"proposed_borrowing","soundChange":"Louisiana French bayouque is compared with reconstructed early Choctaw *bayok.","semanticChange":"A local watercourse label is proposed to have entered colonial Louisiana French.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Handbook of North American Indians editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster calls the Choctaw route possible and explains both the supporting place-name evidence and the absence of secure later bayuk attestations.","chronologyNote":"Proposed early colonial contact route.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":316,"id":316,"entryId":62,"entrySlug":"bayou","childFormId":377,"parentFormId":378,"canonicalEdgeId":336,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted beyond the insecure early Choctaw reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The trail stops at a hypothesis whose limitations are visible.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Modern bók is related contextual evidence; derivation from *bayok is not treated as established.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":317,"id":317,"entryId":63,"entrySlug":"yogurt","childFormId":379,"parentFormId":380,"canonicalEdgeId":337,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Turkish yoğurt was adapted to English spelling and pronunciation as yogurt or yoghurt.","semanticChange":"The fermented milk referent remained central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Türk Dil Kurumu","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly identifies Turkish yoğurt; TDK documents the modern Turkish word.","chronologyNote":"English record by 1625.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":318,"id":318,"entryId":63,"entrySlug":"yogurt","childFormId":380,"parentFormId":381,"canonicalEdgeId":338,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"The noun yoğurt is analyzed in relation to the verbal base yogur- or modern yoğur-.","semanticChange":"A process word for kneading or working a mixture is proposed as the morphological base of the food noun.","scholar":"Emin Erdem Özbek","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Özbek reviews historical forms and argues for the structural and semantic relation; the site preserves the proposal label.","chronologyNote":"Historical Turkic development before modern Turkish; no invented exact date.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":319,"id":319,"entryId":63,"entrySlug":"yogurt","childFormId":381,"parentFormId":382,"canonicalEdgeId":339,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper reconstructed Turkic base is promoted from the reviewed sources.","semanticChange":"The linguistic path stops separately from claims about the food’s prehistoric invention.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Lexical ancestry does not establish the origin place or inventor of fermented milk.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":320,"id":320,"entryId":64,"entrySlug":"shaman","childFormId":383,"parentFormId":384,"canonicalEdgeId":340,"relationType":"borrowing_via_competing_routes","soundChange":"English shaman is ultimately from Evenki šamān; Russian and German mediation are historically discussed, but one fully specified immediate chain is not forced into this edge.","semanticChange":"A specific Siberian practitioner name was generalized in European scholarship across diverse traditions.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Andrei A. Znamenski","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster identifies the ultimate Evenki source; Znamenski documents its transmission and Western generalization.","chronologyNote":"English record by 1698; European transmission around the turn of the eighteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":321,"id":321,"entryId":64,"entrySlug":"shaman","childFormId":384,"parentFormId":385,"canonicalEdgeId":341,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"Competing Tungusic-internal and Buddhist Central Asian ancestry theories prevent a secure deeper promotion.","semanticChange":"The path stops at Evenki while the wider-origin debate remains visible.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Peter Zieme","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"A formal resemblance to Sanskrit śramaṇa and its Central Asian descendants is not treated as a proven ancestor of Evenki šamān.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":322,"id":322,"entryId":65,"entrySlug":"kimchi","childFormId":386,"parentFormId":387,"canonicalEdgeId":343,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English kimchi adapts Korean 김치 through the established romanized spelling; kimchee is a secondary English variant.","semanticChange":"The name of the fermented preparation travels with the food category.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors · National Institute of Korean Language","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"English first-known-use report: 1888.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":323,"id":323,"entryId":65,"entrySlug":"kimchi","childFormId":387,"parentFormId":388,"canonicalEdgeId":344,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The reviewed sources establish the living Korean form but do not supply a securely sourced deeper lexical chain.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at 김치 rather than turning orthographic history into unsupported ancestry.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":324,"id":324,"entryId":66,"entrySlug":"llama","childFormId":389,"parentFormId":390,"canonicalEdgeId":345,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English retains the Spanish spelling while adapting pronunciation.","semanticChange":"The animal name remains stable through the borrowing.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"English first-known-use report: 1600.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":325,"id":325,"entryId":66,"entrySlug":"llama","childFormId":390,"parentFormId":391,"canonicalEdgeId":346,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Spanish adopted Quechua llama with little visible alteration.","semanticChange":"The Quechua animal name remained the animal label.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · RAE editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Colonial Spanish transmission preceded the English record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":326,"id":326,"entryId":66,"entrySlug":"llama","childFormId":391,"parentFormId":392,"canonicalEdgeId":347,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The reviewed sources identify Quechua but do not present a deeper reconstruction or a uniquely localized donor variety.","semanticChange":"The trail ends at the attested Quechua animal word.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":327,"id":327,"entryId":67,"entrySlug":"alpaca","childFormId":393,"parentFormId":394,"canonicalEdgeId":348,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English adopted Spanish alpaca with pronunciation adaptation.","semanticChange":"Animal, fiber, and cloth senses expanded in English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"English first-known-use report: 1747.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":328,"id":328,"entryId":67,"entrySlug":"alpaca","childFormId":394,"parentFormId":395,"canonicalEdgeId":349,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Spanish adapted an Aymara form represented as allpaqa, all-paka, or modern official allphaqa.","semanticChange":"The Aymara animal name remained the animal label and later supported fiber and cloth senses.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · RAE · Peruvian Ministry of Education editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The sources use different orthographies for the Aymara form, not different etymologies.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":329,"id":329,"entryId":67,"entrySlug":"alpaca","childFormId":395,"parentFormId":396,"canonicalEdgeId":350,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper Aymaran reconstruction is supplied by the reviewed sources.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the attested Aymara animal word.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":330,"id":330,"entryId":68,"entrySlug":"tipi","childFormId":397,"parentFormId":398,"canonicalEdgeId":351,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"The English spelling family tepee / teepee / tipi adapts Dakota thípi and regularizes its sounds in English.","semanticChange":"A Dakota dwelling term becomes an English name for a specific Great Plains dwelling form.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The spelling-family first-known-use report is 1743.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":331,"id":331,"entryId":68,"entrySlug":"tipi","childFormId":398,"parentFormId":399,"canonicalEdgeId":352,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Dakota thípi is formed on thí- “to dwell”; the final morphology is treated conservatively rather than assigned a folk literal gloss.","semanticChange":"The act or state of dwelling supplies a noun for a dwelling.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":332,"id":332,"entryId":68,"entrySlug":"tipi","childFormId":399,"parentFormId":400,"canonicalEdgeId":353,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Attested Dakota thí- continues reconstructed Proto-Dakota *thí with stable initial aspiration and stressed vowel.","semanticChange":"The dwelling meaning remains stable.","scholar":"Rankin et al., Comparative Siouan Dictionary","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":333,"id":333,"entryId":68,"entrySlug":"tipi","childFormId":400,"parentFormId":401,"canonicalEdgeId":354,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Dakota *thí continues Proto-Mississippi Valley Siouan *htí with subgroup-specific ordering and aspiration development.","semanticChange":"The dwelling and house field remains stable.","scholar":"Rankin et al., Comparative Siouan Dictionary","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":334,"id":334,"entryId":68,"entrySlug":"tipi","childFormId":401,"parentFormId":402,"canonicalEdgeId":355,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Mississippi Valley Siouan *htí continues Proto-Siouan *ahtí• with loss or reanalysis of the initial vowel and inherited consonantal material.","semanticChange":"The reconstructed field remains dwell, dwelling, house.","scholar":"Rankin et al., Comparative Siouan Dictionary","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":335,"id":335,"entryId":68,"entrySlug":"tipi","childFormId":402,"parentFormId":403,"canonicalEdgeId":356,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The comparative dictionary presents *ahtí• as the Proto-Siouan horizon for this set; no deeper ancestor is promoted here.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the reviewed comparative reconstruction ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":336,"id":336,"entryId":69,"entrySlug":"hogan","childFormId":404,"parentFormId":405,"canonicalEdgeId":357,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English hogan anglicizes Navajo hooghan, shortening the long vowel and regularizing the consonant and unstressed ending.","semanticChange":"A Diné home or dwelling term becomes the English label for the traditional structure.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Navajo Word of the Day editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"English first-known-use report: 1871.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":337,"id":337,"entryId":69,"entrySlug":"hogan","childFormId":405,"parentFormId":406,"canonicalEdgeId":358,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The reviewed sources establish hooghan but do not provide a specialist comparative Athabaskan reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the living Navajo word rather than promoting an unsourced internal split.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":338,"id":338,"entryId":70,"entrySlug":"poncho","childFormId":407,"parentFormId":408,"canonicalEdgeId":359,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English borrowed American Spanish poncho with limited phonological adaptation.","semanticChange":"The garment sense remains central and later extends to rainwear.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"English first-known-use report: 1717.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":339,"id":339,"entryId":70,"entrySlug":"poncho","childFormId":408,"parentFormId":409,"canonicalEdgeId":360,"relationType":"proposed_borrowing","soundChange":"One analysis derives American Spanish poncho from Mapuche forms such as pontho / ponchu / pontro; competing scholarship argues that the Indigenous forms may instead reflect Spanish.","semanticChange":"A blanket or textile term and the sleeveless garment label are historically associated, but the direction of transfer is unresolved.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Sánchez Cabezas · RAE · Iwasaki","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster and Sánchez support a Mapuche route; RAE and Iwasaki support or favor a Spanish-internal route.","chronologyNote":"Spanish records and Mapuche lexicography overlap too closely for this dossier to declare one direction proven.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":340,"id":340,"entryId":70,"entrySlug":"poncho","childFormId":409,"parentFormId":410,"canonicalEdgeId":361,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"Competing Mapuche and Spanish analyses prevent a single secure deeper chain.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the dispute instead of converting a proposal into fact.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":341,"id":341,"entryId":28,"entrySlug":"science","childFormId":411,"parentFormId":185,"canonicalEdgeId":363,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English science / cience stabilizes as Early Modern science.","semanticChange":"Knowledge and learning remain broad while an organized branch or body of knowledge becomes a salient application.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · John Harris","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The 1704 printed witness establishes this historical sense in use; it does not date the sense’s beginning.","chronologyNote":"Middle English into Early Modern English; the branch-of-knowledge sense is directly witnessed in 1704.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":342,"id":342,"entryId":71,"entrySlug":"clew","childFormId":412,"parentFormId":413,"canonicalEdgeId":364,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English clew / clewe survives as Modern English clew with loss of inflection and stabilized spelling.","semanticChange":"The literal thread-ball sense survives; nautical senses develop from the corner or fastening of a sail and the guiding spelling clue diverges later.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The modern spelling overlaps chronologically with the historical evidence sense.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":343,"id":343,"entryId":71,"entrySlug":"clew","childFormId":413,"parentFormId":414,"canonicalEdgeId":22,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English vowel sequence and inflection simplified in Middle English.","semanticChange":"A concrete ball or wound thread was retained.","scholar":"Bosworth–Toller · historical lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":344,"id":344,"entryId":71,"entrySlug":"clew","childFormId":414,"parentFormId":415,"canonicalEdgeId":366,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The reviewed sources compare related forms but do not promote one direct ancestor beyond Old English cliewen.","semanticChange":"The thread-ball history reaches the current evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Akin forms are preserved as relatives, not converted into a linear parent.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":345,"id":345,"entryId":72,"entrySlug":"candid","childFormId":416,"parentFormId":417,"canonicalEdgeId":367,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English borrowed the adjective through Middle French candide with spelling and pronunciation adapted to English.","semanticChange":"Brightness, favor, and unblemished quality develop toward openness, fairness, and frank expression.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The first reported English sense in 1597 is white.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":346,"id":346,"entryId":72,"entrySlug":"candid","childFormId":417,"parentFormId":418,"canonicalEdgeId":368,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle French candide was borrowed from Latin candidus with regular Romance adaptation.","semanticChange":"Latin brightness and whiteness support French brilliance and favorable disposition.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":347,"id":347,"entryId":72,"entrySlug":"candid","childFormId":418,"parentFormId":419,"canonicalEdgeId":32,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"candidus belongs to the candēre family of shining and whiteness.","semanticChange":"Physical brightness and whiteness extended to clarity and unblemished quality.","scholar":"Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":348,"id":348,"entryId":72,"entrySlug":"candid","childFormId":419,"parentFormId":420,"canonicalEdgeId":370,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin candēre is derived from a zero-grade stative formation of reconstructed *(s)kend-.","semanticChange":"Shining, gleaming, and whiteness retain the reconstructed brightness core.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The form is reconstructed and the graph also preserves an older proposed *kand- route.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":349,"id":349,"entryId":72,"entrySlug":"candid","childFormId":420,"parentFormId":421,"canonicalEdgeId":371,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *(s)kend- reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The brightness history reaches its current comparative horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The asterisk marks an inference; the boundary prevents it from becoming an invented deeper word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":350,"id":350,"entryId":73,"entrySlug":"candor","childFormId":422,"parentFormId":423,"canonicalEdgeId":372,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English candor was borrowed through French candeur with English spelling and pronunciation.","semanticChange":"Brightness and unstained purity become frankness and honest expression.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster also allows direct Latin participation in the borrowing history.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":351,"id":351,"entryId":73,"entrySlug":"candor","childFormId":423,"parentFormId":424,"canonicalEdgeId":373,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French candeur was borrowed from Latin candor with Romance sound and spelling adaptation.","semanticChange":"Radiance, whiteness, and favorable disposition support purity, innocence, and later frankness.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":352,"id":352,"entryId":73,"entrySlug":"candor","childFormId":424,"parentFormId":425,"canonicalEdgeId":374,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin candor is an abstract noun in -or formed beside candēre.","semanticChange":"The act or state of shining yields brightness, radiance, and whiteness.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":353,"id":353,"entryId":73,"entrySlug":"candor","childFormId":425,"parentFormId":426,"canonicalEdgeId":370,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin candēre is derived from a zero-grade stative formation of reconstructed *(s)kend-.","semanticChange":"Shining, gleaming, and whiteness retain the reconstructed brightness core.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The form is reconstructed and the graph also preserves an older proposed *kand- route.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":354,"id":354,"entryId":73,"entrySlug":"candor","childFormId":426,"parentFormId":427,"canonicalEdgeId":376,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *(s)kend- reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The brightness history reaches its current comparative horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The asterisk marks an inference; the boundary prevents it from becoming an invented deeper word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":355,"id":355,"entryId":74,"entrySlug":"calculus","childFormId":428,"parentFormId":429,"canonicalEdgeId":377,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English borrowed Latin calculus without a mediating vernacular form in the reviewed route; pronunciation and plural behavior were anglicized.","semanticChange":"Latin counting and reckoning specialize into mathematical systems while the bodily-stone sense also survives.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports English use in 1666.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":356,"id":356,"entryId":74,"entrySlug":"calculus","childFormId":429,"parentFormId":430,"canonicalEdgeId":95,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"Calculus has traditionally been treated as an irregular diminutive of calx, but the phonology and meanings are problematic and a shared non-Indo-European source with a Greek stone-word has been proposed.","semanticChange":"A small stone or pebble may connect to lime or limestone; the route is unsettled.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors summarizing Festus and Beekes","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The calculus-to-calx derivation is not secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":357,"id":357,"entryId":74,"entrySlug":"calculus","childFormId":430,"parentFormId":431,"canonicalEdgeId":379,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The traditional limestone route and substrate alternatives do not yield a single secure deeper chain.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the live etymological dispute.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The competing Greek/common-source branch is preserved separately.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":358,"id":358,"entryId":75,"entrySlug":"intellect","childFormId":432,"parentFormId":433,"canonicalEdgeId":380,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English intellect continues a medieval French or directly Latin learned form; this dossier displays the published Old French route.","semanticChange":"Perception and understanding become the modern capacity for knowing and reasoning.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster allows Middle French or direct Latin transmission; American Heritage specifies Old French intellecte.","chronologyNote":"The English record begins in the 14th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":359,"id":359,"entryId":75,"entrySlug":"intellect","childFormId":433,"parentFormId":434,"canonicalEdgeId":381,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French intellecte was borrowed from Latin intellectus with Romance spelling and pronunciation.","semanticChange":"Latin perception and understanding remain the core meaning.","scholar":"American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":360,"id":360,"entryId":75,"entrySlug":"intellect","childFormId":434,"parentFormId":435,"canonicalEdgeId":382,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin intellectus is the action noun and participial formation of intellegere.","semanticChange":"The act of perceiving or understanding becomes the faculty or product of understanding.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":361,"id":361,"entryId":75,"entrySlug":"intellect","childFormId":435,"parentFormId":436,"canonicalEdgeId":73,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin intellegere is traditionally analyzed as inter- plus legere, with phonological assimilation.","semanticChange":"Selecting or discerning among becomes understanding; the exact semantic bridge should not be over-literalized.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Latin lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The morphology is strong; a slogan such as “choose between” is not a full semantic history.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":362,"id":362,"entryId":75,"entrySlug":"intellect","childFormId":436,"parentFormId":437,"canonicalEdgeId":60,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin legere is traditionally assigned to the *leǵ- family; *sleǵ- remains a published alternative.","semanticChange":"Gathering and selecting extend into reading.","scholar":"Indo-European lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Root shape is disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":363,"id":363,"entryId":75,"entrySlug":"intellect","childFormId":437,"parentFormId":438,"canonicalEdgeId":385,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper ancestor is promoted beyond *leǵ-.","semanticChange":"The gathering, selection, and understanding path reaches its reviewed horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary preserves the live *leǵ- / *sleǵ- dispute.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":364,"id":364,"entryId":76,"entrySlug":"hospitality","childFormId":439,"parentFormId":440,"canonicalEdgeId":386,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English hospitalite loses final -e and stabilizes as hospitality under learned spelling influence.","semanticChange":"Reception of guests and provision of lodging broaden into the modern social and commercial hospitality field.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"English use is reported from the 14th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":365,"id":365,"entryId":76,"entrySlug":"hospitality","childFormId":440,"parentFormId":441,"canonicalEdgeId":387,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English hospitalite was borrowed from Anglo-French hospitalité with English spelling adaptation.","semanticChange":"Reception and accommodation of guests remain central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":366,"id":366,"entryId":76,"entrySlug":"hospitality","childFormId":441,"parentFormId":442,"canonicalEdgeId":388,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French hospitalité continues Latin hospitālitās through Romance sound and suffix adaptation.","semanticChange":"Entertainment or reception of guests remains the inherited meaning.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":367,"id":367,"entryId":76,"entrySlug":"hospitality","childFormId":442,"parentFormId":443,"canonicalEdgeId":389,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin hospitālitās is an abstract noun in -itās formed from hospitālis.","semanticChange":"The adjective “hospitable” becomes the state or practice of entertaining guests.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":368,"id":368,"entryId":76,"entrySlug":"hospitality","childFormId":443,"parentFormId":444,"canonicalEdgeId":139,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin hospitālis is formed from the stem hospit- of hospes with the adjective suffix -ālis.","semanticChange":"The host/guest relationship becomes the quality of being for guests or hospitable.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":369,"id":369,"entryId":76,"entrySlug":"hospitality","childFormId":444,"parentFormId":445,"canonicalEdgeId":122,"relationType":"compound_reflex","soundChange":"Latin hospes (stem hospit-) is analyzed as a reduced reflex of the compound *ghos-pot-, with substantial phonetic reduction acknowledged by the sources.","semanticChange":"A “guest-master” encoded the reciprocal role in which the same person could be guest on one occasion and host on another.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The host/guest reciprocity is well supported; Merriam-Webster notes that the degree of phonetic reduction has led some scholars to question the precise compound etymology.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":370,"id":370,"entryId":76,"entrySlug":"hospitality","childFormId":445,"parentFormId":446,"canonicalEdgeId":123,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"The first member *ghos- of *ghos-pot- continues the *ghos-ti- guest/stranger base; the compound also contains *pot- “master.”","semanticChange":"The reciprocal outsider becomes the “guest-master,” the person who stands for mutual duties of hospitality.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage Indo-European Roots","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The compound analysis is reconstructed and has a separate *pot- component edge in the canonical graph.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":371,"id":371,"entryId":76,"entrySlug":"hospitality","childFormId":446,"parentFormId":447,"canonicalEdgeId":393,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No single deeper ancestor of *ghos-ti- is selected for this dossier.","semanticChange":"The hospitality lineage reaches an explicit evidence boundary.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"A proposed *ǵhes- analysis remains a competing branch elsewhere in the graph.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":372,"id":372,"entryId":77,"entrySlug":"calculator","childFormId":448,"parentFormId":449,"canonicalEdgeId":396,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English calkelatour loses unstressed material and stabilizes with the learned agent ending -or as calculator.","semanticChange":"The human reckoner sense survives while the agent label later transfers to mechanical and electronic calculating devices.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The word is reported from the 14th century; the source does not assign one first date to the machine sense.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":373,"id":373,"entryId":77,"entrySlug":"calculator","childFormId":449,"parentFormId":450,"canonicalEdgeId":397,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English calkelatour adapts Latin calculātor with vernacular vowel and consonant spelling.","semanticChange":"The Latin arithmetic teacher or reckoner remains a person who counts or computes.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":374,"id":374,"entryId":77,"entrySlug":"calculator","childFormId":450,"parentFormId":451,"canonicalEdgeId":398,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin calculātor is an agent noun in -tor formed from the stem calculā- of calculāre.","semanticChange":"The act of counting or computing is recast as the person who performs it.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":375,"id":375,"entryId":77,"entrySlug":"calculator","childFormId":451,"parentFormId":452,"canonicalEdgeId":94,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Calculāre is derived from calculus.","semanticChange":"Manipulating counting pebbles becomes the general act of computation.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":376,"id":376,"entryId":77,"entrySlug":"calculator","childFormId":452,"parentFormId":453,"canonicalEdgeId":95,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"Calculus has traditionally been treated as an irregular diminutive of calx, but the phonology and meanings are problematic and a shared non-Indo-European source with a Greek stone-word has been proposed.","semanticChange":"A small stone or pebble may connect to lime or limestone; the route is unsettled.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors summarizing Festus and Beekes","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The calculus-to-calx derivation is not secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":377,"id":377,"entryId":77,"entrySlug":"calculator","childFormId":453,"parentFormId":454,"canonicalEdgeId":401,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The traditional limestone route and substrate alternatives do not yield a single secure deeper chain.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the live etymological dispute.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The canonical calculus node preserves the separate common-substrate proposal.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":378,"id":378,"entryId":78,"entrySlug":"intelligent","childFormId":455,"parentFormId":456,"canonicalEdgeId":402,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English intelligent adapts the Latin participial stem intelligent- with English stress, vowel, and final-consonant treatment.","semanticChange":"Latin understanding and discernment become the English adjective for mental capacity, judgment, and later computer-guided behavior.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports first known English use circa 1540.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":379,"id":379,"entryId":78,"entrySlug":"intelligent","childFormId":456,"parentFormId":457,"canonicalEdgeId":72,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"intelligēns is the present participial formation of intellegere / intelligere.","semanticChange":"The one understanding supplies the adjective and abstract noun family.","scholar":"Latin lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":380,"id":380,"entryId":78,"entrySlug":"intelligent","childFormId":457,"parentFormId":458,"canonicalEdgeId":73,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin intellegere is traditionally analyzed as inter- plus legere, with phonological assimilation.","semanticChange":"Selecting or discerning among becomes understanding; the exact semantic bridge should not be over-literalized.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Latin lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The morphology is strong; a slogan such as “choose between” is not a full semantic history.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":381,"id":381,"entryId":78,"entrySlug":"intelligent","childFormId":458,"parentFormId":459,"canonicalEdgeId":60,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin legere is traditionally assigned to the *leǵ- family; *sleǵ- remains a published alternative.","semanticChange":"Gathering and selecting extend into reading.","scholar":"Indo-European lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Root shape is disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":382,"id":382,"entryId":78,"entrySlug":"intelligent","childFormId":459,"parentFormId":460,"canonicalEdgeId":406,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the live reconstruction dispute.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary prevents either reconstructed root shape from being treated as an attested word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":383,"id":383,"entryId":79,"entrySlug":"conscience","childFormId":461,"parentFormId":462,"canonicalEdgeId":407,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English conscience continues into modern English with spelling retained and pronunciation substantially reduced.","semanticChange":"Moral awareness remains central while older general awareness survives only marginally or archaically.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports English use from the thirteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":384,"id":384,"entryId":79,"entrySlug":"conscience","childFormId":462,"parentFormId":463,"canonicalEdgeId":408,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English adopts Anglo-French conscience with English stress and phonological adaptation.","semanticChange":"Inward knowledge and moral awareness remain linked during the borrowing.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"American Heritage labels the French source Old French rather than Anglo-French.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":385,"id":385,"entryId":79,"entrySlug":"conscience","childFormId":463,"parentFormId":464,"canonicalEdgeId":409,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French conscience continues Latin cōnscientia through regular Romance reduction and spelling development.","semanticChange":"Knowledge and awareness increasingly center on inward and moral self-knowledge.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":386,"id":386,"entryId":79,"entrySlug":"conscience","childFormId":464,"parentFormId":465,"canonicalEdgeId":410,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin cōnscientia is an abstract noun formed from the participial stem cōnscient-.","semanticChange":"Being aware or knowing becomes knowledge, consciousness, and moral awareness as an abstract state.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":387,"id":387,"entryId":79,"entrySlug":"conscience","childFormId":465,"parentFormId":466,"canonicalEdgeId":411,"relationType":"inflectional_derivation","soundChange":"Cōnsciēns is the present participle of cōnscīre.","semanticChange":"The act or state of being aware is expressed as knowing or conscious.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":388,"id":388,"entryId":79,"entrySlug":"conscience","childFormId":466,"parentFormId":467,"canonicalEdgeId":412,"relationType":"prefixed_derivation","soundChange":"Latin cōnscīre combines assimilated com- with scīre; the prefix is analyzed as with/together or as intensive.","semanticChange":"Knowing becomes mutual, shared, thorough, or self-aware knowledge, with moral guilt among its attested applications.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The sources do not assign one exclusive semantic value to com-.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":389,"id":389,"entryId":79,"entrySlug":"conscience","childFormId":467,"parentFormId":468,"canonicalEdgeId":160,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"Latin scīre has been compared with an Indo-European cutting/separating base; the exact formation and even the semantic bridge remain disputed.","semanticChange":"A proposed development moves from cutting or separating to distinguishing and then knowing.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · de Vaan · Ernout and Meillet · American Heritage","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster records competing morphological analyses and calls the semantic progression questionable; Ernout and Meillet call the comparison uncertain.","chronologyNote":"The comparison belongs to prehistory, not a directly attested change.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":390,"id":390,"entryId":79,"entrySlug":"conscience","childFormId":468,"parentFormId":469,"canonicalEdgeId":414,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed *skei- comparison.","semanticChange":"The graph stops where the reviewed comparative analysis stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":391,"id":391,"entryId":80,"entrySlug":"conscious","childFormId":470,"parentFormId":471,"canonicalEdgeId":415,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English conscious adapts Latin cōnscius with English stress, vowel reduction, and the learned -ous ending.","semanticChange":"Latin knowing and awareness develop across English senses of perception, wakefulness, subjective feeling, and deliberate action.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports the adjective circa 1600.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":392,"id":392,"entryId":80,"entrySlug":"conscious","childFormId":471,"parentFormId":472,"canonicalEdgeId":416,"relationType":"prefixed_derivation","soundChange":"Latin cōnscius contains com- plus scīre, with assimilation and adjectival formation.","semanticChange":"Knowing with another or being aware becomes the condition of awareness expressed by the adjective.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The prefix can also carry an intensive force in the wider conscience family.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":393,"id":393,"entryId":80,"entrySlug":"conscious","childFormId":472,"parentFormId":473,"canonicalEdgeId":160,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"Latin scīre has been compared with an Indo-European cutting/separating base; the exact formation and even the semantic bridge remain disputed.","semanticChange":"A proposed development moves from cutting or separating to distinguishing and then knowing.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · de Vaan · Ernout and Meillet · American Heritage","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster records competing morphological analyses and calls the semantic progression questionable; Ernout and Meillet call the comparison uncertain.","chronologyNote":"The comparison belongs to prehistory, not a directly attested change.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":394,"id":394,"entryId":80,"entrySlug":"conscious","childFormId":473,"parentFormId":474,"canonicalEdgeId":418,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed *skei- comparison.","semanticChange":"The graph stops where the reviewed comparative analysis stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":395,"id":395,"entryId":81,"entrySlug":"omniscient","childFormId":475,"parentFormId":476,"canonicalEdgeId":419,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English omniscient borrows the learned Latin stem omniscient- with English stress and final-syllable reduction.","semanticChange":"The all-knowing sense is retained and later applied to narrators as well as beings or persons.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports first known English use in 1598.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":396,"id":396,"entryId":81,"entrySlug":"omniscient","childFormId":476,"parentFormId":477,"canonicalEdgeId":420,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Merriam-Webster analyzes omnisciēns as a back-formation from Medieval Latin omniscientia.","semanticChange":"The abstract state of all-knowledge supplies an adjective meaning all-knowing.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"American Heritage instead presents Medieval Latin omnisciēns directly as omni- plus sciēns.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":397,"id":397,"entryId":81,"entrySlug":"omniscient","childFormId":477,"parentFormId":478,"canonicalEdgeId":421,"relationType":"compound_derivation","soundChange":"Medieval Latin omniscientia combines the all-quantifying omni- element with the scientia knowledge family.","semanticChange":"Knowledge is quantified as complete or universal knowledge.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":398,"id":398,"entryId":81,"entrySlug":"omniscient","childFormId":478,"parentFormId":479,"canonicalEdgeId":165,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The noun scientia is formed from the participial stem scient- / sciens.","semanticChange":"A knowing person/state supplies an abstract noun for knowledge.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":399,"id":399,"entryId":81,"entrySlug":"omniscient","childFormId":479,"parentFormId":480,"canonicalEdgeId":166,"relationType":"inflectional_derivation","soundChange":"Sciens is the present participle of sciō, scīre.","semanticChange":"The activity of knowing is expressed as “knowing.”","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":400,"id":400,"entryId":81,"entrySlug":"omniscient","childFormId":480,"parentFormId":481,"canonicalEdgeId":160,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"Latin scīre has been compared with an Indo-European cutting/separating base; the exact formation and even the semantic bridge remain disputed.","semanticChange":"A proposed development moves from cutting or separating to distinguishing and then knowing.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · de Vaan · Ernout and Meillet · American Heritage","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster records competing morphological analyses and calls the semantic progression questionable; Ernout and Meillet call the comparison uncertain.","chronologyNote":"The comparison belongs to prehistory, not a directly attested change.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":401,"id":401,"entryId":81,"entrySlug":"omniscient","childFormId":481,"parentFormId":482,"canonicalEdgeId":425,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed *skei- comparison.","semanticChange":"The graph stops where the reviewed comparative analysis stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":402,"id":402,"entryId":82,"entrySlug":"prescient","childFormId":483,"parentFormId":484,"canonicalEdgeId":426,"relationType":"borrowing_via_competing_routes","soundChange":"English prescient is compatible with French transmission and direct learned borrowing from Latin; the displayed French form preserves the mediated route.","semanticChange":"Foreknowledge remains central while ordinary usage often relaxes toward unusually accurate foresight.","scholar":"American Heritage · Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"American Heritage specifies French transmission; Merriam-Webster gives Latin; Etymonline gives French and direct Latin.","chronologyNote":"Etymonline dates English prescient to the 1620s.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":403,"id":403,"entryId":82,"entrySlug":"prescient","childFormId":484,"parentFormId":485,"canonicalEdgeId":427,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French prescient borrows Latin praesciēns with Romance pronunciation and spelling.","semanticChange":"Foreknowing remains the central meaning.","scholar":"American Heritage · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Etymonline dates the French form to the fifteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":404,"id":404,"entryId":82,"entrySlug":"prescient","childFormId":485,"parentFormId":486,"canonicalEdgeId":428,"relationType":"inflectional_derivation","soundChange":"Latin praesciēns is the present participle of praescīre.","semanticChange":"The act of knowing beforehand is expressed as foreknowing.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":405,"id":405,"entryId":82,"entrySlug":"prescient","childFormId":486,"parentFormId":487,"canonicalEdgeId":429,"relationType":"prefixed_derivation","soundChange":"Latin praescīre combines prae- “before” with scīre “to know.”","semanticChange":"Knowing is located in advance: to know beforehand.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":406,"id":406,"entryId":82,"entrySlug":"prescient","childFormId":487,"parentFormId":488,"canonicalEdgeId":160,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"Latin scīre has been compared with an Indo-European cutting/separating base; the exact formation and even the semantic bridge remain disputed.","semanticChange":"A proposed development moves from cutting or separating to distinguishing and then knowing.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · de Vaan · Ernout and Meillet · American Heritage","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster records competing morphological analyses and calls the semantic progression questionable; Ernout and Meillet call the comparison uncertain.","chronologyNote":"The comparison belongs to prehistory, not a directly attested change.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":407,"id":407,"entryId":82,"entrySlug":"prescient","childFormId":488,"parentFormId":489,"canonicalEdgeId":431,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed *skei- comparison.","semanticChange":"The graph stops where the reviewed comparative analysis stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":408,"id":408,"entryId":83,"entrySlug":"dialogue","childFormId":490,"parentFormId":491,"canonicalEdgeId":432,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English dialoge develops the modern -ue spelling and later English pronunciation.","semanticChange":"The literary conversation sense broadens to ordinary exchange, dramatic speech, and institutional discussion.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"English evidence begins around 1200 or in the thirteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":409,"id":409,"entryId":83,"entrySlug":"dialogue","childFormId":491,"parentFormId":492,"canonicalEdgeId":433,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English adopts Anglo-French dialogue / dialoge with English spelling and pronunciation.","semanticChange":"A represented conversation remains the central meaning.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":410,"id":410,"entryId":83,"entrySlug":"dialogue","childFormId":492,"parentFormId":493,"canonicalEdgeId":434,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French dialogue continues Latin dialogus through Romance transmission.","semanticChange":"Conversation and the literary dialogue remain linked.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":411,"id":411,"entryId":83,"entrySlug":"dialogue","childFormId":493,"parentFormId":494,"canonicalEdgeId":435,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin dialogus borrows and phonologically adapts Greek dialogos.","semanticChange":"The Greek conversation and discourse term becomes a Latin literary form.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":412,"id":412,"entryId":83,"entrySlug":"dialogue","childFormId":494,"parentFormId":495,"canonicalEdgeId":436,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Greek dialogos belongs to the verbal family of dialegesthai “to converse.”","semanticChange":"The act of speaking through or across becomes conversation and a represented exchange.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":413,"id":413,"entryId":83,"entrySlug":"dialogue","childFormId":495,"parentFormId":496,"canonicalEdgeId":437,"relationType":"prefixed_derivation","soundChange":"Greek dialegesthai contains dia- “through, across, between” plus legein / legesthai “to speak.”","semanticChange":"Speaking across or through supplies conversation; the prefix does not encode the numeral two.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":414,"id":414,"entryId":83,"entrySlug":"dialogue","childFormId":496,"parentFormId":497,"canonicalEdgeId":49,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Greek λέγω is traditionally derived from PIE *leǵ-; some scholarship argues that an initial *s should be reconstructed.","semanticChange":"The daughter evidence spans collecting and speaking, but the exact semantic path remains reconstructed.","scholar":"UT Austin LRC · IE-CoR · Kaczyńska","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The competing *sleǵ- analysis prevents an unqualified grade.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":415,"id":415,"entryId":83,"entrySlug":"dialogue","childFormId":497,"parentFormId":498,"canonicalEdgeId":439,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops rather than laundering a contested root into certainty.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":416,"id":416,"entryId":84,"entrySlug":"prologue","childFormId":499,"parentFormId":500,"canonicalEdgeId":440,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English prolog develops the modern -ue spelling while retaining the initial pro- and final log sequence.","semanticChange":"The prefatory speech becomes any introductory section and later any preceding event.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"English evidence begins in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":417,"id":417,"entryId":84,"entrySlug":"prologue","childFormId":500,"parentFormId":501,"canonicalEdgeId":441,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English prolog adopts Anglo-French prologue with English spelling adaptation.","semanticChange":"The prefatory discourse meaning remains stable.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":418,"id":418,"entryId":84,"entrySlug":"prologue","childFormId":501,"parentFormId":502,"canonicalEdgeId":442,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French prologue continues Latin prologus through Romance transmission.","semanticChange":"The introductory speech or preface remains central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":419,"id":419,"entryId":84,"entrySlug":"prologue","childFormId":502,"parentFormId":503,"canonicalEdgeId":443,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin prologus borrows and adapts Greek prologos.","semanticChange":"The Greek before-speech becomes a Latin theatrical and literary preface.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":420,"id":420,"entryId":84,"entrySlug":"prologue","childFormId":503,"parentFormId":504,"canonicalEdgeId":444,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"Greek prologos combines pro- “before” with logos “speech or discourse”; this path follows the logos component.","semanticChange":"A speech positioned before a performance becomes the prologue.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The separate pro- component is preserved as a second canonical parent.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":421,"id":421,"entryId":84,"entrySlug":"prologue","childFormId":504,"parentFormId":505,"canonicalEdgeId":48,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"λόγος is a verbal noun in the λέγω family, with an o-grade formation represented in traditional analysis.","semanticChange":"Gathering, counting, recounting, speech, account, and reason form a historically layered semantic network.","scholar":"Logeion · comparative Greek lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The semantic sequence should not be reduced to a single just-so story.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":422,"id":422,"entryId":84,"entrySlug":"prologue","childFormId":505,"parentFormId":506,"canonicalEdgeId":49,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Greek λέγω is traditionally derived from PIE *leǵ-; some scholarship argues that an initial *s should be reconstructed.","semanticChange":"The daughter evidence spans collecting and speaking, but the exact semantic path remains reconstructed.","scholar":"UT Austin LRC · IE-CoR · Kaczyńska","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The competing *sleǵ- analysis prevents an unqualified grade.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":423,"id":423,"entryId":84,"entrySlug":"prologue","childFormId":506,"parentFormId":507,"canonicalEdgeId":447,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops rather than laundering a contested root into certainty.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":424,"id":424,"entryId":85,"entrySlug":"legible","childFormId":508,"parentFormId":509,"canonicalEdgeId":448,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"The Middle English learned form stabilizes as modern legible with later English stress and vowel development.","semanticChange":"Literal readability remains primary while discernibility and understandability become figurative extensions.