{"schemaVersion":"2026-08-28.107","dataset":"disputes","description":"Competing or unresolved scholarly analyses preserved without false convergence, with permanent audit URLs.","totalRows":865,"license":null,"licenseNote":"Reuse terms for SET-U editorial data are not yet declared. Source works retain their own rights.","data":[{"cursor":1,"id":1,"entryId":1,"entrySlug":"love","title":"How wide was the PIE meaning?","position":"“Love” is a convenient gloss, but daughter languages point to a field including desire, pleasure, approval, and care.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Mallory & Adams; Pokorny data","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/1","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/love"},{"cursor":2,"id":2,"entryId":1,"entrySlug":"love","title":"One word for one feeling?","position":"Proto-Indo-European did not preserve a single lexeme matching the entire modern English category LOVE.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Comparative lexical evidence","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph uses a semantic field rather than a one-word equivalence.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/2","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/love"},{"cursor":3,"id":3,"entryId":2,"entrySlug":"etymology","title":"Is *set-u- certain?","position":"No. It is a serious published reconstruction, but the exact morphology and wider family are analyzed differently by scholars.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Beekes 2010; de Lamberterie; Etygram dossier","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/3","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymology"},{"cursor":4,"id":4,"entryId":2,"entrySlug":"etymology","title":"Did etymology originally mean modern science?","position":"No. Ancient etymology pursued a word’s “true sense”; the modern comparative discipline developed much later.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"History of linguistics","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/4","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymology"},{"cursor":5,"id":5,"entryId":3,"entrySlug":"salary","title":"Were soldiers paid in salt?","position":"No ancient source supports the familiar claim. Pliny notes only an undefined connection between salt and military honors or payments.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster etymology note; Pliny, Natural History 31.89","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The viral payment-in-salt story is excluded.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/5","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/salary"},{"cursor":6,"id":6,"entryId":3,"entrySlug":"salary","title":"What was the original salt connection?","position":"Unknown. A salt allowance, purchase money, and euphemistic honorarium have all been proposed without decisive evidence.","confidence":"speculative","sourceSummary":"Historical lexicography","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/6","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/salary"},{"cursor":7,"id":7,"entryId":4,"entrySlug":"sincere","title":"sine cera — “without wax”","position":"Rejected. The phonology, morphology, and documentary record do not support it.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Oxford English Dictionary","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Excluded as a folk etymology.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/7","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/sincere"},{"cursor":8,"id":8,"entryId":4,"entrySlug":"sincere","title":"A secure alternative","position":"Not yet. The Latin word is clear, but its formation has attracted competing proposals.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Latin etymological dictionaries","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/8","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/sincere"},{"cursor":9,"id":9,"entryId":5,"entrySlug":"clue","title":"Is clue borrowed from Greek?","position":"No. Greek myth influenced the English word’s meaning; the word itself is inherited from Old English.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"OED historical senses","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Model as semantic influence, not lexical borrowing.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/9","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/clue"},{"cursor":10,"id":10,"entryId":6,"entrySlug":"disaster","title":"Is the “bad star” composition real?","position":"Yes. Italian disastro is analyzed as a negative prefix plus astro “star,” reflecting an astrological frame for misfortune.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster, Disaster — Word History","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Represented as morphology and semantic history, not as modern causal science.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/10","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/disaster"},{"cursor":11,"id":11,"entryId":6,"entrySlug":"disaster","title":"Exactly which Romance language handed the word to English?","position":"French and Italian stages are both central in reference accounts; a single linear donor route can overstate the surviving evidence.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and Romance historical lexicography","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/11","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/disaster"},{"cursor":12,"id":12,"entryId":7,"entrySlug":"candidate","title":"Did candidates claim moral purity?","position":"The whitened toga is historical and lexical. Reading it as a guaranteed moral-purity claim goes beyond what the word formation alone proves.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Corpus of Latin Dictionaries; CNRTL","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/12","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/candidate"},{"cursor":13,"id":13,"entryId":7,"entrySlug":"candidate","title":"Is *kand- a secure endpoint?","position":"No. The Latin candēre family is attested, but its deeper reconstructed root and cognate set remain analysis-dependent.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Latin and Indo-European etymological dictionaries","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/13","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/candidate"},{"cursor":14,"id":14,"entryId":8,"entrySlug":"quarantine","title":"Was the first quarantine forty days?","position":"No. Dubrovnik’s 1377 law required thirty days; the interval was later extended to forty, which supplied the enduring name.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Oxford BioScience; CDC historical accounts","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The timeline explicitly separates the first isolation law from the forty-based word.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/14","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/quarantine"},{"cursor":15,"id":15,"entryId":8,"entrySlug":"quarantine","title":"Why forty?","position":"Religious symbolism, inherited medical theory, logistics, and observation have all been proposed; no single motivation is treated as proven here.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"CDC and historical scholarship","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/15","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/quarantine"},{"cursor":16,"id":16,"entryId":9,"entrySlug":"logic","title":"Is the deepest root *leǵ- or *sleǵ-?","position":"The traditional *leǵ- reconstruction remains widely represented, while published scholarship argues that the gather/collect root began with *s. The graph preserves both analyses.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"UT Austin LRC; IE-CoR; Kaczyńska 2013","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/16","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/logic"},{"cursor":17,"id":17,"entryId":9,"entrySlug":"logic","title":"Does λόγος simply mean “logic”?","position":"No. λόγος ranges across account, reckoning, explanation, speech, discourse, word, and reason; “logic” is one specialized descendant.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Logeion: λόγος; Merriam-Webster","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The node keeps a semantic field rather than a one-word gloss.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/17","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/logic"},{"cursor":18,"id":18,"entryId":9,"entrySlug":"logic","title":"Did “gather” straightforwardly become “speak”?","position":"The collect/say comparison is old and substantial, but a neat story about “gathering words” exceeds what the comparative forms alone can prove.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Comparative Greek and Indo-European lexicography","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/18","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/logic"},{"cursor":19,"id":19,"entryId":10,"entrySlug":"legal","title":"Is legal descended from English law?","position":"No. legal is borrowed through Anglo-French from Latin lēgālis and lēx; English law has a separate Germanic and Scandinavian ancestry.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster: legal; Merriam-Webster: law","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph models semantic neighbors separately from historical ancestors.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/19","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/legal"},{"cursor":20,"id":20,"entryId":10,"entrySlug":"legal","title":"Did Latin lēx originally mean a “collection of rules”?","position":"That semantic bridge and the deeper gather-root connection are plausible published analyses, not an uncontested fact. The root shape *leǵ- versus *sleǵ- is also disputed.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Logeion: lex; Kaczyńska 2013; Indo-European lexicography","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/20","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/legal"},{"cursor":21,"id":21,"entryId":11,"entrySlug":"lecture","title":"Was a lecture originally spoken?","position":"The immediate Latin ancestor lectūra meant an act of reading. The instructional spoken discourse is a later semantic development.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster: lecture","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/21","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/lecture"},{"cursor":22,"id":22,"entryId":11,"entrySlug":"lecture","title":"Does the root prove that reading is “gathering letters”?","position":"No. Latin legere covers gathering, selecting, and reading, but the precise semantic steps cannot be recovered from a slogan alone.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Latin and Indo-European lexicography","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/22","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/lecture"},{"cursor":23,"id":23,"entryId":12,"entrySlug":"legend","title":"Did legend originally mean a false story?","position":"No. Medieval Latin legenda meant things to be read. The uncertainty or fictionality of a traditional story is a later development.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster: legend","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/23","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/legend"},{"cursor":24,"id":24,"entryId":12,"entrySlug":"legend","title":"Why did appointed readings become unverifiable stories?","position":"Association with saints’ lives and inherited narratives supplies the historical environment, but the semantic expansion was gradual rather than one datable pivot.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Historical lexicography","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/24","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/legend"},{"cursor":25,"id":25,"entryId":13,"entrySlug":"intelligence","title":"Does intelligence literally mean “choosing between”?","position":"The Latin form is traditionally analyzed through inter- and legere, and selection or discernment informs the semantic history. A literal gloss is not a complete account of cognition.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster: intelligent; Logeion: intellegō","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/25","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/intelligence"},{"cursor":26,"id":26,"entryId":13,"entrySlug":"intelligence","title":"How did intelligence become secret information?","position":"The word already meant understanding and knowledge; news and strategic information developed from that information sense, later naming the services that gather it.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster historical senses","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/26","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/intelligence"},{"cursor":27,"id":27,"entryId":14,"entrySlug":"collect","title":"Are the prayer and gathering senses identical histories?","position":"They converge on Latin collēctus / colligere, but the prayer noun may refer specifically to a congregation’s gathering place; the immediate motivation is qualified as “perhaps.”","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster: collect","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/27","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/collect"},{"cursor":28,"id":28,"entryId":14,"entrySlug":"collect","title":"Is collect really com- plus legere?","position":"Yes. Latin colligere contains the assimilated together-prefix com- / col- and legere “gather, select.”","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster: collect; Logeion: colligō","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/28","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/collect"},{"cursor":29,"id":29,"entryId":15,"entrySlug":"algorithm","title":"Is algorithm originally a Greek mathematical word?","position":"No. The lexical line reaches the Arabic name al-Khwārizmī through Medieval Latin. Greek arithmos likely influenced the later spelling, but it is not the source of the name.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster: algorithm and algorism; MacTutor ALGORITHM entry","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph separates ancestry from later spelling influence.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/29","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/algorithm"},{"cursor":30,"id":30,"entryId":15,"entrySlug":"algorithm","title":"Does the word commemorate an abstract concept or a person?","position":"It ultimately reflects a geographic personal name, “the Khwārizmian,” which became attached to transmitted arithmetic.