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The sources place English use in the late fourteenth or fifteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":425,"id":425,"entryId":85,"entrySlug":"legible","childFormId":509,"parentFormId":510,"canonicalEdgeId":449,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English legible borrows Late Latin legibilis with English phonological adaptation.","semanticChange":"The ability to be read remains the inherited meaning.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":426,"id":426,"entryId":85,"entrySlug":"legible","childFormId":510,"parentFormId":511,"canonicalEdgeId":450,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Late Latin legibilis is formed from Latin legere “to read” with an ability suffix.","semanticChange":"The activity of reading becomes the quality of being readable.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · American Heritage · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":427,"id":427,"entryId":85,"entrySlug":"legible","childFormId":511,"parentFormId":512,"canonicalEdgeId":60,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin legere is traditionally assigned to the *leǵ- family; *sleǵ- remains a published alternative.","semanticChange":"Gathering and selecting extend into reading.","scholar":"Indo-European lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Root shape is disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":428,"id":428,"entryId":85,"entrySlug":"legible","childFormId":512,"parentFormId":513,"canonicalEdgeId":452,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the live reconstruction dispute.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":429,"id":429,"entryId":86,"entrySlug":"legislation","childFormId":514,"parentFormId":515,"canonicalEdgeId":453,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English legislation borrows French législation with learned English stress and pronunciation.","semanticChange":"The making of laws and the resulting body of laws remain central while legislative-business senses develop.","scholar":"Etymonline · CNRTL editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster reports an earlier English horizon than Etymonline; the borrowing itself is secure.","chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports 1606; Etymonline gives the 1650s.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":430,"id":430,"entryId":86,"entrySlug":"legislation","childFormId":515,"parentFormId":516,"canonicalEdgeId":454,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French législation borrows Medieval or Late Latin legislatio with regular Romance adaptation.","semanticChange":"Proposal or bearing of a law develops into law-making authority and a body of laws.","scholar":"CNRTL · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"CNRTL attests Medieval Latin legislatio around 1238 and French législation in 1372–74.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":431,"id":431,"entryId":86,"entrySlug":"legislation","childFormId":516,"parentFormId":517,"canonicalEdgeId":455,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"Latin legislatio contains legis, the genitive of lēx “law”; this path follows the law component while lātio is modeled separately.","semanticChange":"Law is the object being proposed, borne forward, or enacted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · CNRTL · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The lātio carrying/proposing component is a second canonical parent.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":432,"id":432,"entryId":86,"entrySlug":"legislation","childFormId":517,"parentFormId":518,"canonicalEdgeId":55,"relationType":"proposed_inheritance","soundChange":"Latin lēx has traditionally been connected with the gather / collect family; published work argues for a root with initial *s.","semanticChange":"A collection or selection of rules is a proposed semantic bridge, not an uncontested fact.","scholar":"Kaczyńska · Indo-European lexicography","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Both the root shape and exact semantic derivation remain disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":433,"id":433,"entryId":86,"entrySlug":"legislation","childFormId":518,"parentFormId":519,"canonicalEdgeId":457,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the live reconstruction dispute.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":434,"id":434,"entryId":87,"entrySlug":"law","childFormId":520,"parentFormId":521,"canonicalEdgeId":464,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English lawe / laue stabilizes as law while later English vowel history produces the modern pronunciation.","semanticChange":"The inherited legal-rule sense expands to bodies of law, professions, and regular principles in science.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Modern spelling postdates the source-reported Old and Middle English forms.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":435,"id":435,"entryId":87,"entrySlug":"law","childFormId":521,"parentFormId":522,"canonicalEdgeId":465,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English lagu continues into Middle English with loss of final unstressed -u and spelling variation including laue and lawe.","semanticChange":"Ordinance, rule, and legal order remain central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline · UT LRC editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":436,"id":436,"entryId":87,"entrySlug":"law","childFormId":522,"parentFormId":523,"canonicalEdgeId":466,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old English adapts a Scandinavian law-word represented by Old Norse lǫg / lög and lag.","semanticChange":"What is laid down or put in order becomes a prescribed rule and legal institution.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The exact contact event and donor inflection are not reduced to one date.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":437,"id":437,"entryId":87,"entrySlug":"law","childFormId":523,"parentFormId":524,"canonicalEdgeId":467,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Norse lag and lög reflect a reconstructed Germanic *lagam formation in the lay-family.","semanticChange":"A layer, laying, or ordered placement supplies the legal sense “what is laid down.”","scholar":"American Heritage · UT LRC · Cleasby–Vigfusson","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Reference traditions vary in notation and inflectional detail.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":438,"id":438,"entryId":87,"entrySlug":"law","childFormId":524,"parentFormId":525,"canonicalEdgeId":468,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *lagam reflects an o-grade formation in the PIE *legh- “lie, lay” family.","semanticChange":"The concrete act of laying becomes an established order and law.","scholar":"American Heritage · UT LRC · Etymonline editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The broad comparative family is secure; exact intermediate morphology is reconstructed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":439,"id":439,"entryId":87,"entrySlug":"law","childFormId":525,"parentFormId":526,"canonicalEdgeId":469,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the comparative *legh- horizon.","semanticChange":"The site stops without treating the separate *leǵ- gather root or uncertain Latin comparison as an ancestor.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · UT LRC","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":440,"id":440,"entryId":88,"entrySlug":"arithmetic","childFormId":527,"parentFormId":528,"canonicalEdgeId":470,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English arsmetike / arsmetrik is respelled arithmetic under renewed alignment with Latin and Greek.","semanticChange":"The counting art remains arithmetic while its domain broadens within modern mathematics.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Sources differ between a mid-thirteenth-century and fifteenth-century English horizon.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":441,"id":441,"entryId":88,"entrySlug":"arithmetic","childFormId":528,"parentFormId":529,"canonicalEdgeId":471,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English adapts Old French and Anglo-French forms; a folk association with ars metrica contributes the extra r in some spellings.","semanticChange":"The practical and learned counting discipline remains central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline · MacTutor editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":442,"id":442,"entryId":88,"entrySlug":"arithmetic","childFormId":529,"parentFormId":530,"canonicalEdgeId":472,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French arsmetique / arismatike continues Latin arithmetica through regular learned transmission and medieval respelling.","semanticChange":"Arithmetic remains the counting discipline.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":443,"id":443,"entryId":88,"entrySlug":"arithmetic","childFormId":530,"parentFormId":531,"canonicalEdgeId":473,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin arithmetica borrows and adapts Greek arithmētikē.","semanticChange":"The Greek counting art enters Latin education and mathematical vocabulary.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · MacTutor editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":444,"id":444,"entryId":88,"entrySlug":"arithmetic","childFormId":531,"parentFormId":532,"canonicalEdgeId":474,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Greek arithmētikē is built in the arithmos “number” family.","semanticChange":"Number or counting supplies the name of the counting art.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline · MacTutor editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":445,"id":445,"entryId":88,"entrySlug":"arithmetic","childFormId":532,"parentFormId":533,"canonicalEdgeId":475,"relationType":"proposed_inheritance","soundChange":"Greek arithmos is analyzed through a counting base represented by Merriam-Webster as PIE *h₂rei-; Etymonline publishes an expanded *erei-dhmo- formation.","semanticChange":"The inherited counting sense remains, while the precise prehistoric formation is reconstructed.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The references agree on a counting family but use materially different root and formation notation.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":446,"id":446,"entryId":88,"entrySlug":"arithmetic","childFormId":533,"parentFormId":534,"canonicalEdgeId":476,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The graph stops beyond the competing reconstruction notations.","semanticChange":"No deeper number-word is promoted as settled fact.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Merriam-Webster","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":447,"id":447,"entryId":89,"entrySlug":"emoticon","childFormId":535,"parentFormId":536,"canonicalEdgeId":477,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"English emoticon truncates and joins emotion with icon; this dossier path follows the emotion component.","semanticChange":"Feeling supplies the expressive content of the keyboard-character image.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Unicode Consortium","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The icon component is preserved as a second cited canonical parent.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":448,"id":448,"entryId":89,"entrySlug":"emoticon","childFormId":536,"parentFormId":537,"canonicalEdgeId":478,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English emotion borrows Middle French émotion with English stress and vowel adaptation.","semanticChange":"Movement, disturbance, and agitation develop toward strong feeling and later feeling generally.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports English use in 1579; Etymonline places the earliest horizon in the 1570s.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":449,"id":449,"entryId":89,"entrySlug":"emoticon","childFormId":537,"parentFormId":538,"canonicalEdgeId":479,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Middle French émotion is formed in the Old French emouvoir / esmovoir movement family.","semanticChange":"The act or state of stirring and agitation becomes the abstract noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":450,"id":450,"entryId":89,"entrySlug":"emoticon","childFormId":538,"parentFormId":539,"canonicalEdgeId":480,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French emouvoir / esmovoir continues Latin ēmovēre with Romance sound and spelling development.","semanticChange":"Moving out or displacing extends to stirring and agitation.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":451,"id":451,"entryId":89,"entrySlug":"emoticon","childFormId":539,"parentFormId":540,"canonicalEdgeId":481,"relationType":"prefixed_derivation","soundChange":"Latin ēmovēre combines ex- / ē- “out” with movēre “move”; this linear path follows the verbal base.","semanticChange":"Moving out, removing, or displacing develops an agitation sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The ex- component is also modeled as a cited graph branch.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":452,"id":452,"entryId":89,"entrySlug":"emoticon","childFormId":540,"parentFormId":541,"canonicalEdgeId":482,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin movēre is assigned to the PIE movement root *meue- in the reviewed source.","semanticChange":"Physical pushing and movement underlie the later agitation and feeling family.","scholar":"Etymonline editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The exact PIE notation follows the reviewed reference.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":453,"id":453,"entryId":89,"entrySlug":"emoticon","childFormId":541,"parentFormId":542,"canonicalEdgeId":483,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond *meue-.","semanticChange":"The emotion branch stops at its cited reconstruction while the icon branch stops separately at uncertain Greek prehistory.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Etymonline","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":454,"id":454,"entryId":90,"entrySlug":"salt","childFormId":543,"parentFormId":544,"canonicalEdgeId":484,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English salt continues with stable spelling into modern English while pronunciation changes.","semanticChange":"The material sense remains while figurative savor, sailor, and chemical-class senses develop.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":455,"id":455,"entryId":90,"entrySlug":"salt","childFormId":544,"parentFormId":545,"canonicalEdgeId":485,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English sealt loses or reshapes inherited inflection while the stem stabilizes as Middle English salt.","semanticChange":"The condiment and preservative meaning remains central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · UT LRC editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":456,"id":456,"entryId":90,"entrySlug":"salt","childFormId":545,"parentFormId":546,"canonicalEdgeId":486,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English sealt regularly continues reconstructed Proto-Germanic *saltom.","semanticChange":"The material salt sense remains stable across Germanic.","scholar":"Etymonline · UT LRC editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic form is reconstructed, not attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":457,"id":457,"entryId":90,"entrySlug":"salt","childFormId":546,"parentFormId":547,"canonicalEdgeId":487,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *saltom belongs to the Indo-European salt family represented as *séh₂l- in the existing dossier and *sal- in other references.","semanticChange":"The material salt meaning remains stable; no payment sense exists at the reconstructed stage.","scholar":"Mallory & Adams · Etymonline · UT LRC editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Root notation differs across references without changing the comparative salt-family claim.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":458,"id":458,"entryId":90,"entrySlug":"salt","childFormId":547,"parentFormId":548,"canonicalEdgeId":488,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reconstructed salt family.","semanticChange":"The graph stops before speculation while preserving the real path shared with Latin sāl and salary.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Mallory & Adams · UT LRC","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":459,"id":459,"entryId":91,"entrySlug":"algorism","childFormId":549,"parentFormId":550,"canonicalEdgeId":495,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English algorisme / augrim stabilizes as the historical headword algorism with regularized spelling and pronunciation.","semanticChange":"Calculation with Hindu-Arabic numerals remains central; later use becomes chiefly historical.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Etymonline reports an early-thirteenth-century horizon; Merriam-Webster reports the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":460,"id":460,"entryId":91,"entrySlug":"algorism","childFormId":550,"parentFormId":551,"canonicalEdgeId":496,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English forms adapt Old French algorisme / augorisme with variable vowels, consonants, and endings.","semanticChange":"The art of reckoning with Hindu-Arabic numerals remains central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster also allows direct Medieval Latin transmission; the canonical graph preserves that already-cited parent as a parallel route.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":461,"id":461,"entryId":91,"entrySlug":"algorism","childFormId":551,"parentFormId":552,"canonicalEdgeId":497,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French algorisme / augorisme adapts Medieval Latin algorismus with Romance vowel and ending changes.","semanticChange":"The learned arithmetic term enters vernacular calculation vocabulary.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline · MacTutor editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The sources describe French and Latin stages without reducing every spelling to one transmission event.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":462,"id":462,"entryId":91,"entrySlug":"algorism","childFormId":552,"parentFormId":553,"canonicalEdgeId":85,"relationType":"eponymic_borrowing","soundChange":"The Arabic name al-Khwārizmī was heavily Latinized as Algoritmi / algorismus; the initial article was absorbed into the form.","semanticChange":"A scholar's geographic name came to denote the arithmetic associated with transmitted texts.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · MacTutor editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Latin arithmetic texts circulated from the 12th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":463,"id":463,"entryId":91,"entrySlug":"algorism","childFormId":553,"parentFormId":554,"canonicalEdgeId":86,"relationType":"nisba_derivation","soundChange":"Arabic al- plus Khwārizm plus the relational suffix -ī forms “the Khwārizmian.”","semanticChange":"A place of origin becomes a personal identifier.","scholar":"Arabic onomastic analysis · Merriam-Webster editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Name attested for the 9th-century scholar.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":464,"id":464,"entryId":91,"entrySlug":"algorism","childFormId":554,"parentFormId":555,"canonicalEdgeId":500,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper analysis of the toponym is promoted without dedicated Iranian and Central Asian onomastic review.","semanticChange":"The graph stops at the geographic name rather than inventing a lexical root.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":465,"id":465,"entryId":92,"entrySlug":"emotion","childFormId":556,"parentFormId":557,"canonicalEdgeId":478,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English emotion borrows Middle French émotion with English stress and vowel adaptation.","semanticChange":"Movement, disturbance, and agitation develop toward strong feeling and later feeling generally.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports English use in 1579; Etymonline places the earliest horizon in the 1570s.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":466,"id":466,"entryId":92,"entrySlug":"emotion","childFormId":557,"parentFormId":558,"canonicalEdgeId":479,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Middle French émotion is formed in the Old French emouvoir / esmovoir movement family.","semanticChange":"The act or state of stirring and agitation becomes the abstract noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":467,"id":467,"entryId":92,"entrySlug":"emotion","childFormId":558,"parentFormId":559,"canonicalEdgeId":480,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French emouvoir / esmovoir continues Latin ēmovēre with Romance sound and spelling development.","semanticChange":"Moving out or displacing extends to stirring and agitation.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":468,"id":468,"entryId":92,"entrySlug":"emotion","childFormId":559,"parentFormId":560,"canonicalEdgeId":481,"relationType":"prefixed_derivation","soundChange":"Latin ēmovēre combines ex- / ē- “out” with movēre “move”; this linear path follows the verbal base.","semanticChange":"Moving out, removing, or displacing develops an agitation sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The ex- component is also modeled as a cited graph branch.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":469,"id":469,"entryId":92,"entrySlug":"emotion","childFormId":560,"parentFormId":561,"canonicalEdgeId":482,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin movēre is assigned to the PIE movement root *meue- in the reviewed source.","semanticChange":"Physical pushing and movement underlie the later agitation and feeling family.","scholar":"Etymonline editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The exact PIE notation follows the reviewed reference.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":470,"id":470,"entryId":92,"entrySlug":"emotion","childFormId":561,"parentFormId":562,"canonicalEdgeId":506,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond *meue-.","semanticChange":"The standalone emotion dossier stops at its cited movement reconstruction.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Etymonline","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":471,"id":471,"entryId":93,"entrySlug":"icon","childFormId":563,"parentFormId":564,"canonicalEdgeId":491,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English icon borrows Late Latin īcōn with English stress and vowel adaptation.","semanticChange":"Image and likeness extend into religious, symbolic, cultural, and computing senses.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"English first-known-use is reported in 1572.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":472,"id":472,"entryId":93,"entrySlug":"icon","childFormId":564,"parentFormId":565,"canonicalEdgeId":492,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Late Latin īcōn borrows and adapts Greek eikōn.","semanticChange":"The representation, image, and likeness field remains central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":473,"id":473,"entryId":93,"entrySlug":"icon","childFormId":565,"parentFormId":566,"canonicalEdgeId":493,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond Greek eikōn because the proposed base is uncertain.","semanticChange":"The image-and-likeness family reaches a stated evidentiary horizon.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"A proposed Lithuanian comparison is reported as doubtful.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":474,"id":474,"entryId":94,"entrySlug":"lay","childFormId":567,"parentFormId":568,"canonicalEdgeId":510,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English leggen / leyen stabilizes as lay while pronunciation and spelling converge on the modern form.","semanticChange":"Putting or setting down remains central while many constructions and figurative uses develop.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":475,"id":475,"entryId":94,"entrySlug":"lay","childFormId":568,"parentFormId":569,"canonicalEdgeId":511,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English lecgan continues into Middle English with palatal and spelling developments represented by leggen and leyen.","semanticChange":"The causative set-down meaning remains stable.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster · Etymonline · American Heritage editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":476,"id":476,"entryId":94,"entrySlug":"lay","childFormId":569,"parentFormId":570,"canonicalEdgeId":512,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English lecgan continues reconstructed Proto-Germanic *lagojanan with West Germanic sound development.","semanticChange":"To cause something to lie yields the transitive verb to lay or set down.","scholar":"Etymonline · UT LRC editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic form and exact phonological sequence are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":477,"id":477,"entryId":94,"entrySlug":"lay","childFormId":570,"parentFormId":571,"canonicalEdgeId":513,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *lagojanan is a causative formation in the PIE *legh- lie-and-lay family.","semanticChange":"A state of lying supplies a causative act of putting or setting down.","scholar":"Etymonline · UT LRC editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The comparative family is secure while the intermediate form is reconstructed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":478,"id":478,"entryId":94,"entrySlug":"lay","childFormId":571,"parentFormId":572,"canonicalEdgeId":514,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the comparative *legh- horizon.","semanticChange":"The graph stops without merging the unrelated poem, non-clerical, or past-tense homonyms.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · UT LRC","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":479,"id":479,"entryId":55,"entrySlug":"kayak","childFormId":352,"parentFormId":573,"canonicalEdgeId":515,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No still deeper form is promoted beyond *qan-yaq in the reviewed kayak dossier.","semanticChange":"The kayak lineage reaches the reviewed Proto-Eskimo formation and stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · José Andrés Alonso de la Fuente","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The specialist article proposes a deeper base for qajaq, modeled in that dossier, while the English donor variety remains unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":480,"id":480,"entryId":95,"entrySlug":"tapu","childFormId":574,"parentFormId":575,"canonicalEdgeId":516,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Māori tapu preserves the t and vowels of the wider Oceanic comparison; intermediate subgroup stages are not invented.","semanticChange":"Sacredness, prohibition, restriction, and being set apart remain central.","scholar":"POLLEX editors · John C. Moorfield","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Māori word is attested; *tampu is a comparative reconstruction.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":481,"id":481,"entryId":95,"entrySlug":"tapu","childFormId":575,"parentFormId":576,"canonicalEdgeId":517,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted beyond Proto-Oceanic *tampu.","semanticChange":"The Māori dossier reaches the current reviewed comparative horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · POLLEX editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":482,"id":482,"entryId":96,"entrySlug":"kapu","childFormId":577,"parentFormId":578,"canonicalEdgeId":518,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Hawaiian kapu reflects the characteristic Hawaiian development of earlier *t to k after the older k-space changed; the rest of the form remains visibly close.","semanticChange":"Sacred, prohibited, consecrated, and set-apart senses continue across the family.","scholar":"Robert A. Blust · POLLEX editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"POLLEX supplies the lexical comparison; Blust documents the Hawaiian *t to k sound change and its historical complexity.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":483,"id":483,"entryId":96,"entrySlug":"kapu","childFormId":578,"parentFormId":579,"canonicalEdgeId":519,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted beyond Proto-Oceanic *tampu.","semanticChange":"The Hawaiian dossier reaches the current reviewed comparative horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · POLLEX editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":484,"id":484,"entryId":97,"entrySlug":"aguacate","childFormId":580,"parentFormId":581,"canonicalEdgeId":321,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Spanish aguacate adapted Nahuatl āhuacatl to Spanish phonology and spelling.","semanticChange":"The avocado sense was carried into Spanish, while the source word’s testicle sense did not become the ordinary Spanish fruit meaning.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · RAE · ASALE editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Both dictionaries explicitly give Nahuatl āhuacatl or ahuacatl and document its avocado and testicle senses.","chronologyNote":"Colonial-era transfer into Spanish; no invented exact year.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":485,"id":485,"entryId":97,"entrySlug":"aguacate","childFormId":581,"parentFormId":582,"canonicalEdgeId":521,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form or semantic derivation direction is promoted beyond the documented Nahuatl word.","semanticChange":"The graph preserves fruit-and-testicle polysemy without converting it into an unsupported naming event.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · RAE · UNAM","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":486,"id":486,"entryId":98,"entrySlug":"qajaq","childFormId":583,"parentFormId":584,"canonicalEdgeId":522,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Greenlandic qajaq continues the independently reconstructed Proto-Eskimo kayak formation; exact intermediate dialect stages are not over-specified.","semanticChange":"The watercraft referent remains central.","scholar":"José Andrés Alonso de la Fuente · Oqaasileriffik","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Greenlandic form is attested and the Proto-Eskimo form reconstructed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":487,"id":487,"entryId":98,"entrySlug":"qajaq","childFormId":584,"parentFormId":585,"canonicalEdgeId":523,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"The source analyzes *qan-yaq within Proto-Eskimo from *qan(ə)-; the notation is preserved without inventing an unattested segment-by-segment derivation.","semanticChange":"A motion or approach base is proposed beneath the lexicalized kayak formation.","scholar":"José Andrés Alonso de la Fuente","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The deeper internal analysis is published but remains analytical rather than directly attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":488,"id":488,"entryId":98,"entrySlug":"qajaq","childFormId":585,"parentFormId":586,"canonicalEdgeId":524,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted beyond the reviewed Proto-Eskimo base.","semanticChange":"The graph stops before speculative macro-family comparison.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · José Andrés Alonso de la Fuente","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":489,"id":489,"entryId":99,"entrySlug":"kayik","childFormId":587,"parentFormId":588,"canonicalEdgeId":525,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Old Turkic kayguk develops into Turkish kayık through documented Turkic consonant-cluster reduction and vowel history; it does not descend from Inuit qayaq.","semanticChange":"The small-boat referent remains central.","scholar":"José Andrés Alonso de la Fuente · Türk Dil Kurumu","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The historical and modern forms are independently documented.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":490,"id":490,"entryId":99,"entrySlug":"kayik","childFormId":588,"parentFormId":589,"canonicalEdgeId":526,"relationType":"proposed_derivation","soundChange":"The reviewed study places kayguk in an internal Turkic *kad- / *kad-ï history; a competing *kay- “turn, bend” account remains open.","semanticChange":"A fir-tree or wood base is proposed to have developed into a boat word, plausibly through material association.","scholar":"José Andrés Alonso de la Fuente","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The historical kayguk form is secure; the deeper derivational analysis is disputed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":491,"id":491,"entryId":99,"entrySlug":"kayik","childFormId":589,"parentFormId":590,"canonicalEdgeId":527,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper form is promoted beyond the competing Turkic analyses.","semanticChange":"The dossier ends inside Turkic and explicitly rejects chance similarity as ancestry.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · José Andrés Alonso de la Fuente","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":492,"id":492,"entryId":100,"entrySlug":"cha-portuguese","childFormId":591,"parentFormId":592,"canonicalEdgeId":528,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Portuguese chá adapts a Cantonese cha-type form with Portuguese spelling and /ʃ/ realization; Infopédia instead labels the source Mandarin.","semanticChange":"The meaning remains tea, later extending regularly to the plant, leaves, infusion, and social uses.","scholar":"Östen Dahl · Porto Editora Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"WALS explicitly gives a Cantonese route through Macao, while Infopédia gives Mandarin. The graph follows the historically specific route and exposes the disagreement.","chronologyNote":"Portuguese contact through Macao in the sixteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":493,"id":493,"entryId":100,"entrySlug":"cha-portuguese","childFormId":592,"parentFormId":593,"canonicalEdgeId":529,"relationType":"sinitic_reflex","soundChange":"Cantonese cha is treated as a Sinitic reflex of the word reconstructed as Old Chinese *lˤra; no false one-line sound law is invented.","semanticChange":"The tea meaning remains stable.","scholar":"Östen Dahl · William H. Baxter · Laurent Sagart","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"WALS identifies the Cantonese cha family; Baxter and Sagart supply the reviewed Old Chinese reconstruction. Intermediate readings are not over-specified.","chronologyNote":"Old Chinese reconstruction to the historically documented Cantonese form.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":494,"id":494,"entryId":100,"entrySlug":"cha-portuguese","childFormId":593,"parentFormId":594,"canonicalEdgeId":530,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond Baxter and Sagart’s *lˤra in this reviewed path.","semanticChange":"The plant-name history reaches the present editorial evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"This is a boundary of the selected evidence, not proof that no deeper proposal has ever been published.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":495,"id":495,"entryId":101,"entrySlug":"chay-persian","childFormId":595,"parentFormId":596,"canonicalEdgeId":233,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Persian čāy is reported as derived from Chinese ch’a, retaining the cha onset and adding the final glide represented in Persian transliteration.","semanticChange":"The meaning remains tea.","scholar":"Daniel Balland · Marcel Bazin","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Encyclopaedia Iranica gives the Chinese derivation but says the date and mechanism of Persian adoption remain uncertain.","chronologyNote":"Chinese to Persian overland transmission; Persian awareness is reported by the 11th century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":496,"id":496,"entryId":101,"entrySlug":"chay-persian","childFormId":596,"parentFormId":597,"canonicalEdgeId":230,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Modern Mandarin chá continues the Chinese word represented by reconstructed Middle Chinese *drae, with the onset and vowel changes summarized by the Baxter–Sagart correspondence table.","semanticChange":"The tea meaning remains stable.","scholar":"William H. Baxter · Laurent Sagart","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The modern form is attested, while the Middle Chinese phonological value is reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Middle Chinese to modern Mandarin.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":497,"id":497,"entryId":101,"entrySlug":"chay-persian","childFormId":597,"parentFormId":598,"canonicalEdgeId":231,"relationType":"historical_reconstruction","soundChange":"Baxter and Sagart reconstruct Middle Chinese drae from Old Chinese *lˤra for the same character 茶.","semanticChange":"The gloss remains a plant name associated with tea.","scholar":"William H. Baxter · Laurent Sagart","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Both phonological stages are scholarly reconstructions even though the character and lexical tradition are historically attested.","chronologyNote":"Old Chinese to Middle Chinese.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":498,"id":498,"entryId":101,"entrySlug":"chay-persian","childFormId":598,"parentFormId":599,"canonicalEdgeId":534,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond Baxter and Sagart’s *lˤra in this reviewed path.","semanticChange":"The plant-name history reaches the present editorial evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"This is a boundary of the selected evidence, not proof that no deeper proposal has ever been published.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":499,"id":499,"entryId":102,"entrySlug":"cay-turkish","childFormId":600,"parentFormId":601,"canonicalEdgeId":535,"relationType":"borrowing_via_persian","soundChange":"Turkish çay belongs to the Chinese cha/chay family, but the reviewed Turkish study argues that historical Turkey Turkish received it through Persian rather than by direct Chinese contact.","semanticChange":"The core tea meaning remains, then Turkish develops ordinary plant, beverage, gathering, and refreshment senses.","scholar":"Erdoğan Boz · Östen Dahl","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Boz identifies Persian as the better bridge language; WALS supports the broader overland cha-type distribution without resolving every local intermediary.","chronologyNote":"Overland transmission into historical Turkey Turkish; no exact adoption year is invented.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":500,"id":500,"entryId":102,"entrySlug":"cay-turkish","childFormId":601,"parentFormId":602,"canonicalEdgeId":230,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Modern Mandarin chá continues the Chinese word represented by reconstructed Middle Chinese *drae, with the onset and vowel changes summarized by the Baxter–Sagart correspondence table.","semanticChange":"The tea meaning remains stable.","scholar":"William H. Baxter · Laurent Sagart","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The modern form is attested, while the Middle Chinese phonological value is reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Middle Chinese to modern Mandarin.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":501,"id":501,"entryId":102,"entrySlug":"cay-turkish","childFormId":602,"parentFormId":603,"canonicalEdgeId":231,"relationType":"historical_reconstruction","soundChange":"Baxter and Sagart reconstruct Middle Chinese drae from Old Chinese *lˤra for the same character 茶.","semanticChange":"The gloss remains a plant name associated with tea.","scholar":"William H. Baxter · Laurent Sagart","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Both phonological stages are scholarly reconstructions even though the character and lexical tradition are historically attested.","chronologyNote":"Old Chinese to Middle Chinese.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":502,"id":502,"entryId":102,"entrySlug":"cay-turkish","childFormId":603,"parentFormId":604,"canonicalEdgeId":538,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond Baxter and Sagart’s *lˤra in this reviewed path.","semanticChange":"The plant-name history reaches the present editorial evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"This is a boundary of the selected evidence, not proof that no deeper proposal has ever been published.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":503,"id":503,"entryId":103,"entrySlug":"chay-russian","childFormId":605,"parentFormId":606,"canonicalEdgeId":539,"relationType":"borrowing_via_turkic","soundChange":"Russian чай is traced through a relay of Turkic forms—including Turkish, Crimean Tatar, Tatar, Kyrgyz, Altai, and Uyghur comparisons—to northern Chinese ch’a; no single immediate donor is silently selected.","semanticChange":"The tea meaning remains stable across the relay.","scholar":"Max Vasmer · Östen Dahl","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Vasmer supports a Turkic-mediated chain but lists several candidates; WALS supplies the global overland pattern.","chronologyNote":"Historical overland transmission from China through Turkic-speaking networks into Russian.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":504,"id":504,"entryId":103,"entrySlug":"chay-russian","childFormId":606,"parentFormId":607,"canonicalEdgeId":230,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Modern Mandarin chá continues the Chinese word represented by reconstructed Middle Chinese *drae, with the onset and vowel changes summarized by the Baxter–Sagart correspondence table.","semanticChange":"The tea meaning remains stable.","scholar":"William H. Baxter · Laurent Sagart","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The modern form is attested, while the Middle Chinese phonological value is reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Middle Chinese to modern Mandarin.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":505,"id":505,"entryId":103,"entrySlug":"chay-russian","childFormId":607,"parentFormId":608,"canonicalEdgeId":231,"relationType":"historical_reconstruction","soundChange":"Baxter and Sagart reconstruct Middle Chinese drae from Old Chinese *lˤra for the same character 茶.","semanticChange":"The gloss remains a plant name associated with tea.","scholar":"William H. Baxter · Laurent Sagart","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Both phonological stages are scholarly reconstructions even though the character and lexical tradition are historically attested.","chronologyNote":"Old Chinese to Middle Chinese.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":506,"id":506,"entryId":103,"entrySlug":"chay-russian","childFormId":608,"parentFormId":609,"canonicalEdgeId":542,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond Baxter and Sagart’s *lˤra in this reviewed path.","semanticChange":"The plant-name history reaches the present editorial evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"This is a boundary of the selected evidence, not proof that no deeper proposal has ever been published.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":507,"id":507,"entryId":104,"entrySlug":"chay-urdu","childFormId":610,"parentFormId":611,"canonicalEdgeId":543,"relationType":"overland_borrowing_route","soundChange":"Urdu cāy belongs to the cha/chay family ultimately derived from Chinese chá; Rekhta labels the current Urdu headword Persian in origin, while the graph does not invent an exact dated Persian-to-Urdu event.","semanticChange":"The general tea meaning remains, with local extensions to infusions and social tea.","scholar":"Rekhta Dictionary Editors · Östen Dahl · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Rekhta supports Persian origin; WALS and Merriam-Webster support the wider overland family but do not establish one complete sequence of intermediaries.","chronologyNote":"Overland transmission into the Hindi–Urdu continuum before the modern English culinary borrowing.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":508,"id":508,"entryId":104,"entrySlug":"chay-urdu","childFormId":611,"parentFormId":612,"canonicalEdgeId":230,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Modern Mandarin chá continues the Chinese word represented by reconstructed Middle Chinese *drae, with the onset and vowel changes summarized by the Baxter–Sagart correspondence table.","semanticChange":"The tea meaning remains stable.","scholar":"William H. Baxter · Laurent Sagart","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The modern form is attested, while the Middle Chinese phonological value is reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Middle Chinese to modern Mandarin.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":509,"id":509,"entryId":104,"entrySlug":"chay-urdu","childFormId":612,"parentFormId":613,"canonicalEdgeId":231,"relationType":"historical_reconstruction","soundChange":"Baxter and Sagart reconstruct Middle Chinese drae from Old Chinese *lˤra for the same character 茶.","semanticChange":"The gloss remains a plant name associated with tea.","scholar":"William H. Baxter · Laurent Sagart","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Both phonological stages are scholarly reconstructions even though the character and lexical tradition are historically attested.","chronologyNote":"Old Chinese to Middle Chinese.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":510,"id":510,"entryId":104,"entrySlug":"chay-urdu","childFormId":613,"parentFormId":614,"canonicalEdgeId":546,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond Baxter and Sagart’s *lˤra in this reviewed path.","semanticChange":"The plant-name history reaches the present editorial evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"This is a boundary of the selected evidence, not proof that no deeper proposal has ever been published.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":511,"id":511,"entryId":105,"entrySlug":"etymos","childFormId":615,"parentFormId":616,"canonicalEdgeId":547,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The Greek form is analyzed from *setu-mo- with loss of initial *s and Greek development of the reconstructed formation.","semanticChange":"A reconstructed adjective of truth or reality continues as Greek “true, real, actual.”","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Martin Gális","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The *setu-mo- morphology is published but not directly attested or universally settled.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":512,"id":512,"entryId":105,"entrySlug":"etymos","childFormId":616,"parentFormId":617,"canonicalEdgeId":548,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed *-mo- adjective is built on the reconstructed *set-u- base.","semanticChange":"The true-order base becomes an adjective meaning true or real.","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Charles de Lamberterie","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Both the base and derivational segmentation are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":513,"id":513,"entryId":105,"entrySlug":"etymos","childFormId":617,"parentFormId":618,"canonicalEdgeId":549,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form commands secure consensus beyond the *set-u- proposal.","semanticChange":"The Greek true-word family reaches its present comparative evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary does not deny alternative proposals; it refuses to select one as fact.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":514,"id":514,"entryId":106,"entrySlug":"eteos","childFormId":619,"parentFormId":620,"canonicalEdgeId":550,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The proposed path from *set-eu-o- to Greek ἐτεός includes loss of the inherited initial sibilant; Gális discusses psilosis and only tentatively raises contact as an explanation.","semanticChange":"A possessive true-order adjective yields the attested senses true and really.","scholar":"Martin Gális · Robert Beekes","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The preform and phonological account are scholarly reconstructions, not written stages.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":515,"id":515,"entryId":106,"entrySlug":"eteos","childFormId":620,"parentFormId":621,"canonicalEdgeId":551,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed possessive adjective *set-eu-o- is analyzed from a *set-u- or *steu- base.","semanticChange":"The base notion of true order becomes “having true order; real.”","scholar":"Martin Gális · Robert Beekes","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The exact ablaut and suffixal analysis remain debated.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":516,"id":516,"entryId":106,"entrySlug":"eteos","childFormId":621,"parentFormId":622,"canonicalEdgeId":552,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed *set-u- horizon.","semanticChange":"The ἐτεός line ends where competing analyses begin.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary preserves the uncertainty exposed by the etymological sources.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":517,"id":517,"entryId":107,"entrySlug":"stoyg","childFormId":623,"parentFormId":624,"canonicalEdgeId":553,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Classical Armenian ստոյգ is compared with a reconstructed *stéu-gho- preform; the consonant sequence and vocalism are comparative, not attested.","semanticChange":"The reconstructed real or certain sense continues in the Armenian adjective and adverb.","scholar":"Hrach Martirosyan · Robert Beekes","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The lexical identity is secure, while this exact preform belongs to a proposed Indo-European analysis.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":518,"id":518,"entryId":107,"entrySlug":"stoyg","childFormId":624,"parentFormId":625,"canonicalEdgeId":554,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed Armenian preform is connected through extension and reorganization of the *set-u- or *steu- base; no single intermediate is written.","semanticChange":"The comparative field remains truth, certainty, and reality.","scholar":"Hrach Martirosyan · Robert Beekes · Martin Gális","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"This edge encodes a published comparison, not proof of one uncontested parent form.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":519,"id":519,"entryId":107,"entrySlug":"stoyg","childFormId":625,"parentFormId":626,"canonicalEdgeId":555,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No unique older ancestor is selected beyond the Greek-Armenian *set-u- comparison.","semanticChange":"The comparative trail ends in competing morphological analyses.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"A cognate proposal is not converted into a certain proto-word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":520,"id":520,"entryId":108,"entrySlug":"etymon","childFormId":627,"parentFormId":628,"canonicalEdgeId":556,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English borrowed Latin etymon with learned spelling and English pronunciation.","semanticChange":"The source-word sense was retained and generalized across same-language, foreign-language, and derivational sources.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports English use from 1573.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":521,"id":521,"entryId":108,"entrySlug":"etymon","childFormId":628,"parentFormId":629,"canonicalEdgeId":557,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin etymon borrowed the Greek neuter noun with direct learned adaptation.","semanticChange":"The true or original sense of a word remained the technical referent.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":522,"id":522,"entryId":108,"entrySlug":"etymon","childFormId":629,"parentFormId":630,"canonicalEdgeId":558,"relationType":"substantivization","soundChange":"The neuter form ἔτυμον of the adjective ἔτυμος was used substantivally.","semanticChange":"“The true” becomes the true sense of a word according to its origin.","scholar":"Liddell · Scott · Jones","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"LSJ marks the technical noun in later writers rather than Attic prose.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":523,"id":523,"entryId":108,"entrySlug":"etymon","childFormId":630,"parentFormId":631,"canonicalEdgeId":547,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The Greek form is analyzed from *setu-mo- with loss of initial *s and Greek development of the reconstructed formation.","semanticChange":"A reconstructed adjective of truth or reality continues as Greek “true, real, actual.”","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Martin Gális","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The *setu-mo- morphology is published but not directly attested or universally settled.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":524,"id":524,"entryId":108,"entrySlug":"etymon","childFormId":631,"parentFormId":632,"canonicalEdgeId":548,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed *-mo- adjective is built on the reconstructed *set-u- base.","semanticChange":"The true-order base becomes an adjective meaning true or real.","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Charles de Lamberterie","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Both the base and derivational segmentation are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":525,"id":525,"entryId":108,"entrySlug":"etymon","childFormId":632,"parentFormId":633,"canonicalEdgeId":561,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form commands secure consensus beyond the *set-u- proposal.","semanticChange":"The technical noun’s deep line reaches the same open comparative horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The secure Greco-Latin-English route does not make the prehistoric morphology certain.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":526,"id":526,"entryId":109,"entrySlug":"etymologie-french","childFormId":634,"parentFormId":635,"canonicalEdgeId":562,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"French spelling regularized medieval variants such as ethimologie toward étymologie.","semanticChange":"A learned word used for titles, word explanations, and wordplay developed the modern linguistic senses.","scholar":"CNRTL Editors · Académie française Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"CNRTL separates the earliest records from the later technical senses.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":527,"id":527,"entryId":109,"entrySlug":"etymologie-french","childFormId":635,"parentFormId":636,"canonicalEdgeId":563,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French transmitted the learned Latin form.","semanticChange":"Scholarly explanation of a word’s origin continued.","scholar":"French historical lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":528,"id":528,"entryId":109,"entrySlug":"etymologie-french","childFormId":636,"parentFormId":637,"canonicalEdgeId":564,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin borrowed Greek ἐτυμολογία.","semanticChange":"A Greek technical concept entered Latin grammatical tradition.","scholar":"Latin and Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":529,"id":529,"entryId":109,"entrySlug":"etymologie-french","childFormId":637,"parentFormId":638,"canonicalEdgeId":565,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The compound joins ἔτυμος “true, real” and -λογία “account, study.”","semanticChange":"A word’s “true sense” becomes an object of analysis.","scholar":"Ancient Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":530,"id":530,"entryId":109,"entrySlug":"etymologie-french","childFormId":638,"parentFormId":639,"canonicalEdgeId":547,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The Greek form is analyzed from *setu-mo- with loss of initial *s and Greek development of the reconstructed formation.","semanticChange":"A reconstructed adjective of truth or reality continues as Greek “true, real, actual.”","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Martin Gális","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The *setu-mo- morphology is published but not directly attested or universally settled.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":531,"id":531,"entryId":109,"entrySlug":"etymologie-french","childFormId":639,"parentFormId":640,"canonicalEdgeId":548,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed *-mo- adjective is built on the reconstructed *set-u- base.","semanticChange":"The true-order base becomes an adjective meaning true or real.","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Charles de Lamberterie","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Both the base and derivational segmentation are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":532,"id":532,"entryId":109,"entrySlug":"etymologie-french","childFormId":640,"parentFormId":641,"canonicalEdgeId":568,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form commands secure consensus beyond the *set-u- proposal.","semanticChange":"The French word’s deep line reaches the same open comparative horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The attested French transmission and disputed proto-analysis remain separate evidence classes.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":533,"id":533,"entryId":110,"entrySlug":"etetymos","childFormId":642,"parentFormId":643,"canonicalEdgeId":569,"relationType":"reduplication","soundChange":"The poetic form expands ἔτυμος as ἐτήτυμος; LSJ labels the relationship reduplication without requiring a separate deeper lexical parent.","semanticChange":"The meaning remains true while the poetic form gains expressive or metrical shape.","scholar":"Liddell · Scott · Jones","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The relationship is attested in the ancient poetic record and explicitly classified by LSJ.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":534,"id":534,"entryId":110,"entrySlug":"etetymos","childFormId":643,"parentFormId":644,"canonicalEdgeId":547,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The Greek form is analyzed from *setu-mo- with loss of initial *s and Greek development of the reconstructed formation.","semanticChange":"A reconstructed adjective of truth or reality continues as Greek “true, real, actual.”","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Martin Gális","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The *setu-mo- morphology is published but not directly attested or universally settled.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":535,"id":535,"entryId":110,"entrySlug":"etetymos","childFormId":644,"parentFormId":645,"canonicalEdgeId":548,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed *-mo- adjective is built on the reconstructed *set-u- base.","semanticChange":"The true-order base becomes an adjective meaning true or real.","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Charles de Lamberterie","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Both the base and derivational segmentation are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":536,"id":536,"entryId":110,"entrySlug":"etetymos","childFormId":645,"parentFormId":646,"canonicalEdgeId":572,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form commands secure consensus beyond the *set-u- proposal.","semanticChange":"The poetic true-word line reaches the present comparative evidence horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary preserves competing analyses rather than selecting one as fact.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":537,"id":537,"entryId":111,"entrySlug":"etymon-french","childFormId":647,"parentFormId":648,"canonicalEdgeId":573,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French adapted learned etymon as étymon with French stress and a nasalized final vowel.","semanticChange":"The technical source-form sense was retained while expanding to include attested and reconstructed forms.","scholar":"ATILF · CNRTL Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"CNRTL names Latin as the donor, while the Académie summarizes a direct Greek borrowing; the immediate route remains open.","chronologyNote":"CNRTL reports the French record from 1892.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":538,"id":538,"entryId":111,"entrySlug":"etymon-french","childFormId":648,"parentFormId":649,"canonicalEdgeId":557,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin etymon borrowed the Greek neuter noun with direct learned adaptation.","semanticChange":"The true or original sense of a word remained the technical referent.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":539,"id":539,"entryId":111,"entrySlug":"etymon-french","childFormId":649,"parentFormId":650,"canonicalEdgeId":558,"relationType":"substantivization","soundChange":"The neuter form ἔτυμον of the adjective ἔτυμος was used substantivally.","semanticChange":"“The true” becomes the true sense of a word according to its origin.","scholar":"Liddell · Scott · Jones","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"LSJ marks the technical noun in later writers rather than Attic prose.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":540,"id":540,"entryId":111,"entrySlug":"etymon-french","childFormId":650,"parentFormId":651,"canonicalEdgeId":547,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The Greek form is analyzed from *setu-mo- with loss of initial *s and Greek development of the reconstructed formation.","semanticChange":"A reconstructed adjective of truth or reality continues as Greek “true, real, actual.”","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Martin Gális","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The *setu-mo- morphology is published but not directly attested or universally settled.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":541,"id":541,"entryId":111,"entrySlug":"etymon-french","childFormId":651,"parentFormId":652,"canonicalEdgeId":548,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed *-mo- adjective is built on the reconstructed *set-u- base.","semanticChange":"The true-order base becomes an adjective meaning true or real.","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Charles de Lamberterie","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Both the base and derivational segmentation are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":542,"id":542,"entryId":111,"entrySlug":"etymon-french","childFormId":652,"parentFormId":653,"canonicalEdgeId":578,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form commands secure consensus beyond the *set-u- proposal.","semanticChange":"The French technical noun reaches the same open comparative horizon.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Allowing hypothetical etyma does not license a fabricated deeper ancestor.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":543,"id":543,"entryId":112,"entrySlug":"etymologique-french","childFormId":654,"parentFormId":655,"canonicalEdgeId":579,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"French adapted Latin etymologicus as étymologique with French stress, vowels, and the learned -ique ending.","semanticChange":"The Latin origin-conforming adjective developed the modern French senses “related to etymology” and “conforming to origin.”","scholar":"ATILF · Académie française Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"CNRTL reports French use around 1550; the Académie dates the word to the sixteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":544,"id":544,"entryId":112,"entrySlug":"etymologique-french","childFormId":655,"parentFormId":656,"canonicalEdgeId":580,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin etymologicus adapted Greek etymologikos within learned grammatical vocabulary.","semanticChange":"The adjective retained the sense of belonging to or based on etymology.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The reviewed sources establish the donor chain but do not identify one dated transfer event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":545,"id":545,"entryId":112,"entrySlug":"etymologique-french","childFormId":656,"parentFormId":657,"canonicalEdgeId":581,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Greek ἐτυμολογικός adds the adjectival suffix -ικός to ἐτυμολογία.","semanticChange":"The name of an inquiry becomes an adjective meaning belonging to or based on that inquiry.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":546,"id":546,"entryId":112,"entrySlug":"etymologique-french","childFormId":657,"parentFormId":658,"canonicalEdgeId":565,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The compound joins ἔτυμος “true, real” and -λογία “account, study.”","semanticChange":"A word’s “true sense” becomes an object of analysis.","scholar":"Ancient Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":547,"id":547,"entryId":112,"entrySlug":"etymologique-french","childFormId":658,"parentFormId":659,"canonicalEdgeId":547,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The Greek form is analyzed from *setu-mo- with loss of initial *s and Greek development of the reconstructed formation.","semanticChange":"A reconstructed adjective of truth or reality continues as Greek “true, real, actual.”","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Martin Gális","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The *setu-mo- morphology is published but not directly attested or universally settled.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":548,"id":548,"entryId":112,"entrySlug":"etymologique-french","childFormId":659,"parentFormId":660,"canonicalEdgeId":548,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed *-mo- adjective is built on the reconstructed *set-u- base.","semanticChange":"The true-order base becomes an adjective meaning true or real.","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Charles de Lamberterie","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Both the base and derivational segmentation are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":549,"id":549,"entryId":112,"entrySlug":"etymologique-french","childFormId":660,"parentFormId":661,"canonicalEdgeId":585,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form commands secure consensus beyond the *set-u- proposal.","semanticChange":"The French adjective reaches the same open comparative horizon as the wider true-word family.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary preserves competing analyses instead of selecting one as fact.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":550,"id":550,"entryId":113,"entrySlug":"etymological","childFormId":662,"parentFormId":663,"canonicalEdgeId":586,"relationType":"learned_formation","soundChange":"English drops Latin -us through the learned adjective etymologic and adds adjectival -al; a competing internal etymology + -ical analysis remains visible in the graph.","semanticChange":"A Latin adjective about word origins becomes the English adjective of relation or conformity.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster and Etymonline segment the English formation differently.","chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports first known use in 1588; Etymonline reports the 1590s.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":551,"id":551,"entryId":113,"entrySlug":"etymological","childFormId":663,"parentFormId":664,"canonicalEdgeId":580,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin etymologicus adapted Greek etymologikos within learned grammatical vocabulary.","semanticChange":"The adjective retained the sense of belonging to or based on etymology.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The reviewed sources establish the donor chain but do not identify one dated transfer event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":552,"id":552,"entryId":113,"entrySlug":"etymological","childFormId":664,"parentFormId":665,"canonicalEdgeId":581,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Greek ἐτυμολογικός adds the adjectival suffix -ικός to ἐτυμολογία.","semanticChange":"The name of an inquiry becomes an adjective meaning belonging to or based on that inquiry.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":553,"id":553,"entryId":113,"entrySlug":"etymological","childFormId":665,"parentFormId":666,"canonicalEdgeId":565,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The compound joins ἔτυμος “true, real” and -λογία “account, study.”","semanticChange":"A word’s “true sense” becomes an object of analysis.","scholar":"Ancient Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":554,"id":554,"entryId":113,"entrySlug":"etymological","childFormId":666,"parentFormId":667,"canonicalEdgeId":547,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The Greek form is analyzed from *setu-mo- with loss of initial *s and Greek development of the reconstructed formation.","semanticChange":"A reconstructed adjective of truth or reality continues as Greek “true, real, actual.”","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Martin Gális","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The *setu-mo- morphology is published but not directly attested or universally settled.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":555,"id":555,"entryId":113,"entrySlug":"etymological","childFormId":667,"parentFormId":668,"canonicalEdgeId":548,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed *-mo- adjective is built on the reconstructed *set-u- base.","semanticChange":"The true-order base becomes an adjective meaning true or real.","scholar":"Robert Beekes · Charles de Lamberterie","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Both the base and derivational segmentation are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":556,"id":556,"entryId":113,"entrySlug":"etymological","childFormId":668,"parentFormId":669,"canonicalEdgeId":592,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form commands secure consensus beyond the *set-u- proposal.","semanticChange":"The adjective reaches the open comparative horizon rather than a manufactured ultimate root.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The boundary preserves competing analyses.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":557,"id":557,"entryId":114,"entrySlug":"etymologist","childFormId":670,"parentFormId":671,"canonicalEdgeId":593,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"English adds the person-forming suffix -ist to etymology.","semanticChange":"The discipline name becomes the title of a specialist who studies word histories.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Douglas Harper","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The sources report different surviving-use horizons: 1604 and the 1630s.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":558,"id":558,"entryId":114,"entrySlug":"etymologist","childFormId":671,"parentFormId":672,"canonicalEdgeId":7,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English adapted the learned French form and later aligned spelling with the classical model.","semanticChange":"The technical term broadened into the modern historical discipline.","scholar":"OED · historical lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":559,"id":559,"entryId":114,"entrySlug":"etymologist","childFormId":672,"parentFormId":673,"canonicalEdgeId":8,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French transmitted the learned Latin form.","semanticChange":"Scholarly explanation of a word’s origin continued.","scholar":"French historical lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":560,"id":560,"entryId":114,"entrySlug":"etymologist","childFormId":673,"parentFormId":674,"canonicalEdgeId":9,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin borrowed Greek ἐτυμολογία.","semanticChange":"A Greek technical concept entered Latin grammatical tradition.","scholar":"Latin and Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":561,"id":561,"entryId":114,"entrySlug":"etymologist","childFormId":674,"parentFormId":675,"canonicalEdgeId":10,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The compound joins ἔτυμος “true, real” and -λογία “account, study.”","semanticChange":"A word’s “true sense” becomes an object of analysis.","scholar":"Ancient Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":562,"id":562,"entryId":114,"entrySlug":"etymologist","childFormId":675,"parentFormId":676,"canonicalEdgeId":11,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The attested Greek adjective is analyzed through an earlier *setu-mo- formation; initial *s is lost in the proposed path.","semanticChange":"Truth, actuality, and proper order form the reconstructed semantic field.","scholar":"Beekes 2010 · Pinault · de Lamberterie","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The exact morphology and wider family have competing analyses.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":563,"id":563,"entryId":114,"entrySlug":"etymologist","childFormId":676,"parentFormId":677,"canonicalEdgeId":599,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form commands secure consensus.","semanticChange":"The title reaches the same disputed comparative horizon as its discipline noun.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The specialist suffix follows a separate branch.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":564,"id":564,"entryId":115,"entrySlug":"etymologize","childFormId":678,"parentFormId":679,"canonicalEdgeId":600,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"English adds verb-forming -ize to etymology.","semanticChange":"The name of the inquiry becomes the act of discovering, stating, or studying etymologies.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Douglas Harper","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The transitive use is reported from 1532 or the 1530s; intransitive use is reported from the 1650s.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":565,"id":565,"entryId":115,"entrySlug":"etymologize","childFormId":679,"parentFormId":680,"canonicalEdgeId":7,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English adapted the learned French form and later aligned spelling with the classical model.","semanticChange":"The technical term broadened into the modern historical discipline.","scholar":"OED · historical lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":566,"id":566,"entryId":115,"entrySlug":"etymologize","childFormId":680,"parentFormId":681,"canonicalEdgeId":8,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French transmitted the learned Latin form.","semanticChange":"Scholarly explanation of a word’s origin continued.","scholar":"French historical lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":567,"id":567,"entryId":115,"entrySlug":"etymologize","childFormId":681,"parentFormId":682,"canonicalEdgeId":9,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin borrowed Greek ἐτυμολογία.","semanticChange":"A Greek technical concept entered Latin grammatical tradition.","scholar":"Latin and Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":568,"id":568,"entryId":115,"entrySlug":"etymologize","childFormId":682,"parentFormId":683,"canonicalEdgeId":10,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The compound joins ἔτυμος “true, real” and -λογία “account, study.”","semanticChange":"A word’s “true sense” becomes an object of analysis.","scholar":"Ancient Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":569,"id":569,"entryId":115,"entrySlug":"etymologize","childFormId":683,"parentFormId":684,"canonicalEdgeId":11,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The attested Greek adjective is analyzed through an earlier *setu-mo- formation; initial *s is lost in the proposed path.","semanticChange":"Truth, actuality, and proper order form the reconstructed semantic field.","scholar":"Beekes 2010 · Pinault · de Lamberterie","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The exact morphology and wider family have competing analyses.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":570,"id":570,"entryId":115,"entrySlug":"etymologize","childFormId":684,"parentFormId":685,"canonicalEdgeId":606,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form commands secure consensus.","semanticChange":"The verb reaches the same disputed comparative horizon as its base noun.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The -ize component follows a separately sourced graph branch.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":571,"id":571,"entryId":116,"entrySlug":"word","childFormId":686,"parentFormId":687,"canonicalEdgeId":624,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern English preserves the inherited spelling word while pronunciation continues the history of English vowel and rhotic systems.","semanticChange":"The core linguistic-unit sense continues alongside utterance, promise, news, command, and technical extensions.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports use before the twelfth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":572,"id":572,"entryId":116,"entrySlug":"word","childFormId":687,"parentFormId":688,"canonicalEdgeId":625,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English word continues Old English word with no donor-language substitution.","semanticChange":"Word, utterance, and expression remain central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":573,"id":573,"entryId":116,"entrySlug":"word","childFormId":688,"parentFormId":689,"canonicalEdgeId":626,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English word continues reconstructed Germanic *wurdam through inherited West Germanic development.","semanticChange":"Something spoken remains a word or utterance.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The Germanic form is reconstructed, not a written donor token.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":574,"id":574,"entryId":116,"entrySlug":"word","childFormId":689,"parentFormId":690,"canonicalEdgeId":627,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Germanic *wurdam reflects the zero-grade *wr̥-dho- formation with inherited Germanic nominal development.","semanticChange":"The reconstructed spoken-unit noun remains the source of the Germanic word family.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative reconstruction; no single transmission date is claimed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":575,"id":575,"entryId":116,"entrySlug":"word","childFormId":690,"parentFormId":691,"canonicalEdgeId":628,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Zero-grade *wr̥- combines with the reconstructed *-dho- nominal suffix.","semanticChange":"The speaking root becomes a noun for something spoken.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both forms are reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":576,"id":576,"entryId":116,"entrySlug":"word","childFormId":691,"parentFormId":692,"canonicalEdgeId":629,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *werh1- speaking root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed and must not be mistaken for an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":577,"id":577,"entryId":117,"entrySlug":"verb","childFormId":693,"parentFormId":694,"canonicalEdgeId":630,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"English verb regularizes the Middle English final vowel away while preserving the learned stem.","semanticChange":"The specialized grammatical class remains central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known use is reported in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":578,"id":578,"entryId":117,"entrySlug":"verb","childFormId":694,"parentFormId":695,"canonicalEdgeId":631,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English verbe borrows Anglo-French verbe with minor English phonological adaptation.","semanticChange":"The grammatical term is transmitted without a return to the broader meaning word.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":579,"id":579,"entryId":117,"entrySlug":"verb","childFormId":695,"parentFormId":696,"canonicalEdgeId":632,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French verbe continues Latin verbum with Romance loss of the final syllable.","semanticChange":"The Latin grammatical use becomes the French and English class name.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":580,"id":580,"entryId":117,"entrySlug":"verb","childFormId":696,"parentFormId":697,"canonicalEdgeId":633,"relationType":"semantic_specialization","soundChange":"The Latin form is unchanged; the grammatical use selects one technical sense of verbum.","semanticChange":"A general word or utterance becomes the name of the predicate word class.","scholar":"Lewis and Short","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Lewis and Short cite Varro and Cicero for the grammatical use.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":581,"id":581,"entryId":117,"entrySlug":"verb","childFormId":697,"parentFormId":698,"canonicalEdgeId":634,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The reconstructed *wer-dho- formation develops into Latin verbum; the graph records the published comparison without inventing intermediate spellings.","semanticChange":"A formation meaning something spoken becomes Latin word, utterance, and later grammatical verb.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative reconstruction; not a directly dated transmission event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":582,"id":582,"entryId":117,"entrySlug":"verb","childFormId":698,"parentFormId":699,"canonicalEdgeId":635,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Full-grade *wer- combines with the reconstructed *-dho- suffix.","semanticChange":"The speaking root becomes a nominal formation for something spoken.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both forms are reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":583,"id":583,"entryId":117,"entrySlug":"verb","childFormId":699,"parentFormId":700,"canonicalEdgeId":636,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *werh1- speaking root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The English grammatical history does not make the prehistoric root directly observable.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":584,"id":584,"entryId":118,"entrySlug":"verbal","childFormId":701,"parentFormId":702,"canonicalEdgeId":637,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"English verbal regularizes the Middle English final vowel while preserving the learned base and suffix.","semanticChange":"The relational word sense continues while verb-related and spoken-language senses develop alongside it.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known use is reported in the fifteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":585,"id":585,"entryId":118,"entrySlug":"verbal","childFormId":702,"parentFormId":703,"canonicalEdgeId":638,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English verbale borrows Late Latin verbalis with English adaptation of the final syllable.","semanticChange":"Of words or verbs enters English and later supports the spoken-rather-than-written contrast.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":586,"id":586,"entryId":118,"entrySlug":"verbal","childFormId":703,"parentFormId":704,"canonicalEdgeId":639,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Late Latin verbalis adds the relational suffix -alis to verbum.","semanticChange":"A word or verb becomes the base of an adjective meaning of or consisting of words.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The suffix follows a separately traversable graph branch.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":587,"id":587,"entryId":118,"entrySlug":"verbal","childFormId":704,"parentFormId":705,"canonicalEdgeId":634,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The reconstructed *wer-dho- formation develops into Latin verbum; the graph records the published comparison without inventing intermediate spellings.","semanticChange":"A formation meaning something spoken becomes Latin word, utterance, and later grammatical verb.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative reconstruction; not a directly dated transmission event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":588,"id":588,"entryId":118,"entrySlug":"verbal","childFormId":705,"parentFormId":706,"canonicalEdgeId":635,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Full-grade *wer- combines with the reconstructed *-dho- suffix.","semanticChange":"The speaking root becomes a nominal formation for something spoken.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both forms are reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":589,"id":589,"entryId":118,"entrySlug":"verbal","childFormId":706,"parentFormId":707,"canonicalEdgeId":642,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *werh1- speaking root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The -alis branch ends separately.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":590,"id":590,"entryId":119,"entrySlug":"adverb","childFormId":708,"parentFormId":709,"canonicalEdgeId":643,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"English adverb regularizes the Middle English final vowel while retaining the learned compound.","semanticChange":"The grammatical class remains a modifier category whose actual scope is wider than verbs alone.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known use is reported in the fifteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":591,"id":591,"entryId":119,"entrySlug":"adverb","childFormId":709,"parentFormId":710,"canonicalEdgeId":644,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English adverbe borrows Middle French adverbe.","semanticChange":"The grammatical category is transmitted through French.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":592,"id":592,"entryId":119,"entrySlug":"adverb","childFormId":710,"parentFormId":711,"canonicalEdgeId":645,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle French adverbe continues Latin adverbium with Romance loss of the final syllable.","semanticChange":"The Latin technical category enters French and English grammatical vocabulary.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":593,"id":593,"entryId":119,"entrySlug":"adverb","childFormId":711,"parentFormId":712,"canonicalEdgeId":646,"relationType":"compound_member","soundChange":"Latin adverbium contains verbum as its lexical member; ad- is exposed as a second canonical parent.","semanticChange":"A word attached toward another expression becomes a technical modifier category.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster also identifies the term as a translation of Greek epirrhema.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":594,"id":594,"entryId":119,"entrySlug":"adverb","childFormId":712,"parentFormId":713,"canonicalEdgeId":634,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The reconstructed *wer-dho- formation develops into Latin verbum; the graph records the published comparison without inventing intermediate spellings.","semanticChange":"A formation meaning something spoken becomes Latin word, utterance, and later grammatical verb.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative reconstruction; not a directly dated transmission event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":595,"id":595,"entryId":119,"entrySlug":"adverb","childFormId":713,"parentFormId":714,"canonicalEdgeId":635,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Full-grade *wer- combines with the reconstructed *-dho- suffix.","semanticChange":"The speaking root becomes a nominal formation for something spoken.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both forms are reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":596,"id":596,"entryId":119,"entrySlug":"adverb","childFormId":714,"parentFormId":715,"canonicalEdgeId":649,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *werh1- speaking root.","semanticChange":"The lexical branch ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The ad- component reaches a separate boundary.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":597,"id":597,"entryId":120,"entrySlug":"proverb","childFormId":716,"parentFormId":717,"canonicalEdgeId":650,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"English proverb regularizes the Middle English final vowel while preserving the learned stem.","semanticChange":"The traditional-saying sense continues.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known use is reported in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":598,"id":598,"entryId":120,"entrySlug":"proverb","childFormId":717,"parentFormId":718,"canonicalEdgeId":651,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English proverbe borrows Anglo-French proverbe.","semanticChange":"The traditional maxim enters English through French.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":599,"id":599,"entryId":120,"entrySlug":"proverb","childFormId":718,"parentFormId":719,"canonicalEdgeId":652,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French proverbe continues Latin proverbium with Romance loss of the final syllable.","semanticChange":"The Latin saying term becomes the French and English noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":600,"id":600,"entryId":120,"entrySlug":"proverb","childFormId":719,"parentFormId":720,"canonicalEdgeId":653,"relationType":"compound_member","soundChange":"Latin proverbium contains verbum as its lexical member; pro- is exposed as a second canonical parent.","semanticChange":"A marked or public saying becomes the traditional maxim named by the compound.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The compound structure is secure; the reviewed dictionary does not reduce the semantic force of pro- to one modern gloss.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":601,"id":601,"entryId":120,"entrySlug":"proverb","childFormId":720,"parentFormId":721,"canonicalEdgeId":634,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The reconstructed *wer-dho- formation develops into Latin verbum; the graph records the published comparison without inventing intermediate spellings.","semanticChange":"A formation meaning something spoken becomes Latin word, utterance, and later grammatical verb.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative reconstruction; not a directly dated transmission event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":602,"id":602,"entryId":120,"entrySlug":"proverb","childFormId":721,"parentFormId":722,"canonicalEdgeId":635,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Full-grade *wer- combines with the reconstructed *-dho- suffix.","semanticChange":"The speaking root becomes a nominal formation for something spoken.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both forms are reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":603,"id":603,"entryId":120,"entrySlug":"proverb","childFormId":722,"parentFormId":723,"canonicalEdgeId":656,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *werh1- speaking root.","semanticChange":"The lexical branch ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The pro- component reaches a separate boundary.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":604,"id":604,"entryId":121,"entrySlug":"verbatim","childFormId":724,"parentFormId":725,"canonicalEdgeId":657,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English verbatim borrows Medieval Latin verbatim with learned stress and pronunciation adaptation.","semanticChange":"Word for word remains the core adverbial meaning; adjective use develops later in English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The adverb is reported from the fifteenth century and the adjective from 1613.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":605,"id":605,"entryId":121,"entrySlug":"verbatim","childFormId":725,"parentFormId":726,"canonicalEdgeId":658,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Medieval Latin verbatim forms an adverb on verbum with -atim.","semanticChange":"A word becomes the base of the distributive sense word by word.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The suffix follows a separately traversable graph branch.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":606,"id":606,"entryId":121,"entrySlug":"verbatim","childFormId":726,"parentFormId":727,"canonicalEdgeId":634,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The reconstructed *wer-dho- formation develops into Latin verbum; the graph records the published comparison without inventing intermediate spellings.","semanticChange":"A formation meaning something spoken becomes Latin word, utterance, and later grammatical verb.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative reconstruction; not a directly dated transmission event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":607,"id":607,"entryId":121,"entrySlug":"verbatim","childFormId":727,"parentFormId":728,"canonicalEdgeId":635,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Full-grade *wer- combines with the reconstructed *-dho- suffix.","semanticChange":"The speaking root becomes a nominal formation for something spoken.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both forms are reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":608,"id":608,"entryId":121,"entrySlug":"verbatim","childFormId":728,"parentFormId":729,"canonicalEdgeId":661,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *werh1- speaking root.","semanticChange":"The lexical branch ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The -atim component reaches a separate boundary.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":609,"id":609,"entryId":122,"entrySlug":"true","childFormId":730,"parentFormId":731,"canonicalEdgeId":671,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern true continues Middle English trewe through regular English spelling and pronunciation history.","semanticChange":"Faithful and steadfast remain live senses beside factual accuracy.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports use before the twelfth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":610,"id":610,"entryId":122,"entrySlug":"true","childFormId":731,"parentFormId":732,"canonicalEdgeId":672,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English trewe continues Old English trēowe.","semanticChange":"Faithful, steadfast, and trustworthy remain central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":611,"id":611,"entryId":122,"entrySlug":"true","childFormId":732,"parentFormId":733,"canonicalEdgeId":673,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English trēowe continues reconstructed Germanic *treuwaz.","semanticChange":"The Germanic firmness adjective develops the faithful and trustworthy field.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The Germanic form is reconstructed, not an attested donor token.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":612,"id":612,"entryId":122,"entrySlug":"true","childFormId":733,"parentFormId":734,"canonicalEdgeId":674,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Germanic *treuwaz reflects the variant *dreu- grade of reconstructed *deru-.","semanticChange":"Firm and steadfast motivate the faithful and trustworthy field without erasing later meanings.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative reconstruction; no single transmission event is claimed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":613,"id":613,"entryId":122,"entrySlug":"true","childFormId":734,"parentFormId":735,"canonicalEdgeId":675,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *deru- firmness-and-wood root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":614,"id":614,"entryId":123,"entrySlug":"truth","childFormId":736,"parentFormId":737,"canonicalEdgeId":676,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern truth continues Middle English trewthe through English spelling and sound history.","semanticChange":"Fidelity and constancy coexist historically with sincerity and factual correspondence.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports use before the twelfth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":615,"id":615,"entryId":123,"entrySlug":"truth","childFormId":737,"parentFormId":738,"canonicalEdgeId":677,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English trewthe continues Old English trēowþ.","semanticChange":"Loyalty, faith, and truth remain joined in the historical noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":616,"id":616,"entryId":123,"entrySlug":"truth","childFormId":738,"parentFormId":739,"canonicalEdgeId":678,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English trēowþ continues reconstructed Germanic *treuwithō through inherited West Germanic development.","semanticChange":"The abstract noun denotes faith, loyalty, and truth.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The Germanic form is reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":617,"id":617,"entryId":123,"entrySlug":"truth","childFormId":739,"parentFormId":740,"canonicalEdgeId":679,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Germanic *treuwithō is an abstract noun formation on *treuwaz.","semanticChange":"Being firm or faithful becomes the quality of faith, loyalty, or truth.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both Germanic forms are reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":618,"id":618,"entryId":123,"entrySlug":"truth","childFormId":740,"parentFormId":741,"canonicalEdgeId":674,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Germanic *treuwaz reflects the variant *dreu- grade of reconstructed *deru-.","semanticChange":"Firm and steadfast motivate the faithful and trustworthy field without erasing later meanings.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative reconstruction; no single transmission event is claimed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":619,"id":619,"entryId":123,"entrySlug":"truth","childFormId":741,"parentFormId":742,"canonicalEdgeId":681,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *deru- firmness-and-wood root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":620,"id":620,"entryId":124,"entrySlug":"trust","childFormId":743,"parentFormId":744,"canonicalEdgeId":682,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern trust continues Middle English truste through regular English form history.","semanticChange":"Confidence and assured reliance remain central while legal and institutional senses develop alongside them.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports noun use in the twelfth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":621,"id":621,"entryId":124,"entrySlug":"trust","childFormId":744,"parentFormId":745,"canonicalEdgeId":683,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English truste is probably borrowed from Scandinavian, perhaps specifically Old Norse traust.","semanticChange":"Confidence and firmness enter the English trust noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The sources independently use cautious probably or perhaps language rather than claiming a certain donor token.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":622,"id":622,"entryId":124,"entrySlug":"trust","childFormId":745,"parentFormId":746,"canonicalEdgeId":684,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Norse traust continues reconstructed Germanic *traustam.","semanticChange":"Confidence and firmness remain the core semantic field.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The Germanic noun is reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":623,"id":623,"entryId":124,"entrySlug":"trust","childFormId":746,"parentFormId":747,"canonicalEdgeId":685,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Germanic *traustam is an abstract noun formation related to *treuwaz.","semanticChange":"Firm or faithful becomes confidence, reliance, or firmness.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both Germanic forms are reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":624,"id":624,"entryId":124,"entrySlug":"trust","childFormId":747,"parentFormId":748,"canonicalEdgeId":674,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Germanic *treuwaz reflects the variant *dreu- grade of reconstructed *deru-.","semanticChange":"Firm and steadfast motivate the faithful and trustworthy field without erasing later meanings.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative reconstruction; no single transmission event is claimed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":625,"id":625,"entryId":124,"entrySlug":"trust","childFormId":748,"parentFormId":749,"canonicalEdgeId":687,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *deru- firmness-and-wood root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":626,"id":626,"entryId":125,"entrySlug":"troth","childFormId":750,"parentFormId":751,"canonicalEdgeId":688,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern troth continues Middle English trouth with regular English spelling and sound development.","semanticChange":"Pledged fidelity narrows a historical noun that also covered truth and loyalty.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports noun use in the twelfth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":627,"id":627,"entryId":125,"entrySlug":"troth","childFormId":751,"parentFormId":752,"canonicalEdgeId":689,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English trouth continues Old English trēowþ.","semanticChange":"Truth, faith, and pledged fidelity remain joined before later lexical specialization.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":628,"id":628,"entryId":125,"entrySlug":"troth","childFormId":752,"parentFormId":753,"canonicalEdgeId":678,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English trēowþ continues reconstructed Germanic *treuwithō through inherited West Germanic development.","semanticChange":"The abstract noun denotes faith, loyalty, and truth.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The Germanic form is reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":629,"id":629,"entryId":125,"entrySlug":"troth","childFormId":753,"parentFormId":754,"canonicalEdgeId":679,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Germanic *treuwithō is an abstract noun formation on *treuwaz.","semanticChange":"Being firm or faithful becomes the quality of faith, loyalty, or truth.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both Germanic forms are reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":630,"id":630,"entryId":125,"entrySlug":"troth","childFormId":754,"parentFormId":755,"canonicalEdgeId":674,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Germanic *treuwaz reflects the variant *dreu- grade of reconstructed *deru-.","semanticChange":"Firm and steadfast motivate the faithful and trustworthy field without erasing later meanings.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative reconstruction; no single transmission event is claimed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":631,"id":631,"entryId":125,"entrySlug":"troth","childFormId":755,"parentFormId":756,"canonicalEdgeId":693,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *deru- firmness-and-wood root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":632,"id":632,"entryId":126,"entrySlug":"betroth","childFormId":757,"parentFormId":758,"canonicalEdgeId":694,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern betroth continues Middle English bitrouthen with regular English spelling and sound development.","semanticChange":"The marriage promise remains the specialized sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports use in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":633,"id":633,"entryId":126,"entrySlug":"betroth","childFormId":758,"parentFormId":759,"canonicalEdgeId":695,"relationType":"compound_member","soundChange":"Middle English bitrouthen contains trouth as its lexical member; bi- or be- follows a second canonical parent.","semanticChange":"A pledge of truth or troth specializes as a promise in marriage.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The prefix branch is separately modeled and cited.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":634,"id":634,"entryId":126,"entrySlug":"betroth","childFormId":759,"parentFormId":760,"canonicalEdgeId":689,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English trouth continues Old English trēowþ.","semanticChange":"Truth, faith, and pledged fidelity remain joined before later lexical specialization.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":635,"id":635,"entryId":126,"entrySlug":"betroth","childFormId":760,"parentFormId":761,"canonicalEdgeId":678,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English trēowþ continues reconstructed Germanic *treuwithō through inherited West Germanic development.","semanticChange":"The abstract noun denotes faith, loyalty, and truth.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The Germanic form is reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":636,"id":636,"entryId":126,"entrySlug":"betroth","childFormId":761,"parentFormId":762,"canonicalEdgeId":679,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Germanic *treuwithō is an abstract noun formation on *treuwaz.","semanticChange":"Being firm or faithful becomes the quality of faith, loyalty, or truth.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both Germanic forms are reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":637,"id":637,"entryId":126,"entrySlug":"betroth","childFormId":762,"parentFormId":763,"canonicalEdgeId":674,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Germanic *treuwaz reflects the variant *dreu- grade of reconstructed *deru-.","semanticChange":"Firm and steadfast motivate the faithful and trustworthy field without erasing later meanings.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative reconstruction; no single transmission event is claimed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":638,"id":638,"entryId":126,"entrySlug":"betroth","childFormId":763,"parentFormId":764,"canonicalEdgeId":700,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *deru- firmness-and-wood root.","semanticChange":"The lexical trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word; the prefix branch ends separately.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":639,"id":639,"entryId":127,"entrySlug":"truce","childFormId":765,"parentFormId":766,"canonicalEdgeId":701,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern singular truce continues Middle English trewes after the inherited plural was reanalyzed as a singular form.","semanticChange":"Agreements or pledges specialize as a temporary suspension of hostilities.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports noun use in the thirteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":640,"id":640,"entryId":127,"entrySlug":"truce","childFormId":766,"parentFormId":767,"canonicalEdgeId":702,"relationType":"inflectional_reanalysis","soundChange":"Middle English plural trewes is formed on singular trewe and later supplies the English singular truce.","semanticChange":"Multiple agreements or pledges furnish the form reanalyzed for one suspension of hostilities.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The cited dictionary explicitly marks trewes as plural.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":641,"id":641,"entryId":127,"entrySlug":"truce","childFormId":767,"parentFormId":768,"canonicalEdgeId":703,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English trewe continues Old English trēow in the pledge and fidelity sense.","semanticChange":"A pledge or agreement continues the older fidelity noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":642,"id":642,"entryId":127,"entrySlug":"truce","childFormId":768,"parentFormId":769,"canonicalEdgeId":704,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English trēow continues reconstructed Germanic *treuwō in the pledge branch.","semanticChange":"Pledge and fidelity remain the semantic center.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The Germanic noun is reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":643,"id":643,"entryId":127,"entrySlug":"truce","childFormId":769,"parentFormId":770,"canonicalEdgeId":705,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Germanic *treuwō continues the reconstructed suffixed formation *drew-o-.","semanticChange":"A firmness formation develops the pledge and fidelity noun.