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster; MacTutor","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/30","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/algorithm"},{"cursor":31,"id":31,"entryId":15,"entrySlug":"algorithm","title":"Was algorithm first used in 1699 or 1926?","position":"Both dates describe different editorial claims. Oxford/MacTutor reports the spelling in 1699 for numeral calculation; Merriam-Webster gives 1926 for the currently defined finite-procedure sense.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"MacTutor citing OED; Merriam-Webster First Known Use","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"SET-U stores both attestations and labels the sense boundary.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/31","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/algorithm"},{"cursor":32,"id":32,"entryId":16,"entrySlug":"algebra","title":"Did algebra originally mean symbols and variables?","position":"No. Al-jabr named restoration or completion, including a specific equation-solving operation; the word later expanded to the discipline.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Oxford Word Origin; MacTutor ALGEBRA entry","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/32","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/algebra"},{"cursor":33,"id":33,"entryId":16,"entrySlug":"algebra","title":"Is the bone-setting sense a fake folk story?","position":"No. Arabic and Romance transmission includes reunion of broken parts and bone-setting. That real medical sense should not be confused with the mathematical title history.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Oxford Word Origin","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/33","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/algebra"},{"cursor":34,"id":34,"entryId":17,"entrySlug":"calculate","title":"Is calculus securely a diminutive of calx “limestone”?","position":"Not securely. The traditional analysis is morphologically and semantically irregular; an alternative links Latin calculus and Greek stone words through a possible shared substrate source.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster calculus and chalk etymology notes","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/34","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/calculate"},{"cursor":35,"id":35,"entryId":17,"entrySlug":"calculate","title":"Were Roman calculations literally made with stones?","position":"Latin calculus did name a pebble used on a counting board, and the computation sense developed from that practice.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster calculate and calculus","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/35","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/calculate"},{"cursor":36,"id":36,"entryId":18,"entrySlug":"robot","title":"Did Karel Čapek personally invent robot?","position":"Karel introduced and popularized it in R.U.R., but Merriam-Webster reports that his brother Josef suggested the name from robota.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster robot, Did You Know?","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/36","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/robot"},{"cursor":37,"id":37,"entryId":18,"entrySlug":"robot","title":"Does robot literally mean orphan?","position":"No. Robot descends immediately from Czech compulsory labor. Orphan belongs to a remote comparative family around transferred status, dependency, and bereavement; a distant root relationship is not a modern definition.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster robot and orphan; University of Warsaw robota","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/37","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/robot"},{"cursor":38,"id":38,"entryId":19,"entrySlug":"muscle","title":"Is musculus really a “little mouse”?","position":"Latin musculus is morphologically the diminutive of mūs “mouse.”","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage independently report the diminutive derivation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The morphological derivation is treated as established; this does not settle the exact visual analogy.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/38","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/muscle"},{"cursor":39,"id":39,"entryId":19,"entrySlug":"muscle","title":"What exactly resembled a mouse?","position":"The naming may refer to the shape of a muscle, a tendon, or movement visible beneath the skin; the reviewed sources do not select one mechanism as secure.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster’s homophone history presents resemblance explanations cautiously.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/39","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/muscle"},{"cursor":40,"id":40,"entryId":19,"entrySlug":"muscle","title":"Did anatomical muscle reach English through French?","position":"The anatomical English word passed through Middle English and Old French from Latin musculus.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage gives the Old French channel; Merriam-Webster gives the Latin diminutive base.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The French borrowing path is retained for the anatomical dossier.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/40","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/muscle"},{"cursor":41,"id":41,"entryId":20,"entrySlug":"mussel","title":"Do mussel and muscle share the Latin mouse family?","position":"The English words have distinct immediate histories but converge in the Latin musculus / mūscula family derived from mūs.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster, American Heritage, and the American Heritage Indo-European root appendix align on the family.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph shares the Latin musculus, Latin mūs, and PIE *mūs- nodes while keeping the English and Middle English senses separate.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/41","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/mussel"},{"cursor":42,"id":42,"entryId":20,"entrySlug":"mussel","title":"Did Dutch mossel reshape the spelling mussel?","position":"Dutch mossel may have influenced the current English spelling.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"American Heritage labels the Dutch influence as possible rather than certain.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/42","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/mussel"},{"cursor":43,"id":43,"entryId":20,"entrySlug":"mussel","title":"Why was a shellfish named through the mouse family?","position":"The exact resemblance that carried the mouse-derived Latin word to a mussel is not securely identified in the reviewed record.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster documents the shared forms but cautions against overclaiming the naming mechanism.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/43","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/mussel"},{"cursor":44,"id":44,"entryId":21,"entrySlug":"mouse","title":"Was English mouse borrowed from Latin mūs?","position":"No. Old English mūs continues a Germanic branch; Latin mūs is a cognate parallel branch.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage and the University of Texas lexicon place the English and Latin forms in parallel branches of the same reconstructed family.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins English and Latin only at PIE *mūs-, never by a false Latin-to-English edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/44","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/mouse"},{"cursor":45,"id":45,"entryId":21,"entrySlug":"mouse","title":"How secure is Proto-Indo-European *mūs-?","position":"The cross-branch mouse word is reconstructed as PIE *mūs-, while any deeper ancestor remains outside the reviewed evidence.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The American Heritage Indo-European root appendix and the University of Texas LRC lexicon both publish the reconstruction.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The reconstruction is admitted as probable and ends at an explicit UNKNOWN boundary.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/45","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/mouse"},{"cursor":46,"id":46,"entryId":22,"entrySlug":"host","title":"Could hospes mean both host and guest?","position":"Yes. Latin hospes and its descendants reflect reciprocal hospitality in which the same participant could receive hospitality and later return it.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster explicitly explains the dual meanings through customs of reciprocity; American Heritage lists host, guest, and stranger.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph preserves one polysemous Latin node rather than forcing two unrelated words.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/46","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/host"},{"cursor":47,"id":47,"entryId":22,"entrySlug":"host","title":"Is hospes securely reduced from *ghos-pot-?","position":"The guest-master compound is a strong published analysis, but the amount of phonetic reduction has led some scholars to question its exact form.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster publishes the compound while explicitly recording the objection; American Heritage also publishes *ghos-pot-.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/47","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/host"},{"cursor":48,"id":48,"entryId":23,"entrySlug":"guest","title":"How broadly distributed is *ghos-ti-?","position":"The reconstruction is supported by Germanic, Italic, and Slavic evidence but is limited to a western set of Indo-European branches.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster calls it an etymon limited to three western branches; American Heritage and the University of Texas publish the reconstruction.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/48","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/guest"},{"cursor":49,"id":49,"entryId":23,"entrySlug":"guest","title":"Did Old Norse shape the Middle English forms?","position":"Old Norse gestr may have reinforced the Middle English initial g, but the English word is fundamentally inherited from Old English and Germanic.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster states the Norse contribution cautiously as “probably in part.”","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/49","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/guest"},{"cursor":50,"id":50,"entryId":23,"entrySlug":"guest","title":"Was guest borrowed from Latin hostis?","position":"No. English guest continues the Germanic branch; Latin hostis is a parallel cognate branch that meets it at *ghos-ti-.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster, American Heritage, and the University of Texas lexicon distinguish the Germanic and Latin reflexes.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph has no Latin-to-English guest edge and joins the words only at their reconstructed ancestor.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/50","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/guest"},{"cursor":51,"id":51,"entryId":24,"entrySlug":"hostile","title":"How did a reciprocal stranger become an enemy?","position":"Early Latin hostis referred to a foreigner or legally recognized outsider before later Roman usage restricted it to a hostile outsider or enemy.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster cites early legal usage and Varro’s observation of the semantic change; the comparative sources retain both stranger and enemy glosses.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic edge is accepted while its social transition remains a historical process rather than a single dated event.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/51","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hostile"},{"cursor":52,"id":52,"entryId":24,"entrySlug":"hostile","title":"Does *ghos-ti- descend from *ǵhes- “take, give in exchange”?","position":"A deeper exchange root has been proposed, but Merriam-Webster labels the analysis hypothetical and the other reviewed root references stop at *ghos-ti-.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster presents *ǵhes- only as a possible deeper base; American Heritage and the University of Texas do not require it for the published family.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/52","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hostile"},{"cursor":53,"id":53,"entryId":25,"entrySlug":"hospital","title":"Did hospital originally mean a medical institution?","position":"No. The earliest English senses concern lodging for travelers and charitable residence; medical care becomes established later.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster’s dictionary entry and historical essay distinguish the 14th-century lodging/charity history from the 15th-century medical development.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The timeline shows the lodging and charitable senses before modern medical specialization.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/53","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hospital"},{"cursor":54,"id":54,"entryId":25,"entrySlug":"hospital","title":"How secure is the remote hospes compound?","position":"Hospital’s path to Latin hospitāle and hospes is secure; the further reduction of hospes from *ghos-pot- remains probable rather than certain.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage support the remote family while Merriam-Webster records phonological objections.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/54","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hospital"},{"cursor":55,"id":55,"entryId":26,"entrySlug":"hotel","title":"Is hotel directly shortened from hospital?","position":"No. Hotel and hospital are doublets: both reach Latin hospitāle, but hotel comes through French hôtel and Old French hostel while hospital comes through Anglo-French hospital.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster’s hotel entry and family history distinguish the two French transmission paths.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Separate descendant edges converge at the shared Medieval Latin hospitāle node.