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both forms are reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":644,"id":644,"entryId":127,"entrySlug":"truce","childFormId":770,"parentFormId":771,"canonicalEdgeId":706,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Reconstructed *drew-o- is a suffixed formation under *deru-.","semanticChange":"Firmness supports both wood and pledge branches without making one descendant the parent of the other.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative morphology; no single date or token is claimed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":645,"id":645,"entryId":127,"entrySlug":"truce","childFormId":771,"parentFormId":772,"canonicalEdgeId":707,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *deru- firmness-and-wood root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":646,"id":646,"entryId":128,"entrySlug":"tree","childFormId":773,"parentFormId":774,"canonicalEdgeId":708,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern tree continues the Middle English plant noun through regular English spelling and sound history.","semanticChange":"The woody plant remains central while branching diagrams and structures develop as extensions.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports use before the twelfth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":647,"id":647,"entryId":128,"entrySlug":"tree","childFormId":774,"parentFormId":775,"canonicalEdgeId":709,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English tree continues Old English trēow in the wood and plant sense.","semanticChange":"Tree and wood remain the semantic center.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":648,"id":648,"entryId":128,"entrySlug":"tree","childFormId":775,"parentFormId":776,"canonicalEdgeId":710,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English trēow continues reconstructed Germanic *trewam in the tree branch.","semanticChange":"The inherited noun denotes tree or wood.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The Germanic noun is reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":649,"id":649,"entryId":128,"entrySlug":"tree","childFormId":776,"parentFormId":777,"canonicalEdgeId":711,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Germanic *trewam continues the reconstructed suffixed formation *drew-o-.","semanticChange":"A firmness formation develops the wood and tree noun.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both forms are reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":650,"id":650,"entryId":128,"entrySlug":"tree","childFormId":777,"parentFormId":778,"canonicalEdgeId":706,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Reconstructed *drew-o- is a suffixed formation under *deru-.","semanticChange":"Firmness supports both wood and pledge branches without making one descendant the parent of the other.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative morphology; no single date or token is claimed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":651,"id":651,"entryId":128,"entrySlug":"tree","childFormId":778,"parentFormId":779,"canonicalEdgeId":713,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *deru- firmness-and-wood root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":652,"id":652,"entryId":129,"entrySlug":"right","childFormId":780,"parentFormId":781,"canonicalEdgeId":717,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern right continues Middle English right through English spelling and sound history.","semanticChange":"Justice, correctness, suitability, straightness, and direction remain part of a polysemous word.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports use before the twelfth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":653,"id":653,"entryId":129,"entrySlug":"right","childFormId":781,"parentFormId":782,"canonicalEdgeId":718,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English right continues Old English riht.","semanticChange":"The inherited field joins straight, correct, and just.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":654,"id":654,"entryId":129,"entrySlug":"right","childFormId":782,"parentFormId":783,"canonicalEdgeId":719,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English riht reflects Germanic *rehtaz through regular West Germanic history.","semanticChange":"The Germanic adjective retains right, just, correct, and straight senses.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The parent is reconstructed rather than directly attested.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":655,"id":655,"entryId":129,"entrySlug":"right","childFormId":783,"parentFormId":784,"canonicalEdgeId":720,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Germanic *rehtaz reflects reconstructed *reg-to- with the expected Germanic consonant history.","semanticChange":"A straight or directed formation supports correctness and rightness.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both stages before Old English are comparative reconstructions.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":656,"id":656,"entryId":129,"entrySlug":"right","childFormId":784,"parentFormId":785,"canonicalEdgeId":721,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Reconstructed *reg-to- is a suffixed formation under centum *h₃reg-.","semanticChange":"The formation specializes the straight-and-direct root as a right or straight adjective.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative morphology, not one dated coinage event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":657,"id":657,"entryId":129,"entrySlug":"right","childFormId":785,"parentFormId":786,"canonicalEdgeId":722,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Centum *h₃reg- reflects the oldest published form *h₃reg̑-.","semanticChange":"The straight, direct, lead, and rule field is preserved across the reconstructed notation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both nodes are reconstructed analytical forms, not separately attested words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":658,"id":658,"entryId":129,"entrySlug":"right","childFormId":786,"parentFormId":787,"canonicalEdgeId":723,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *h₃reg̑- root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":659,"id":659,"entryId":130,"entrySlug":"rule","childFormId":788,"parentFormId":789,"canonicalEdgeId":724,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern rule continues Middle English reule through English spelling and pronunciation history.","semanticChange":"A guide for action expands across standards, authority, procedures, and measurement.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports use in the thirteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":660,"id":660,"entryId":130,"entrySlug":"rule","childFormId":789,"parentFormId":790,"canonicalEdgeId":725,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English reule was borrowed from Anglo-French reule.","semanticChange":"The guide or standard sense crosses into English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":661,"id":661,"entryId":130,"entrySlug":"rule","childFormId":790,"parentFormId":791,"canonicalEdgeId":726,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French reule continues Latin rēgula through Romance sound and spelling history.","semanticChange":"A straightedge or ruler also supplies an abstract guide or principle.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":662,"id":662,"entryId":130,"entrySlug":"rule","childFormId":791,"parentFormId":792,"canonicalEdgeId":727,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin rēgula continues reconstructed suffixed *rēg-olā-.","semanticChange":"A straight piece or rod develops both measuring and normative rule senses.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The parent is a comparative morphological reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":663,"id":663,"entryId":130,"entrySlug":"rule","childFormId":792,"parentFormId":793,"canonicalEdgeId":728,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Reconstructed *rēg-olā- is a suffixed formation under centum *h₃reg-.","semanticChange":"The straight-piece formation specializes the straight-and-direct root.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative morphology, not one dated coinage event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":664,"id":664,"entryId":130,"entrySlug":"rule","childFormId":793,"parentFormId":794,"canonicalEdgeId":722,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Centum *h₃reg- reflects the oldest published form *h₃reg̑-.","semanticChange":"The straight, direct, lead, and rule field is preserved across the reconstructed notation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both nodes are reconstructed analytical forms, not separately attested words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":665,"id":665,"entryId":130,"entrySlug":"rule","childFormId":794,"parentFormId":795,"canonicalEdgeId":730,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *h₃reg̑- root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":666,"id":666,"entryId":131,"entrySlug":"regular","childFormId":796,"parentFormId":797,"canonicalEdgeId":731,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern regular continues Middle English reguler through English spelling and sound history.","semanticChange":"Living by a rule expands to orderly, patterned, recurring, standard, and normal.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports adjective use in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":667,"id":667,"entryId":131,"entrySlug":"regular","childFormId":797,"parentFormId":798,"canonicalEdgeId":732,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English reguler was borrowed through Anglo-French reguler.","semanticChange":"The rule-governed adjective crosses into English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":668,"id":668,"entryId":131,"entrySlug":"regular","childFormId":798,"parentFormId":799,"canonicalEdgeId":733,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French reguler continues Late Latin rēgulāris through Romance transmission.","semanticChange":"According to a rule remains the central inherited relation.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":669,"id":669,"entryId":131,"entrySlug":"regular","childFormId":799,"parentFormId":800,"canonicalEdgeId":734,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Late Latin rēgulāris is an adjective formed from Latin rēgula.","semanticChange":"Of a bar or according to rule develops orderly and regular senses.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":670,"id":670,"entryId":131,"entrySlug":"regular","childFormId":800,"parentFormId":801,"canonicalEdgeId":727,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin rēgula continues reconstructed suffixed *rēg-olā-.","semanticChange":"A straight piece or rod develops both measuring and normative rule senses.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The parent is a comparative morphological reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":671,"id":671,"entryId":131,"entrySlug":"regular","childFormId":801,"parentFormId":802,"canonicalEdgeId":728,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Reconstructed *rēg-olā- is a suffixed formation under centum *h₃reg-.","semanticChange":"The straight-piece formation specializes the straight-and-direct root.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative morphology, not one dated coinage event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":672,"id":672,"entryId":131,"entrySlug":"regular","childFormId":802,"parentFormId":803,"canonicalEdgeId":722,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Centum *h₃reg- reflects the oldest published form *h₃reg̑-.","semanticChange":"The straight, direct, lead, and rule field is preserved across the reconstructed notation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both nodes are reconstructed analytical forms, not separately attested words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":673,"id":673,"entryId":131,"entrySlug":"regular","childFormId":803,"parentFormId":804,"canonicalEdgeId":738,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *h₃reg̑- root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":674,"id":674,"entryId":132,"entrySlug":"regulate","childFormId":805,"parentFormId":806,"canonicalEdgeId":739,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern regulate continues the reported Middle English verb.","semanticChange":"Govern or direct according to rule expands to ordering, controlling, and technical adjustment.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports use in the fifteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":675,"id":675,"entryId":132,"entrySlug":"regulate","childFormId":806,"parentFormId":807,"canonicalEdgeId":740,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"The Middle English verb reflects Late Latin regulātus.","semanticChange":"A regulated or directed participle supplies the English verb formation.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":676,"id":676,"entryId":132,"entrySlug":"regulate","childFormId":807,"parentFormId":808,"canonicalEdgeId":741,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"Late Latin regulātus is the past participle of regulāre.","semanticChange":"The participle preserves the verb’s directing and regulating sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":677,"id":677,"entryId":132,"entrySlug":"regulate","childFormId":808,"parentFormId":809,"canonicalEdgeId":742,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Late Latin regulāre is formed from Latin rēgula.","semanticChange":"To regulate or direct means act according to a rule.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":678,"id":678,"entryId":132,"entrySlug":"regulate","childFormId":809,"parentFormId":810,"canonicalEdgeId":727,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin rēgula continues reconstructed suffixed *rēg-olā-.","semanticChange":"A straight piece or rod develops both measuring and normative rule senses.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The parent is a comparative morphological reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":679,"id":679,"entryId":132,"entrySlug":"regulate","childFormId":810,"parentFormId":811,"canonicalEdgeId":728,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Reconstructed *rēg-olā- is a suffixed formation under centum *h₃reg-.","semanticChange":"The straight-piece formation specializes the straight-and-direct root.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative morphology, not one dated coinage event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":680,"id":680,"entryId":132,"entrySlug":"regulate","childFormId":811,"parentFormId":812,"canonicalEdgeId":722,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Centum *h₃reg- reflects the oldest published form *h₃reg̑-.","semanticChange":"The straight, direct, lead, and rule field is preserved across the reconstructed notation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both nodes are reconstructed analytical forms, not separately attested words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":681,"id":681,"entryId":132,"entrySlug":"regulate","childFormId":812,"parentFormId":813,"canonicalEdgeId":746,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *h₃reg̑- root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":682,"id":682,"entryId":133,"entrySlug":"royal","childFormId":814,"parentFormId":815,"canonicalEdgeId":747,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern royal continues Middle English roial through English spelling and sound history.","semanticChange":"Of a monarch or crown expands to magnificent and superior.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports adjective use in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":683,"id":683,"entryId":133,"entrySlug":"royal","childFormId":815,"parentFormId":816,"canonicalEdgeId":748,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English roial was borrowed from Anglo-French roial or real.","semanticChange":"The monarch adjective crosses into English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":684,"id":684,"entryId":133,"entrySlug":"royal","childFormId":816,"parentFormId":817,"canonicalEdgeId":749,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French roial continues Latin rēgālis through Romance sound and spelling history.","semanticChange":"The kingly adjective remains monarch-centered.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":685,"id":685,"entryId":133,"entrySlug":"royal","childFormId":817,"parentFormId":818,"canonicalEdgeId":750,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin rēgālis is formed from rēx, rēg-, king.","semanticChange":"Kingly or royal is transparently derived from the king noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":686,"id":686,"entryId":133,"entrySlug":"royal","childFormId":818,"parentFormId":819,"canonicalEdgeId":751,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin rēx reflects reconstructed lengthened-grade *rēg-.","semanticChange":"The lengthened grade supplies an Indo-European king formation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The parent is reconstructed; rēx is attested Latin.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":687,"id":687,"entryId":133,"entrySlug":"royal","childFormId":819,"parentFormId":820,"canonicalEdgeId":752,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Lengthened-grade *rēg- belongs under centum *h₃reg-.","semanticChange":"The ruler or king formation specializes the straight, direct, lead, and rule family.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative ablaut analysis, not one dated institutional event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":688,"id":688,"entryId":133,"entrySlug":"royal","childFormId":820,"parentFormId":821,"canonicalEdgeId":722,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Centum *h₃reg- reflects the oldest published form *h₃reg̑-.","semanticChange":"The straight, direct, lead, and rule field is preserved across the reconstructed notation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both nodes are reconstructed analytical forms, not separately attested words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":689,"id":689,"entryId":133,"entrySlug":"royal","childFormId":821,"parentFormId":822,"canonicalEdgeId":754,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *h₃reg̑- root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":690,"id":690,"entryId":134,"entrySlug":"regal","childFormId":823,"parentFormId":824,"canonicalEdgeId":755,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern regal continues the Middle English adjective.","semanticChange":"Royal or kingly expands to magnificent or splendid.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports use in the fifteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":691,"id":691,"entryId":134,"entrySlug":"regal","childFormId":824,"parentFormId":825,"canonicalEdgeId":756,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English regal was borrowed through Old French, with direct Latin or Anglo-French transmission also reported.","semanticChange":"The monarch adjective enters English while the exact medieval channel remains plural in the authorities.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"American Heritage gives Old French; Merriam-Webster permits Anglo-French or Latin.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":692,"id":692,"entryId":134,"entrySlug":"regal","childFormId":825,"parentFormId":826,"canonicalEdgeId":757,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French regal continues Latin rēgālis.","semanticChange":"The kingly adjective remains monarch-centered.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":693,"id":693,"entryId":134,"entrySlug":"regal","childFormId":826,"parentFormId":827,"canonicalEdgeId":750,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin rēgālis is formed from rēx, rēg-, king.","semanticChange":"Kingly or royal is transparently derived from the king noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":694,"id":694,"entryId":134,"entrySlug":"regal","childFormId":827,"parentFormId":828,"canonicalEdgeId":751,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin rēx reflects reconstructed lengthened-grade *rēg-.","semanticChange":"The lengthened grade supplies an Indo-European king formation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The parent is reconstructed; rēx is attested Latin.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":695,"id":695,"entryId":134,"entrySlug":"regal","childFormId":828,"parentFormId":829,"canonicalEdgeId":752,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Lengthened-grade *rēg- belongs under centum *h₃reg-.","semanticChange":"The ruler or king formation specializes the straight, direct, lead, and rule family.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative ablaut analysis, not one dated institutional event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":696,"id":696,"entryId":134,"entrySlug":"regal","childFormId":829,"parentFormId":830,"canonicalEdgeId":722,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Centum *h₃reg- reflects the oldest published form *h₃reg̑-.","semanticChange":"The straight, direct, lead, and rule field is preserved across the reconstructed notation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both nodes are reconstructed analytical forms, not separately attested words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":697,"id":697,"entryId":134,"entrySlug":"regal","childFormId":830,"parentFormId":831,"canonicalEdgeId":762,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *h₃reg̑- root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":698,"id":698,"entryId":135,"entrySlug":"realm","childFormId":832,"parentFormId":833,"canonicalEdgeId":763,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern realm continues Middle English realme through spelling reduction.","semanticChange":"Kingdom broadens to any domain or sphere.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports use in the thirteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":699,"id":699,"entryId":135,"entrySlug":"realm","childFormId":833,"parentFormId":834,"canonicalEdgeId":764,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English realme continues an altered Old French reiame form.","semanticChange":"Government or kingdom remains the central domain sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Analogical influence from royal is represented on a separate canonical edge.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":700,"id":700,"entryId":135,"entrySlug":"realm","childFormId":834,"parentFormId":835,"canonicalEdgeId":765,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French reiame continues Latin regimen through Romance transmission.","semanticChange":"Control or government becomes a governed territory or kingdom.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":701,"id":701,"entryId":135,"entrySlug":"realm","childFormId":835,"parentFormId":836,"canonicalEdgeId":766,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin regimen is formed from regere, to lead straight, direct, or rule.","semanticChange":"Control and government are nominalized from directing or ruling.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":702,"id":702,"entryId":135,"entrySlug":"realm","childFormId":836,"parentFormId":837,"canonicalEdgeId":767,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin regere continues centum *h₃reg-.","semanticChange":"Lead straight, direct, and rule preserve the reconstructed root field.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":703,"id":703,"entryId":135,"entrySlug":"realm","childFormId":837,"parentFormId":838,"canonicalEdgeId":722,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Centum *h₃reg- reflects the oldest published form *h₃reg̑-.","semanticChange":"The straight, direct, lead, and rule field is preserved across the reconstructed notation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both nodes are reconstructed analytical forms, not separately attested words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":704,"id":704,"entryId":135,"entrySlug":"realm","childFormId":838,"parentFormId":839,"canonicalEdgeId":769,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *h₃reg̑- root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":705,"id":705,"entryId":136,"entrySlug":"rich","childFormId":840,"parentFormId":841,"canonicalEdgeId":770,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern rich continues Middle English riche through English spelling and sound history.","semanticChange":"Power and wealth broaden across abundance, value, color, flavor, and intensity.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports use before the twelfth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":706,"id":706,"entryId":136,"entrySlug":"rich","childFormId":841,"parentFormId":842,"canonicalEdgeId":771,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English riche continues Old English rīce while also receiving French-family influence represented separately.","semanticChange":"Strong and powerful develop toward wealthy and abundant.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"American Heritage reports both Old English and Old French inputs.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":707,"id":707,"entryId":136,"entrySlug":"rich","childFormId":842,"parentFormId":843,"canonicalEdgeId":772,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English rīce reflects Germanic *rīkja-.","semanticChange":"The powerful or kingly adjective supports later wealth senses.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The Germanic form is reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":708,"id":708,"entryId":136,"entrySlug":"rich","childFormId":843,"parentFormId":844,"canonicalEdgeId":773,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Germanic *rīkja- was borrowed from Celtic *rīg-yo-.","semanticChange":"A kingly or powerful formation enters Germanic before the English and French branches.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both donor and recipient forms are reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":709,"id":709,"entryId":136,"entrySlug":"rich","childFormId":844,"parentFormId":845,"canonicalEdgeId":774,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Celtic *rīg-yo- belongs to lengthened-grade *rēg-.","semanticChange":"The Celtic kingly formation specializes the Indo-European ruler branch.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative morphology, not one dated borrowing token.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":710,"id":710,"entryId":136,"entrySlug":"rich","childFormId":845,"parentFormId":846,"canonicalEdgeId":752,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Lengthened-grade *rēg- belongs under centum *h₃reg-.","semanticChange":"The ruler or king formation specializes the straight, direct, lead, and rule family.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative ablaut analysis, not one dated institutional event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":711,"id":711,"entryId":136,"entrySlug":"rich","childFormId":846,"parentFormId":847,"canonicalEdgeId":722,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Centum *h₃reg- reflects the oldest published form *h₃reg̑-.","semanticChange":"The straight, direct, lead, and rule field is preserved across the reconstructed notation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both nodes are reconstructed analytical forms, not separately attested words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":712,"id":712,"entryId":136,"entrySlug":"rich","childFormId":847,"parentFormId":848,"canonicalEdgeId":777,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *h₃reg̑- root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":713,"id":713,"entryId":137,"entrySlug":"direct","childFormId":849,"parentFormId":850,"canonicalEdgeId":782,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern direct continues Middle English directen with loss of the infinitive ending and stabilized modern spelling.","semanticChange":"Guiding, aiming, ordering, straightness, and immediacy expand across verb, adjective, and adverb functions.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports the verb in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":714,"id":714,"entryId":137,"entrySlug":"direct","childFormId":850,"parentFormId":851,"canonicalEdgeId":783,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English directen was borrowed through Anglo-French directer in the verb route.","semanticChange":"To guide or point crosses into English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":715,"id":715,"entryId":137,"entrySlug":"direct","childFormId":851,"parentFormId":852,"canonicalEdgeId":784,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French directer continues Latin dīrēctus through Romance verbal formation.","semanticChange":"Straightened supplies directing and guiding senses.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":716,"id":716,"entryId":137,"entrySlug":"direct","childFormId":852,"parentFormId":853,"canonicalEdgeId":785,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"Latin dīrēctus is the past participle of dīrigere.","semanticChange":"What has been set straight becomes straight or directed.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":717,"id":717,"entryId":137,"entrySlug":"direct","childFormId":853,"parentFormId":854,"canonicalEdgeId":786,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"Latin dīrigere contains regere beside the separately modeled dī-/dis- prefix.","semanticChange":"Setting apart or into line specializes leading straight, guiding, and directing.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The exact contribution of the prefix is not paraphrased as modern negation.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":718,"id":718,"entryId":137,"entrySlug":"direct","childFormId":854,"parentFormId":855,"canonicalEdgeId":767,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin regere continues centum *h₃reg-.","semanticChange":"Lead straight, direct, and rule preserve the reconstructed root field.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":719,"id":719,"entryId":137,"entrySlug":"direct","childFormId":855,"parentFormId":856,"canonicalEdgeId":722,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Centum *h₃reg- reflects the oldest published form *h₃reg̑-.","semanticChange":"The straight, direct, lead, and rule field is preserved across the reconstructed notation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both nodes are reconstructed analytical forms, not separately attested words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":720,"id":720,"entryId":137,"entrySlug":"direct","childFormId":856,"parentFormId":857,"canonicalEdgeId":789,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *h₃reg̑- root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":721,"id":721,"entryId":138,"entrySlug":"ri","childFormId":858,"parentFormId":859,"canonicalEdgeId":790,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Celtic nominative *rīx-s develops to Old Irish rí, while genitive ríg preserves the stem consonant.","semanticChange":"The king title remains a king noun through the Celtic sound changes.","scholar":"Anders Richardt Jørgensen · Patrizia de Bernardo Stempel","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Old Irish is recorded in the early medieval period; Proto-Celtic is reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":722,"id":722,"entryId":138,"entrySlug":"ri","childFormId":859,"parentFormId":860,"canonicalEdgeId":791,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Celtic *rīx-s reflects the Indo-European lengthened king grade *rēg-.","semanticChange":"King remains the central meaning while Celtic raises inherited *ē to *ī and develops the final cluster.","scholar":"Anders Richardt Jørgensen","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The source gives *rīx-s and genitive *rīg-os from PIE *(h₃)rēg̑-.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":723,"id":723,"entryId":138,"entrySlug":"ri","childFormId":860,"parentFormId":861,"canonicalEdgeId":752,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Lengthened-grade *rēg- belongs under centum *h₃reg-.","semanticChange":"The ruler or king formation specializes the straight, direct, lead, and rule family.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative ablaut analysis, not one dated institutional event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":724,"id":724,"entryId":138,"entrySlug":"ri","childFormId":861,"parentFormId":862,"canonicalEdgeId":722,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Centum *h₃reg- reflects the oldest published form *h₃reg̑-.","semanticChange":"The straight, direct, lead, and rule field is preserved across the reconstructed notation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both nodes are reconstructed analytical forms, not separately attested words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":725,"id":725,"entryId":138,"entrySlug":"ri","childFormId":862,"parentFormId":863,"canonicalEdgeId":794,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *h₃reg̑- root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":726,"id":726,"entryId":139,"entrySlug":"raja","childFormId":864,"parentFormId":865,"canonicalEdgeId":795,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"Sanskrit rājā is the nominative singular of the consonant stem rājan-.","semanticChange":"The inflected form and lexical stem both mean king rather than separate lexical ancestors.","scholar":"Monier Monier-Williams · Harald Wiese","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The relation is grammatical morphology inside Sanskrit.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":727,"id":727,"entryId":139,"entrySlug":"raja","childFormId":865,"parentFormId":866,"canonicalEdgeId":796,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Sanskrit rājan- reflects the reconstructed suffixed king formation *rēg-en-.","semanticChange":"King, ruler, sovereign, and chief preserve the ruler field.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The Sanskrit form is attested; the parent is reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":728,"id":728,"entryId":139,"entrySlug":"raja","childFormId":866,"parentFormId":867,"canonicalEdgeId":797,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Reconstructed *rēg-en- is an n-stem formation on lengthened-grade *rēg-.","semanticChange":"The suffix forms a king noun inside the ruler branch.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative morphology rather than a dated word-formation event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":729,"id":729,"entryId":139,"entrySlug":"raja","childFormId":867,"parentFormId":868,"canonicalEdgeId":752,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Lengthened-grade *rēg- belongs under centum *h₃reg-.","semanticChange":"The ruler or king formation specializes the straight, direct, lead, and rule family.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative ablaut analysis, not one dated institutional event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":730,"id":730,"entryId":139,"entrySlug":"raja","childFormId":868,"parentFormId":869,"canonicalEdgeId":722,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Centum *h₃reg- reflects the oldest published form *h₃reg̑-.","semanticChange":"The straight, direct, lead, and rule field is preserved across the reconstructed notation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both nodes are reconstructed analytical forms, not separately attested words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":731,"id":731,"entryId":139,"entrySlug":"raja","childFormId":869,"parentFormId":870,"canonicalEdgeId":800,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *h₃reg̑- root.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":732,"id":732,"entryId":140,"entrySlug":"woman","childFormId":871,"parentFormId":872,"canonicalEdgeId":804,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English womman develops to modern woman with reduction of the unstressed final syllable and modern spelling.","semanticChange":"The female-person compound remains the ordinary adult-female noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded before the twelfth century in English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":733,"id":733,"entryId":140,"entrySlug":"woman","childFormId":872,"parentFormId":873,"canonicalEdgeId":805,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Old English wīfman contracts and assimilates into Middle English womman.","semanticChange":"The compound remains a woman noun while its internal morphology becomes opaque.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":734,"id":734,"entryId":140,"entrySlug":"woman","childFormId":873,"parentFormId":874,"canonicalEdgeId":806,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"Old English wīfman contains wīf as its first lexical component.","semanticChange":"Woman or wife combines with the separately modeled human-person component mann.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"A morphological relation inside Old English, not a borrowing event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":735,"id":735,"entryId":140,"entrySlug":"woman","childFormId":874,"parentFormId":875,"canonicalEdgeId":807,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No direct parent is promoted beyond Old English wīf in the reviewed dossier spine.","semanticChange":"The trail stops while probable cognate comparisons remain labeled as relatives.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster calls the Tocharian comparison probable rather than supplying a secure direct ancestor.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":736,"id":736,"entryId":141,"entrySlug":"man","childFormId":876,"parentFormId":877,"canonicalEdgeId":808,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern man continues Middle English man with stabilized spelling and pronunciation.","semanticChange":"A broad human-being word develops an increasingly salient adult-male sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded before the twelfth century in English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":737,"id":737,"entryId":141,"entrySlug":"man","childFormId":877,"parentFormId":878,"canonicalEdgeId":809,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English man continues Old English mann or mon.","semanticChange":"Human being and person remain central while male-specific usage expands.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":738,"id":738,"entryId":141,"entrySlug":"man","childFormId":878,"parentFormId":879,"canonicalEdgeId":810,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English mann reflects Proto-Germanic *mann-.","semanticChange":"The human-person field remains visible across Germanic.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The parent is reconstructed; the child is attested.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":739,"id":739,"entryId":141,"entrySlug":"man","childFormId":879,"parentFormId":880,"canonicalEdgeId":811,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *mann- is analyzed under the extended Indo-European form *manu-.","semanticChange":"The human-being noun continues across the reconstructed stages.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":740,"id":740,"entryId":141,"entrySlug":"man","childFormId":880,"parentFormId":881,"canonicalEdgeId":812,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Extended *manu- is built on the root *man-¹.","semanticChange":"The extension forms a human-being noun without invoking the separate think root.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":741,"id":741,"entryId":141,"entrySlug":"man","childFormId":881,"parentFormId":882,"canonicalEdgeId":813,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *man-¹.","semanticChange":"The human-being trail ends before unsupported root-merging.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"American Heritage prints man-¹ and men-¹ as distinct entries.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":742,"id":742,"entryId":142,"entrySlug":"female","childFormId":883,"parentFormId":884,"canonicalEdgeId":814,"relationType":"analogical_reshaping","soundChange":"Earlier femelle or femel was respelled female under the influence of male.","semanticChange":"The sex-class meaning continues while surface spelling creates a misleading resemblance.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Influence is not common ancestry or morphological composition.","chronologyNote":"The remodeling occurs within English after borrowing.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":743,"id":743,"entryId":142,"entrySlug":"female","childFormId":884,"parentFormId":885,"canonicalEdgeId":815,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English femelle continues Old French femele or femelle.","semanticChange":"The female noun crosses from French into English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":744,"id":744,"entryId":142,"entrySlug":"female","childFormId":885,"parentFormId":886,"canonicalEdgeId":816,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old French femele continues Latin fēmella.","semanticChange":"The female noun continues through Romance.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":745,"id":745,"entryId":142,"entrySlug":"female","childFormId":886,"parentFormId":887,"canonicalEdgeId":817,"relationType":"diminutive_derivation","soundChange":"Latin fēmella is a diminutive of fēmina.","semanticChange":"A young-female formation continues the broader woman or female noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":746,"id":746,"entryId":142,"entrySlug":"female","childFormId":887,"parentFormId":888,"canonicalEdgeId":818,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin fēmina is analyzed from the suffixed reduced formation *dhē-mnā-.","semanticChange":"The reconstructed formation connects a woman noun to the suckle root without defining modern women by that history.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative morphology, not a dated social definition.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":747,"id":747,"entryId":142,"entrySlug":"female","childFormId":888,"parentFormId":889,"canonicalEdgeId":819,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Reconstructed *dhē-mnā- is built on the oldest root form *dheh₁(i)-.","semanticChange":"The formation specializes the root meaning to suck or suckle.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":748,"id":748,"entryId":142,"entrySlug":"female","childFormId":889,"parentFormId":890,"canonicalEdgeId":820,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dheh₁(i)-.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":749,"id":749,"entryId":143,"entrySlug":"male","childFormId":891,"parentFormId":892,"canonicalEdgeId":821,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern male continues Middle English male.","semanticChange":"The male sex-class meaning remains central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":750,"id":750,"entryId":143,"entrySlug":"male","childFormId":892,"parentFormId":893,"canonicalEdgeId":822,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English male was borrowed from Anglo-French masle or male.","semanticChange":"The noun and adjective cross into English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":751,"id":751,"entryId":143,"entrySlug":"male","childFormId":893,"parentFormId":894,"canonicalEdgeId":823,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Anglo-French masle continues Latin masculus through Romance sound change.","semanticChange":"The male noun and adjective continue through French.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":752,"id":752,"entryId":143,"entrySlug":"male","childFormId":894,"parentFormId":895,"canonicalEdgeId":824,"relationType":"diminutive_derivation","soundChange":"Latin masculus is a diminutive of mās.","semanticChange":"The Latin male base receives a diminutive formation.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":753,"id":753,"entryId":143,"entrySlug":"male","childFormId":895,"parentFormId":896,"canonicalEdgeId":825,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond Latin mās in the reviewed headword sources.","semanticChange":"The trail stops without inventing a reconstruction or linking unrelated mal-.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"A missing deeper parent is represented explicitly.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":754,"id":754,"entryId":144,"entrySlug":"human","childFormId":897,"parentFormId":898,"canonicalEdgeId":826,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern human continues Middle English humain with modern spelling.","semanticChange":"Human reference remains while noun and adjective uses develop.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The adjective is reported from the fifteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":755,"id":755,"entryId":144,"entrySlug":"human","childFormId":898,"parentFormId":899,"canonicalEdgeId":827,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English humain was borrowed through Anglo-French humain.","semanticChange":"The human adjective crosses through French into English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":756,"id":756,"entryId":144,"entrySlug":"human","childFormId":899,"parentFormId":900,"canonicalEdgeId":828,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Anglo-French humain continues Latin hūmānus through Romance.","semanticChange":"The human adjective continues across the borrowing channel.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":757,"id":757,"entryId":144,"entrySlug":"human","childFormId":900,"parentFormId":901,"canonicalEdgeId":829,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin hūmānus belongs to the Latin homō, human-being, family.","semanticChange":"A human adjective is formed from the human noun family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":758,"id":758,"entryId":144,"entrySlug":"human","childFormId":901,"parentFormId":902,"canonicalEdgeId":830,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin homō is analyzed from the reconstructed suffixed formation *(dh)ghom-on-.","semanticChange":"Human being is reconstructed as an earthling formation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Earthling is a comparative gloss, not an attested original slogan.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":759,"id":759,"entryId":144,"entrySlug":"human","childFormId":902,"parentFormId":903,"canonicalEdgeId":831,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The earthling formation *(dh)ghom-on- is built on *dhghem-, earth.","semanticChange":"The earth root supplies a human-being formation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":760,"id":760,"entryId":144,"entrySlug":"human","childFormId":903,"parentFormId":904,"canonicalEdgeId":832,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dhghem-.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":761,"id":761,"entryId":145,"entrySlug":"person","childFormId":905,"parentFormId":906,"canonicalEdgeId":833,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Modern person continues Middle English persone with loss of final unstressed e and stabilized spelling.","semanticChange":"Role and individual reference develop into the modern person noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded in the thirteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":762,"id":762,"entryId":145,"entrySlug":"person","childFormId":906,"parentFormId":907,"canonicalEdgeId":834,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English persone was borrowed through Anglo-French persone.","semanticChange":"The person and character noun crosses through French into English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":763,"id":763,"entryId":145,"entrySlug":"person","childFormId":907,"parentFormId":908,"canonicalEdgeId":835,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Anglo-French persone continues Latin persōna.","semanticChange":"Mask, role, character, and person senses travel through Romance.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":764,"id":764,"entryId":145,"entrySlug":"person","childFormId":908,"parentFormId":909,"canonicalEdgeId":836,"relationType":"competing_borrowing","soundChange":"Latin persōna is probably related to or borrowed from Etruscan phersu.","semanticChange":"An Etruscan masked figure is proposed behind the Latin mask, role, and person word.","scholar":"Oxford Classical Dictionary Editors · Marta Di Napoli · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The route is widely reported but not a securely demonstrated ordinary borrowing with an uncontested sound history.","chronologyNote":"Etruscan phersu is represented in sixth-century BCE material; Latin evidence follows in antiquity.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":765,"id":765,"entryId":145,"entrySlug":"person","childFormId":909,"parentFormId":910,"canonicalEdgeId":837,"relationType":"proposed_comparison","soundChange":"Etruscan phersu has been compared with Greek πρόσωπον, but the exact historical direction and mediation are uncertain.","semanticChange":"Masked figure, face, mask, and character provide a semantic comparison.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Marta Di Napoli","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The graph preserves the published comparison without upgrading it to consensus ancestry.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":766,"id":766,"entryId":145,"entrySlug":"person","childFormId":910,"parentFormId":911,"canonicalEdgeId":838,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"Greek πρόσωπον is conventionally analyzed with ὤψ or ὠπ-, eye or face, beside separately modeled pros-.","semanticChange":"Face and eye supply the visible-surface component that develops mask and character senses.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Liddell, Scott, and Jones","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"A morphological analysis inside Greek.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":767,"id":767,"entryId":145,"entrySlug":"person","childFormId":911,"parentFormId":912,"canonicalEdgeId":839,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Greek ὤψ reflects the Indo-European see and eye root *h₃ekʷ-.","semanticChange":"Eye and face continue the visual root field.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":768,"id":768,"entryId":145,"entrySlug":"person","childFormId":912,"parentFormId":913,"canonicalEdgeId":840,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *h₃ekʷ-.","semanticChange":"The visual-root branch ends where the published comparative analysis ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"This deep boundary does not erase the earlier uncertainty between Latin, Etruscan, and Greek.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":769,"id":769,"entryId":146,"entrySlug":"lord","childFormId":914,"parentFormId":915,"canonicalEdgeId":848,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English loverd or lord reduces to modern lord, with loss of the unstressed medial vowel and stabilized spelling.","semanticChange":"The master and title senses continue while the compound becomes opaque.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded before the twelfth century in English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":770,"id":770,"entryId":146,"entrySlug":"lord","childFormId":915,"parentFormId":916,"canonicalEdgeId":849,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English loverd continues Old English hlāford with phonological reduction.","semanticChange":"A household master term develops through medieval rank and title uses.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":771,"id":771,"entryId":146,"entrySlug":"lord","childFormId":916,"parentFormId":917,"canonicalEdgeId":850,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"Old English hlāford contains hlāf, loaf or bread, as its first lexical component.","semanticChange":"The household title encodes provision through the loaf component beside guardian.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"A morphological relation inside Old English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":772,"id":772,"entryId":146,"entrySlug":"lord","childFormId":917,"parentFormId":918,"canonicalEdgeId":851,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper parent is promoted for Old English hlāf in this reviewed dossier.","semanticChange":"The loaf branch stops while the separately modeled guardian branch continues.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The headword sources establish the compound without supplying a reviewed deeper loaf ancestry.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":773,"id":773,"entryId":147,"entrySlug":"lady","childFormId":919,"parentFormId":920,"canonicalEdgeId":852,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English lady continues into modern lady with stabilized spelling and pronunciation.","semanticChange":"Household rank develops into aristocratic and polite forms of address.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded before the twelfth century in English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":774,"id":774,"entryId":147,"entrySlug":"lady","childFormId":920,"parentFormId":921,"canonicalEdgeId":853,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English lady continues Old English hlǣfdige with contraction and loss of the compound’s transparency.","semanticChange":"Mistress-of-household and rank senses continue while literal morphology recedes.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":775,"id":775,"entryId":147,"entrySlug":"lady","childFormId":921,"parentFormId":922,"canonicalEdgeId":854,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"Old English hlǣfdige contains hlāf, loaf or bread, as its first lexical component.","semanticChange":"The household designation shares provision imagery with lord but not the same second component.