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/55","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hotel"},{"cursor":56,"id":56,"entryId":26,"entrySlug":"hotel","title":"When did hotel enter English?","position":"Merriam-Webster reports 1687 for the lodging noun, after French hôtel had developed from Old French hostel.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The Merriam-Webster entry supplies the date and French succession; the family essay supplies the doublet context.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The source-reported year is retained as an attestation record, not upgraded into a directly inspected witness.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/56","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hotel"},{"cursor":57,"id":57,"entryId":27,"entrySlug":"nice","title":"Did nice originally mean pleasant?","position":"No. Merriam-Webster reports early foolish, wanton, silly, and simple senses; pleasant or agreeable becomes prominent much later.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster’s dictionary and semantic-history essay preserve the sequence without pretending it was one clean jump.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph separates the medieval and modern sense profiles.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/57","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/nice"},{"cursor":58,"id":58,"entryId":27,"entrySlug":"nice","title":"Is nice securely related to a root meaning cut?","position":"The Latin knowing family is secure, but the further comparison of scīre with a cutting/separating root is only proposed.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster records rival formations and calls the semantic progression questionable; Ernout and Meillet call the comparison uncertain, while American Heritage publishes *skei-.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/58","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/nice"},{"cursor":59,"id":59,"entryId":28,"entrySlug":"science","title":"Did science always mean modern natural science?","position":"No. Its earliest English and Latin histories center on knowledge, learning, awareness, and branches of knowledge.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster reports a fourteenth-century knowledge sense and the broader Latin scientia range.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic timeline shows later specialization without erasing surviving broad senses.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/59","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/science"},{"cursor":60,"id":60,"entryId":28,"entrySlug":"science","title":"Does Latin scīre securely descend from *skei- “cut, split”?","position":"No single analysis is secure. A discern-from-separating bridge is plausible, but the formation and semantic development remain disputed.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster summarizes the Lexikon der indogermanischen Verben, de Vaan, and Ernout-Meillet disagreements; American Heritage publishes the comparison.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/60","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/science"},{"cursor":61,"id":61,"entryId":29,"entrySlug":"decimate","title":"Must decimate mean only kill one in ten?","position":"No. That was its earliest English historical sense, but drastic reduction and destruction have been established since the seventeenth century.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster dates the exact sense to 1660 and documents broadening within decades.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph preserves both the numerical origin and legitimate semantic change.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/61","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/decimate"},{"cursor":62,"id":62,"entryId":29,"entrySlug":"decimate","title":"Is the Roman tenth-member story invented?","position":"No. The Latin and historical punishment sense is real; the error is using etymology to ban later English meanings.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster distinguishes the genuine Roman/Latin history from prescriptive folklore about current usage.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The contrarian truth retains both halves rather than choosing a pedantic myth.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/62","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/decimate"},{"cursor":63,"id":63,"entryId":30,"entrySlug":"decimal","title":"Is decimal named after the decimal point?","position":"No. The adjective and noun come from the Latin tenth/ten family; the visible point is part of later notation, not the word’s ancestor.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster derives decimal through French and Medieval Latin from decima and decem.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph terminates in the numeral family, not punctuation.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/63","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/decimal"},{"cursor":64,"id":64,"entryId":30,"entrySlug":"decimal","title":"Did the decimal noun and adjective enter together?","position":"Merriam-Webster reports the adjective in 1608 and the noun in 1623. These are lexicographic first-use reports, not inspected objects.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster supplies separate first-known-use dates for the two parts of speech.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The headword witness records the earlier adjective date and discloses its evidence limit.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/64","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/decimal"},{"cursor":65,"id":65,"entryId":31,"entrySlug":"december","title":"Why does the twelfth month mean tenth?","position":"The Latin name belongs to an early Roman year beginning in March, when December occupied the tenth position. Calendar reform changed the position while the name persisted.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster explicitly explains the March-starting calendar and literal tenth-month name.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The contradiction is historical layering, not a mistranslation.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/65","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/december"},{"cursor":66,"id":66,"entryId":31,"entrySlug":"december","title":"Did English receive December through Old English or French?","position":"The reviewed source allows either Old English or Anglo-French transmission from Latin and does not choose between them.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster’s etymology states “from Old English or Anglo-French, both from Latin.”","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/66","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/december"},{"cursor":67,"id":67,"entryId":32,"entrySlug":"check","title":"Did check begin with verification?","position":"No. The oldest sequence starts with chess, then stop and restraint; verification and banking are later semantic branches.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster orders the senses and separately explains the anti-forgery counterfoil behind the bank draft.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic history displays branching rather than projecting the modern meaning backward.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/67","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/check"},{"cursor":68,"id":68,"entryId":32,"entrySlug":"check","title":"Did Arabic šāh pass directly into French?","position":"The Arabic source is well supported, but Merriam-Webster leaves direct borrowing versus mediation through Spanish jaque unresolved.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster explicitly presents both transmission possibilities.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/68","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/check"},{"cursor":69,"id":69,"entryId":33,"entrySlug":"chess","title":"Does chess descend through šāh or through šatranj?","position":"Merriam-Webster routes the French forms through the king-call šāh; Encyclopaedia Iranica groups English chess with descendants of the Indian-Persian-Arabic game-name caturaṅga / čatrang / šatranj.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Both reviewed authorities are preserved as separately cited graph branches.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/69","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/chess"},{"cursor":70,"id":70,"entryId":33,"entrySlug":"chess","title":"Is the grass called chess part of the game family?","position":"No connection is asserted. Merriam-Webster labels the grass-name origin unknown.","confidence":"boundary","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster separates the two noun entries and marks the botanical origin unknown.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Sense keys and dossier scope prevent a spelling match from merging unrelated lexemes.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/70","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/chess"},{"cursor":71,"id":71,"entryId":34,"entrySlug":"checkmate","title":"Does checkmate literally mean the king is dead?","position":"That is a longstanding Arabic analysis, but Merriam-Webster and Encyclopaedia Iranica favor a Persian loan meaning left, helpless, broken, or paralyzed.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster cites Moghadam and calls the death reading more plausibly folk etymology; Iranica argues that other pieces die while the king becomes powerless.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/71","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/checkmate"},{"cursor":72,"id":72,"entryId":34,"entrySlug":"checkmate","title":"Is figurative checkmate a late metaphor?","position":"Not entirely. Merriam-Webster reports Middle English chekmaten with both chess and frustrate senses.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionary explicitly includes frustrate in the Middle English gloss.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph begins the semantic coexistence in Middle English.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/72","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/checkmate"},{"cursor":73,"id":73,"entryId":35,"entrySlug":"shah","title":"Did the English word shah produce check?","position":"No. English shah and English check are cousins: both reach back independently to Persian šāh, while check travels through chess, Arabic, and French.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster supplies the direct shah borrowing and the longer check route.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical Persian node is shared without falsely making one English word the parent of the other.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/73","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/shah"},{"cursor":74,"id":74,"entryId":35,"entrySlug":"shah","title":"Is the deepest root of xšāyaθiyā settled?","position":"No. Merriam-Webster publishes the traditional *tkeH- comparison and records a materially different LIV derivation from *h₃ekʷ-.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The competing reconstructions appear as separate canonical parent edges.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/74","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/shah"},{"cursor":75,"id":75,"entryId":36,"entrySlug":"tea","title":"Does every language follow a simple sea-versus-land rule?","position":"No. WALS documents a powerful distributional tendency, not a universal law: 110 sampled languages have Sinitic cha-derived forms, 84 have Min Nan te-derived forms, and 36 belong to neither class.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"WALS supplies the 230-language classification and discusses exceptions including Portuguese chá and non-Chinese native terms.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"SET-U presents maritime and overland routes as tendencies and keeps the “other” class visible.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/75","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/tea"},{"cursor":76,"id":76,"entryId":36,"entrySlug":"tea","title":"Did English tea pass through Dutch?","position":"WALS describes a Dutch-mediated European route, while Merriam-Webster compresses the etymology to borrowing from Xiamen Chinese dé. The displayed Dutch stage is probable, not silently declared unanimous.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The two reviewed references differ in how much transmission history they encode.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/76","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/tea"},{"cursor":77,"id":77,"entryId":37,"entrySlug":"chai","title":"Did English chai come from one identifiable donor language?","position":"The modern culinary sense strongly points toward South Asian usage, but Merriam-Webster lists Turkish, Russian, Persian, Hindi, and Urdu source forms without selecting one unique donor.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The dossier uses Hindustani as a representative route and labels the edge probable rather than erasing the alternatives.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/77","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/chai"},{"cursor":78,"id":78,"entryId":37,"entrySlug":"chai","title":"Is *lˤra the final word on the ancestry of tea?","position":"It is the final reviewed reconstruction in this dossier, not a declaration that no deeper hypothesis exists. No unique deeper form is promoted until a competing analysis is encoded with direct evidence.","confidence":"boundary","sourceSummary":"Baxter and Sagart provide the Old Chinese reconstruction; WALS supports the Chinese-derived global families but does not establish one deeper ancestor.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/78","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/chai"},{"cursor":79,"id":79,"entryId":38,"entrySlug":"ten","title":"Is English ten borrowed from Latin decem?","position":"No. English ten is inherited through Old English and Germanic, while Latin decem is a cognate from the same Indo-European numeral.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster gives the Germanic inheritance path; American Heritage places both Germanic and Latin descendants under *dekm̥.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The global graph joins them at the reconstructed root without making Latin the parent of English ten.