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"A morphological relation inside Old English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":776,"id":776,"entryId":147,"entrySlug":"lady","childFormId":922,"parentFormId":923,"canonicalEdgeId":855,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No deeper parent is promoted for Old English hlāf in this reviewed dossier.","semanticChange":"The loaf branch stops while the separately modeled kneading branch continues.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The headword sources establish the compound without supplying a reviewed deeper loaf ancestry.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":777,"id":777,"entryId":148,"entrySlug":"husband","childFormId":924,"parentFormId":925,"canonicalEdgeId":856,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English husbonde develops into modern husband with reduction of the final vowel and stabilized spelling.","semanticChange":"Householder and master senses narrow toward the married-man relation.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded in the thirteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":778,"id":778,"entryId":148,"entrySlug":"husband","childFormId":925,"parentFormId":926,"canonicalEdgeId":857,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English husbonde continues Old English hūsbōnda.","semanticChange":"The borrowed householder noun develops the spouse sense in English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":779,"id":779,"entryId":148,"entrySlug":"husband","childFormId":926,"parentFormId":927,"canonicalEdgeId":858,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old English hūsbōnda was borrowed from Old Norse hūsbōndi.","semanticChange":"A Norse householder and master term enters English before becoming the basic spouse term.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The donor and recipient are historical Germanic languages.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":780,"id":780,"entryId":148,"entrySlug":"husband","childFormId":927,"parentFormId":928,"canonicalEdgeId":859,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"Old Norse hūsbōndi contains bōndi or būandi, householder, as its second component.","semanticChange":"The householder element supplies the resident or master role.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"A morphological relation inside Old Norse.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":781,"id":781,"entryId":148,"entrySlug":"husband","childFormId":928,"parentFormId":929,"canonicalEdgeId":860,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Old Norse bōndi or būandi is a participial noun from būa.","semanticChange":"A dwelling action supplies the householder noun.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":782,"id":782,"entryId":148,"entrySlug":"husband","childFormId":929,"parentFormId":930,"canonicalEdgeId":861,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Norse būa reflects Proto-Germanic *bōwan.","semanticChange":"Dwelling and inhabiting continue across the inherited verb.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":783,"id":783,"entryId":148,"entrySlug":"husband","childFormId":930,"parentFormId":931,"canonicalEdgeId":862,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *bōwan reflects the lengthened o-grade *bhōw-.","semanticChange":"The dwell and live formation continues at reconstructed depth.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":784,"id":784,"entryId":148,"entrySlug":"husband","childFormId":931,"parentFormId":932,"canonicalEdgeId":863,"relationType":"morphological_derivation","soundChange":"The lengthened-grade *bhōw- is analyzed under *bheuə-, to be, exist, or grow.","semanticChange":"Living and dwelling belong to the wider being and becoming field.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":785,"id":785,"entryId":148,"entrySlug":"husband","childFormId":932,"parentFormId":933,"canonicalEdgeId":864,"relationType":"root_extension","soundChange":"The root entry identifies *bheuhₓ- as the oldest shape behind *bheuə- or *bheu-.","semanticChange":"The being, existing, and growing field remains at the deepest reviewed level.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":786,"id":786,"entryId":148,"entrySlug":"husband","childFormId":933,"parentFormId":934,"canonicalEdgeId":865,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *bheuhₓ-.","semanticChange":"The trail ends where the published comparative root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed, not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":787,"id":787,"entryId":149,"entrySlug":"wife","childFormId":935,"parentFormId":936,"canonicalEdgeId":866,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English wif develops into modern wife with the Great Vowel Shift and final silent-e spelling.","semanticChange":"The older woman-or-wife field narrows toward the spouse sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded before the twelfth century in English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":788,"id":788,"entryId":149,"entrySlug":"wife","childFormId":936,"parentFormId":937,"canonicalEdgeId":867,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English wif continues Old English wīf.","semanticChange":"Woman and wife senses continue through medieval English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":789,"id":789,"entryId":149,"entrySlug":"wife","childFormId":937,"parentFormId":938,"canonicalEdgeId":868,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No direct parent is promoted beyond Old English wīf.","semanticChange":"The trail stops while a probable Tocharian comparison remains explicitly non-parental.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reviewed sources do not supply a secure direct ancestor.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":790,"id":790,"entryId":150,"entrySlug":"girl","childFormId":939,"parentFormId":940,"canonicalEdgeId":869,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English girle develops into modern girl with stabilized spelling and pronunciation.","semanticChange":"A child or young person of either sex narrows to a female child or young woman.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Middle English Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":791,"id":791,"entryId":150,"entrySlug":"girl","childFormId":940,"parentFormId":941,"canonicalEdgeId":870,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No established parent is promoted beyond Middle English girle.","semanticChange":"The secure trail ends before an uncertain Old English and garment comparison.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"American Heritage labels the origin unknown; the Middle English Dictionary marks its proposals with question marks.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":792,"id":792,"entryId":151,"entrySlug":"boy","childFormId":942,"parentFormId":943,"canonicalEdgeId":871,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English boi develops into modern boy with stabilized spelling.","semanticChange":"Male servant, churl, and young-male senses settle around the modern male-child center.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":793,"id":793,"entryId":151,"entrySlug":"boy","childFormId":943,"parentFormId":944,"canonicalEdgeId":872,"relationType":"competing_borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English boi has been compared with Old French embuié, a person in fetters.","semanticChange":"The servant or churl field is proposed to connect with a restrained person.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Oxford labels the origin unknown, and American Heritage introduces this path only as possible.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":794,"id":794,"entryId":151,"entrySlug":"boy","childFormId":944,"parentFormId":945,"canonicalEdgeId":873,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Old French embuié is the participial person-form of embuier, to fetter.","semanticChange":"A person in fetters is named from the restraining action.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":795,"id":795,"entryId":151,"entrySlug":"boy","childFormId":945,"parentFormId":946,"canonicalEdgeId":874,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Old French embuier is formed on buie, a fetter or shackle.","semanticChange":"The verb continues the restraint meaning of the noun.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":796,"id":796,"entryId":151,"entrySlug":"boy","childFormId":946,"parentFormId":947,"canonicalEdgeId":875,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French buie continues Latin bōia.","semanticChange":"The restraint noun crosses from Latin into French.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":797,"id":797,"entryId":151,"entrySlug":"boy","childFormId":947,"parentFormId":948,"canonicalEdgeId":876,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin bōia is traced to Greek boeía dorá, ox hide.","semanticChange":"An ox-hide material expression is proposed behind a restraining collar or yoke.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":798,"id":798,"entryId":151,"entrySlug":"boy","childFormId":948,"parentFormId":949,"canonicalEdgeId":877,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Greek boeía, bovine or of an ox, is formed from boûs, ox or cow.","semanticChange":"The material name specializes the cattle word as ox hide.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":799,"id":799,"entryId":151,"entrySlug":"boy","childFormId":949,"parentFormId":950,"canonicalEdgeId":878,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Greek boûs reflects Proto-Indo-European *gʷou-.","semanticChange":"The ox, bull, and cow field continues at reconstructed depth.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":800,"id":800,"entryId":151,"entrySlug":"boy","childFormId":950,"parentFormId":951,"canonicalEdgeId":879,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *gʷou-.","semanticChange":"The proposed trail ends where the published cattle root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The final boundary does not resolve the disputed connection back to boy.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":801,"id":801,"entryId":152,"entrySlug":"loaf","childFormId":952,"parentFormId":953,"canonicalEdgeId":898,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English lof develops into modern loaf with later spelling and pronunciation stabilization.","semanticChange":"The shaped bread mass remains the lexical center.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded before the twelfth century in English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":802,"id":802,"entryId":152,"entrySlug":"loaf","childFormId":953,"parentFormId":954,"canonicalEdgeId":899,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English lof continues Old English hlāf through the recorded English sound and spelling history.","semanticChange":"Bread and loaf senses remain continuous.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":803,"id":803,"entryId":152,"entrySlug":"loaf","childFormId":954,"parentFormId":955,"canonicalEdgeId":900,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English hlāf reflects reconstructed Proto-Germanic *hlaibaz.","semanticChange":"The Germanic bread and loaf meaning is retained.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The parent is a comparative reconstruction, visibly marked with an asterisk.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":804,"id":804,"entryId":152,"entrySlug":"loaf","childFormId":955,"parentFormId":956,"canonicalEdgeId":901,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No securely established parent is promoted beyond reconstructed *hlaibaz.","semanticChange":"The Germanic bread word reaches an evidential boundary; a possible substrate comparison remains separately graded proposed.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"American Heritage says perhaps when comparing a common European substrate source.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":805,"id":805,"entryId":153,"entrySlug":"wib-old-high-german","childFormId":957,"parentFormId":958,"canonicalEdgeId":902,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No reconstructed direct parent is promoted beyond attested Old High German wīb.","semanticChange":"The historical woman and wife word reaches an unresolved origin rather than a fabricated proto-form.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Duden Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Duden explicitly labels the origin unclear and offers two possibilities only as perhaps.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":806,"id":806,"entryId":154,"entrySlug":"humble","childFormId":959,"parentFormId":960,"canonicalEdgeId":908,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English humble continues into modern humble with spelling stability and later pronunciation standardization.","semanticChange":"Low rank, modesty, and lack of pretension remain in the semantic field.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded in English in the thirteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":807,"id":807,"entryId":154,"entrySlug":"humble","childFormId":960,"parentFormId":961,"canonicalEdgeId":909,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English adopts Anglo-French humble with English phonological adaptation.","semanticChange":"The low and modest senses are retained.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The source identifies the donor language but does not supply one exact borrowing event.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":808,"id":808,"entryId":154,"entrySlug":"humble","childFormId":961,"parentFormId":962,"canonicalEdgeId":910,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Anglo-French humble continues Latin humilis through Romance reshaping; no single intermediate phonetic derivation is asserted.","semanticChange":"Physical and social lowness develop into modest or deferential senses.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":809,"id":809,"entryId":154,"entrySlug":"humble","childFormId":962,"parentFormId":963,"canonicalEdgeId":911,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin humilis is formed from humus, earth or ground, with adjectival morphology and vowel adjustment.","semanticChange":"Near-the-ground or low develops into low in rank and humble.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The etymology establishes the formation, not one datable instant of metaphorical change.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":810,"id":810,"entryId":154,"entrySlug":"humble","childFormId":963,"parentFormId":964,"canonicalEdgeId":845,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin humus reflects the Indo-European earth root *dhghem-.","semanticChange":"Earth and soil preserve the root meaning.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Humus is a sibling branch, not an ancestor of homō or human.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":811,"id":811,"entryId":154,"entrySlug":"humble","childFormId":964,"parentFormId":965,"canonicalEdgeId":913,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dhghem-.","semanticChange":"The humble trail ends where the published comparative earth root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":812,"id":812,"entryId":155,"entrySlug":"humus","childFormId":966,"parentFormId":967,"canonicalEdgeId":914,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English adopts New Latin humus without material spelling change and with English pronunciation.","semanticChange":"The broad earth word specializes as the organic portion of soil.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known English use is reported in 1796.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":813,"id":813,"entryId":155,"entrySlug":"humus","childFormId":967,"parentFormId":968,"canonicalEdgeId":915,"relationType":"learned_continuation","soundChange":"New Latin humus reuses the ancient Latin form humus in scientific vocabulary.","semanticChange":"Earth and soil are narrowed toward a technical soil constituent.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":814,"id":814,"entryId":155,"entrySlug":"humus","childFormId":968,"parentFormId":969,"canonicalEdgeId":845,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin humus reflects the Indo-European earth root *dhghem-.","semanticChange":"Earth and soil preserve the root meaning.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Humus is a sibling branch, not an ancestor of homō or human.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":815,"id":815,"entryId":155,"entrySlug":"humus","childFormId":969,"parentFormId":970,"canonicalEdgeId":917,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dhghem-.","semanticChange":"The humus trail ends where the published comparative earth root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":816,"id":816,"entryId":156,"entrySlug":"bridegroom","childFormId":971,"parentFormId":972,"canonicalEdgeId":918,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"The Scots Middle English spelling brydegrome stabilizes as modern bridegroom.","semanticChange":"The marrying-man meaning continues after the compound is reinterpreted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The modern form is recorded from 1525.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":817,"id":817,"entryId":156,"entrySlug":"bridegroom","childFormId":972,"parentFormId":973,"canonicalEdgeId":919,"relationType":"folk_etymological_remodeling","soundChange":"Opaque Middle English bridegome is remodeled as brydegrome under the influence of the familiar word groom.","semanticChange":"The bride-man meaning remains while speakers reinterpret the second element.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The alteration is visible in Scots Middle English before the modern form.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":818,"id":818,"entryId":156,"entrySlug":"bridegroom","childFormId":973,"parentFormId":974,"canonicalEdgeId":920,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English bridegome continues Old English brȳdguma with regular reduction of the final inflection.","semanticChange":"Bride-man remains the compound meaning.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":819,"id":819,"entryId":156,"entrySlug":"bridegroom","childFormId":974,"parentFormId":975,"canonicalEdgeId":921,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"Old English brȳdguma contains guma, man, as its second lexical component beside brȳd, bride.","semanticChange":"The marrying man is named through the inherited human-being noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"A morphological relation inside Old English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":820,"id":820,"entryId":156,"entrySlug":"bridegroom","childFormId":975,"parentFormId":976,"canonicalEdgeId":922,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English guma reflects reconstructed Proto-Germanic *gumōn-.","semanticChange":"The man or human-being sense continues across Germanic.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":821,"id":821,"entryId":156,"entrySlug":"bridegroom","childFormId":976,"parentFormId":977,"canonicalEdgeId":923,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *gumōn- reflects the suffixed zero-grade formation *(dh)ghm̥-on-.","semanticChange":"The Germanic man noun is analyzed as an earthling formation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"This zero-grade formation is distinct from the o-grade formation behind Latin homō.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":822,"id":822,"entryId":156,"entrySlug":"bridegroom","childFormId":977,"parentFormId":978,"canonicalEdgeId":924,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The earthling formation *(dh)ghm̥-on- is built on *dhghem-, earth.","semanticChange":"An earth-root formation supplies a human-being noun.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":823,"id":823,"entryId":156,"entrySlug":"bridegroom","childFormId":978,"parentFormId":979,"canonicalEdgeId":925,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dhghem-.","semanticChange":"The bridegroom trail ends where the published comparative earth root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":824,"id":824,"entryId":157,"entrySlug":"dough","childFormId":980,"parentFormId":981,"canonicalEdgeId":926,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English dogh develops into modern dough with later spelling stabilization while the inherited vowel history produces /oʊ/.","semanticChange":"The kneadable flour mass remains the lexical center; money is a later slang extension.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded before the twelfth century in English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":825,"id":825,"entryId":157,"entrySlug":"dough","childFormId":981,"parentFormId":982,"canonicalEdgeId":927,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English dogh continues Old English dāg through the recorded English sound and spelling history.","semanticChange":"The dough meaning is retained.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":826,"id":826,"entryId":157,"entrySlug":"dough","childFormId":982,"parentFormId":983,"canonicalEdgeId":928,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English dāg reflects reconstructed Proto-Germanic *daigaz.","semanticChange":"The kneadable mass meaning continues in the Germanic noun family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":827,"id":827,"entryId":157,"entrySlug":"dough","childFormId":983,"parentFormId":984,"canonicalEdgeId":929,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *daigaz reflects the suffixed o-grade formation *dhoigh-o-.","semanticChange":"The Germanic dough noun is a formed or kneaded mass.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":828,"id":828,"entryId":157,"entrySlug":"dough","childFormId":984,"parentFormId":985,"canonicalEdgeId":930,"relationType":"morphological_derivation","soundChange":"The suffixed o-grade *dhoigh-o- is built on *dheigh-, to form or build.","semanticChange":"A concrete kneaded mass specializes the general forming action.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":829,"id":829,"entryId":157,"entrySlug":"dough","childFormId":985,"parentFormId":986,"canonicalEdgeId":888,"relationType":"root_extension","soundChange":"The root appendix identifies *dheig̑h- as the oldest shape behind centum *dheigh-.","semanticChange":"The form-and-build field continues at the deepest reviewed level.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":830,"id":830,"entryId":157,"entrySlug":"dough","childFormId":986,"parentFormId":987,"canonicalEdgeId":932,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dheig̑h-.","semanticChange":"The dough trail ends where the published comparative root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":831,"id":831,"entryId":158,"entrySlug":"figure","childFormId":988,"parentFormId":989,"canonicalEdgeId":933,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English figure continues into modern figure with spelling stability and later English pronunciation development.","semanticChange":"Shape, likeness, symbol, number, person, and calculation senses expand from representation.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded in English in the thirteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":832,"id":832,"entryId":158,"entrySlug":"figure","childFormId":989,"parentFormId":990,"canonicalEdgeId":934,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English borrows Anglo-French figure with English phonological adaptation.","semanticChange":"The shape, form, likeness, and symbol field is retained.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"American Heritage labels the French source Old French; that alternate channel remains visible in the graph.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":833,"id":833,"entryId":158,"entrySlug":"figure","childFormId":990,"parentFormId":991,"canonicalEdgeId":935,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Anglo-French figure continues Latin figūra through Romance transmission.","semanticChange":"Shape, outward appearance, likeness, and represented form remain central.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":834,"id":834,"entryId":158,"entrySlug":"figure","childFormId":991,"parentFormId":992,"canonicalEdgeId":936,"relationType":"morphological_derivation","soundChange":"Latin figūra reflects the suffixed zero-grade formation *dhigh-ūrā-.","semanticChange":"A result of forming or kneading becomes shape, form, and representation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster instead analyzes figūra through the stem of fingere; that compatible but differently segmented route remains a cited graph branch.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":835,"id":835,"entryId":158,"entrySlug":"figure","childFormId":992,"parentFormId":993,"canonicalEdgeId":937,"relationType":"morphological_derivation","soundChange":"The suffixed formation *dhigh-ūrā- is built on *dheigh-, to form or build.","semanticChange":"The result-of-forming noun continues the root’s shaping field.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":836,"id":836,"entryId":158,"entrySlug":"figure","childFormId":993,"parentFormId":994,"canonicalEdgeId":888,"relationType":"root_extension","soundChange":"The root appendix identifies *dheig̑h- as the oldest shape behind centum *dheigh-.","semanticChange":"The form-and-build field continues at the deepest reviewed level.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":837,"id":837,"entryId":158,"entrySlug":"figure","childFormId":994,"parentFormId":995,"canonicalEdgeId":939,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dheig̑h-.","semanticChange":"The figure trail ends where the published comparative root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":838,"id":838,"entryId":159,"entrySlug":"chthonic","childFormId":996,"parentFormId":997,"canonicalEdgeId":945,"relationType":"learned_borrowing","soundChange":"English chthonic adapts Greek khthonios with the learned chthon- spelling and English adjectival pronunciation.","semanticChange":"Of the earth and under the earth develops into the specialized underworld sense.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known English use is reported in 1882.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":839,"id":839,"entryId":159,"entrySlug":"chthonic","childFormId":997,"parentFormId":998,"canonicalEdgeId":946,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Greek khthonios is formed from khthōn, earth, with adjectival morphology.","semanticChange":"Earth becomes of the earth, including what lies in or under it.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":840,"id":840,"entryId":159,"entrySlug":"chthonic","childFormId":998,"parentFormId":999,"canonicalEdgeId":947,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Greek khthōn reflects the Indo-European o-grade *dh(e)ghom-.","semanticChange":"Earth preserves the root meaning.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":841,"id":841,"entryId":159,"entrySlug":"chthonic","childFormId":999,"parentFormId":1000,"canonicalEdgeId":948,"relationType":"ablaut_formation","soundChange":"The o-grade *dh(e)ghom- is a vocalic formation of the earth root *dhghem-.","semanticChange":"The earth meaning remains stable across the reconstructed formation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":842,"id":842,"entryId":159,"entrySlug":"chthonic","childFormId":1000,"parentFormId":1001,"canonicalEdgeId":949,"relationType":"root_extension","soundChange":"The appendix identifies *dhg̑hem- as the oldest shape behind centum *dhghem-.","semanticChange":"The earth field continues at the deepest reviewed level.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":843,"id":843,"entryId":159,"entrySlug":"chthonic","childFormId":1001,"parentFormId":1002,"canonicalEdgeId":950,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dhg̑hem-.","semanticChange":"The chthonic trail ends where the published comparative earth root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":844,"id":844,"entryId":160,"entrySlug":"exhume","childFormId":1003,"parentFormId":1004,"canonicalEdgeId":951,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English exhume continues into modern exhume with later pronunciation standardization.","semanticChange":"Physical removal from burial remains primary while recovery from obscurity develops figuratively.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded in English from the fifteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":845,"id":845,"entryId":160,"entrySlug":"exhume","childFormId":1004,"parentFormId":1005,"canonicalEdgeId":952,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English borrows Medieval Latin exhumare with minimal written reshaping.","semanticChange":"The literal removal-from-earth sense is retained.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":846,"id":846,"entryId":160,"entrySlug":"exhume","childFormId":1005,"parentFormId":1006,"canonicalEdgeId":953,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"Medieval Latin exhumare is formed on Latin humus beside the prefix ex-.","semanticChange":"Earth supplies the burial-ground object from which something is removed.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"A morphological structure, not a claim that English humus donated exhume.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":847,"id":847,"entryId":160,"entrySlug":"exhume","childFormId":1006,"parentFormId":1007,"canonicalEdgeId":954,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin humus reflects the suffixed o-grade formation *(dh)ghom-o-.","semanticChange":"Earth and soil preserve the reconstructed meaning.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":848,"id":848,"entryId":160,"entrySlug":"exhume","childFormId":1007,"parentFormId":1008,"canonicalEdgeId":955,"relationType":"morphological_derivation","soundChange":"The suffixed o-grade *(dh)ghom-o- is built on *dhghem-, earth.","semanticChange":"The earth meaning remains stable.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":849,"id":849,"entryId":160,"entrySlug":"exhume","childFormId":1008,"parentFormId":1009,"canonicalEdgeId":949,"relationType":"root_extension","soundChange":"The appendix identifies *dhg̑hem- as the oldest shape behind centum *dhghem-.","semanticChange":"The earth field continues at the deepest reviewed level.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":850,"id":850,"entryId":160,"entrySlug":"exhume","childFormId":1009,"parentFormId":1010,"canonicalEdgeId":957,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dhg̑hem-.","semanticChange":"The exhume trail ends where the published comparative earth root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":851,"id":851,"entryId":161,"entrySlug":"bride","childFormId":1011,"parentFormId":1012,"canonicalEdgeId":958,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English bride continues into modern bride with regular spelling and pronunciation history.","semanticChange":"The newly married or about-to-marry woman remains the lexical center.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Recorded in English before the twelfth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":852,"id":852,"entryId":161,"entrySlug":"bride","childFormId":1012,"parentFormId":1013,"canonicalEdgeId":959,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English bride continues Old English brȳd.","semanticChange":"Bride, wife, and spouse senses remain in the historical field.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Joseph Bosworth and Thomas Northcote Toller","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":853,"id":853,"entryId":161,"entrySlug":"bride","childFormId":1013,"parentFormId":1014,"canonicalEdgeId":960,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"The reviewed sources compare Old English brȳd with Germanic relatives but do not promote a common reconstructed parent.","semanticChange":"The bride trail stops without inventing deeper semantics.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Merriam-Webster Editors · Joseph Bosworth and Thomas Northcote Toller","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Old High German brūt is preserved as a comparative relative, not a direct parent.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":854,"id":854,"entryId":162,"entrySlug":"dairy","childFormId":1015,"parentFormId":1016,"canonicalEdgeId":961,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English deierie develops into modern dairy through vowel, spelling, and stress standardization.","semanticChange":"A milk-production place expands to the products and industry associated with it.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known use is reported in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":855,"id":855,"entryId":162,"entrySlug":"dairy","childFormId":1016,"parentFormId":1017,"canonicalEdgeId":962,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English deierie reflects Anglo-French deyerie or daerie with English orthographic adaptation.","semanticChange":"The place of milk handling remains the center.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":856,"id":856,"entryId":162,"entrySlug":"dairy","childFormId":1017,"parentFormId":1018,"canonicalEdgeId":963,"relationType":"derivational_base","soundChange":"Anglo-French deyerie is formed on Middle English deie beside Anglo-French -erie.","semanticChange":"The woman responsible for milk production becomes the base for the place where that work occurs.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The English base entering an Anglo-French formation makes this more than a one-way donor chain.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":857,"id":857,"entryId":162,"entrySlug":"dairy","childFormId":1018,"parentFormId":1019,"canonicalEdgeId":964,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English deie continues Old English dǣge with regular reduction and spelling change.","semanticChange":"Woman managing milk and food production continues the earlier female baker or servant role.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":858,"id":858,"entryId":162,"entrySlug":"dairy","childFormId":1019,"parentFormId":1020,"canonicalEdgeId":965,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English dǣge reflects reconstructed Proto-Germanic *daigjōn-.","semanticChange":"The occupational female baker or servant meaning continues.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":859,"id":859,"entryId":162,"entrySlug":"dairy","childFormId":1020,"parentFormId":1021,"canonicalEdgeId":966,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *daigjōn- is derived from the dough base *daiga-.","semanticChange":"A person associated with kneading or dough becomes a female baker and later servant.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The occupational formation and the dough noun *daigaz remain distinct nodes.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":860,"id":860,"entryId":162,"entrySlug":"dairy","childFormId":1021,"parentFormId":1022,"canonicalEdgeId":967,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Germanic *daiga- belongs to the form-and-build family under *dheigh-.","semanticChange":"Dough and kneading specialize the broader act of forming.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":861,"id":861,"entryId":162,"entrySlug":"dairy","childFormId":1022,"parentFormId":1023,"canonicalEdgeId":888,"relationType":"root_extension","soundChange":"The root appendix identifies *dheig̑h- as the oldest shape behind centum *dheigh-.","semanticChange":"The form-and-build field continues at the deepest reviewed level.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":862,"id":862,"entryId":162,"entrySlug":"dairy","childFormId":1023,"parentFormId":1024,"canonicalEdgeId":969,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dheig̑h-.","semanticChange":"The dairy trail ends where the published comparative form-and-build root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":863,"id":863,"entryId":163,"entrySlug":"fiction","childFormId":1025,"parentFormId":1026,"canonicalEdgeId":970,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English ficcioun develops into modern fiction through French-influenced spelling and English pronunciation.","semanticChange":"Mental invention expands into narrative, imaginative, legal, and pretense senses.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known English use is reported in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":864,"id":864,"entryId":163,"entrySlug":"fiction","childFormId":1026,"parentFormId":1027,"canonicalEdgeId":971,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English ficcioun borrows Middle French fiction with English orthographic adaptation.","semanticChange":"Invention and feigning senses continue.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":865,"id":865,"entryId":163,"entrySlug":"fiction","childFormId":1027,"parentFormId":1028,"canonicalEdgeId":972,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle French fiction continues the borrowed Latin action noun fictiō.","semanticChange":"Shaping, feigning, and pretense narrow and reorganize in French and English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":866,"id":866,"entryId":163,"entrySlug":"fiction","childFormId":1028,"parentFormId":1029,"canonicalEdgeId":973,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin fictiō is formed from the variant stem fig- beside the action suffix -tiō.","semanticChange":"The action of shaping or molding extends to feigning and pretense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"A morphological relation inside Latin.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":867,"id":867,"entryId":163,"entrySlug":"fiction","childFormId":1029,"parentFormId":1030,"canonicalEdgeId":974,"relationType":"stem_allomorphy","soundChange":"Latin fig- is the variant stem of fingere used before the action-noun suffix.","semanticChange":"The shaping and making field remains intact.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":868,"id":868,"entryId":163,"entrySlug":"fiction","childFormId":1030,"parentFormId":1031,"canonicalEdgeId":975,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin fingere reflects the nasalized zero-grade formation *dhi-n-gh-.","semanticChange":"Molding, fashioning, making a likeness, and pretending continue the shaping field.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":869,"id":869,"entryId":163,"entrySlug":"fiction","childFormId":1031,"parentFormId":1032,"canonicalEdgeId":976,"relationType":"morphological_derivation","soundChange":"The nasalized formation *dhi-n-gh- is built on *dheigh-, to form or build.","semanticChange":"Shaping remains the semantic center.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":870,"id":870,"entryId":163,"entrySlug":"fiction","childFormId":1032,"parentFormId":1033,"canonicalEdgeId":888,"relationType":"root_extension","soundChange":"The root appendix identifies *dheig̑h- as the oldest shape behind centum *dheigh-.","semanticChange":"The form-and-build field continues at the deepest reviewed level.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":871,"id":871,"entryId":163,"entrySlug":"fiction","childFormId":1033,"parentFormId":1034,"canonicalEdgeId":978,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dheig̑h-.","semanticChange":"The fiction trail ends where the published comparative form-and-build root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":872,"id":872,"entryId":164,"entrySlug":"feign","childFormId":1035,"parentFormId":1036,"canonicalEdgeId":979,"relationType":"continuation","soundChange":"Middle English feynen and feignen develop into modern feign with spelling and pronunciation standardization.","semanticChange":"Making, fabricating, likeness, and pretense narrow toward deliberate false appearance.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"First known English use is reported in the thirteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":873,"id":873,"entryId":164,"entrySlug":"feign","childFormId":1036,"parentFormId":1037,"canonicalEdgeId":980,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English borrows the Anglo-French feign- stem with English inflection.","semanticChange":"The make, fabricate, likeness, and pretense field is retained.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":874,"id":874,"entryId":164,"entrySlug":"feign","childFormId":1037,"parentFormId":1038,"canonicalEdgeId":981,"relationType":"stem_derivation","soundChange":"Anglo-French feign- is the inflectional stem of feindre.","semanticChange":"The fashioning and pretending senses remain connected.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":875,"id":875,"entryId":164,"entrySlug":"feign","childFormId":1038,"parentFormId":1039,"canonicalEdgeId":982,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Anglo-French feindre continues Latin fingere through Romance sound and form history; no single unattested intermediate is inserted.","semanticChange":"To shape or make a likeness develops naturally toward pretending to be.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":876,"id":876,"entryId":164,"entrySlug":"feign","childFormId":1039,"parentFormId":1040,"canonicalEdgeId":975,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin fingere reflects the nasalized zero-grade formation *dhi-n-gh-.","semanticChange":"Molding, fashioning, making a likeness, and pretending continue the shaping field.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":877,"id":877,"entryId":164,"entrySlug":"feign","childFormId":1040,"parentFormId":1041,"canonicalEdgeId":976,"relationType":"morphological_derivation","soundChange":"The nasalized formation *dhi-n-gh- is built on *dheigh-, to form or build.","semanticChange":"Shaping remains the semantic center.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":878,"id":878,"entryId":164,"entrySlug":"feign","childFormId":1041,"parentFormId":1042,"canonicalEdgeId":888,"relationType":"root_extension","soundChange":"The root appendix identifies *dheig̑h- as the oldest shape behind centum *dheigh-.","semanticChange":"The form-and-build field continues at the deepest reviewed level.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":879,"id":879,"entryId":164,"entrySlug":"feign","childFormId":1042,"parentFormId":1043,"canonicalEdgeId":986,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dheig̑h-.","semanticChange":"The feign trail ends where the published comparative form-and-build root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":880,"id":880,"entryId":165,"entrySlug":"humiliate","childFormId":1044,"parentFormId":1045,"canonicalEdgeId":995,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"English humiliate adapts the stem of Late Latin humiliātus, dropping Latin inflection and developing the English -ate pronunciation.","semanticChange":"Made low or humble develops into reduction in status, dignity, or self-estimation and the causing of shame.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports English use circa 1534.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":881,"id":881,"entryId":165,"entrySlug":"humiliate","childFormId":1045,"parentFormId":1046,"canonicalEdgeId":996,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"Late Latin humiliātus is the past participle of humiliāre.","semanticChange":"The completed state of being made low preserves the causative verb meaning.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"A Late Latin inflectional relation.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":882,"id":882,"entryId":165,"entrySlug":"humiliate","childFormId":1046,"parentFormId":1047,"canonicalEdgeId":997,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Late Latin humiliāre is formed from Latin humilis with verbal morphology.","semanticChange":"Low or humble becomes the causative action to make low or humble.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":883,"id":883,"entryId":165,"entrySlug":"humiliate","childFormId":1047,"parentFormId":1048,"canonicalEdgeId":911,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin humilis is formed from humus, earth or ground, with adjectival morphology and vowel adjustment.","semanticChange":"Near-the-ground or low develops into low in rank and humble.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The etymology establishes the formation, not one datable instant of metaphorical change.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":884,"id":884,"entryId":165,"entrySlug":"humiliate","childFormId":1048,"parentFormId":1049,"canonicalEdgeId":954,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin humus reflects the suffixed o-grade formation *(dh)ghom-o-.","semanticChange":"Earth and soil preserve the reconstructed meaning.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":885,"id":885,"entryId":165,"entrySlug":"humiliate","childFormId":1049,"parentFormId":1050,"canonicalEdgeId":955,"relationType":"morphological_derivation","soundChange":"The suffixed o-grade *(dh)ghom-o- is built on *dhghem-, earth.","semanticChange":"The earth meaning remains stable.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":886,"id":886,"entryId":165,"entrySlug":"humiliate","childFormId":1050,"parentFormId":1051,"canonicalEdgeId":949,"relationType":"root_extension","soundChange":"The appendix identifies *dhg̑hem- as the oldest shape behind centum *dhghem-.","semanticChange":"The earth field continues at the deepest reviewed level.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":887,"id":887,"entryId":165,"entrySlug":"humiliate","childFormId":1051,"parentFormId":1052,"canonicalEdgeId":1002,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dhg̑hem-.","semanticChange":"The humiliate trail ends where the published comparative earth root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":888,"id":888,"entryId":166,"entrySlug":"humility","childFormId":1053,"parentFormId":1054,"canonicalEdgeId":1004,"relationType":"orthographic_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English humilite continues as humility with modern English -ity spelling and pronunciation.","semanticChange":"The inherited humble-quality sense continues into the current freedom-from-pride center.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The sources identify the form sequence but do not date one exact spelling replacement.","chronologyNote":"Merriam-Webster reports English use in the fourteenth century.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":889,"id":889,"entryId":166,"entrySlug":"humility","childFormId":1054,"parentFormId":1055,"canonicalEdgeId":1005,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English humilite adapts the French form without its written accent and within English phonology.","semanticChange":"The French humble-quality and religious-abasement field enters Middle English.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The broad fourteenth-century horizon is lexicographic, not an exact borrowing event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":890,"id":890,"entryId":166,"entrySlug":"humility","childFormId":1055,"parentFormId":1056,"canonicalEdgeId":1006,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French humilité adapts Latin humilitās with the Romance noun ending represented as -ité.","semanticChange":"The ecclesiastical virtue and abasement senses continue in French.","scholar":"CNRTL · ATILF Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"CNRTL treats the French noun as borrowed from Latin; this edge does not invent an unattested intermediate form.","chronologyNote":"CNRTL reports a later-tenth-century French record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":891,"id":891,"entryId":166,"entrySlug":"humility","childFormId":1056,"parentFormId":1057,"canonicalEdgeId":1007,"relationType":"semantic_specialization","soundChange":"The Latin form humilitās remains segmentally continuous across the modeled sense boundary.","semanticChange":"Literal and social lowness is positively specialized in ecclesiastical Latin as humility opposed to pride.","scholar":"Charlton T. Lewis · Charles Short","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"This is a sense-specific graph split, not a claim that two unrelated Latin nouns existed.","chronologyNote":"Lewis and Short labels the positive sense ecclesiastical Latin.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":892,"id":892,"entryId":166,"entrySlug":"humility","childFormId":1057,"parentFormId":1058,"canonicalEdgeId":1008,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin humilitās is formed from humilis with the abstract noun suffix -itās.","semanticChange":"The property of being low names physical lowness, low station, insignificance, and related abstractions.","scholar":"Charlton T. Lewis · Charles Short","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":893,"id":893,"entryId":166,"entrySlug":"humility","childFormId":1058,"parentFormId":1059,"canonicalEdgeId":911,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin humilis is formed from humus, earth or ground, with adjectival morphology and vowel adjustment.","semanticChange":"Near-the-ground or low develops into low in rank and humble.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The etymology establishes the formation, not one datable instant of metaphorical change.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":894,"id":894,"entryId":166,"entrySlug":"humility","childFormId":1059,"parentFormId":1060,"canonicalEdgeId":954,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin humus reflects the suffixed o-grade formation *(dh)ghom-o-.","semanticChange":"Earth and soil preserve the reconstructed meaning.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":895,"id":895,"entryId":166,"entrySlug":"humility","childFormId":1060,"parentFormId":1061,"canonicalEdgeId":955,"relationType":"morphological_derivation","soundChange":"The suffixed o-grade *(dh)ghom-o- is built on *dhghem-, earth.","semanticChange":"The earth meaning remains stable.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":896,"id":896,"entryId":166,"entrySlug":"humility","childFormId":1061,"parentFormId":1062,"canonicalEdgeId":949,"relationType":"root_extension","soundChange":"The appendix identifies *dhg̑hem- as the oldest shape behind centum *dhghem-.","semanticChange":"The earth field continues at the deepest reviewed level.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":897,"id":897,"entryId":166,"entrySlug":"humility","childFormId":1062,"parentFormId":1063,"canonicalEdgeId":1013,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dhg̑hem-.","semanticChange":"The humility trail ends where the published comparative earth root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":898,"id":898,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","childFormId":1064,"parentFormId":1065,"canonicalEdgeId":1014,"relationType":"orthographic_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English humiliacioun continues as humiliation with modern -ation spelling and English pronunciation.","semanticChange":"A broad humbling or abasement noun develops the current action, state, instance, degradation, disgrace, and shame center.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The sources identify the form sequence and current senses but do not date one exact semantic switch.","chronologyNote":"The Middle English occurrence predates the source-reported English verb humiliate.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":899,"id":899,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","childFormId":1065,"parentFormId":1066,"canonicalEdgeId":1015,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English humiliacioun adapts Middle French humiliation with the common English -acioun representation of the Romance noun ending.","semanticChange":"The action and condition of lowering or humbling crosses into Middle English.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The surviving Chaucer record does not prove one exact borrowing year.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":900,"id":900,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","childFormId":1066,"parentFormId":1067,"canonicalEdgeId":1016,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle French humiliation continues Christian Latin humiliātiō within Romance phonology and spelling.","semanticChange":"Lowering, abasement, subduing, and self-humbling remain available in the medieval French record.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · CNRTL and ATILF Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"CNRTL treats the French noun as a borrowing from Christian Latin and supplies source-reported French sense records.","chronologyNote":"The French examples are reported before 1449 and in 1495.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":901,"id":901,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","childFormId":1067,"parentFormId":1068,"canonicalEdgeId":1017,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Late Latin humiliātiō is formed on humiliātus with the Latin action-noun ending -iō.","semanticChange":"The made-low participial stem becomes an action, process, or condition noun for lowering and humbling.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · CNRTL and ATILF Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster publishes the morphological formation; CNRTL independently documents the Christian Latin action-noun senses.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":902,"id":902,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","childFormId":1068,"parentFormId":1069,"canonicalEdgeId":996,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"Late Latin humiliātus is the past participle of humiliāre.","semanticChange":"The completed state of being made low preserves the causative verb meaning.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"A Late Latin inflectional relation.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":903,"id":903,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","childFormId":1069,"parentFormId":1070,"canonicalEdgeId":997,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Late Latin humiliāre is formed from Latin humilis with verbal morphology.","semanticChange":"Low or humble becomes the causative action to make low or humble.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":904,"id":904,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","childFormId":1070,"parentFormId":1071,"canonicalEdgeId":911,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Latin humilis is formed from humus, earth or ground, with adjectival morphology and vowel adjustment.","semanticChange":"Near-the-ground or low develops into low in rank and humble.