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/79","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/ten"},{"cursor":80,"id":80,"entryId":39,"entrySlug":"dime","title":"Was dime invented as a coin name in 1786?","position":"The coin sense is reported from 1786, but the word itself already existed in Middle English and Anglo-French for a tenth part or tithe.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster separates the older etymological word from the first-known-use date of the coin sense.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier preserves both the medieval word and the later United States specialization.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/80","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/dime"},{"cursor":81,"id":81,"entryId":40,"entrySlug":"hostel","title":"Is hostel a shortened modern form of hotel?","position":"No. Hostel is the historically older-looking English doublet. Both words descend by different French histories from Latin hospitāle.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The hostel entry supplies the medieval route; the Merriam-Webster family history compares hospital, hostel, hotel, and hospice directly.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph shares hospitāle while keeping each borrowing route separate.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/81","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hostel"},{"cursor":82,"id":82,"entryId":41,"entrySlug":"hospice","title":"Did hospice always mean palliative care?","position":"No. The 1818 English record names lodging, especially a religious guesthouse; palliative care is a later specialization.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The hospice entry and hospital-family history distinguish the older lodging institution from the later end-of-life-care sense.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic edge and timeline refuse to backdate modern medical care to the first English record.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/82","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hospice"},{"cursor":83,"id":83,"entryId":42,"entrySlug":"lesson","title":"Did lesson originally mean a spoken class?","position":"Its secure ancestry points first to reading: Anglo-French leçon and Late Latin lectio, an act or selection of reading from legere. Instruction and learned-experience senses develop from that base.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster directly traces the word through lectio and legere and preserves reading in the current sense inventory.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier models reading before instruction instead of projecting the modern classroom backward.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/83","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/lesson"},{"cursor":84,"id":84,"entryId":43,"entrySlug":"select","title":"Is select descended from English lecture or lesson?","position":"No. The English words are cousins. Select comes from Latin selectus and seligere; lecture and lesson take other Latin formations that independently reach legere.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The select, lecture, and lesson entries expose separate Latin branches while the canonical graph shares legere.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins the dossiers at Latin legere without making one modern English word the ancestor of another.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/84","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/select"},{"cursor":85,"id":85,"entryId":44,"entrySlug":"hostis","title":"Did Latin hostis always mean enemy?","position":"No. Roman sources remembered an older foreigner or stranger sense before usage restricted the word toward a public or armed enemy.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Lewis and Short cite Cicero, Varro, and Festus on the semantic shift; comparative sources connect the older outsider to *ghos-ti-.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier separates the older outsider horizon from the later enemy-centered use.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/85","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hostis"},{"cursor":86,"id":86,"entryId":45,"entrySlug":"mys","title":"Are Greek mouse and muscle merely accidental homonyms?","position":"The reviewed Liddell–Scott entry treats μῦς as one lexical entry with both rodent and body-muscle senses, and Modern Greek explicitly derives both learned senses from Ancient Greek.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The Centre for the Greek Language publishes both the Ancient Greek polysemy and the Modern Greek continuation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph keeps the two senses together in Greek while distinguishing the parallel Latin and Germanic branches.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/86","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/mys"},{"cursor":87,"id":87,"entryId":46,"entrySlug":"nescience","title":"Was nescience coined in modern English by negating science?","position":"No. English borrowed the learned noun through Late Latin nescientia, itself built through nesciens and nescīre from the Latin negative plus scīre.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster supplies the complete Latin sequence and reports English use in 1612.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins nescience and science at Latin scīre without making either English word the parent of the other.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/87","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/nescience"},{"cursor":88,"id":88,"entryId":47,"entrySlug":"liebe","title":"Are German Liebe and English love the same immediate inherited noun?","position":"No. Their histories converge deeper in the desire-and-care family, but Old High German liubî is analyzed through Germanic *leubīn while Old English lufu follows the *lubō branch.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The EWA article publishes the German formation; Kroonen supplies the comparative Germanic family already used by the English dossier.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph keeps the two Germanic noun formations distinct and joins them only at reconstructed *lewbʰ-.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/88","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/liebe"},{"cursor":89,"id":89,"entryId":48,"entrySlug":"lief","title":"Did Dutch lief come from English love?","position":"No. Dutch lief is an inherited Germanic adjective cognate with forms including Gothic liufs and German lieb; English love is a separate noun descendant in the same wider family.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Franck’s dictionary compares the Germanic adjective reflexes, and Kroonen supplies the reconstructed family.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph treats lief and love as cousins, not parent and child.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/89","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/lief"},{"cursor":90,"id":90,"entryId":49,"entrySlug":"liufs","title":"Does the asterisk in Project Wulfila’s lemma *liufs mean Gothic itself is reconstructed?","position":"No. Project Wulfila links the normalized lemma to 33 inflected occurrences in surviving Gothic manuscripts. The citation form is inferred, while the lexeme and its inflections are attested.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The lemma page labels *liufs and enumerates manuscript-linked liuba, liuban, liubans, liubin, and liubai tokens; Mark 1:11 links liuba to Codex Argenteus folio 57v.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"SET-U stores liufs as an attested lexical headword, discloses the normalized citation-form issue, and reserves reconstructed status for Proto-Germanic *leubaz and PIE *lewbʰ-.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/90","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/liufs"},{"cursor":91,"id":91,"entryId":50,"entrySlug":"lieb","title":"Is German lieb a shortened form of Liebe?","position":"No. The adjective descends through Middle High German liep and Old High German liob. The noun Liebe continues a related abstract-noun formation analyzed as deadjectival within the older family.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Duden supplies the adjective’s independent historical sequence; the EWA article analyzes the Old High German love noun as a deadjectival abstract formation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph gives lieb its own inherited adjective route, connects Liebe through its distinct abstract-noun formation, and joins both only at the deeper desire-and-care family.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/91","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/lieb"},{"cursor":92,"id":92,"entryId":51,"entrySlug":"emoji","title":"Is emoji formed from emotion plus icon?","position":"No. Unicode and Merriam-Webster identify Japanese 絵 e “picture” plus 文字 moji “written character.” Emotion plus icon is the distinct English formation emoticon.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Two independent institutional references give the same Japanese compound analysis and Unicode explicitly contrasts emoticon.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph branches 絵文字 into 絵 and 文字; it does not create emotion or icon parents.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/92","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/emoji"},{"cursor":93,"id":93,"entryId":52,"entrySlug":"sauna","title":"Is Finnish sauna ultimately an ancient Germanic loan?","position":"Petri Kallio proposes Proto-Finnic *sakna as an ancient borrowing from Palaeo-Germanic *stagh-ná-, with pile or stack developing through stone-pile stove to sauna. The proposal has support but remains disputed.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Kotus says the Germanic account has gained support; Ylikoski reports both LÄGLOS skepticism and Koivulehto's acceptance.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"SET-U preserves the proposed edge, the semantic bridge, the challenge, and the stopping boundary together.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/93","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/sauna"},{"cursor":94,"id":94,"entryId":53,"entrySlug":"ubuntu","title":"Does ubuntu literally parse as “I am because we are”?","position":"No at the level of word formation. The lexical sources analyze a human stem -ntu and an abstract-noun prefix ubu-; the familiar sentence is a philosophical gloss rather than a component-by-component translation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionary identifies the -ntu human stem; the scholarly volume explicitly analyzes ubu- plus -ntu.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph exposes the morphemes while keeping philosophical interpretations distinct from lexical morphology.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/94","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/ubuntu"},{"cursor":95,"id":95,"entryId":54,"entrySlug":"taboo","title":"Did taboo originally mean only “forbidden”?","position":"No. The Tongan reflexes and wider Oceanic reconstruction carry a semantic field that includes prohibited, under ritual restriction, sacred, holy, and consecrated.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster supplies the Tongan borrowing; POLLEX supplies the comparative semantic range and Proto-Oceanic reconstruction.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph and truth ledger retain sacredness and prohibition together instead of back-projecting only the modern casual English sense.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/95","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/taboo"},{"cursor":96,"id":96,"entryId":55,"entrySlug":"kayak","title":"Can the English donor be narrowed to one Inuit language?","position":"Not from the reviewed English etymology. It gives only Inuit qayaq. Official Greenlandic qajaq evidence proves a related living form, not that Greenlandic was uniquely the immediate donor.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster uses the broad label Inuit; Oqaasileriffik documents Greenlandic qajaq terminology without tracing the English borrowing event.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The donor node is explicitly labeled variety unspecified, and narrower forms remain related evidence.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/96","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kayak"},{"cursor":97,"id":97,"entryId":56,"entrySlug":"hammock","title":"Are the suspended-bed and terrain senses of hammock one word?","position":"No in the reviewed dictionary. The suspended bed comes from Spanish hamaca from Taíno; the southern U.S. terrain sense is tied to earlier English forms and a Germanic comparison.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster presents the two nouns under separate etymologies and dates; the RAE independently confirms Taíno hamaca for Spanish.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Only the suspended-bed lineage is traced through Taíno in this dossier.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/97","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hammock"},{"cursor":98,"id":98,"entryId":57,"entrySlug":"avocado","title":"Does avocado literally prove that the fruit was named “testicle”?","position":"The source word āhuacatl is documented with both avocado and testicle senses. The reviewed dictionary entries do not establish which sense came first or that one was a deliberate anatomical naming of the other.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and the RAE independently report the same Nahuatl polysemy and the Spanish transmission route.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"SET-U states the two-source lexical fact and labels the stronger naming story as an unsupported inference.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/98","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/avocado"},{"cursor":99,"id":99,"entryId":58,"entrySlug":"boomerang","title":"Which Aboriginal language supplied boomerang?","position":"Dharug bumarin and a Dharawal bou-mar-rang form are published candidates, but the Australian National Dictionary Centre says the exact source language remains uncertain.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster assigns Dharug; the Australian Museum gives a Turuwal or Dharawal form; ANU explicitly keeps the language unresolved.