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The etymology establishes the formation, not one datable instant of metaphorical change.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":905,"id":905,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","childFormId":1071,"parentFormId":1072,"canonicalEdgeId":954,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin humus reflects the suffixed o-grade formation *(dh)ghom-o-.","semanticChange":"Earth and soil preserve the reconstructed meaning.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":906,"id":906,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","childFormId":1072,"parentFormId":1073,"canonicalEdgeId":955,"relationType":"morphological_derivation","soundChange":"The suffixed o-grade *(dh)ghom-o- is built on *dhghem-, earth.","semanticChange":"The earth meaning remains stable.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":907,"id":907,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","childFormId":1073,"parentFormId":1074,"canonicalEdgeId":949,"relationType":"root_extension","soundChange":"The appendix identifies *dhg̑hem- as the oldest shape behind centum *dhghem-.","semanticChange":"The earth field continues at the deepest reviewed level.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":908,"id":908,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","childFormId":1074,"parentFormId":1075,"canonicalEdgeId":1024,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond reviewed *dhg̑hem-.","semanticChange":"The humiliation trail ends where the published comparative earth root ends.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The root is reconstructed rather than attested.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":909,"id":909,"entryId":168,"entrySlug":"logy","childFormId":1076,"parentFormId":1077,"canonicalEdgeId":1025,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English -logie is continued by modern English -logy with spelling and pronunciation adapted to later English patterns.","semanticChange":"The learned form remains productive across expression, discourse, doctrine, theory, science, and study senses rather than narrowing to one universal gloss.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The sources establish the historical form and semantic range, but do not supply one coinage date for the combining form itself.","chronologyNote":"The form is evidenced inside words; the hyphenated dictionary headword is a modern lexicographic representation.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":910,"id":910,"entryId":168,"entrySlug":"logy","childFormId":1077,"parentFormId":1078,"canonicalEdgeId":1026,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Middle English -logie borrows the formally matching Old French learned element.","semanticChange":"The discourse or learned-account function continues within borrowed formations.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"American Heritage publishes the route but not one exact transfer event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":911,"id":911,"entryId":168,"entrySlug":"logy","childFormId":1078,"parentFormId":1079,"canonicalEdgeId":1027,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Old French -logie continues Latin -logia with Romance phonological and orthographic adaptation.","semanticChange":"The learned noun-forming function remains associated with accounts and organized subjects.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":912,"id":912,"entryId":168,"entrySlug":"logy","childFormId":1079,"parentFormId":1080,"canonicalEdgeId":1028,"relationType":"borrowing","soundChange":"Latin -logia borrows and transliterates Greek -logiā.","semanticChange":"A Greek formation in the speaking and account family becomes a reusable learned Latin element.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":913,"id":913,"entryId":168,"entrySlug":"logy","childFormId":1080,"parentFormId":1081,"canonicalEdgeId":1029,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Greek -logiā is formed in the logos family; American Heritage also records -logos formations as a contributing channel.","semanticChange":"Word, speech, and discourse support account-of-a-subject formations; “science” is a later specialization, not the only Greek value.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Ancient Greek lexicography","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The dossier follows the explicitly published -logiā-to-logos route while preserving the related -logos channel in the dispute record.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":914,"id":914,"entryId":168,"entrySlug":"logy","childFormId":1081,"parentFormId":1082,"canonicalEdgeId":48,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"λόγος is a verbal noun in the λέγω family, with an o-grade formation represented in traditional analysis.","semanticChange":"Gathering, counting, recounting, speech, account, and reason form a historically layered semantic network.","scholar":"Logeion · comparative Greek lexicography","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The semantic sequence should not be reduced to a single just-so story.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":915,"id":915,"entryId":168,"entrySlug":"logy","childFormId":1082,"parentFormId":1083,"canonicalEdgeId":49,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Greek λέγω is traditionally derived from PIE *leǵ-; some scholarship argues that an initial *s should be reconstructed.","semanticChange":"The daughter evidence spans collecting and speaking, but the exact semantic path remains reconstructed.","scholar":"UT Austin LRC · IE-CoR · Kaczyńska","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The competing *sleǵ- analysis prevents an unqualified grade.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":916,"id":916,"entryId":168,"entrySlug":"logy","childFormId":1083,"parentFormId":1084,"canonicalEdgeId":1032,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed reconstruction.","semanticChange":"The graph stops rather than laundering a contested root into certainty.","scholar":"Open research boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":917,"id":917,"entryId":169,"entrySlug":"rix","childFormId":1085,"parentFormId":1086,"canonicalEdgeId":1033,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The attested Gaulish spelling -rix represents /-rīxs/ and aligns with reconstructed Proto-Celtic *rīx-s; the written host names do not preserve a macron.","semanticChange":"The inherited king noun functions as a compound-name member; its precise contribution can range beyond one mechanically compositional gloss.","scholar":"Anders Richardt Jørgensen · Tristano Bolelli · Enrico Campanile","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The ancestry and king or prince value are established, while the semantic force in every individual name is not.","chronologyNote":"Gaulish is attested in ancient onomastic material; Proto-Celtic is reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":918,"id":918,"entryId":169,"entrySlug":"rix","childFormId":1086,"parentFormId":1087,"canonicalEdgeId":791,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Celtic *rīx-s reflects the Indo-European lengthened king grade *rēg-.","semanticChange":"King remains the central meaning while Celtic raises inherited *ē to *ī and develops the final cluster.","scholar":"Anders Richardt Jørgensen","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The source gives *rīx-s and genitive *rīg-os from PIE *(h₃)rēg̑-.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":919,"id":919,"entryId":169,"entrySlug":"rix","childFormId":1087,"parentFormId":1088,"canonicalEdgeId":752,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Lengthened-grade *rēg- belongs under centum *h₃reg-.","semanticChange":"The ruler or king formation specializes the straight, direct, lead, and rule family.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative ablaut analysis, not one dated institutional event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":920,"id":920,"entryId":169,"entrySlug":"rix","childFormId":1088,"parentFormId":1089,"canonicalEdgeId":722,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Centum *h₃reg- reflects the oldest published form *h₃reg̑-.","semanticChange":"The straight, direct, lead, and rule field is preserved across the reconstructed notation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both nodes are reconstructed analytical forms, not separately attested words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":921,"id":921,"entryId":169,"entrySlug":"rix","childFormId":1089,"parentFormId":1090,"canonicalEdgeId":1037,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *h₃reg̑- root.","semanticChange":"The graph stops where the current comparative analysis stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":922,"id":922,"entryId":170,"entrySlug":"rex","childFormId":1091,"parentFormId":1092,"canonicalEdgeId":1038,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"Nominative rēx and genitive rēgis belong to one paradigm: stem-final g before nominative -s devoices to k, and Latin writes the resulting /ks/ cluster as x; intervocalic g remains visible in rēgis.","semanticChange":"Both forms mean king in different grammatical cases; no semantic ancestry runs from one case form to the other.","scholar":"Norvin W. Richards · Charlton T. Lewis · Charles Short","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The edge is a navigational paradigm relation, not a claim that genitive rēgis historically produced nominative rēx.","chronologyNote":"Synchronic Latin morphology illuminated by historical sound change.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":923,"id":923,"entryId":170,"entrySlug":"rex","childFormId":1092,"parentFormId":1093,"canonicalEdgeId":1039,"relationType":"inflection","soundChange":"Removing the genitive singular ending -is from rēgis exposes the bound stem rēg-.","semanticChange":"The stem retains the king meaning across the inflectional paradigm.","scholar":"Norvin W. Richards · Charlton T. Lewis · Charles Short","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"The bound stem is evidenced by multiple Latin case forms and is not printed as an autonomous token.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":924,"id":924,"entryId":170,"entrySlug":"rex","childFormId":1093,"parentFormId":1094,"canonicalEdgeId":1040,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Latin rēg- reflects the reconstructed Indo-European lengthened king grade *rēg-.","semanticChange":"The ruler or king formation remains the lexical center while the attested Latin stem is separated from its reconstructed comparative parent.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Norvin W. Richards","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The macron is shared notation, but only the Proto-Indo-European node carries an asterisk.","chronologyNote":"Latin is attested; the parent grade is reconstructed.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":925,"id":925,"entryId":170,"entrySlug":"rex","childFormId":1094,"parentFormId":1095,"canonicalEdgeId":752,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Lengthened-grade *rēg- belongs under centum *h₃reg-.","semanticChange":"The ruler or king formation specializes the straight, direct, lead, and rule family.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Comparative ablaut analysis, not one dated institutional event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":926,"id":926,"entryId":170,"entrySlug":"rex","childFormId":1095,"parentFormId":1096,"canonicalEdgeId":722,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Centum *h₃reg- reflects the oldest published form *h₃reg̑-.","semanticChange":"The straight, direct, lead, and rule field is preserved across the reconstructed notation.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Both nodes are reconstructed analytical forms, not separately attested words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":927,"id":927,"entryId":170,"entrySlug":"rex","childFormId":1096,"parentFormId":1097,"canonicalEdgeId":1043,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *h₃reg̑- root.","semanticChange":"The graph stops where the current comparative analysis stops.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":928,"id":928,"entryId":171,"entrySlug":"king","childFormId":1098,"parentFormId":1099,"canonicalEdgeId":1044,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"The Middle English spelling king survives into Present-Day English; later phonetic and orthographic standardization is not compressed into one unsupported sound law.","semanticChange":"The monarch sense continues while preeminence, chess, card, checkers, and verbal extensions accumulate.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Middle English Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The modern semantic branches are documented; this edge does not assign each branch an invented exact date.","chronologyNote":"Middle English into modern English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":929,"id":929,"entryId":171,"entrySlug":"king","childFormId":1099,"parentFormId":1100,"canonicalEdgeId":1045,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English records early kining and cining beside syncopated king forms: the unstressed medial vowel is lost, Old English y is unrounded toward i in Middle English, and k spelling disambiguates the inherited hard consonant.","semanticChange":"The inherited title for a king or monarch remains stable through the contraction.","scholar":"Middle English Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The MED directly supplies both disyllabic and contracted forms; the graph does not claim that one surviving spelling alone generated every dialectal form.","chronologyNote":"Old English into Middle English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":930,"id":930,"entryId":171,"entrySlug":"king","childFormId":1100,"parentFormId":1101,"canonicalEdgeId":1046,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Pre-Old-English i-umlaut fronts short u to y before the following unstressed i: reconstructed *kuning- yields Old English cyning; inherited endings are reduced or lost.","semanticChange":"The reconstructed Germanic king title continues as the attested Old English ruler title.","scholar":"Annah Moon · Rosemarie Lühr","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Moon explicitly exemplifies cyning from *kuning as u > y; EWA independently aligns Old English cyning with *kuninga-.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic comparison to attested Old English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":931,"id":931,"entryId":171,"entrySlug":"king","childFormId":1101,"parentFormId":1102,"canonicalEdgeId":1047,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *kuninga- is formed on *kunja- with the reconstructed suffix *-inga-/-unga-; this main-spine edge follows the lexical base while a parallel graph edge preserves the suffix.","semanticChange":"A lineage or kin term produces a person-title. EWA glosses the original formation as a member of a noble lineage; Meli proposes one who brings distinction to the lineage.","scholar":"Rosemarie Lühr · Marcello Meli","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The kin-base derivation is supported independently by EWA and American Heritage; the precise original social interpretation remains an open dispute.","chronologyNote":"A reconstructed morphological relationship, not one dated coronation or political event.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":932,"id":932,"entryId":171,"entrySlug":"king","childFormId":1102,"parentFormId":1103,"canonicalEdgeId":1048,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic k reflects the Indo-European palatal stop under Grimm’s Law, while the suffixed zero-grade formation develops into Germanic *kunja-.","semanticChange":"A birth or generation formation develops the lineage, family, and kin field.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Rosemarie Lühr","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"American Heritage directly places Germanic *kunjam under *gn̥ə-yo-; EWA publishes the laryngeal correspondence.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":933,"id":933,"entryId":171,"entrySlug":"king","childFormId":1103,"parentFormId":1104,"canonicalEdgeId":1049,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The suffixed zero grade suppresses the root e and combines the reduced root with *-yo-; the full oldest root is reconstructed as *ǵenh₁-.","semanticChange":"Give birth and beget supply derivatives for generation, lineage, family, and tribal groups.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Rosemarie Lühr","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":934,"id":934,"entryId":171,"entrySlug":"king","childFormId":1104,"parentFormId":1105,"canonicalEdgeId":1050,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *ǵenh₁- root.","semanticChange":"The graph stops before comparative reconstruction becomes a creation myth for monarchy.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word or a claim about one original institution.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":935,"id":935,"entryId":172,"entrySlug":"kin","childFormId":1106,"parentFormId":1107,"canonicalEdgeId":1054,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English kin survives as the modern spelling and pronunciation after competing medieval variants recede; no unsupported single dialect is treated as the sole donor.","semanticChange":"The broad race, people, family, ancestry, kind, and category field narrows in ordinary modern use toward relatives, common ancestry, and kindred relationship.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Middle English Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The form continuity and semantic inventories are directly documented; the edge does not assign every sense loss an invented exact date.","chronologyNote":"Middle English into modern English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":936,"id":936,"entryId":172,"entrySlug":"kin","childFormId":1107,"parentFormId":1108,"canonicalEdgeId":1055,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English kin, kyn, kinne, and related forms continue Old English cynn; y is commonly unrounded toward i and the inherited long consonant ceases to be contrastively represented in the modern monosyllable.","semanticChange":"Old English kindred, race, people, tribe, family, lineage, generation, kind, and gender senses continue unevenly into the medieval kin family.","scholar":"Middle English Dictionary Editors · Joseph Bosworth · T. Northcote Toller","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The dictionaries publish the direct ancestry and form inventories; the graph does not pretend one spelling changed everywhere at once.","chronologyNote":"Old English into Middle English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":937,"id":937,"entryId":172,"entrySlug":"kin","childFormId":1108,"parentFormId":1109,"canonicalEdgeId":1056,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The published prehistoric sequence is *kunjō > *kunnjō > *kynni > cynn: West Germanic gemination doubles n before j, i-umlaut fronts u to y, and the glide and ending are lost.","semanticChange":"The Germanic generation, lineage, kind, and family formation continues as the wide Old English cynn semantic field.","scholar":"Elżbieta Adamczyk · R. D. Fulk · Rosemarie Lühr","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Adamczyk prints the exact sequence; Fulk independently identifies Runic kunni as evidence for gemination. The precise dating and analysis of Sievers’ Law remain open.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic through West Germanic prehistory into attested Old English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":938,"id":938,"entryId":172,"entrySlug":"kin","childFormId":1109,"parentFormId":1110,"canonicalEdgeId":1048,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic k reflects the Indo-European palatal stop under Grimm’s Law, while the suffixed zero-grade formation develops into Germanic *kunja-.","semanticChange":"A birth or generation formation develops the lineage, family, and kin field.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Rosemarie Lühr","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"American Heritage directly places Germanic *kunjam under *gn̥ə-yo-; EWA publishes the laryngeal correspondence.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":939,"id":939,"entryId":172,"entrySlug":"kin","childFormId":1110,"parentFormId":1111,"canonicalEdgeId":1049,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The suffixed zero grade suppresses the root e and combines the reduced root with *-yo-; the full oldest root is reconstructed as *ǵenh₁-.","semanticChange":"Give birth and beget supply derivatives for generation, lineage, family, and tribal groups.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Rosemarie Lühr","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":940,"id":940,"entryId":172,"entrySlug":"kin","childFormId":1111,"parentFormId":1112,"canonicalEdgeId":1059,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *ǵenh₁- root.","semanticChange":"The graph stops before comparative reconstruction becomes an origin story for kinship or human society.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first word or a universal theory of relatedness.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":941,"id":941,"entryId":173,"entrySlug":"kind","childFormId":1113,"parentFormId":1114,"canonicalEdgeId":1061,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English kinde and related spellings converge on modern kind; the final unstressed vowel is lost and the vowel participates in the later history that yields /aɪ/.","semanticChange":"The noun retains class, sort, nature, and in-kind senses while the older origin, family, sex, and created-order field recedes or survives in compounds and fixed uses.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Middle English Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The dictionaries directly document the ancestry and sense inventories; the edge does not assign one date to every spelling or semantic loss.","chronologyNote":"Middle English into modern English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":942,"id":942,"entryId":173,"entrySlug":"kind","childFormId":1114,"parentFormId":1115,"canonicalEdgeId":1062,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English kīnde, cinde, kunde, cunde, and related forms continue Old English cynd / gecynd with dialectal vowel and spelling variation; inherited endings and some prefixal marking recede.","semanticChange":"Old English nature, origin, generation, condition, and kind meanings expand and reorganize into medieval essential nature, creation, family, class, species, sex, and manner senses.","scholar":"Middle English Dictionary Editors · Joseph Bosworth · T. Northcote Toller","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The historical dictionaries publish the direct ancestry and broad overlap; no one representative spelling is promoted as the source of every dialectal form.","chronologyNote":"Old English into Middle English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":943,"id":943,"entryId":173,"entrySlug":"kind","childFormId":1115,"parentFormId":1116,"canonicalEdgeId":1063,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *kundjaz develops through West Germanic history to Old English cynd / gecynd: the following j conditions fronting of u to y before the glide and ending disappear; the ge- variant is not treated as part of the reconstructed stem.","semanticChange":"A reconstructed origin, birth, family, race, or kind noun continues in Old English nature, origin, generation, offspring, and category senses.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Bosworth–Toller Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"American Heritage directly prints the Germanic and Old English forms; Bosworth–Toller supplies the attested Old English inventory. The graph distinguishes lexical inheritance from optional prefixal form.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic comparison through West Germanic prehistory into attested Old English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":944,"id":944,"entryId":173,"entrySlug":"kind","childFormId":1116,"parentFormId":1117,"canonicalEdgeId":1064,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The Indo-European palatal stop develops as Germanic k under Grimm’s Law, while a suffixed zero-grade *gn̥ə-t- formation is represented in Germanic *kund- material; the exact consonant and stem reconstruction varies across analyses.","semanticChange":"A formation meaning born or produced develops the origin, family, race, nature, and kind noun field.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Rosemarie Lühr","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"American Heritage publishes *kundjaz from the zero-grade formation. EWA’s comparative discussion preserves *kenþa-, *kunđa-, and *kunđi- analyses and unresolved voicing or borrowing questions for parts of the Germanic evidence.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European to Proto-Germanic reconstruction, without a directly attested intermediate token.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":945,"id":945,"entryId":173,"entrySlug":"kind","childFormId":1117,"parentFormId":1118,"canonicalEdgeId":1065,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The zero grade suppresses the root vowel and adds the *-t- formation to the birth root; the full oldest root is represented as *ǵenh₁-.","semanticChange":"Give birth and beget produce derivatives for what is born, natural, generated, familial, or classed by kind.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":946,"id":946,"entryId":173,"entrySlug":"kind","childFormId":1118,"parentFormId":1119,"canonicalEdgeId":1066,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *ǵenh₁- root.","semanticChange":"The graph stops before lexical evidence is turned into a universal claim about nature, moral goodness, or human classification.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The reconstructed root is not an attested first use of kind or a proof that natural and morally good were originally identical.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":947,"id":947,"entryId":174,"entrySlug":"kindred","childFormId":1120,"parentFormId":1121,"canonicalEdgeId":1072,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English kinrede loses the final weak syllable inherited from -ræden, while an intrusive d develops between n and r and becomes fixed in kindred. The edge preserves kindrede as a medieval variant without treating kind as a component.","semanticChange":"The family, lineage, blood-relation, and kinship noun continues; attributive use produces the adjective for shared ancestry and later for related origin, nature, or character.","scholar":"Elizabeth Closs Traugott · Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Traugott directly identifies kin-reden and the intrusive d; the dictionaries document the form history, noun-to-adjective relationship, and current senses.","chronologyNote":"Middle English reduction into modern English, with no single invented date for d-fixation.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":948,"id":948,"entryId":174,"entrySlug":"kindred","childFormId":1121,"parentFormId":1122,"canonicalEdgeId":1073,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English kinrede continues late Old English cynræden / cynrēde through normal replacement of Old English c and y spellings, reduction of the second element, and loss of inherited inflection; the d-bearing variant is later.","semanticChange":"Old English kinship and kin-conditioned state develops the medieval family, lineage, blood-relations, nation, and collective-relatives field.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Middle English Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The dictionaries align the Middle and late Old English forms; the representative spellings do not collapse dialectal and inflectional variation.","chronologyNote":"Late Old English into Middle English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":949,"id":949,"entryId":174,"entrySlug":"kindred","childFormId":1122,"parentFormId":1123,"canonicalEdgeId":1074,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"The first element of cyn-ræden is Old English cynn in compound form; the compound boundary does not assert a sound change from the whole word to cynn.","semanticChange":"Kin, family, lineage, and people supplies the social relation whose condition or collective state the compound names.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Elizabeth Closs Traugott","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"All three sources analyze the first element as cynn or kin. This is component ancestry, not whole-word inheritance.","chronologyNote":"A late Old English compound analysis.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":950,"id":950,"entryId":174,"entrySlug":"kindred","childFormId":1123,"parentFormId":1124,"canonicalEdgeId":1056,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The published prehistoric sequence is *kunjō > *kunnjō > *kynni > cynn: West Germanic gemination doubles n before j, i-umlaut fronts u to y, and the glide and ending are lost.","semanticChange":"The Germanic generation, lineage, kind, and family formation continues as the wide Old English cynn semantic field.","scholar":"Elżbieta Adamczyk · R. D. Fulk · Rosemarie Lühr","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Adamczyk prints the exact sequence; Fulk independently identifies Runic kunni as evidence for gemination. The precise dating and analysis of Sievers’ Law remain open.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic through West Germanic prehistory into attested Old English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":951,"id":951,"entryId":174,"entrySlug":"kindred","childFormId":1124,"parentFormId":1125,"canonicalEdgeId":1048,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic k reflects the Indo-European palatal stop under Grimm’s Law, while the suffixed zero-grade formation develops into Germanic *kunja-.","semanticChange":"A birth or generation formation develops the lineage, family, and kin field.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Rosemarie Lühr","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"American Heritage directly places Germanic *kunjam under *gn̥ə-yo-; EWA publishes the laryngeal correspondence.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":952,"id":952,"entryId":174,"entrySlug":"kindred","childFormId":1125,"parentFormId":1126,"canonicalEdgeId":1049,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The suffixed zero grade suppresses the root e and combines the reduced root with *-yo-; the full oldest root is reconstructed as *ǵenh₁-.","semanticChange":"Give birth and beget supply derivatives for generation, lineage, family, and tribal groups.","scholar":"Calvert Watkins and American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Rosemarie Lühr","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":null,"chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":953,"id":953,"entryId":174,"entrySlug":"kindred","childFormId":1126,"parentFormId":1127,"canonicalEdgeId":1078,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the reviewed *ǵenh₁- root on this branch.","semanticChange":"The kin branch stops before comparative reconstruction becomes an origin story for kinship, family, or the whole compound.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The separate condition branch receives its own root and evidence boundary.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":954,"id":954,"entryId":175,"entrySlug":"hatred","childFormId":1128,"parentFormId":1129,"canonicalEdgeId":1084,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English hatrede / hatreden loses the final suffixal syllable while the reduced -red spelling and /rɪd/ pronunciation become fixed in modern English.","semanticChange":"The medieval state or condition of hate continues as intense animosity, hostility, or extreme dislike; countable hatreds later names particular hostilities.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The sources agree on the Middle English whole-word stage and the fossilized second component.","chronologyNote":"Middle English into modern English; the evidence does not license one year for final-syllable loss.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":955,"id":955,"entryId":175,"entrySlug":"hatred","childFormId":1129,"parentFormId":1130,"canonicalEdgeId":1085,"relationType":"compound_component","soundChange":"The first element of Middle English hate-rede is hate. This component edge is morphological analysis, not a claim that the whole compound changed into the bare noun.","semanticChange":"Hate supplies the emotion or hostility whose condition the compound names.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Both dictionaries directly segment the word as hate plus -rede.","chronologyNote":"A Middle English compound analysis.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":956,"id":956,"entryId":175,"entrySlug":"hatred","childFormId":1130,"parentFormId":1131,"canonicalEdgeId":1086,"relationType":"lexical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English hate stands beside inherited hete, with a remodeled a-vowel form associated with the verb haten. The graph does not pretend the noun-side replacement was a single regular sound law.","semanticChange":"Old English hate, hostility, and anger continue in Middle English, while the noun form is remodeled or replaced beside the inherited reflex.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"American Heritage presents the noun as from Old English hete; Merriam-Webster instead calls Middle English hate probably derivative of haten and replacing hete.","chronologyNote":"Old English into Middle English, with overlapping inherited and remodeled forms.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":957,"id":957,"entryId":175,"entrySlug":"hatred","childFormId":1131,"parentFormId":1132,"canonicalEdgeId":1087,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The Germanic i-stem *hatiz- yields Old English hete; the exact intermediate West Germanic paradigm is not independently promoted here.","semanticChange":"The Germanic hate, anger, enmity, and spite field continues in the Old English noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster directly aligns the i-stem with Old English hete; Liberman supplies the Germanic cognate set.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into attested Old English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":958,"id":958,"entryId":175,"entrySlug":"hatred","childFormId":1132,"parentFormId":1133,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":959,"id":959,"entryId":175,"entrySlug":"hatred","childFormId":1133,"parentFormId":1134,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":960,"id":960,"entryId":175,"entrySlug":"hatred","childFormId":1134,"parentFormId":1135,"canonicalEdgeId":1090,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form or uniquely recoverable concrete meaning is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- proposal.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before a convenient story about love and hate, pursuit, grief, or care is mistaken for established prehistory.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The secure path reaches Germanic; the displayed PIE lane is a qualified proposal, not a settled endpoint.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":961,"id":961,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","childFormId":1136,"parentFormId":1137,"canonicalEdgeId":1097,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English hate continues into modern /heɪt/ through the Great Vowel Shift and regular loss of final inflectional material; noun and verb converge in one spelling.","semanticChange":"The hostility and enmity field continues while the verb also develops strong-dislike, distaste, and polite-reluctance uses and the noun develops attributive public uses such as hate speech.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The modern continuation is secure even though the immediate source of the Middle English noun is disputed.","chronologyNote":"Middle English into modern English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":962,"id":962,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","childFormId":1137,"parentFormId":1138,"canonicalEdgeId":1093,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The noun hate is analyzed as a zero-derived or remodeled form based on Middle English haten; this edge represents Merriam-Webster’s probable analysis, not unanimous consensus.","semanticChange":"The verbal act or disposition of hating supplies a remodeled noun for the emotion.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"American Heritage instead presents the noun as continuing Old English hete.","chronologyNote":"Middle English internal derivation or remodeling.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":963,"id":963,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","childFormId":1138,"parentFormId":1139,"canonicalEdgeId":1094,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Middle English haten continues Old English hatian with loss of the medial unstressed vowel and inherited infinitive reduction.","semanticChange":"Treat as an enemy or persecute continues as hate; a pursuit sense is relevant to one deeper semantic hypothesis.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · American Heritage Dictionary Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The verb ancestry is secure; the claim that pursuit is primary remains proposed.","chronologyNote":"Old English into Middle English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":964,"id":964,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","childFormId":1139,"parentFormId":1140,"canonicalEdgeId":1095,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English hatian continues the reconstructed Germanic weak verb *hatōjan-, with the inherited stem and reduced inflection.","semanticChange":"The Germanic hostile-disposition verb continues in Old English; pursuit or persecution may preserve a more concrete action sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The formal inheritance is secure; the semantic priority of pursuit is proposed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into attested Old English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":965,"id":965,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","childFormId":1140,"parentFormId":1141,"canonicalEdgeId":1096,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The Germanic weak verb *hatōjan- is derived from the base of the hate noun *hatiz-.","semanticChange":"A noun for hate or enmity supplies the related verb to hate or treat as an enemy.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly derives the verb formation from the noun base.","chronologyNote":"Related Proto-Germanic reconstructed formations.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":966,"id":966,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","childFormId":1141,"parentFormId":1142,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":967,"id":967,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","childFormId":1142,"parentFormId":1143,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":968,"id":968,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","childFormId":1143,"parentFormId":1144,"canonicalEdgeId":1104,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form or single original concrete meaning is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- proposal.","semanticChange":"The trail stops before pursuit, grief, love, care, or hatred is turned into a prehistoric just-so story.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison ends at Germanic; the displayed PIE route remains qualified.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":969,"id":969,"entryId":177,"entrySlug":"hete","childFormId":1145,"parentFormId":1146,"canonicalEdgeId":1087,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The Germanic i-stem *hatiz- yields Old English hete; the exact intermediate West Germanic paradigm is not independently promoted here.","semanticChange":"The Germanic hate, anger, enmity, and spite field continues in the Old English noun.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster directly aligns the i-stem with Old English hete; Liberman supplies the Germanic cognate set.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into attested Old English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":970,"id":970,"entryId":177,"entrySlug":"hete","childFormId":1146,"parentFormId":1147,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":971,"id":971,"entryId":177,"entrySlug":"hete","childFormId":1147,"parentFormId":1148,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":972,"id":972,"entryId":177,"entrySlug":"hete","childFormId":1148,"parentFormId":1149,"canonicalEdgeId":1108,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form or uniquely recoverable concrete meaning is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- proposal.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before Old English hostility is reverse-engineered into one unevidenced prehistoric feeling or action.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison ends at Germanic; the displayed PIE route remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":973,"id":973,"entryId":178,"entrySlug":"hatian","childFormId":1150,"parentFormId":1151,"canonicalEdgeId":1095,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English hatian continues the reconstructed Germanic weak verb *hatōjan-, with the inherited stem and reduced inflection.","semanticChange":"The Germanic hostile-disposition verb continues in Old English; pursuit or persecution may preserve a more concrete action sense.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The formal inheritance is secure; the semantic priority of pursuit is proposed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into attested Old English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":974,"id":974,"entryId":178,"entrySlug":"hatian","childFormId":1151,"parentFormId":1152,"canonicalEdgeId":1096,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The Germanic weak verb *hatōjan- is derived from the base of the hate noun *hatiz-.","semanticChange":"A noun for hate or enmity supplies the related verb to hate or treat as an enemy.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster explicitly derives the verb formation from the noun base.","chronologyNote":"Related Proto-Germanic reconstructed formations.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":975,"id":975,"entryId":178,"entrySlug":"hatian","childFormId":1152,"parentFormId":1153,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":976,"id":976,"entryId":178,"entrySlug":"hatian","childFormId":1153,"parentFormId":1154,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":977,"id":977,"entryId":178,"entrySlug":"hatian","childFormId":1154,"parentFormId":1155,"canonicalEdgeId":1113,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form or uniquely recoverable concrete meaning is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- proposal.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the Old English verb’s objects are reverse-engineered into one unevidenced prehistoric action or feeling.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison ends at Germanic; the displayed PIE route remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":978,"id":978,"entryId":179,"entrySlug":"hettan","childFormId":1156,"parentFormId":1157,"canonicalEdgeId":1114,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The j-conditioned Germanic stem accounts for Old English fronting of a to e and the geminate spelling in hettan; the displayed infinitive is a normalized lemma rather than a quoted corpus token.","semanticChange":"The compared Germanic verb family ranges across hate, pursuit, attack, and persecution, but the priority of those senses is unresolved.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Chr. Peeters · Marta Tío Sáenz","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal Germanic comparison is strong, but the located Old English verbal inventory supplies only hettende and dictionaries disagree on its lemma assignment.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into Old English lexical and textual evidence.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":979,"id":979,"entryId":179,"entrySlug":"hettan","childFormId":1157,"parentFormId":1158,"canonicalEdgeId":1115,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Orel derives *xatjanan from the Germanic hate-noun base he writes *xataz ~ *xatez; the graph crosswalks that base to its already reviewed *hatiz- representation.","semanticChange":"A noun for hate or enmity supplies a weak verb whose attested relatives range from hate to pursuit.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The derivational analysis is published; the exact reconstruction notation differs between sources and is therefore not flattened into false certainty.","chronologyNote":"Related Proto-Germanic reconstructed formations.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":980,"id":980,"entryId":179,"entrySlug":"hettan","childFormId":1158,"parentFormId":1159,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":981,"id":981,"entryId":179,"entrySlug":"hettan","childFormId":1159,"parentFormId":1160,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":982,"id":982,"entryId":179,"entrySlug":"hettan","childFormId":1160,"parentFormId":1161,"canonicalEdgeId":1118,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form or uniquely recoverable concrete meaning is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- proposal.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the Old English verb’s objects are reverse-engineered into one unevidenced prehistoric action or feeling.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison ends at Germanic; the displayed PIE route remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":983,"id":983,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","childFormId":1162,"parentFormId":1163,"canonicalEdgeId":1119,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Regional Early New High German spellings converge on standard hetzen; inflection and pronunciation continue to develop while the lexical stem remains recognizable.","semanticChange":"The inherited chase and incitement senses continue, while reflexive and intransitive hurry uses become prominent in modern German.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion · Oskar Reichmann et al.","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Modern and Early New High German dictionaries document overlapping action senses without requiring a new lexical origin.","chronologyNote":"Early New High German into standardized Modern German.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":984,"id":984,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","childFormId":1163,"parentFormId":1164,"canonicalEdgeId":1120,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle High German hetzen and hatzen continue into Early New High German with regional vowel and spelling variation.","semanticChange":"Driving dogs after quarry extends to urging, provoking, and setting people against other people.","scholar":"Thomas Plate · Oskar Reichmann et al. · Heidelberger Akademie der Wissenschaften","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Historical dictionary records directly document both the hunting construction and transferred human targets.","chronologyNote":"Middle High German into Early New High German.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":985,"id":985,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","childFormId":1164,"parentFormId":1165,"canonicalEdgeId":1121,"relationType":"historical_reconstruction","soundChange":"The Middle High German verb is projected back to an Old High German weak-verb bridge; the a > e fronting and z spelling are compatible with a j-conditioned High German formation, but the exact written OHG form is disputed.","semanticChange":"The reconstructed bridge carries the chase or persecution value inferred from later German and comparative forms.","scholar":"Christopher Gordon Bailey · Friedrich Kluge · Dudenredaktion","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Bailey stars *hezzen, while Kluge and Duden describe an Old High German form without visibly marking it as reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"A reconstructed Old High German bridge inferred beneath attested Middle High German.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":986,"id":986,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","childFormId":1165,"parentFormId":1166,"canonicalEdgeId":1122,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The j-suffix conditions West Germanic fronting and consonant development; High German sound change and later reduction yield the projected *hezzen shape.","semanticChange":"A Germanic factitive or action verb associated with hostility is continued as chase, pursuit, or persecution in the High German branch.","scholar":"Christopher Gordon Bailey · Vladimir Orel","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Germanic comparison is published, but the intermediate Old High German form is reconstructed and its exact morphology varies by source.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into a projected Old High German stage.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":987,"id":987,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","childFormId":1166,"parentFormId":1167,"canonicalEdgeId":1115,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Orel derives *xatjanan from the Germanic hate-noun base he writes *xataz ~ *xatez; the graph crosswalks that base to its already reviewed *hatiz- representation.","semanticChange":"A noun for hate or enmity supplies a weak verb whose attested relatives range from hate to pursuit.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The derivational analysis is published; the exact reconstruction notation differs between sources and is therefore not flattened into false certainty.","chronologyNote":"Related Proto-Germanic reconstructed formations.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":988,"id":988,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","childFormId":1167,"parentFormId":1168,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":989,"id":989,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","childFormId":1168,"parentFormId":1169,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":990,"id":990,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","childFormId":1169,"parentFormId":1170,"canonicalEdgeId":1126,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form or uniquely recoverable concrete meaning is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- proposal.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the medieval hunting scene is projected unchanged into prehistory or converted into a universal origin for hate.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison ends at Germanic; the displayed PIE route remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":991,"id":991,"entryId":181,"entrySlug":"hatjan","childFormId":1171,"parentFormId":1172,"canonicalEdgeId":1127,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The class-I -j- morphology visible in hatjandam supports the normalized infinitive hatjan and corresponds to the reconstructed *-jan- formation; Gothic h continues the Germanic fricative written x in Orel’s notation.","semanticChange":"The surviving Gothic clause means hate. The pursuit sense of Middle High German hetzen is a daughter-branch development and is not projected back as the only Gothic meaning.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Wilhelm Braune · Project Wulfila editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Gothic lexeme and participial morphology are manuscript-attested; the Proto-Germanic parent and the exact relationship to class-III hatan are reconstructed and disputed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the fourth-century Gothic translation tradition and early-sixth-century manuscript.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":992,"id":992,"entryId":181,"entrySlug":"hatjan","childFormId":1172,"parentFormId":1173,"canonicalEdgeId":1115,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Orel derives *xatjanan from the Germanic hate-noun base he writes *xataz ~ *xatez; the graph crosswalks that base to its already reviewed *hatiz- representation.","semanticChange":"A noun for hate or enmity supplies a weak verb whose attested relatives range from hate to pursuit.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The derivational analysis is published; the exact reconstruction notation differs between sources and is therefore not flattened into false certainty.","chronologyNote":"Related Proto-Germanic reconstructed formations.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":993,"id":993,"entryId":181,"entrySlug":"hatjan","childFormId":1173,"parentFormId":1174,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":994,"id":994,"entryId":181,"entrySlug":"hatjan","childFormId":1174,"parentFormId":1175,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":995,"id":995,"entryId":181,"entrySlug":"hatjan","childFormId":1175,"parentFormId":1176,"canonicalEdgeId":1131,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form or uniquely recoverable concrete meaning is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- proposal.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the one surviving Gothic token is reverse-engineered into a universal origin for hate, grief, care, pursuit, or persecution.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison ends at Germanic; the displayed PIE route remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":996,"id":996,"entryId":182,"entrySlug":"hatis","childFormId":1177,"parentFormId":1178,"canonicalEdgeId":1132,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *hatiz- is represented by Gothic hatis word-finally and by the stem hatiz- before a vowel-initial ending, visible in hatiza. Gothic then regularizes the inherited i-stem into neuter a-stem inflection.","semanticChange":"The inherited anger or hostility noun becomes the Gothic translation choice for Greek wrath vocabulary. That contextual specialization does not prove the noun lacked hatred senses elsewhere.","scholar":"R. D. Fulk · John T. Koch · Project Wulfila editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Gothic forms and paradigm alternation are attested; the Proto-Germanic parent and the direction of prehistoric remodeling are comparative analyses.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the fourth-century Gothic translation tradition and surviving sixth-century manuscripts.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":997,"id":997,"entryId":182,"entrySlug":"hatis","childFormId":1178,"parentFormId":1179,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":998,"id":998,"entryId":182,"entrySlug":"hatis","childFormId":1179,"parentFormId":1180,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":999,"id":999,"entryId":182,"entrySlug":"hatis","childFormId":1180,"parentFormId":1181,"canonicalEdgeId":1135,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form or uniquely recoverable concrete meaning is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- proposal.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the surviving Gothic wrath tokens are reverse-engineered into a universal origin for hate, grief, care, pursuit, or persecution.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison ends at Germanic; the displayed PIE route remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1000,"id":1000,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","childFormId":1182,"parentFormId":1183,"canonicalEdgeId":1136,"relationType":"competing_inheritance","soundChange":"On the inherited analysis, Gothic h and the hat- stem continue the Germanic forms Orel writes with x, while the Gothic class-III paradigm is compared with the reconstructed *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan alternation.","semanticChange":"The Germanic weak-verb family meaning hate continues in the two surviving Gothic participles, one of which is substantivized as enemies.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Project Wulfila editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The comparative family is published, but the exact reconstruction varies and Sturtevant argues that Gothic hatan may be a secondary formation beside hatjan rather than a straightforward inherited class-III reflex.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the fourth-century Gothic translation tradition and surviving early-sixth-century manuscript.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1001,"id":1001,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","childFormId":1183,"parentFormId":1184,"canonicalEdgeId":1137,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Orel groups the weak-verb reconstruction with the Germanic hate-noun base he represents as *xataz ~ *xatez; the graph crosswalks that base to its reviewed *hatiz- node.","semanticChange":"A noun family for hate or enmity supplies or associates with weak verbs whose daughter branches express hating, hostility, pursuit, and anger.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The lexical family is secure, but the exact formation of class-III hatan and the direction of any specifically Gothic remodeling remain disputed.","chronologyNote":"Related Proto-Germanic reconstructed formations rather than independently dated words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1002,"id":1002,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","childFormId":1184,"parentFormId":1185,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1003,"id":1003,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","childFormId":1185,"parentFormId":1186,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1004,"id":1004,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","childFormId":1186,"parentFormId":1187,"canonicalEdgeId":1140,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form or uniquely recoverable concrete meaning is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- proposal.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the surviving translation alternation is reverse-engineered into a universal origin for hate, enemy, grief, care, pursuit, or persecution.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison ends at Germanic; the displayed PIE route remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1005,"id":1005,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","childFormId":1188,"parentFormId":1189,"canonicalEdgeId":1142,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Gothic fijan continues the Germanic fi(j)- stem and class-III weak-verb formation. Written Gothic alternates j-bearing forms such as fijan and fijaiþ with j-less fiaiþ, fiais, fiandans, and fiands.","semanticChange":"The reconstructed Germanic hate verb continues as a Gothic experience verb taking the hated stimulus as an accusative object; lexicalized enemy formations remain a separate branch.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen · Daniel Ayora Estevan · Project Wulfila editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Gothic paradigm and branch comparison are strong; the exact Proto-Germanic vocalism and optional-j notation are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the fourth-century Gothic translation tradition and surviving sixth-century manuscripts.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1006,"id":1006,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","childFormId":1189,"parentFormId":1190,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1007,"id":1007,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","childFormId":1190,"parentFormId":1191,"canonicalEdgeId":1144,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the Gothic verb-and-enemy overlap is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric meaning.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deeper base is already proposed; no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1008,"id":1008,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","childFormId":1192,"parentFormId":1193,"canonicalEdgeId":1146,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Gothic fijands continues the Germanic nd-stem formation with regular branch-level adaptation and Gothic inflection.","semanticChange":"The already lexicalized agent formation functions as the ordinary noun enemy while remaining formally close to a live participle.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen · Daniel Ayora Estevan","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Cross-Germanic enemy nouns support inheritance; individual Gothic tokens can remain ambiguous with the participle.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the Gothic textual tradition.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1009,"id":1009,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","childFormId":1193,"parentFormId":1194,"canonicalEdgeId":1147,"relationType":"lexicalized_participle","soundChange":"The present-participial nd-formation is built on the fi(j)- verb stem.","semanticChange":"One who hates lexicalizes as enemy before Gothic, while productive participial use survives beside the noun.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The derivation and pre-Gothic lexicalization are published; the exact moment and every token’s category remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic derivation and lexicalization before the Gothic branch record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1010,"id":1010,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","childFormId":1194,"parentFormId":1195,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1011,"id":1011,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","childFormId":1195,"parentFormId":1196,"canonicalEdgeId":1152,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before enemy or evil spirit is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric concept.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deeper base is already proposed; no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1012,"id":1012,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","childFormId":1197,"parentFormId":1198,"canonicalEdgeId":1154,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English fēond continues the Germanic nd-agent formation with West Germanic vowel and inflectional development.","semanticChange":"The lexicalized one-who-hates formation remains an enemy or foe noun and also supplies a devil sense in Old English.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Bosworth–Toller editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Cross-Germanic comparison and the Old English entry support inheritance; exact intermediate phonetic detail remains reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the Old English written record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1013,"id":1013,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","childFormId":1198,"parentFormId":1199,"canonicalEdgeId":1147,"relationType":"lexicalized_participle","soundChange":"The present-participial nd-formation is built on the fi(j)- verb stem.","semanticChange":"One who hates lexicalizes as enemy before Gothic, while productive participial use survives beside the noun.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The derivation and pre-Gothic lexicalization are published; the exact moment and every token’s category remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic derivation and lexicalization before the Gothic branch record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1014,"id":1014,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","childFormId":1199,"parentFormId":1200,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1015,"id":1015,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","childFormId":1200,"parentFormId":1201,"canonicalEdgeId":1158,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the Old English enemy, Devil, or demon history is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric concept.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deeper base is already proposed; no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1016,"id":1016,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","childFormId":1202,"parentFormId":1203,"canonicalEdgeId":1159,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English fēogan and contracted feón continue the Germanic fi(j)- verb with West Germanic vocalic, consonantal, and inflectional development; the exact prehistoric sequence behind every recorded variant remains reconstructed.","semanticChange":"The inherited Germanic hate or hostility verb remains a transitive verb meaning hate or persecute in Old English.","scholar":"Joseph Bosworth · Thomas Northcote Toller · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Old English forms and cross-Germanic comparison support inheritance; the exact intermediate phonetic history is not directly attested.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the Old English written record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1017,"id":1017,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","childFormId":1203,"parentFormId":1204,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1018,"id":1018,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","childFormId":1204,"parentFormId":1205,"canonicalEdgeId":1161,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the Old English acts of hating or persecuting are reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric concept.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deeper base is already proposed; no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1019,"id":1019,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","childFormId":1206,"parentFormId":1207,"canonicalEdgeId":1153,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English long vowel and inflectional endings pass through Middle English fend, feend, and feond forms into modern fiend.","semanticChange":"The inherited enemy and foe noun develops or foregrounds evil-spirit and cruel-person senses in the English branch.","scholar":"Bosworth–Toller editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The direct English continuation is documented; this edge does not assert that modern senses were absent from Old English.","chronologyNote":"Old English through Middle English into the modern language.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1020,"id":1020,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","childFormId":1207,"parentFormId":1208,"canonicalEdgeId":1154,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old English fēond continues the Germanic nd-agent formation with West Germanic vowel and inflectional development.","semanticChange":"The lexicalized one-who-hates formation remains an enemy or foe noun and also supplies a devil sense in Old English.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Bosworth–Toller editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Cross-Germanic comparison and the Old English entry support inheritance; exact intermediate phonetic detail remains reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the Old English written record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1021,"id":1021,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","childFormId":1208,"parentFormId":1209,"canonicalEdgeId":1147,"relationType":"lexicalized_participle","soundChange":"The present-participial nd-formation is built on the fi(j)- verb stem.","semanticChange":"One who hates lexicalizes as enemy before Gothic, while productive participial use survives beside the noun.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The derivation and pre-Gothic lexicalization are published; the exact moment and every token’s category remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic derivation and lexicalization before the Gothic branch record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1022,"id":1022,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","childFormId":1209,"parentFormId":1210,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1023,"id":1023,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","childFormId":1210,"parentFormId":1211,"canonicalEdgeId":1166,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the Old English enemy, Devil, or demon history is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric concept.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deeper base is already proposed; no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1024,"id":1024,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","childFormId":1212,"parentFormId":1213,"canonicalEdgeId":1167,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle High German long ī undergoes the later High German diphthongization represented by modern /aɪ̯/; noun capitalization and final spelling standardize as Feind.","semanticChange":"The inherited enemy or adversary noun remains available for personal, collective, military, and ideological opposition.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion · Wolfgang Pfeifer","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Both modern dictionaries explicitly give the Middle High German forms as the immediate historical stage; the edge does not assign one day to every spelling or sound transition.","chronologyNote":"Middle High German through Early New High German into the modern written standard.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1025,"id":1025,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","childFormId":1213,"parentFormId":1214,"canonicalEdgeId":1168,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Old High German fīant, fījant, or fīand continues as Middle High German vīant, vīent, and vīnt through High German sound, spelling, and syllabic reduction; the sources preserve variant forms rather than one universal intermediate spelling.","semanticChange":"The lexicalized enemy meaning continues through the attested High German record.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion · Wolfgang Pfeifer · Jacob Grimm","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Three independent dictionary records publish the Old-to-Middle-High-German sequence. Exact local phonetics and the chronology of every variant remain broader than the written headword chain.","chronologyNote":"Old High German records from the eighth century into the Middle High German textual period.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1026,"id":1026,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","childFormId":1214,"parentFormId":1215,"canonicalEdgeId":1169,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old High German fīant reflects the Germanic nd-agent formation after High German branch development in its vowel, glide, consonants, and inflection.","semanticChange":"The already lexicalized one-who-hates formation is inherited as the ordinary enemy noun.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen · Wolfgang Pfeifer","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Old High German form is attested and the cross-Germanic formation is published; the exact Proto-Germanic phonetic path remains reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the eighth-century Old High German record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1027,"id":1027,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","childFormId":1215,"parentFormId":1216,"canonicalEdgeId":1147,"relationType":"lexicalized_participle","soundChange":"The present-participial nd-formation is built on the fi(j)- verb stem.","semanticChange":"One who hates lexicalizes as enemy before Gothic, while productive participial use survives beside the noun.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The derivation and pre-Gothic lexicalization are published; the exact moment and every token’s category remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic derivation and lexicalization before the Gothic branch record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1028,"id":1028,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","childFormId":1216,"parentFormId":1217,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1029,"id":1029,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","childFormId":1217,"parentFormId":1218,"canonicalEdgeId":1172,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the German enemy, English demon, or Grimm’s historical foam comparison is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric concept.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen · Jacob Grimm","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deepest displayed base is already proposed; Grimm’s own alternative was explicitly left awaiting confirmation, so no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1030,"id":1030,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","childFormId":1219,"parentFormId":1220,"canonicalEdgeId":1173,"relationType":"orthographic_standardization","soundChange":"The 1996 German spelling reform writes ss after the short vowel in Hass where the pre-reform standard used ß. No pronunciation change is asserted.","semanticChange":"The lexical meaning remains intense aversion or hostility; the edge models spelling standardization, not a new emotional category.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Duden explicitly flags a 1996 spelling change. Earlier ss usage in Switzerland or other settings is not dated away by the standardization claim.","chronologyNote":"Pre-reform Haß to current standard Hass in 1996.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1031,"id":1031,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","childFormId":1220,"parentFormId":1221,"canonicalEdgeId":1174,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle High German haʒ continues through New High German hasz or Haß with capitalization of the noun and changing conventions for the final sibilant.","semanticChange":"The modern hostile-disposition center becomes dominant while the older action, pursuit, anger-in-action, and friendly-rivalry uses recede or disappear.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion · Wolfgang Pfeifer · Jacob Grimm","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"All three dictionaries connect the historical forms. DWB documents the semantic contrast but does not license one date when every side meaning disappeared.","chronologyNote":"Middle High German through New High German spelling and semantic standardization.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1032,"id":1032,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","childFormId":1221,"parentFormId":1222,"canonicalEdgeId":1175,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"The reviewed dictionaries print the Old and Middle High German noun as haʒ; this edge preserves two attested language periods without inventing a sound change between identical normalized forms.","semanticChange":"DWB says hostile disposition is exclusively attested in Old High German, while Middle High German records also expose hostile action, anger enacted, and rivalry. That is a difference in the surviving record, not proof of one instantaneous innovation.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion · Wolfgang Pfeifer · Jacob Grimm","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The historical stages are explicit. Semantic coverage reflects cited texts and may not exhaust spoken usage.","chronologyNote":"Old High German records from the eighth century into the Middle High German textual period.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1033,"id":1033,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","childFormId":1222,"parentFormId":1223,"canonicalEdgeId":1176,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Under the comparative analysis, Germanic t develops into the Old High German sibilant written ʒ through the High German consonant shift, while i-stem morphology and gender are remodeled in the High German branch.","semanticChange":"The inherited hate, anger, enmity, or hostility field continues as Old High German haʒ; competing sources disagree on whether pursuit, suffering, or hostile disposition best represents the earlier semantic center.","scholar":"Wolfgang Pfeifer · Jacob Grimm · John T. Koch","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Old High German form and cross-Germanic set are attested; the Proto-Germanic form, exact stem alternation, and semantic center are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the eighth-century Old High German record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1034,"id":1034,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","childFormId":1223,"parentFormId":1224,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1035,"id":1035,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","childFormId":1224,"parentFormId":1225,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1036,"id":1036,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","childFormId":1225,"parentFormId":1226,"canonicalEdgeId":1179,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the already disputed *ḱeh₂d- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail stops before one medieval rivalry, one modern feeling, or one scholarly pursuit-or-sorrow proposal is reverse-engineered into universal prehistory.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman · Jacob Grimm","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison is strongest inside Germanic; the displayed Indo-European lane remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1037,"id":1037,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","childFormId":1227,"parentFormId":1228,"canonicalEdgeId":1180,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"The comparative analysis aligns Old Norse hatr and genitive hatrs with the Germanic *hatiz- noun after North Germanic loss or reduction of unstressed material and branch-specific inflection. The public sources establish the comparison more securely than one fully specified sound-law derivation.","semanticChange":"The inherited hate, anger, enmity, or spite field continues in Old Norse hatred, enmity, and spite. One proposed mockery or scorn context remains a qualified side sense rather than the ancestral center.","scholar":"Dictionary of Old Norse Prose editors · Richard Cleasby · Guðbrandur Vigfússon · John T. Koch","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Old Norse form and comparative Germanic set are attested or published; the parent form, exact paradigm history, and semantic center are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the Old Norse textual record, including a directly inspected c.1150-1200 manuscript token.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1038,"id":1038,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","childFormId":1228,"parentFormId":1229,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1039,"id":1039,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","childFormId":1229,"parentFormId":1230,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1040,"id":1040,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","childFormId":1230,"parentFormId":1231,"canonicalEdgeId":1183,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the already disputed *ḱeh₂d- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail stops before one Old Norse grammar anomaly, one uncertain scorn passage, or one modern hate gloss is reverse-engineered into universal prehistory.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison is strongest inside Germanic; the displayed Indo-European lane remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1041,"id":1041,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","childFormId":1232,"parentFormId":1233,"canonicalEdgeId":1184,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Early New High German hassen continues into New High German with the same normalized spelling while pronunciation, inflection, and usage are standardized over time.","semanticChange":"The modern verb retains person-directed hatred and also supports a broad strong-aversion sense for things and actions; the edge does not assign one intensity to every historical token.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion · Wolfgang Pfeifer · Jacob Grimm","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The lexical continuation and current senses are directly documented; no single date is assigned to the semantic balance.","chronologyNote":"Early New High German print into the New High German and current record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1042,"id":1042,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","childFormId":1233,"parentFormId":1234,"canonicalEdgeId":1185,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle High German haʒʒen continues into the hassen spelling of the Early New High German record as the historical sibilant notation and spelling conventions change.","semanticChange":"The Middle High German record already includes ordinary hating and disliking; action-centered persecution contexts recede while hostile disposition becomes central.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion · Jacob Grimm · Matthias Lexer","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The form sequence is explicit in the dictionaries. The semantic development is a corpus-based description, not an instantaneous change.","chronologyNote":"Middle High German into Early New High German textual records.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1043,"id":1043,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","childFormId":1234,"parentFormId":1235,"canonicalEdgeId":1186,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"The reviewed dictionaries connect Middle High German haʒʒen with Old High German haʒʒēn and haʒʒōn. The edge preserves the printed variants rather than inventing one normalized historical token.","semanticChange":"DWB aligns Old High German forms with following or pursuing and describes the later feeling-centered sense as more muted; Middle High German evidence contains both hostile action and disposition.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion · Jacob Grimm · Georg Friedrich Benecke · Wilhelm Müller · Friedrich Zarncke","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The historical forms and located examples are published. No primary manuscript was directly inspected for this dossier.","chronologyNote":"Old High German into the Middle High German textual period.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1044,"id":1044,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","childFormId":1235,"parentFormId":1236,"canonicalEdgeId":1187,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old High German haʒʒōn belongs to the comparative weak-verb set Orel reconstructs as *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan; the High German branch reflects the consonant-shifted Germanic t in the doubled sibilant spelling.","semanticChange":"The inherited Germanic hate field continues in the Old High German verb, but pursuit, hostile action, and hostile disposition remain competing candidates for the earlier semantic center.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Dudenredaktion · Jacob Grimm","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Old High German variants and cross-Germanic set are published; the parent alternatives and semantic center are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the Old High German record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1045,"id":1045,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","childFormId":1236,"parentFormId":1237,"canonicalEdgeId":1137,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Orel groups the weak-verb reconstruction with the Germanic hate-noun base he represents as *xataz ~ *xatez; the graph crosswalks that base to its reviewed *hatiz- node.","semanticChange":"A noun family for hate or enmity supplies or associates with weak verbs whose daughter branches express hating, hostility, pursuit, and anger.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The lexical family is secure, but the exact formation of class-III hatan and the direction of any specifically Gothic remodeling remain disputed.","chronologyNote":"Related Proto-Germanic reconstructed formations rather than independently dated words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1046,"id":1046,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","childFormId":1237,"parentFormId":1238,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1047,"id":1047,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","childFormId":1238,"parentFormId":1239,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1048,"id":1048,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","childFormId":1239,"parentFormId":1240,"canonicalEdgeId":1191,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the already disputed *ḱeh₂d- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail stops before pursuit, persecution, feeling, grief, pain, care, or hatred is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric act.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman · Jacob Grimm","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison is strongest inside Germanic; the displayed Indo-European lane remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1049,"id":1049,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","childFormId":1241,"parentFormId":1242,"canonicalEdgeId":1192,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle Dutch viant, viand, uiant, and vient continue into New Dutch vijand and vyand as initial consonant spelling, vowel representation, final d or t, and the full ending become standardized unevenly across the record.","semanticChange":"The ordinary enemy or opponent remains central. Medieval Devil and monster branches become historical rather than the default modern Dutch sense, while figurative opponent uses expand.","scholar":"Marlies Philippa · Frans Debrabandere · WNT editorial team","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The dictionaries publish the form and sense continuity. No single sound change or semantic switch is assigned to every dialect and token.","chronologyNote":"Middle Dutch textual evidence into New Dutch and current usage.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1050,"id":1050,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","childFormId":1242,"parentFormId":1243,"canonicalEdgeId":1193,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Old Dutch fīunt and fīant continue into Middle Dutch viant, viand, uiant, and vient through West Germanic vowel, initial fricative, glide, inflectional, and spelling developments that the corpus preserves as variants rather than one universal intermediate.","semanticChange":"Enemy or opponent continues. A Devil sense is securely widespread in Middle Dutch, while the earliest Old Dutch Devil reading remains textually disputed.","scholar":"ONW editorial team · VMNW editorial team · Marlies Philippa · Frans Debrabandere","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"ONW and VMNW provide bounded corpus inventories, dated forms, and explicit sense profiles. The exact reading of one Old Dutch Devil token remains open.","chronologyNote":"Old Dutch records from 901–1200 into the thirteenth-century Middle Dutch corpus.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1051,"id":1051,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","childFormId":1243,"parentFormId":1244,"canonicalEdgeId":1194,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Dutch fīunt or fīant reflects the Germanic nd-agent formation after West Germanic and Dutch-branch vowel, glide, consonant, and inflectional development.","semanticChange":"The already lexicalized one-who-hates formation is inherited as the ordinary enemy noun; Christian Devil usage develops inside the attested daughter record rather than inside the reconstruction.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen · Marlies Philippa · Arend Quak · ONW editorial team","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The daughter forms and participial analysis are independently published. The parent remains reconstructed and no written Proto-Germanic token exists.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into Old Dutch textual evidence.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1052,"id":1052,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","childFormId":1244,"parentFormId":1245,"canonicalEdgeId":1147,"relationType":"lexicalized_participle","soundChange":"The present-participial nd-formation is built on the fi(j)- verb stem.","semanticChange":"One who hates lexicalizes as enemy before Gothic, while productive participial use survives beside the noun.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The derivation and pre-Gothic lexicalization are published; the exact moment and every token’s category remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic derivation and lexicalization before the Gothic branch record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1053,"id":1053,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","childFormId":1245,"parentFormId":1246,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1054,"id":1054,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","childFormId":1246,"parentFormId":1247,"canonicalEdgeId":1197,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before enemy or evil spirit is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric concept.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deeper base is already proposed; no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1055,"id":1055,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","childFormId":1248,"parentFormId":1249,"canonicalEdgeId":1198,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Old Swedish fiande and fiände continue through early-modern fiende, fiände, fyende, fynde, fiend, and related spellings before modern fiende becomes standard. The record displays changing vowel notation, glide representation, endings, and orthography rather than one universal intermediate spelling.","semanticChange":"Enemy or opponent remains central. Older Devil usage becomes historical, while military collective and figurative nonhuman uses remain available in the modern noun.","scholar":"Svenska Akademiens ordboksredaktion","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"SO and SAOB publish the form sequence and semantic continuity. The dictionaries do not assign every spelling to one uniform sound change or dialect.","chronologyNote":"Old Swedish evidence from the early 1300s through early-modern and current Swedish.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1056,"id":1056,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","childFormId":1249,"parentFormId":1250,"canonicalEdgeId":1199,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Swedish fiande or fiände reflects the North Germanic continuation of the inherited nd-agent formation, with branch vowel development, glide and consonant history, inflection, and scribal spelling represented by the recorded variants.","semanticChange":"The already lexicalized one-who-hates formation functions as enemy or opponent. A Devil sense is visible inside the attested Swedish branch and is not projected back into Proto-Germanic.","scholar":"Svenska Akademiens ordboksredaktion · Elof Hellquist · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Old Swedish record and cross-Germanic comparison support inheritance. The parent is reconstructed, and the dossier does not invent a written Proto-Norse or Proto-Swedish intermediate.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the medieval Swedish written record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1057,"id":1057,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","childFormId":1250,"parentFormId":1251,"canonicalEdgeId":1147,"relationType":"lexicalized_participle","soundChange":"The present-participial nd-formation is built on the fi(j)- verb stem.","semanticChange":"One who hates lexicalizes as enemy before Gothic, while productive participial use survives beside the noun.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The derivation and pre-Gothic lexicalization are published; the exact moment and every token’s category remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic derivation and lexicalization before the Gothic branch record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1058,"id":1058,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","childFormId":1251,"parentFormId":1252,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1059,"id":1059,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","childFormId":1252,"parentFormId":1253,"canonicalEdgeId":1202,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before enemy, hater, Devil, or harm is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric concept.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deeper base is already proposed; no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1060,"id":1060,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","childFormId":1254,"parentFormId":1255,"canonicalEdgeId":1169,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old High German fīant reflects the Germanic nd-agent formation after High German branch development in its vowel, glide, consonants, and inflection.","semanticChange":"The already lexicalized one-who-hates formation is inherited as the ordinary enemy noun.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen · Wolfgang Pfeifer","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Old High German form is attested and the cross-Germanic formation is published; the exact Proto-Germanic phonetic path remains reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the eighth-century Old High German record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1061,"id":1061,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","childFormId":1255,"parentFormId":1256,"canonicalEdgeId":1147,"relationType":"lexicalized_participle","soundChange":"The present-participial nd-formation is built on the fi(j)- verb stem.","semanticChange":"One who hates lexicalizes as enemy before Gothic, while productive participial use survives beside the noun.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The derivation and pre-Gothic lexicalization are published; the exact moment and every token’s category remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic derivation and lexicalization before the Gothic branch record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1062,"id":1062,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","childFormId":1256,"parentFormId":1257,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1063,"id":1063,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","childFormId":1257,"parentFormId":1258,"canonicalEdgeId":1206,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the qualified *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the historically visible noun, its formulaic verbal residue, or the modern idea of an enemy is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric essence.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deeper base is already proposed; no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1064,"id":1064,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","childFormId":1259,"parentFormId":1260,"canonicalEdgeId":1207,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Norse fjándi and plural fjándr continue the inherited Germanic nd-agent formation after North Germanic vowel, glide, ending, and inflectional developments.","semanticChange":"The already lexicalized one-who-hates formation is inherited as an ordinary enemy noun; demonic, pagan-god, and derogatory branches develop inside the attested Old Norse semantic history.","scholar":"Richard Cleasby · Guðbrandur Vigfússon · Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Old Norse lemma, paradigm, and cross-Germanic comparison are published. The precise Proto-Germanic phonetics and each semantic innovation remain reconstructed or textually bounded.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the source-reported tenth-century poetic and later prose record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1065,"id":1065,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","childFormId":1260,"parentFormId":1261,"canonicalEdgeId":1147,"relationType":"lexicalized_participle","soundChange":"The present-participial nd-formation is built on the fi(j)- verb stem.","semanticChange":"One who hates lexicalizes as enemy before Gothic, while productive participial use survives beside the noun.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The derivation and pre-Gothic lexicalization are published; the exact moment and every token’s category remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic derivation and lexicalization before the Gothic branch record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1066,"id":1066,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","childFormId":1261,"parentFormId":1262,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1067,"id":1067,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","childFormId":1262,"parentFormId":1263,"canonicalEdgeId":1210,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the qualified *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the historically attested enemy, demon, pagan-god, Satan, or insult senses are reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric essence.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deeper base is already proposed; no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1068,"id":1068,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","childFormId":1264,"parentFormId":1265,"canonicalEdgeId":1211,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Old Danish fiende continues through competing Fiende, Fiænde, Finde, Fînde, and Fiend spellings and two- versus three-syllable realizations before modern fjende and its current pronunciations stabilize.","semanticChange":"The ordinary enemy noun remains central while wartime, ideological, animal, abstract-threat, and historical Devil branches remain contextually available.","scholar":"Den Danske Ordbogs redaktion · ODS editorial team · Aage Hansen · Sv. Eegholm-Pedersen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The linked dictionaries publish the forms, pronunciations, and sense network. They do not supply one uniquely dated sound change from every historical spelling to the modern standard.","chronologyNote":"Old Danish record through early-modern variation into current Danish.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1069,"id":1069,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","childFormId":1265,"parentFormId":1266,"canonicalEdgeId":1212,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Danish fiende continues the North Germanic reflex of the inherited fi(j)- plus nd agent formation, with branch-specific vowel, glide, ending, and inflectional developments.","semanticChange":"The already lexicalized one-who-hates formation is inherited as an ordinary enemy noun; the Devil and broader figurative branches belong to attested Danish semantic history.","scholar":"Den Danske Ordbogs redaktion · ODS editorial team · Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Old Danish fiende and the cross-Germanic derivation are published. The exact prehistoric phonetics and every semantic innovation remain reconstructed or textually bounded.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the Old Danish 1100–1300 known-since range.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1070,"id":1070,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","childFormId":1266,"parentFormId":1267,"canonicalEdgeId":1147,"relationType":"lexicalized_participle","soundChange":"The present-participial nd-formation is built on the fi(j)- verb stem.","semanticChange":"One who hates lexicalizes as enemy before Gothic, while productive participial use survives beside the noun.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The derivation and pre-Gothic lexicalization are published; the exact moment and every token’s category remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic derivation and lexicalization before the Gothic branch record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1071,"id":1071,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","childFormId":1267,"parentFormId":1268,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1072,"id":1072,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","childFormId":1268,"parentFormId":1269,"canonicalEdgeId":1215,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the qualified *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the historically attested enemy, Devil, war-opponent, animal, ideological-opponent, or figurative-threat senses are reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric essence.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deeper base is already proposed; no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1073,"id":1073,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","childFormId":1270,"parentFormId":1271,"canonicalEdgeId":1216,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old High German fīēn continues the reconstructed Germanic fi(j)- weak verb after High German branch development in its vowel, optional glide, ending, and inflectional system. The attested forms are not treated as one mechanically complete sound law.","semanticChange":"The hate or hostility verb remains visible in records meaning hate, not love, be hostile, detest, or reject; individual Latin alignments do not force one identical nuance onto every occurrence.","scholar":"Althochdeutsches Wörterbuch editorial team · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Old High German verb and its paradigm are attested through the reviewed dictionary, and the cross-Germanic comparison is published. The exact prehistoric phonetic path remains reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the eighth- and ninth-century Alemannic record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1074,"id":1074,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","childFormId":1271,"parentFormId":1272,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1075,"id":1075,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","childFormId":1272,"parentFormId":1273,"canonicalEdgeId":1218,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the qualified *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the attested hate, hostility, detestation, rejection, or not-love senses are reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric essence.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deeper base is already proposed; no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1076,"id":1076,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","childFormId":1274,"parentFormId":1275,"canonicalEdgeId":1219,"relationType":"historical_surface_development","soundChange":"The early form fía develops into fjá through North Germanic contraction and glide-vowel remodeling. The reviewed lexical sources publish the earlier and later surfaces but do not expose a dated sequence of intermediate written forms.","semanticChange":"The verb remains in the hate field; active and reflexive constructions distribute the participant structure differently without creating separate prehistoric roots.","scholar":"Geir T. Zoëga · Dictionary of Old Norse Prose editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Zoëga explicitly calls fía the early form and ONP cross-references item fía. The exact phonetic stages, chronology, and geographic spread are not directly observed.","chronologyNote":"An early Old Norse form into the normalized poetic fjá lemma; no exact transition date is asserted.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1077,"id":1077,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","childFormId":1275,"parentFormId":1276,"canonicalEdgeId":1220,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Norse fía and fjá continue the reconstructed Germanic fi(j)- verb after North Germanic vowel, glide, contraction, ending, and inflectional developments. The attested surfaces are not treated as one mechanically complete sound law.","semanticChange":"The inherited hate or hostility verb remains finite in three poetic contexts; the reflexive fiásk marks a syntactic development rather than a separate ancestral lexeme.","scholar":"Dictionary of Old Norse Prose editors · Richard Cleasby · Guðbrandur Vigfússon · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Old Norse lemma and forms are attested through reviewed dictionaries and normalized editions, and the cross-Germanic comparison is published. The exact prehistoric phonetic path remains reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the source-reported Old Norse poetic record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1078,"id":1078,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","childFormId":1276,"parentFormId":1277,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1079,"id":1079,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","childFormId":1277,"parentFormId":1278,"canonicalEdgeId":1222,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the qualified *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the poetic hate verb, reflexive construction, enemy noun, or later fiend senses are reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric essence.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deeper base is already proposed; no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1080,"id":1080,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","childFormId":1279,"parentFormId":1280,"canonicalEdgeId":1223,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Norse h continues the Germanic fricative Orel writes x, while the weak-verb stem and North Germanic inflection produce the attested hata paradigm. The reviewed sources do not expose one complete dated series of intermediate spoken forms.","semanticChange":"The inherited hostility verb is distributed across persecution, rejection, humiliation, hate, damage or destruction, participial, and reciprocal constructions. Dictionary sense order is not promoted as a chronological semantic path.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Dictionary of Old Norse Prose editors · Johan Fritzner","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The comparative family is published across Germanic branches, but reconstruction notation varies and the exact prehistoric semantic center is not recoverable.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into Old Norse prose, poetry, and a directly inspected c1200 manuscript token.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1081,"id":1081,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","childFormId":1280,"parentFormId":1281,"canonicalEdgeId":1137,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Orel groups the weak-verb reconstruction with the Germanic hate-noun base he represents as *xataz ~ *xatez; the graph crosswalks that base to its reviewed *hatiz- node.","semanticChange":"A noun family for hate or enmity supplies or associates with weak verbs whose daughter branches express hating, hostility, pursuit, and anger.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The lexical family is secure, but the exact formation of class-III hatan and the direction of any specifically Gothic remodeling remain disputed.","chronologyNote":"Related Proto-Germanic reconstructed formations rather than independently dated words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1082,"id":1082,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","childFormId":1281,"parentFormId":1282,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1083,"id":1083,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","childFormId":1282,"parentFormId":1283,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1084,"id":1084,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","childFormId":1283,"parentFormId":1284,"canonicalEdgeId":1227,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form or uniquely recoverable concrete meaning is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- proposal.","semanticChange":"The graph stops before Old Norse pursuit, contempt, humiliation, damage, or feeling is reverse-engineered into one certain prehistoric origin.