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph contains both proposed routes and the dossier ends at an uncertainty boundary.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/99","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/boomerang"},{"cursor":100,"id":100,"entryId":59,"entrySlug":"mango","title":"Is Malayalam the certain ultimate source of mango?","position":"Portuguese manga is the secure immediate source; Malayalam māṅṅa is probable, not absolute, and no deeper Dravidian reconstruction is promoted in this review.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster uses “probably”; Gundert independently attests Malayalam māṅṅa.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The edge is labeled probable and the graph ends at an evidence boundary.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/100","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/mango"},{"cursor":101,"id":101,"entryId":60,"entrySlug":"jaguar","title":"Did Tupi jawára already mean only Panthera onca?","position":"The cited Tupi gloss is broader: large carnivore. European languages specialized the borrowed name as the jaguar species label.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster gives the broad Tupi gloss; CNRTL documents historical variants and specialization.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic-change field records narrowing rather than projecting the modern zoological sense backward.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/101","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/jaguar"},{"cursor":102,"id":102,"entryId":61,"entrySlug":"moose","title":"Which Eastern Algonquian language directly supplied moose?","position":"The family source is secure, but related Massachusett moos and Eastern Abenaki mos do not by themselves identify one unique direct donor.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster says Algonquian and cites Massachusett as akin; the Canadian Language Museum gives Eastern Abenaki mos.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The donor node remains variety unresolved and the specific forms are relatives.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/102","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/moose"},{"cursor":103,"id":103,"entryId":62,"entrySlug":"bayou","title":"Is Choctaw bayuk a securely attested source of bayou?","position":"No. An early Choctaw *bayok is plausible and accepted in a major handbook, but later bayuk is not securely attested and contraction to bók was conjectural.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster lays out both the historical proposal and its weaknesses; the MBCI dictionary directly documents modern bók “creek.”","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The French edge is established, the Choctaw edge proposed, and the asterisk remains visible.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/103","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/bayou"},{"cursor":104,"id":104,"entryId":63,"entrySlug":"yogurt","title":"Does a Turkish word prove Turkish invention of yogurt?","position":"No. English borrowed Turkish yoğurt, and a Turkish verbal derivation is supported; neither fact alone establishes the prehistoric inventor or birthplace of fermented milk.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and TDK establish the lexical source; Özbek analyzes the Turkish morphology.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier separates linguistic lineage from food-history claims.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/104","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/yogurt"},{"cursor":105,"id":105,"entryId":64,"entrySlug":"shaman","title":"Does Evenki šamān securely descend from Sanskrit śramaṇa?","position":"The resemblance and Central Asian transmission routes have motivated a hypothesis, but direct evidence connecting the Buddhist term to the Evenki word remains insufficient.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster stops at Evenki; Zieme reviews major theories and emphasizes the evidentiary gap.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The Sanskrit comparison is a speculative competing graph edge, not part of the promoted linear ancestry.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/105","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/shaman"},{"cursor":106,"id":106,"entryId":65,"entrySlug":"kimchi","title":"How far beyond Korean 김치 can the trail securely go?","position":"The reviewed sources establish English kimchi from Korean 김치. They do not establish a deeper lexical ancestor, so historical spellings or cultural antiquity are not promoted as a parent edge.","confidence":"boundary","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster stops at Korean kimch’i; the National Institute of Korean Language directly documents modern 김치.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The dossier ends at an explicit evidence boundary pending specialist Korean historical-lexicographic review.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/106","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kimchi"},{"cursor":107,"id":107,"entryId":66,"entrySlug":"llama","title":"Are animal llama and Spanish llama “flame” the same word?","position":"No. The animal word is Quechua through Spanish; the fire homonym is a separate Spanish entry from Latin flamma.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"RAE separates llama¹ “flame” from llama², the Quechua animal word.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The animal sense has its own sense key and the fire word appears only as an unrelated homonym.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/107","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/llama"},{"cursor":108,"id":108,"entryId":67,"entrySlug":"alpaca","title":"Do allpaqa, all-paka, and allphaqa imply competing origins?","position":"No. The references use different editorial and official spellings for the Aymara animal word while agreeing on Aymara ancestry.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster prints allpaqa, RAE all-paka, and Peru’s Ministry of Education allphaqa.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier promotes the official educational spelling and exposes the alternatives as relatives.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/108","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/alpaca"},{"cursor":109,"id":109,"entryId":68,"entrySlug":"tipi","title":"Does tipi simply and literally mean “they dwell”?","position":"The reviewed evidence safely derives thípi from a dwelling root; suffix analyses vary in how they label the final morphology, so the dossier promotes “dwelling” rather than one viral literal sentence.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster derives thípi from thí- “to dwell”; American Heritage analyzes -pi as abstract and collective morphology.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The root and noun relationship are established; the over-specific folk gloss is withheld.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/109","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/tipi"},{"cursor":110,"id":110,"entryId":69,"entrySlug":"hogan","title":"Is hogan a generic word for any Indigenous hut?","position":"No. English borrowed Navajo hooghan, and the living word carries a Diné home and house meaning with a specific traditional cultural frame.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster identifies Navajo hooghan; Navajo Word of the Day describes home, house, and the traditional form.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The summary and semantic edge avoid genericizing the term.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/110","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hogan"},{"cursor":111,"id":111,"entryId":70,"entrySlug":"poncho","title":"Is poncho securely Mapuche or Spanish?","position":"It remains disputed. A major English dictionary and Sánchez support Mapuche ancestry; current RAE and Iwasaki advance a Spanish-internal analysis grounded partly in an early 1530 record.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The sources disagree both on the parent form and on the direction of borrowing between Spanish and Mapuche evidence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"Both routes remain visible; the linear dossier marks the Mapuche edge proposed and the canonical graph adds a competing Spanish route.","citationCount":4,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/111","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/poncho"},{"cursor":112,"id":112,"entryId":71,"entrySlug":"clew","title":"Was a clew originally evidence?","position":"No. The oldest reviewed sense is a ball of thread. The guiding and evidence senses develop from stories in which a thread leads someone through a difficult place.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster distinguishes the literal sense, the mythic guiding association, and the later 17th-century clue spelling.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier keeps clew and clue connected while separating literal ancestry from later metaphor.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/112","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/clew"},{"cursor":113,"id":113,"entryId":71,"entrySlug":"clew","title":"Can the akin German and Sanskrit forms be used as direct parents?","position":"No. The reviewed source labels Old High German kliuwa and Sanskrit glauḥ as akin forms, not successive ancestors of English clew.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster supplies comparisons after the Old English form but no single direct parent beyond it.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The comparisons appear as relatives and the direct path ends at an explicit boundary.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/113","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/clew"},{"cursor":114,"id":114,"entryId":72,"entrySlug":"candid","title":"Did candid always mean honest?","position":"No. The first reported English sense is white; clear, pure, fair, honest, frank, and photographic senses develop later.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster reports the 1597 white sense and explains the semantic expansion from Latin and French brightness.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier orders physical color before moral and behavioral meanings.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/114","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/candid"},{"cursor":115,"id":115,"entryId":72,"entrySlug":"candid","title":"Is the deepest brightness root *kand- or *(s)kend-?","position":"The graph preserves both published analyses. The newer Merriam-Webster route uses *(s)kend- and explains candēre through a zero-grade stative formation; the prior *kand- route remains proposed.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster publishes *(s)kend- while the existing reviewed candidate dossier preserves a proposed *kand- analysis.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/115","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/candid"},{"cursor":116,"id":116,"entryId":73,"entrySlug":"candor","title":"Was candor originally frankness?","position":"Not exclusively. Its earliest English family includes brightness and unstained purity; straightforward honesty becomes the dominant modern sense.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster explicitly contrasts the earliest brightness and purity senses with modern honest expression.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic sequence is shown as radiance to purity to frankness, without claiming one instantaneous shift.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/116","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/candor"},{"cursor":117,"id":117,"entryId":73,"entrySlug":"candor","title":"Did English borrow candor only through French?","position":"French candeur is a published route, while Merriam-Webster describes the English borrowing as French and Latin. Direct learned Latin influence therefore remains visible.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster gives both French and Latin in the English borrowing history.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/117","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/candor"},{"cursor":118,"id":118,"entryId":74,"entrySlug":"calculus","title":"Is Latin calculus securely a diminutive of calx?","position":"No. Festus accepted the traditional limestone derivation, but the phonology and meanings are problematic. The edge remains proposed.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster records the traditional analysis and its problems rather than presenting it as settled.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/118","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/calculus"},{"cursor":119,"id":119,"entryId":74,"entrySlug":"calculus","title":"Could Latin calculus and Greek káchlēx share a non-Indo-European source?","position":"Yes, as a proposal. Beekes' substrate diagnostics for Greek variants motivate a possible common source, but no form is securely reconstructed.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster summarizes the Greek comparison, Beekes' variant evidence, and the shared-source hypothesis.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/119","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/calculus"},{"cursor":120,"id":120,"entryId":75,"entrySlug":"intellect","title":"Did intellect enter English through French or directly from Latin?","position":"Both routes are published. American Heritage specifies Old French intellecte; Merriam-Webster permits Middle French or Latin. The displayed French route is probable, not exclusive.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Two reviewed dictionaries preserve different levels of specificity for the transmission route.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/120","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/intellect"},{"cursor":121,"id":121,"entryId":75,"entrySlug":"intellect","title":"Does intellect literally mean “choosing between”?","position":"The morphology of intellegere is traditionally analyzed through inter- and legere, and selection informs the semantic history. That slogan is not a complete theory of cognition.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and Latin lexicography support the morphology; SET-U separates it from over-literal psychological claims.