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison ends inside the Germanic family; the displayed PIE route remains qualified.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1085,"id":1085,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","childFormId":1285,"parentFormId":1286,"canonicalEdgeId":1228,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Frisian h corresponds to the Germanic fricative Orel writes x. The attested weak-verb forms show spelling and inflectional variation including hatia, hatijen, hatie, hata, and hatien, but the reviewed sources do not publish one complete dated series of intermediate spoken changes.","semanticChange":"The inherited hostility verb is used across hate or rejection, damage, feud-language enemy pursuit, road obstruction, legal adversity, and theological condemnation. No dictionary sense order is promoted as a chronological semantic path.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Dietrich Hofmann · Anne Tjerk Popkema · Corpus Oudfries editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The comparative Germanic family is published, but reconstruction notation varies and one corpus homograph must be excluded from the hate lineage.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into source-reported Old Frisian legal and theological records.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1086,"id":1086,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","childFormId":1286,"parentFormId":1287,"canonicalEdgeId":1137,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Orel groups the weak-verb reconstruction with the Germanic hate-noun base he represents as *xataz ~ *xatez; the graph crosswalks that base to its reviewed *hatiz- node.","semanticChange":"A noun family for hate or enmity supplies or associates with weak verbs whose daughter branches express hating, hostility, pursuit, and anger.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The lexical family is secure, but the exact formation of class-III hatan and the direction of any specifically Gothic remodeling remain disputed.","chronologyNote":"Related Proto-Germanic reconstructed formations rather than independently dated words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1087,"id":1087,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","childFormId":1287,"parentFormId":1288,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1088,"id":1088,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","childFormId":1288,"parentFormId":1289,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1089,"id":1089,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","childFormId":1289,"parentFormId":1290,"canonicalEdgeId":1232,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form or uniquely recoverable concrete meaning is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- proposal.","semanticChange":"The graph stops before Old Frisian harm, obstruction, rejection, enemy pursuit, or theological hate is reverse-engineered into one certain prehistoric origin.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison ends inside the Germanic family; the displayed PIE route remains qualified.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1090,"id":1090,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","childFormId":1291,"parentFormId":1292,"canonicalEdgeId":1233,"relationType":"proposed_inheritance","soundChange":"Koch compares Middle Irish cais with Proto-Celtic *katsi-. The reviewed evidence does not publish a complete, dated chain of Goidelic sound changes, so no missing intermediate forms are invented.","semanticChange":"The attested Irish entry carries both love and hate readings. The reconstruction does not identify which reading is older or prove that the opposition was already present in Proto-Celtic.","scholar":"John T. Koch · Royal Irish Academy eDIL editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Celtic comparison is published, but the daughter path is incompletely exposed and the semantic direction remains unknown.","chronologyNote":"A conventional Proto-Celtic horizon is compared with source-reported medieval and early modern Irish citations.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1091,"id":1091,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","childFormId":1292,"parentFormId":1293,"canonicalEdgeId":1234,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Koch analyzes *katsi- from *kad-t/si-. The displayed consonant cluster and affricate outcome follow that published reconstruction rather than an independently observed sound record.","semanticChange":"A proposed suffixal formation is assigned to the Celtic love and hatred field; no single direction of semantic development is recovered.","scholar":"John T. Koch","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The notation and morphological segmentation are a comparative proposal.","chronologyNote":"Analytical pre-Celtic formation into proposed Proto-Celtic, not directly attested stages.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1092,"id":1092,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","childFormId":1293,"parentFormId":1294,"canonicalEdgeId":1235,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed *kad-t/si- formation is analyzed from the base *kad- with suffixal material.","semanticChange":"The wider comparison links semantically difficult fields including love, hatred, care, grief, and enmity; the graph preserves the comparison without declaring a single original meaning.","scholar":"John T. Koch · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The formal proposal is published, while the cross-branch semantic unity is disputed.","chronologyNote":"Two reconstructed analytical levels rather than independently dated lexical tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1093,"id":1093,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","childFormId":1294,"parentFormId":1295,"canonicalEdgeId":1236,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *kad- comparison.","semanticChange":"The graph stops before the attested love and hate readings are reverse-engineered into a universal prehistoric emotion or action.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · John T. Koch · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The displayed route is a published proposal, not a secure endpoint shared by all reviewed scholarship.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1094,"id":1094,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","childFormId":1296,"parentFormId":1297,"canonicalEdgeId":1237,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The consonantal stem hatiz- of hatis receives the class-II weak-verb formation represented by the citation form hatizōn and the written second-person plural hatizoþ. The long ō is an editorial phonological representation, not a separate manuscript letter.","semanticChange":"A noun for hatred, wrath, or anger supplies a verb whose one surviving context means be angry with or at someone. One token does not establish whether the verb ever carried the noun’s entire semantic range.","scholar":"Todd B. Krause · Jonathan Slocum · Joseph Wright · Wilhelm Streitberg · Project Wulfila editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Independent grammars publish the denominative class-II formation, and the corpus directly supplies one inflected token. The exact historical moment of derivation is not witnessed.","chronologyNote":"A Gothic lexical derivation represented in the fourth-century translation tradition and an early-sixth-century manuscript.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1095,"id":1095,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","childFormId":1297,"parentFormId":1298,"canonicalEdgeId":1132,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Proto-Germanic *hatiz- is represented by Gothic hatis word-finally and by the stem hatiz- before a vowel-initial ending, visible in hatiza. Gothic then regularizes the inherited i-stem into neuter a-stem inflection.","semanticChange":"The inherited anger or hostility noun becomes the Gothic translation choice for Greek wrath vocabulary. That contextual specialization does not prove the noun lacked hatred senses elsewhere.","scholar":"R. D. Fulk · John T. Koch · Project Wulfila editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Gothic forms and paradigm alternation are attested; the Proto-Germanic parent and the direction of prehistoric remodeling are comparative analyses.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the fourth-century Gothic translation tradition and surviving sixth-century manuscripts.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1096,"id":1096,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","childFormId":1298,"parentFormId":1299,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1097,"id":1097,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","childFormId":1299,"parentFormId":1300,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1098,"id":1098,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","childFormId":1300,"parentFormId":1301,"canonicalEdgeId":1241,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form or uniquely recoverable concrete meaning is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- proposal.","semanticChange":"The trail ends before the one surviving Gothic anger question is reverse-engineered into a universal origin for anger, hate, grief, care, pursuit, or persecution.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison ends at Germanic; the displayed PIE route remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1099,"id":1099,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","childFormId":1302,"parentFormId":1303,"canonicalEdgeId":1242,"relationType":"paradigm_variant","soundChange":"The quantity-normalized citation form hazzōn selects the ōn member of a source set also printed as hazōn and haʒʒōn; hazzēn, hazēn, and haʒʒēn represent the neighboring ēn member. This edge is paradigm navigation, not a claim that one written form changed directly into the combined display.","semanticChange":"The variants occupy the same reviewed hate, emulation, following, and hostile-pursuit field. The edge does not assign every gloss to every token or prove that the ēn and ōn records were interchangeable in every dialect.","scholar":"Dudenredaktion · Jacob Grimm · Starling editors · University of Texas Linguistics Research Center · Mirjam Marti Heinzle","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Independent sources print both vowel-class forms, and corpus-wide research establishes ēn / ōn double forms as an Old High German phenomenon. The accessible article abstract does not verify hazzōn among its twenty repeated examples, and no underlying token was directly inspected.","chronologyNote":"Old High German citation and source-reporting layers rather than two directly dated adjacent sound changes.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1100,"id":1100,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","childFormId":1303,"parentFormId":1304,"canonicalEdgeId":1187,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old High German haʒʒōn belongs to the comparative weak-verb set Orel reconstructs as *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan; the High German branch reflects the consonant-shifted Germanic t in the doubled sibilant spelling.","semanticChange":"The inherited Germanic hate field continues in the Old High German verb, but pursuit, hostile action, and hostile disposition remain competing candidates for the earlier semantic center.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Dudenredaktion · Jacob Grimm","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The Old High German variants and cross-Germanic set are published; the parent alternatives and semantic center are reconstructed.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the Old High German record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1101,"id":1101,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","childFormId":1304,"parentFormId":1305,"canonicalEdgeId":1137,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Orel groups the weak-verb reconstruction with the Germanic hate-noun base he represents as *xataz ~ *xatez; the graph crosswalks that base to its reviewed *hatiz- node.","semanticChange":"A noun family for hate or enmity supplies or associates with weak verbs whose daughter branches express hating, hostility, pursuit, and anger.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The lexical family is secure, but the exact formation of class-III hatan and the direction of any specifically Gothic remodeling remain disputed.","chronologyNote":"Related Proto-Germanic reconstructed formations rather than independently dated words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1102,"id":1102,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","childFormId":1305,"parentFormId":1306,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1103,"id":1103,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","childFormId":1306,"parentFormId":1307,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1104,"id":1104,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","childFormId":1307,"parentFormId":1308,"canonicalEdgeId":1247,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the already disputed *ḱeh₂d- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail stops before pursuit, persecution, feeling, grief, pain, care, or hatred is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric act.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman · Jacob Grimm","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison is strongest inside Germanic; the displayed Indo-European lane remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1105,"id":1105,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","childFormId":1309,"parentFormId":1310,"canonicalEdgeId":1248,"relationType":"paradigm_variant","soundChange":"The normalized lemma fīunt selects the headword used by ONW from a historical aggregate also represented as fīant in EWN. The exact corpus inventory includes fiunt-, fiund-, uiand-, uiend-, and viann- surface forms; this edge is lemma and paradigm navigation, not one sound change between two written tokens.","semanticChange":"The records remain inside the enemy or opponent noun, with one separately disputed Devil gloss. No surface variant is assigned every sense.","scholar":"Instituut voor de Nederlandse Taal editorial team · Marlies Philippa · Frans Debrabandere · Arend Quak","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The official historical dictionary publishes the lemma, frequency table, and surface forms; EWN supplies the wider historical display. The combined node is editorial aggregation rather than one token.","chronologyNote":"Old Dutch headword normalization over records linguistically dated 901–1200.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1106,"id":1106,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","childFormId":1310,"parentFormId":1311,"canonicalEdgeId":1194,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Dutch fīunt or fīant reflects the Germanic nd-agent formation after West Germanic and Dutch-branch vowel, glide, consonant, and inflectional development.","semanticChange":"The already lexicalized one-who-hates formation is inherited as the ordinary enemy noun; Christian Devil usage develops inside the attested daughter record rather than inside the reconstruction.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen · Marlies Philippa · Arend Quak · ONW editorial team","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The daughter forms and participial analysis are independently published. The parent remains reconstructed and no written Proto-Germanic token exists.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into Old Dutch textual evidence.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1107,"id":1107,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","childFormId":1311,"parentFormId":1312,"canonicalEdgeId":1147,"relationType":"lexicalized_participle","soundChange":"The present-participial nd-formation is built on the fi(j)- verb stem.","semanticChange":"One who hates lexicalizes as enemy before Gothic, while productive participial use survives beside the noun.","scholar":"Daniel Ayora Estevan · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The derivation and pre-Gothic lexicalization are published; the exact moment and every token’s category remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic derivation and lexicalization before the Gothic branch record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1108,"id":1108,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","childFormId":1312,"parentFormId":1313,"canonicalEdgeId":1143,"relationType":"competing_comparative_derivation","soundChange":"The proposed analysis connects the Germanic fi(j)- verb to a laryngeal-bearing Indo-European base through prehistoric present-stem remodeling; intermediate formal analyses vary and are not presented as written stages.","semanticChange":"A proposed harm, blame, suffering, or hostility field develops toward the Germanic verb hate, but the original semantic center is not uniquely recoverable.","scholar":"Guus Kroonen","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The Proto-Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed PIE route. The exact intermediate reconstruction and semantic unity remain analytical proposals.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Proto-Indo-European base to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1109,"id":1109,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","childFormId":1313,"parentFormId":1314,"canonicalEdgeId":1252,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *peh₁- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail stops before the fossilized noun, the lost Dutch verb, or the modern category enemy is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric essence.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Guus Kroonen","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deepest displayed base is already proposed; no earlier node is treated as secure.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1110,"id":1110,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","childFormId":1315,"parentFormId":1316,"canonicalEdgeId":1253,"relationType":"orthographic_variant","soundChange":"The normalized lemma hatōn abstracts over written infinitive hatan in Munich manuscript M and haton in manuscript C. The macron and final-vowel normalization are editorial analyses; this edge does not claim that one token changed directly into the other.","semanticChange":"No meaning change is assigned. Both infinitive readings belong to the same reviewed hate verb, while their object dates and manuscript identities remain separate.","scholar":"Gerhard Köbler · University of Texas Linguistics Research Center · SET-U manuscript review","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"Köbler explicitly prints hatōn as the entry and hatan or haton as the Heliand 1451 manuscript readings. The Munich hatan pixels were directly inspected.","chronologyNote":"Normalized dictionary lemma over ninth- and tenth-century written evidence.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1111,"id":1111,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","childFormId":1316,"parentFormId":1317,"canonicalEdgeId":1254,"relationType":"competing_inheritance","soundChange":"Old Saxon h continues the Germanic fricative represented by Orel as x, while the attested ō-class paradigm is compared with reconstructed weak-verb alternatives. Orel prints *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan; Köbler prints *hatōn.","semanticChange":"The inherited Germanic hostility verb continues as Old Saxon hate or, in lexicographic description, pursue. The evidence does not establish pursuit as the one earlier or original meaning.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Gerhard Köbler · University of Texas Linguistics Research Center","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The branch lexeme and cross-Germanic family are secure, but reconstruction notation, weak-verb subclass history, and the semantic center vary by source.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the Old Saxon Heliand and gloss record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1112,"id":1112,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","childFormId":1317,"parentFormId":1318,"canonicalEdgeId":1137,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"Orel groups the weak-verb reconstruction with the Germanic hate-noun base he represents as *xataz ~ *xatez; the graph crosswalks that base to its reviewed *hatiz- node.","semanticChange":"A noun family for hate or enmity supplies or associates with weak verbs whose daughter branches express hating, hostility, pursuit, and anger.","scholar":"Vladimir Orel · Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The lexical family is secure, but the exact formation of class-III hatan and the direction of any specifically Gothic remodeling remain disputed.","chronologyNote":"Related Proto-Germanic reconstructed formations rather than independently dated words.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1113,"id":1113,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","childFormId":1318,"parentFormId":1319,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1114,"id":1114,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","childFormId":1319,"parentFormId":1320,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1115,"id":1115,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","childFormId":1320,"parentFormId":1321,"canonicalEdgeId":1258,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail stops before hate, pursuit, hater, enemy, grief, care, or pain is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric act or feeling.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison is strongest inside Germanic; the displayed Indo-European lane remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1116,"id":1116,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","childFormId":1322,"parentFormId":1323,"canonicalEdgeId":1259,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Saxon heti is directly compared with the reconstructed Germanic noun represented here as *hatiz-. The inherited h-t frame and i-stem comparison are published; no unattested West Germanic intermediate or falsely precise sound-change date is inserted.","semanticChange":"The Germanic hate, anger, enmity, and hostility field continues in an Old Saxon noun whose located contexts include endured persecution or hostile speech and confessed hostility. No one daughter context is promoted as the original meaning.","scholar":"R. D. Fulk · Gerhard Köbler · Wolfgang Pfeifer · Linguistics Research Center editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The inherited family is secure, while Fulk and Köbler use an i-stem analysis and Pfeifer calls the wider noun an old es/os-stem. The exact reconstructed morphology is therefore not singular.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into ninth- and tenth-century Old Saxon textual and manuscript evidence.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1117,"id":1117,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","childFormId":1323,"parentFormId":1324,"canonicalEdgeId":1088,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, Grimm’s Law maps Indo-European *ḱ to Germanic h and *d to Germanic t, while the suffixal formation is remodeled as the Germanic i-stem.","semanticChange":"A proposed grief, pain, care, or hatred formation narrows or develops into the Germanic hate and enmity family.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Merriam-Webster says “perhaps” and calls the semantic relations far from transparent; Liberman argues that several proposed non-Germanic cognates may not belong together.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Indo-European proposal to Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1118,"id":1118,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","childFormId":1324,"parentFormId":1325,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1119,"id":1119,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","childFormId":1325,"parentFormId":1326,"canonicalEdgeId":1262,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail stops before hate, persecution, hostile speech, confession, grief, care, pain, anger, or battle is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric essence.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"Secure comparison is strongest inside Germanic; the displayed Indo-European lane remains qualified and semantically unresolved.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1120,"id":1120,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","childFormId":1327,"parentFormId":1328,"canonicalEdgeId":1263,"relationType":"competing_inheritance","soundChange":"Under Köbler's analysis, the normalized Old Saxon h-ō-t-i frame continues a Germanic *hw-ō-t-j- adjective. The five written Old Saxon surfaces vary between ho- and huo- and across inflectional endings; the edge does not assign one exact phonetic date to those spellings.","semanticChange":"A reconstructed hostile or threatening adjective continues in Heliand contexts of hostile minds and hostile intent. The branch evidence does not prove that sharpened or incited was the adjective's consciously felt meaning.","scholar":"Gerhard Köbler","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Köbler explicitly publishes the reconstruction, but UT assigns the same Old Saxon adjective to the hate family instead.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the ninth- and tenth-century Heliand witness record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1121,"id":1121,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","childFormId":1328,"parentFormId":1329,"canonicalEdgeId":1264,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The adjective in *-ja- is compared with the long-vowel Germanic noun *hwōtō. The located entry does not independently settle whether the adjective derives from the noun, the noun from a related verb, or both from a shared base.","semanticChange":"The compared noun means threat while the adjective means hostile or enraged. The graph preserves the semantic proximity without converting it into one documented derivational event.","scholar":"Gerhard Köbler","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"Köbler prints “compare Germanic *hwōtō” rather than a fully argued direction of derivation.","chronologyNote":"Related Proto-Germanic reconstructed formations.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1122,"id":1122,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","childFormId":1329,"parentFormId":1330,"canonicalEdgeId":1265,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"Köbler compares the Germanic hwōt- formation with Pokorny's labiovelar *kʷē̆d- / *kʷō̆d- complex; the UT page independently displays reflexes with Germanic hw- and meanings sharpen, whet, and incite.","semanticChange":"A physical field of boring, pricking, or stabbing develops in Germanic comparanda toward sharpness, whetting, incitement, and threat. The exact path to the Old Saxon hostile adjective remains proposed.","scholar":"Gerhard Köbler · Linguistics Research Center editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The deep etymon and Germanic reflex field are published independently, but the specific *hwōtō link is supplied by Köbler and is not listed on UT's reflex page.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Indo-European comparison into Proto-Germanic reconstructed formations.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1123,"id":1123,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","childFormId":1330,"parentFormId":1331,"canonicalEdgeId":1266,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the *kʷē̆d- / *kʷō̆d- comparison.","semanticChange":"The trail stops before boring, pricking, whetting, inciting, threatening, and hostility are compressed into one recoverable prehistoric scene.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Linguistics Research Center editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The displayed etymon is already reconstructed, and the UT database warns that its reflex pages remain under active construction.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1124,"id":1124,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","childFormId":1332,"parentFormId":1333,"canonicalEdgeId":1268,"relationType":"proposed_inheritance","soundChange":"Under the proposed comparison, the palatal stop is represented by Greek k, while the long-vowel pattern appears as Ionic-Attic η beside Doric ā in κᾶδος. The exact Proto-Hellenic sequence and every laryngeal or suffixal step are reconstructed rather than attested.","semanticChange":"The Greek care, anxiety, grief, mourning, and funeral field is compared with a wider formation that also contains hostility and hatred words. The edge does not make every branch sense descend from one recoverable emotional scene.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors · John T. Koch · Linguistics Research Center editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The formal comparison is published across multiple sources, but Merriam-Webster calls the semantic relations far from transparent and Liberman challenges the wider family's unity.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Indo-European formation into the attested Greek record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1125,"id":1125,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","childFormId":1333,"parentFormId":1334,"canonicalEdgeId":1089,"relationType":"derivation","soundChange":"The proposed zero-grade or reduced root formation *ḱh₂d-es- is analyzed from the full-grade base *ḱeh₂d- with suffixation.","semanticChange":"The source groups grief, pain, care, mourning, and hatred meanings, but no single original semantic path is promoted.","scholar":"Merriam-Webster Editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The formal analysis is published, while the semantic unity remains expressly difficult.","chronologyNote":"Two analytical reconstructed levels, not independently attested spoken tokens.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1126,"id":1126,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","childFormId":1334,"parentFormId":1335,"canonicalEdgeId":1270,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the disputed *ḱeh₂d- comparison.","semanticChange":"The graph stops before care, grief, funeral obligation, marriage kinship, hostile pursuit, and hate are collapsed into a just-so story.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · Anatoly Liberman","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The securely attested Greek record does not establish one uncontested deeper family or original scene.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1127,"id":1127,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","childFormId":1336,"parentFormId":1337,"canonicalEdgeId":1273,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle English friend and related spellings continue into the modern standard while vowel quantity, vowel quality, and spelling conventions converge on /frɛnd/. No one spelling date is treated as a single sound-change event.","semanticChange":"The companion, ally, supporter, relation, and address senses continue; later specialized uses, including a social-network contact, expand the noun without replacing its historical range.","scholar":"Oxford English Dictionary editors · Middle English Dictionary editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"OED and MED directly document the spelling continuum and overlapping senses. The precise diffusion of modern pronunciation across regions is not reduced to one date.","chronologyNote":"Middle English forms into early modern and current English.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1128,"id":1128,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","childFormId":1337,"parentFormId":1338,"canonicalEdgeId":1274,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"OED describes late Old English incipient monophthongization of ēo and Middle English coexistence of long close ē, short ĕ, and short ĭ. MED directly derives frẹ̄nd and its variants from Old English frēond and its inflected forms.","semanticChange":"The inherited friend, ally, and relation noun remains lexically stable enough to recognize while its contextual and address uses diversify.","scholar":"Oxford English Dictionary editors · Middle English Dictionary editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The lexical descent is explicit. Surviving spelling variation prevents one mechanically uniform phonetic path.","chronologyNote":"Old English into the conventionally dated Middle English record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1129,"id":1129,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","childFormId":1338,"parentFormId":1339,"canonicalEdgeId":1275,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"OED derives the West Germanic stem vowel from *iu, produced by contraction of the base vowel *ī, earlier *ij, with the participial suffix vowel; Old English ēo and īo reflect branch and dialect development.","semanticChange":"An inherited present-participial agent formation functions as the ordinary noun friend, relation, or favored person in Old English.","scholar":"Oxford English Dictionary editors · American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The cross-Germanic set and participial morphology are published, but *frijōnd- is reconstructed and the exact prehistoric phonetic sequence was never written down.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into Old English textual evidence.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1130,"id":1130,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","childFormId":1339,"parentFormId":1340,"canonicalEdgeId":1276,"relationType":"participial_derivation","soundChange":"The agent noun is built with Germanic present-participial nd-morphology on the *frī- or earlier *frij- base. OED traces the later *iu diphthong to contraction with the suffixal vowel.","semanticChange":"A productive loving or favorably disposed participant becomes a lexical noun for friend or relation. The derivation does not make every later friend literally a person performing a continuous act of loving.","scholar":"Oxford English Dictionary editors · Bosworth · Toller · American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Three independent dictionary treatments identify the participial relation. The exact lexicalization date and every prehistoric inflection remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Germanic derivation before the daughter-language records.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1131,"id":1131,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","childFormId":1340,"parentFormId":1341,"canonicalEdgeId":1277,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"American Heritage compares Germanic *frī- with Indo-European *prī-. The initial Germanic f corresponds to the older labial stop under the comparative analysis; the exact intermediate morphology is not promoted as attested.","semanticChange":"The reconstructed like, love, or friendliness field is compared across Indo-European, but no one original institution of friendship or freedom is recovered.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The source publishes the root cross-reference, while the accessible record does not establish one directly attested proto-form, sentence, or social structure.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Indo-European base to Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1132,"id":1132,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","childFormId":1341,"parentFormId":1342,"canonicalEdgeId":1278,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *prī- comparison.","semanticChange":"The graph stops before friendship, love, freedom, peace, kinship, or group membership is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric story.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deepest displayed form is already reconstructed; no securely reviewed earlier node clears the evidence boundary.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1133,"id":1133,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","childFormId":1343,"parentFormId":1344,"canonicalEdgeId":1279,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle High German initial v in the written tradition gives way to modern F; the historical vowel and glide develop into the modern /ɔʏ̯/ diphthong, while final obstruent devoicing yields /t/ in the citation form. Capitalization standardizes with the German noun.","semanticChange":"Friend, relative, lover, ally, and supporter senses continue with different weights; the modern lexical category is not reduced to an active participle.","scholar":"Wolfgang Pfeifer · Dudenredaktion · Jacob Grimm","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"All three German sources publish the direct Middle High German continuation. The description does not assign every regional sound or spelling change to one date.","chronologyNote":"Middle High German through Early New High German into the modern written standard.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1134,"id":1134,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","childFormId":1344,"parentFormId":1345,"canonicalEdgeId":1280,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Old High German friunt continues as Middle High German vriunt with High German orthographic and phonological development; historical f and v spellings do not mark a new lexical root.","semanticChange":"The inherited friend and relation noun expands across neighbor, lover, trusted companion, and social ally uses.","scholar":"Wolfgang Pfeifer · Jacob Grimm","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"DWDS/Pfeifer and Grimm explicitly give Old High German friunt followed by Middle High German vriunt.","chronologyNote":"Old High German into the Middle High German textual record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1135,"id":1135,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","childFormId":1345,"parentFormId":1346,"canonicalEdgeId":1281,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old High German friunt reflects the inherited Germanic participial stem represented as *frijōnd-. The exact pre-High-German vowel sequence and full paradigm are reconstructed from the cognate set.","semanticChange":"An inherited loving or favorably disposed participant is already lexicalized as an ordinary friend or relation noun in the recorded High German branch.","scholar":"Wolfgang Pfeifer · Jacob Grimm","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The daughter-language forms and participial analysis are explicit, but the parent form was not written and no exact lexicalization event survives.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the eighth-century Old High German record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1136,"id":1136,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","childFormId":1346,"parentFormId":1347,"canonicalEdgeId":1276,"relationType":"participial_derivation","soundChange":"The agent noun is built with Germanic present-participial nd-morphology on the *frī- or earlier *frij- base. OED traces the later *iu diphthong to contraction with the suffixal vowel.","semanticChange":"A productive loving or favorably disposed participant becomes a lexical noun for friend or relation. The derivation does not make every later friend literally a person performing a continuous act of loving.","scholar":"Oxford English Dictionary editors · Bosworth · Toller · American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Three independent dictionary treatments identify the participial relation. The exact lexicalization date and every prehistoric inflection remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Germanic derivation before the daughter-language records.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1137,"id":1137,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","childFormId":1347,"parentFormId":1348,"canonicalEdgeId":1277,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"American Heritage compares Germanic *frī- with Indo-European *prī-. The initial Germanic f corresponds to the older labial stop under the comparative analysis; the exact intermediate morphology is not promoted as attested.","semanticChange":"The reconstructed like, love, or friendliness field is compared across Indo-European, but no one original institution of friendship or freedom is recovered.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The source publishes the root cross-reference, while the accessible record does not establish one directly attested proto-form, sentence, or social structure.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Indo-European base to Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1138,"id":1138,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","childFormId":1348,"parentFormId":1349,"canonicalEdgeId":1284,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *prī- comparison.","semanticChange":"The graph stops before one prehistoric essence is reverse-engineered from love, kinship, freedom, peace, or friendship.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deepest displayed form is reconstructed and proposed; no reviewed earlier node clears the evidence boundary.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1139,"id":1139,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","childFormId":1350,"parentFormId":1351,"canonicalEdgeId":1285,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Middle Dutch vrient and its reduced variants continue into modern vriend. The current spelling retains ie while standard pronunciation is one syllable /vrint/; WNT discusses vrind as reduction and vriend as potentially etymologizing spelling.","semanticChange":"The ordinary friend sense continues while historical relation, lover, ally, patron, mediator, and supporter uses remain separately documented.","scholar":"EWN editors · WNT editors · MNW editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"The dictionaries directly publish the Middle-to-modern continuation and variants. The exact social diffusion of each spelling is not collapsed into one event.","chronologyNote":"Middle Dutch into New Dutch and the current standard.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1140,"id":1140,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","childFormId":1351,"parentFormId":1352,"canonicalEdgeId":1286,"relationType":"historical_continuation","soundChange":"Old Dutch friunt continues into Middle Dutch vrient and variants vreent, vrint, and vrunt through West Germanic and Dutch sound and spelling development.","semanticChange":"The inherited friend or favored-person noun persists while recorded ally, relation, lover, and address uses diversify.","scholar":"EWN editors · MNW editors · WNT editors","confidence":"established","confidenceNote":"EWN supplies the Old and Middle Dutch records; MNW and WNT independently inventory the later forms.","chronologyNote":"Old Dutch around 1100 into the early Middle Dutch record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1141,"id":1141,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","childFormId":1352,"parentFormId":1353,"canonicalEdgeId":1287,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Dutch friunt reflects reconstructed *frijōnd-, with daughter-language vowel and participial-stem evidence supporting the comparison rather than one preserved proto-spelling.","semanticChange":"An inherited loving or favorably disposed participant is lexicalized as the noun friend before the surviving Old Dutch record.","scholar":"EWN editors · WNT editors · MNW editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"EWN explicitly prints the reconstruction and all three dictionaries identify the participial origin; the parent form itself is unattested.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the Old Dutch record around 1100.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1142,"id":1142,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","childFormId":1353,"parentFormId":1354,"canonicalEdgeId":1276,"relationType":"participial_derivation","soundChange":"The agent noun is built with Germanic present-participial nd-morphology on the *frī- or earlier *frij- base. OED traces the later *iu diphthong to contraction with the suffixal vowel.","semanticChange":"A productive loving or favorably disposed participant becomes a lexical noun for friend or relation. The derivation does not make every later friend literally a person performing a continuous act of loving.","scholar":"Oxford English Dictionary editors · Bosworth · Toller · American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Three independent dictionary treatments identify the participial relation. The exact lexicalization date and every prehistoric inflection remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Germanic derivation before the daughter-language records.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1143,"id":1143,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","childFormId":1354,"parentFormId":1355,"canonicalEdgeId":1277,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"American Heritage compares Germanic *frī- with Indo-European *prī-. The initial Germanic f corresponds to the older labial stop under the comparative analysis; the exact intermediate morphology is not promoted as attested.","semanticChange":"The reconstructed like, love, or friendliness field is compared across Indo-European, but no one original institution of friendship or freedom is recovered.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The source publishes the root cross-reference, while the accessible record does not establish one directly attested proto-form, sentence, or social structure.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Indo-European base to Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1144,"id":1144,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","childFormId":1355,"parentFormId":1356,"canonicalEdgeId":1290,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *prī- comparison.","semanticChange":"The route stops before De Vries or Weijnen ritual-kinship proposals, freedom, love, or friendship are declared the unique prehistoric origin.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"No reviewed earlier node clears the evidence boundary.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1145,"id":1145,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","childFormId":1357,"parentFormId":1358,"canonicalEdgeId":1291,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"Old Norse frændi reflects the inherited Germanic nd-participial stem represented as *frijōnd-. North Germanic vowel development and contraction produce the normalized long front vowel represented by fræ- or editorial frǽ-, while the exact prehistoric sequence remains reconstructed.","semanticChange":"The inherited loving or favorably disposed participant lexicalizes in the Scandinavian branch with kinship as its recorded center, while friend and companion uses remain visible. Cognacy therefore survives alongside semantic divergence.","scholar":"Oxford English Dictionary editors · Richard Cleasby · Guðbrandur Vigfússon · Johan Fritzner · Dictionary of Old Norse Prose editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The cognate set, participial analysis, attested lemma, and semantic distribution are published. The parent form, exact contraction sequence, and moment when kinship became central were not directly recorded.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into the Old Norse poetic and prose record.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1146,"id":1146,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","childFormId":1358,"parentFormId":1359,"canonicalEdgeId":1276,"relationType":"participial_derivation","soundChange":"The agent noun is built with Germanic present-participial nd-morphology on the *frī- or earlier *frij- base. OED traces the later *iu diphthong to contraction with the suffixal vowel.","semanticChange":"A productive loving or favorably disposed participant becomes a lexical noun for friend or relation. The derivation does not make every later friend literally a person performing a continuous act of loving.","scholar":"Oxford English Dictionary editors · Bosworth · Toller · American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Three independent dictionary treatments identify the participial relation. The exact lexicalization date and every prehistoric inflection remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Germanic derivation before the daughter-language records.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1147,"id":1147,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","childFormId":1359,"parentFormId":1360,"canonicalEdgeId":1277,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"American Heritage compares Germanic *frī- with Indo-European *prī-. The initial Germanic f corresponds to the older labial stop under the comparative analysis; the exact intermediate morphology is not promoted as attested.","semanticChange":"The reconstructed like, love, or friendliness field is compared across Indo-European, but no one original institution of friendship or freedom is recovered.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The source publishes the root cross-reference, while the accessible record does not establish one directly attested proto-form, sentence, or social structure.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Indo-European base to Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1148,"id":1148,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","childFormId":1360,"parentFormId":1361,"canonicalEdgeId":1294,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *prī- comparison.","semanticChange":"The graph stops before friendship, kinship, love, freedom, alliance, or ritual brotherhood is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric story.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deepest displayed form is already reconstructed and proposed; no reviewed earlier node clears the evidence boundary.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1149,"id":1149,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","childFormId":1362,"parentFormId":1363,"canonicalEdgeId":1275,"relationType":"inheritance","soundChange":"OED derives the West Germanic stem vowel from *iu, produced by contraction of the base vowel *ī, earlier *ij, with the participial suffix vowel; Old English ēo and īo reflect branch and dialect development.","semanticChange":"An inherited present-participial agent formation functions as the ordinary noun friend, relation, or favored person in Old English.","scholar":"Oxford English Dictionary editors · American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"The cross-Germanic set and participial morphology are published, but *frijōnd- is reconstructed and the exact prehistoric phonetic sequence was never written down.","chronologyNote":"Proto-Germanic reconstruction into Old English textual evidence.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1150,"id":1150,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","childFormId":1363,"parentFormId":1364,"canonicalEdgeId":1276,"relationType":"participial_derivation","soundChange":"The agent noun is built with Germanic present-participial nd-morphology on the *frī- or earlier *frij- base. OED traces the later *iu diphthong to contraction with the suffixal vowel.","semanticChange":"A productive loving or favorably disposed participant becomes a lexical noun for friend or relation. The derivation does not make every later friend literally a person performing a continuous act of loving.","scholar":"Oxford English Dictionary editors · Bosworth · Toller · American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"probable","confidenceNote":"Three independent dictionary treatments identify the participial relation. The exact lexicalization date and every prehistoric inflection remain unrecoverable.","chronologyNote":"Germanic derivation before the daughter-language records.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1151,"id":1151,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","childFormId":1364,"parentFormId":1365,"canonicalEdgeId":1277,"relationType":"comparative_derivation","soundChange":"American Heritage compares Germanic *frī- with Indo-European *prī-. The initial Germanic f corresponds to the older labial stop under the comparative analysis; the exact intermediate morphology is not promoted as attested.","semanticChange":"The reconstructed like, love, or friendliness field is compared across Indo-European, but no one original institution of friendship or freedom is recovered.","scholar":"American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"proposed","confidenceNote":"The source publishes the root cross-reference, while the accessible record does not establish one directly attested proto-form, sentence, or social structure.","chronologyNote":"Proposed Indo-European base to Germanic reconstruction.","editorialStatus":"reviewed"},{"cursor":1152,"id":1152,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","childFormId":1365,"parentFormId":1366,"canonicalEdgeId":1298,"relationType":"knowledge_boundary","soundChange":"No older form is promoted beyond the proposed *prī- comparison.","semanticChange":"The graph stops before the Old English social range is reverse-engineered into one universal prehistoric institution of love, freedom, friendship, kinship, or alliance.","scholar":"SET-U editorial boundary · American Heritage Dictionary editors","confidence":"boundary","confidenceNote":"The deepest displayed form is already reconstructed and proposed; no reviewed earlier node clears the evidence boundary.","chronologyNote":null,"editorialStatus":"reviewed"}]}