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The edge carries the morphological insight and an explicit anti-essentialist confidence note.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/121","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/intellect"},{"cursor":122,"id":122,"entryId":76,"entrySlug":"hospitality","title":"Could Latin hospes mean both host and guest?","position":"Yes. The reciprocal hospitality relationship allowed the same participant to receive hospitality on one occasion and return it on another.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage publish both roles under the same Latin form.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph preserves one polysemous Latin node rather than inventing unrelated homonyms.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/122","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hospitality"},{"cursor":123,"id":123,"entryId":76,"entrySlug":"hospitality","title":"Is hospes securely reduced from *ghos-pot-?","position":"The guest-master compound is a strong published analysis, but the amount of phonetic reduction has led scholars to question its exact form.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster records the phonological objection while American Heritage publishes the compound analysis.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/123","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hospitality"},{"cursor":124,"id":124,"entryId":77,"entrySlug":"calculator","title":"Was a calculator originally a machine?","position":"No. The reviewed English history begins with Middle English calkelatour, a person who counted or computed; the machine inherits that human agent label.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster documents the medieval human meaning, Latin agent noun, modern device definition, and 14th-century horizon.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier places the human reckoner before the undated machine specialization.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/124","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/calculator"},{"cursor":125,"id":125,"entryId":77,"entrySlug":"calculator","title":"Does calculator securely descend beyond Latin calculus to calx?","position":"The calculator-to-calculare-to-calculus chain is established, but the traditional calculus-to-calx derivation is proposed. A possible shared Mediterranean substrate source remains a competing route.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster records both the traditional limestone analysis and the Greek or common-substrate objections.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/125","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/calculator"},{"cursor":126,"id":126,"entryId":78,"entrySlug":"intelligent","title":"Was English intelligent formed from English intelligence?","position":"No. The adjective is borrowed from Latin intelligent-, intelligens; the English noun intelligence follows its own abstract-noun transmission through French and Latin intelligentia.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster publishes different immediate histories for the adjective and noun.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph connects both words at their Latin family without inventing an English noun-to-adjective derivation.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/126","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/intelligent"},{"cursor":127,"id":127,"entryId":78,"entrySlug":"intelligent","title":"Is *leǵ- the only published root shape behind intelligent?","position":"No. The traditional *leǵ- analysis remains probable, while *sleǵ- is a published alternative. Neither reconstructed shape is treated as an attested word.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The UT Austin Indo-European Lexicon supplies *leg-; Kaczyńska argues for *sleg-.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/127","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/intelligent"},{"cursor":128,"id":128,"entryId":79,"entrySlug":"conscience","title":"Did conscience always mean only a moral judge?","position":"No. Moral awareness is early and central, but the Latin family and an obsolete English sense also include consciousness or general awareness.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage document moral senses beside the broader knowing and awareness history.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier does not erase morality; it places it inside the wider recorded semantic field.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/128","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/conscience"},{"cursor":129,"id":129,"entryId":79,"entrySlug":"conscience","title":"Does the con- in conscience mean together or intensively?","position":"Both analyses are published. Merriam-Webster presents com- plus scire, while American Heritage labels com- intensive; the dossier keeps the edge probable rather than forcing one exclusive gloss.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Two current dictionaries assign different semantic force to the same prefix.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/129","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/conscience"},{"cursor":130,"id":130,"entryId":80,"entrySlug":"conscious","title":"Was conscious shortened from English consciousness?","position":"No. The reviewed etymologies derive the adjective directly from Latin cōnscius, and Merriam-Webster reports the adjective circa 1600.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage independently publish the direct Latin ancestry.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph does not invent an English noun-to-adjective derivation.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/130","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/conscious"},{"cursor":131,"id":131,"entryId":80,"entrySlug":"conscious","title":"Does knowing securely descend from cutting or splitting?","position":"No. The *skei- comparison is published, but the exact formation of Latin scīre and the semantic bridge from separating to knowing remain disputed.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The existing science dossier preserves competing morphological analyses and explicit semantic doubt.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/131","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/conscious"},{"cursor":132,"id":132,"entryId":81,"entrySlug":"omniscient","title":"Was omniscient assembled in English from omni plus science?","position":"No. English borrowed a learned Latin all-knowing form; the compound analysis belongs inside Latin, not as a new English coinage from the modern noun science.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage independently give Latin immediate ancestry.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier connects the word to science at Latin scientia without inventing an English compound.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/132","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/omniscient"},{"cursor":133,"id":133,"entryId":81,"entrySlug":"omniscient","title":"Is the immediate Latin form Medieval Latin or New Latin?","position":"The references differ. American Heritage labels omnisciēns Medieval Latin; Merriam-Webster labels the immediate form New Latin and analyzes it as a back-formation from Medieval Latin omniscientia.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Two current dictionaries publish different periodization and morphological detail.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/133","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/omniscient"},{"cursor":134,"id":134,"entryId":82,"entrySlug":"prescient","title":"Does prescient etymologically mean seeing the future?","position":"No. Its documented Latin structure is prae- “before” plus scīre “to know”: foreknowledge, not a sight-word formation.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage independently publish the before-plus-know analysis.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The modern foresight metaphor remains a meaning, not the word's morphology.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/134","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/prescient"},{"cursor":135,"id":135,"entryId":82,"entrySlug":"prescient","title":"Did English receive prescient through French or directly from Latin?","position":"Both routes are published. American Heritage specifies French transmission; Merriam-Webster gives Latin; Etymonline explicitly allows French and direct Latin.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The displayed French route is evidence-backed but not exclusive.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/135","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/prescient"},{"cursor":136,"id":136,"entryId":83,"entrySlug":"dialogue","title":"Does dialogue etymologically require exactly two speakers?","position":"No. Greek dia- means through, across, or between, not two; both reviewed histories explicitly reject or contradict the two-person restriction.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and Etymonline document dia- plus legein, and Etymonline explicitly identifies the two-person reading as a confusion with di-.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"SET-U treats participant count as a usage property, not a false morphological limit.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/136","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/dialogue"},{"cursor":137,"id":137,"entryId":83,"entrySlug":"dialogue","title":"Is *leǵ- the only published deepest root shape?","position":"No. The traditional *leǵ- analysis remains widely represented, while a published *sleǵ- reconstruction challenges the initial consonant and cautions against a simple semantic tale.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"UT Austin supplies *leg-; Kaczyńska argues for *sleg-.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/137","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/dialogue"},{"cursor":138,"id":138,"entryId":84,"entrySlug":"prologue","title":"Does the -logue in prologue mean a field of study?","position":"No. Greek prologos is pro- “before” plus logos “speech or discourse”: a speech beforehand. English -logy belongs to the same wider family but is not the component analyzed here.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and Etymonline independently publish the before-speech formation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph connects the words at logos without replacing one suffix with another.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/138","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/prologue"},{"cursor":139,"id":139,"entryId":84,"entrySlug":"prologue","title":"Is *leǵ- the only published deepest root shape?","position":"No. The traditional *leǵ- analysis remains widely represented, while a published *sleǵ- reconstruction challenges the initial consonant.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"UT Austin supplies *leg-; Kaczyńska argues for *sleg-.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/139","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/prologue"},{"cursor":140,"id":140,"entryId":85,"entrySlug":"legible","title":"Did legible begin as a word for general understandability?","position":"The secure formation is literal reading: Late Latin legibilis from legere “to read.” Discernible and understandable are later or extended senses, not the morphological source.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster, American Heritage, and Etymonline independently publish the Latin reading formation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier keeps figurative senses but does not project them backward.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/140","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/legible"},{"cursor":141,"id":141,"entryId":85,"entrySlug":"legible","title":"Is *leǵ- the only published deepest root shape?","position":"No. Latin legere is traditionally compared with *leǵ-, while *sleǵ- remains a published alternative.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"UT Austin supplies *leg-; Kaczyńska argues for *sleg-.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/141","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/legible"},{"cursor":142,"id":142,"entryId":86,"entrySlug":"legislation","title":"Was legislation formed from the English verb legislate?","position":"No. English legislation is recorded by the seventeenth century, while Etymonline dates legislate to 1805 as a back-formation from legislation or legislator.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster reports legislation in 1606; Etymonline reports the noun in the 1650s and the verb in 1805.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph runs from the Latin and French noun family toward English, not backward from the later verb.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/142","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/legislation"},{"cursor":143,"id":143,"entryId":86,"entrySlug":"legislation","title":"When does the reviewed English record for legislation begin?","position":"The references disagree. Merriam-Webster reports 1606; Etymonline gives the 1650s, while CNRTL cites NED for before 1655. The earliest reviewed year remains source-reported rather than object-verified.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Three current historical references expose a real lexicographic chronology conflict.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/143","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/legislation"},{"cursor":144,"id":144,"entryId":86,"entrySlug":"legislation","title":"Does Latin lēx securely descend from the gather root *leǵ-?","position":"Not securely. A collection-of-rules bridge is plausible and published, but the direction, root shape, and precise cognates remain disputed.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"UT Austin presents the traditional *leg- family; Kaczyńska argues for *sleg- and questions the comparison.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/144","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/legislation"},{"cursor":145,"id":145,"entryId":87,"entrySlug":"law","title":"Is English law the source of legal—or vice versa?","position":"No. Law comes through Old English lagu from Scandinavian; legal comes through Anglo-French and Latin legalis from lēx. Their shared modern subject matter is not an immediate genealogical relationship.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster publishes distinct immediate histories for law and legal.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossiers remain separate until their explicitly competing deep routes are reached.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/145","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/law"},{"cursor":146,"id":146,"entryId":87,"entrySlug":"law","title":"Can Latin lēx and Germanic law converge at *legh-?","position":"Possibly, but uncertain. American Heritage presents Latin lēx from *leǵ- as one analysis and separately allows a possible “laid down” route from *legh-.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The roots appendix explicitly labels the *legh- comparison possible but uncertain; the existing legal dossier also preserves a separate *leǵ- / *sleǵ- dispute.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph publishes a proposed competing edge from lēx to *legh- without replacing the existing route.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/146","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/law"},{"cursor":147,"id":147,"entryId":88,"entrySlug":"arithmetic","title":"Are arithmetic and algorithm cognates?","position":"No. Arithmetic descends through Greek arithmos “number.” Algorithm descends from al-Khwārizmī's name; arithmos influenced the later spelling rather than supplying the ancestor.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage and MacTutor explicitly distinguish the ancestry from the spelling influence.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The connection is a cited historical-context link, not a lexical edge.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/147","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/arithmetic"},{"cursor":148,"id":148,"entryId":88,"entrySlug":"arithmetic","title":"Does the English record begin in the 13th or 15th century?","position":"The reviewed source reports differ. Etymonline gives mid-thirteenth-century arsmetike; Merriam-Webster gives a fifteenth-century first-known-use horizon.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Two historical dictionary records publish different English horizons.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"Both reports remain visible pending direct inspection and reconciliation of their underlying objects.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/148","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/arithmetic"},{"cursor":149,"id":149,"entryId":88,"entrySlug":"arithmetic","title":"Is the deepest counting root *h₂rei- or *erei-dhmo- from *re-?","position":"The references use different levels and notations: Merriam-Webster derives the Greek base through *h₂rei-, while Etymonline prints an expanded *erei-dhmo- formation tied to *re-.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The sources agree on a counting family but not one directly interchangeable string representation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The linear route uses *h₂rei- and explicitly records the competing expanded formation.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/149","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/arithmetic"},{"cursor":150,"id":150,"entryId":89,"entrySlug":"emoticon","title":"Is emoticon another name or etymology for emoji?","position":"No. Emoticon is English emotion plus icon. Emoji is Japanese e “picture” plus moji “character.” They can depict overlapping things without sharing a word formation.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Unicode defines both formations side by side; Merriam-Webster separately analyzes each word.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The two dossiers are joined by a context link and rabbit hole, never by a fabricated ancestry edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/150","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/emoticon"},{"cursor":151,"id":151,"entryId":89,"entrySlug":"emoticon","title":"Was emoticon first used in 1987 or only by 1992?","position":"Merriam-Webster reports first known use in 1987; Etymonline reports the word by January 1992 and quotes an August 1992 explanation.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The sources differ in their reported earliest horizons while agreeing on emotion plus icon.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"1987 is retained as the earlier lexicographic horizon; the later published report remains visible pending direct primary-object review.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/151","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/emoticon"},{"cursor":152,"id":152,"entryId":89,"entrySlug":"emoticon","title":"Can icon be securely reconstructed beyond Greek eikōn?","position":"Not from the reviewed evidence. Merriam-Webster calls the proposed deeper base uncertain and a Lithuanian comparison doubtful; Etymonline likewise stops at uncertain Greek prehistory.","confidence":"boundary","sourceSummary":"Both headword histories explicitly qualify the Greek form's deeper origin.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The icon branch ends at a separate cited knowledge boundary.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/152","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/emoticon"},{"cursor":153,"id":153,"entryId":90,"entrySlug":"salt","title":"Does the salt relationship prove soldiers were paid in salt?","position":"No. Salt and salary belong to the same comparative salt family, but the real lexical kinship does not establish the viral literal-payment story.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"UT LRC lists both salt and salary in the sal- reflex family; Merriam-Webster rejects the ordinary soldiers-paid-in-salt claim.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph connects the words while the claim layer rejects the unsupported payroll narrative.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/153","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/salt"},{"cursor":154,"id":154,"entryId":90,"entrySlug":"salt","title":"Is the PIE salt root written *sal- or *séh₂l-?","position":"Both appear in the reviewed references at different representational resolutions. SET-U reuses *séh₂l- as the canonical dossier node and records *sal- as an alternative notation, not a second word.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Mallory and Adams supply the laryngeal representation; UT LRC and Etymonline print *sal-.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The dispute concerns reconstruction notation and analysis, not whether the daughter words belong to a salt family.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/154","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/salt"},{"cursor":155,"id":155,"entryId":91,"entrySlug":"algorism","title":"Does the English record begin in the 13th or 14th century?","position":"The reviewed reports differ. Etymonline gives an early-thirteenth-century algorism; Merriam-Webster gives a fourteenth-century first-known-use horizon.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Two historical dictionaries publish different English horizons.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"Both remain visible pending inspection and reconciliation of the underlying medieval objects.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/155","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/algorism"},{"cursor":156,"id":156,"entryId":91,"entrySlug":"algorism","title":"Did English algorism arrive through French or directly from Medieval Latin?","position":"The sources preserve both channels. Merriam-Webster names Middle French and Medieval Latin; Etymonline emphasizes Old French from Medieval Latin.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionaries do not require one exclusive route for every English spelling.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The linear dossier follows French while the canonical graph retains the already-cited direct Medieval Latin parent of the shared Middle English node.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/156","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/algorism"},{"cursor":157,"id":157,"entryId":91,"entrySlug":"algorism","title":"Was algorithm the original form and algorism a corruption?","position":"No. Algorism is older. Algorithm is the later altered form, with its th commonly explained through Greek arithmos or arithmetic influence.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster, American Heritage, Etymonline, and MacTutor distinguish ancestry from later respelling.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The lexical graph connects both through shared Middle English algorisme while arithmetic remains a context link, not an ancestor.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/157","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/algorism"},{"cursor":158,"id":158,"entryId":92,"entrySlug":"emotion","title":"Was emotion first used in the 1570s or exactly 1579?","position":"Etymonline gives the decade; Merriam-Webster gives 1579. These are compatible levels of precision, not proof of one first utterance.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionaries publish decade-level and exact lexicographic reports.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"SET-U retains the exact institutional report while labeling the evidence as source-reported rather than directly inspected.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/158","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/emotion"},{"cursor":159,"id":159,"entryId":92,"entrySlug":"emotion","title":"Does emotion etymologically mean “energy in motion”?","position":"No. That slogan is a modern folk segmentation. The documented route is French émotion through emouvoir / esmovoir to Latin ex- plus movēre, literally a movement-out or stirring family.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster, American Heritage, and Etymonline publish the French and Latin morphology.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph exposes the actual prefix and verb as cited parents instead of substituting an English rhyme.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/159","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/emotion"},{"cursor":160,"id":160,"entryId":92,"entrySlug":"emotion","title":"Can the movement family be pushed securely beyond *meue-?","position":"Not from the reviewed evidence. Etymonline publishes *meue- for the movement root, but this dossier does not promote an older form without specialist comparative review.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The reconstruction is cited; a deeper ancestor is not supplied by the reviewed headword sources.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The final node is an explicit knowledge boundary.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/160","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/emotion"},{"cursor":161,"id":161,"entryId":93,"entrySlug":"icon","title":"Can Greek eikōn be securely reconstructed further?","position":"Not from the reviewed evidence. Merriam-Webster calls the proposed base uncertain and the Lithuanian comparison doubtful; Etymonline likewise marks the Greek prehistory uncertain.","confidence":"boundary","sourceSummary":"The headword histories explicitly qualify the proposed deeper route.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The graph stops at Greek eikōn rather than converting a doubtful comparison into an ancestor.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/161","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/icon"},{"cursor":162,"id":162,"entryId":93,"entrySlug":"icon","title":"Does the English record begin in the 1570s or in 1572?","position":"Merriam-Webster reports 1572; Etymonline reports the 1570s. The exact year fits within the broader decade but remains a source-reported horizon.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Two historical dictionaries publish different precision for the same early period.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"1572 is stored as the exact lexicographic report while the broader horizon remains visible.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/162","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/icon"},{"cursor":163,"id":163,"entryId":93,"entrySlug":"icon","title":"Are the sacred image, celebrity, and computer icon different etymological words?","position":"No. They are semantic extensions within the image-and-likeness family; the later uses do not create separate ancestors.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionaries trace the extensions under one Greek and Latin lineage.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Sense history stays on one canonical node while dated journey stages show the later expansions.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/163","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/icon"},{"cursor":164,"id":164,"entryId":94,"entrySlug":"lay","title":"Are all English words spelled lay one historical word?","position":"No. The set-down verb is inherited from Old English lecgan; the poem noun and non-clerical adjective come through distinct French, Latin, and Greek histories.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage and Merriam-Webster separate the homonym entries and their etymologies.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"This dossier follows only the transitive verb and names the excluded homonyms explicitly.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/164","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/lay"},{"cursor":165,"id":165,"entryId":94,"entrySlug":"lay","title":"Are lay and lie simply the same verb?","position":"They are historically related but grammatically distinct inherited verbs: lay is transitive and causative, while lie is intransitive; lay is also the standard past tense of lie, which creates modern ambiguity.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage documents the historical relationship and the long-standing usage distinction.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph connects the word family without collapsing the modern lexemes or their grammatical roles.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/165","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/lay"},{"cursor":166,"id":166,"entryId":94,"entrySlug":"lay","title":"Is Proto-Germanic *lagojanan an attested form?","position":"No. It is a reconstruction printed by Etymonline; comparative evidence supports the family, while exact notation and intermediate morphology remain analytical.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Etymonline supplies the form and UT LRC supplies the comparative reflex set.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The asterisk and probable grade remain visible on the node and both adjacent edges.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/166","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/lay"},{"cursor":167,"id":167,"entryId":94,"entrySlug":"lay","title":"Does law descend from lay—or lay from law?","position":"Neither. They are lexical cousins whose lineages converge at reconstructed *legh-. Law reaches it through a Scandinavian nominal formation; lay reaches it through an inherited causative verb.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"UT LRC lists both law and lay reflexes in the legh- family.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The shared canonical root creates the connection without a false direct-parent edge.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/167","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/lay"},{"cursor":168,"id":168,"entryId":95,"entrySlug":"tapu","title":"Did English taboo come from Māori tapu?","position":"No. Merriam-Webster identifies Tongan tabu as the English donor. Māori tapu is a related Oceanic reflex, not the borrowing source.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The English dictionary names Tongan; POLLEX independently lists Māori and Tongan reflexes.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph joins the words only at reconstructed *tampu.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/168","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/tapu"},{"cursor":169,"id":169,"entryId":95,"entrySlug":"tapu","title":"Does tapu mean only “forbidden”?","position":"No. Te Aka defines a culturally specific field spanning sacredness, restriction, being set apart, prohibition, atua protection, and social or environmental responsibility.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Te Aka supplies the Māori semantic analysis and POLLEX supplies the wider comparative field.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier does not reduce tapu to its casual English loanword descendant.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/169","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/tapu"},{"cursor":170,"id":170,"entryId":96,"entrySlug":"kapu","title":"Is kapu merely a misspelling of tapu?","position":"No. Hawaiian kapu reflects a documented historical *t to k development; POLLEX lists it as the Hawaiian reflex of the same Oceanic family.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Blust documents the sound change and POLLEX supplies the lexical comparison.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph preserves distinct attested nodes and one shared reconstruction.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/170","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kapu"},{"cursor":171,"id":171,"entryId":96,"entrySlug":"kapu","title":"Did Hawaiian kapu directly give English taboo?","position":"No. English taboo is traced to Tongan tabu. Hawaiian kapu is a cognate reflex whose resemblance reveals family history, not the borrowing event.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster identifies Tongan while POLLEX distinguishes the Hawaiian reflex.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Connection without direct descent is made explicit.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/171","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kapu"},{"cursor":172,"id":172,"entryId":97,"entrySlug":"aguacate","title":"Does āhuacatl prove that the fruit was named after a testicle?","position":"No. The historical dictionaries establish that one Nahuatl word had fruit and anatomical senses; they do not establish which sense came first or motivated the other.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"RAE and UNAM independently document the polysemy without a direction-of-derivation claim.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The contrarian reveal is the documented fact plus the refusal to overclaim it.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/172","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/aguacate"},{"cursor":173,"id":173,"entryId":97,"entrySlug":"aguacate","title":"Can aguacate be securely pushed deeper than āhuacatl?","position":"Not from the reviewed sources. The institutional dictionaries reach the Nahuatl word and its historical witnesses but do not establish a deeper lexical ancestor.","confidence":"boundary","sourceSummary":"The cited records document the attested form rather than a deeper reconstruction.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The final node remains an explicit research boundary.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/173","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/aguacate"},{"cursor":174,"id":174,"entryId":98,"entrySlug":"qajaq","title":"Was Greenlandic qajaq the unique direct donor of English kayak?","position":"The reviewed English etymology says only Inuit qayaq. Greenlandic qajaq proves a living related form, but not one uniquely identified borrowing event.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster uses the broad label Inuit; Oqaasileriffik documents Greenlandic; the specialist article reconstructs the wider history.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The lexical family is joined while donor-variety precision remains unresolved.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/174","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/qajaq"},{"cursor":175,"id":175,"entryId":98,"entrySlug":"qajaq","title":"Is qajaq related to Turkish kayık because both words mean boat?","position":"No. The specialist philological study reconstructs independent Eskimo and Turkic histories and explicitly rejects genealogical or borrowing scenarios.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The article is devoted to testing and rejecting this exact comparison.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"A sourced context link records the seductive resemblance as non-ancestry.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/175","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/qajaq"},{"cursor":176,"id":176,"entryId":99,"entrySlug":"kayik","title":"Is Turkish kayık an Arctic borrowing related to qayaq?","position":"No. Old Turkic kayguk is documented centuries before the modern surface resemblance and belongs to a separate Turkic history.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The specialist study compares the philological records and rejects both genealogy and borrowing.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph keeps the two boat families disconnected.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/176","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kayik"},{"cursor":177,"id":177,"entryId":99,"entrySlug":"kayik","title":"Does kayguk continue *kad- “fir tree” or a *kay- “turn, bend” base?","position":"The reviewed article argues for a *kad- / *kad-ï analysis and discusses the older *kay- account. The historical kayguk stage is secure; the deeper derivation remains proposed.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"One specialist study presents and evaluates the competing Turkic analyses.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"Both analyses remain named; the linear dossier follows the article's preferred route at proposed confidence.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/177","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kayik"},{"cursor":178,"id":178,"entryId":100,"entrySlug":"cha-portuguese","title":"Was Portuguese chá borrowed specifically from Cantonese or from Mandarin?","position":"WALS gives a Cantonese cha route through Macao; Infopédia labels the source Mandarin chá. The shared cha-type Chinese family is secure, but the immediate variety label is not unanimous.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"A typological-historical source and Portuguese institutional dictionary disagree at the donor-variety level.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The graph follows the more historically specific Macao–Cantonese route at probable confidence and cites the challenge on the edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/178","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cha-portuguese"},{"cursor":179,"id":179,"entryId":100,"entrySlug":"cha-portuguese","title":"Does Portuguese chá disprove the sea-versus-land rule?","position":"It disproves the rule as a universal law, not the global tendency. Portuguese merchants used a maritime route yet Portuguese retained a cha-type form.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"WALS names Portuguese chá as an exception while still documenting the broad maritime te and overland cha distributions.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The leaderboard turns the exception into a lesson about probabilistic historical patterns.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/179","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cha-portuguese"},{"cursor":180,"id":180,"entryId":101,"entrySlug":"chay-persian","title":"When and how did Persian adopt čāy?","position":"The exact date and mechanism remain unknown. Iranica derives the word from Chinese ch’a but explicitly says the adoption event is uncertain.","confidence":"boundary","sourceSummary":"The strongest reviewed Persian reference separates etymological origin from an undocumented borrowing event.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"No fabricated caravan, intermediary language, or exact year is placed in the graph.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/180","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/chay-persian"},{"cursor":181,"id":181,"entryId":101,"entrySlug":"chay-persian","title":"Does Bīrūnī prove tea was already a common Persian drink in the 11th century?","position":"No. The report proves learned awareness and discussion of use in China and Tibet; Iranica says this does not establish broad Persian consumption at that time.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Iranica distinguishes early textual awareness from the later spread of tea in the Persian world.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The attestation is labeled a secondary report of awareness, not a Persian first-use token.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/181","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/chay-persian"},{"cursor":182,"id":182,"entryId":102,"entrySlug":"cay-turkish","title":"Was Turkish çay borrowed directly from Chinese?","position":"The ultimate source is Chinese, but Boz argues that Persian is the more credible bridge into historical Turkey Turkish. “From Chinese” is genealogically true and historically incomplete.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The Turkish scholarly study evaluates dictionary traditions and explicitly favors Persian as the bridge language.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The relation type names the Persian relay and retains probable confidence.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/182","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cay-turkish"},{"cursor":183,"id":183,"entryId":102,"entrySlug":"cay-turkish","title":"Can Turkish çay be assigned one exact borrowing date?","position":"Not from the reviewed evidence. The route can be argued more securely than a single adoption year.","confidence":"boundary","sourceSummary":"The current dictionary and diachronic semantic study document the word and its path without licensing one exact first token.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The journey stage keeps both date and point unresolved.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/183","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cay-turkish"},{"cursor":184,"id":184,"entryId":103,"entrySlug":"chay-russian","title":"Which Turkic language directly supplied Russian чай?","position":"Vasmer lists several Turkic comparanda and routes but does not reduce them to one uniquely established immediate donor.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionary explicitly preserves Turkish, Crimean Tatar, Tatar, Kyrgyz, Altai, Uyghur, and Mongolian comparisons.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The graph uses a Turkic-relay relation instead of a fabricated one-language parent.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/184","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/chay-russian"},{"cursor":185,"id":185,"entryId":103,"entrySlug":"chay-russian","title":"Is Russian чай simply a direct Chinese loan?","position":"No secure one-hop event is established. Vasmer’s etymology routes the word through Turkic-speaking networks before reaching Chinese ch’a.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Vasmer supplies the mediated chain; WALS supplies the broader overland distribution.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier distinguishes ultimate origin from transmission history.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/185","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/chay-russian"},{"cursor":186,"id":186,"entryId":104,"entrySlug":"chay-urdu","title":"Has Urdu always spelled the tea word چائے?","position":"No. Rekhta’s historical note reports older چا and چاہ spellings and says modern standard usage has largely converged on چائے.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The lexicographic note cites Abru, Shakespear’s 1834 dictionary, and later dictionaries while distinguishing modern standard usage.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Historical spelling evidence is preserved as attestations rather than invented ancestor nodes.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/186","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/chay-urdu"},{"cursor":187,"id":187,"entryId":104,"entrySlug":"chay-urdu","title":"Did Urdu receive cāy directly from Chinese or through Persian?","position":"Rekhta labels the current Urdu headword Persian in origin, while the wider references establish only the Chinese-derived overland family. Persian is therefore probable as the immediate source, not promoted as a uniquely dated event.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Urdu lexicography supplies the Persian label; WALS and Merriam-Webster supply the broader family context.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The edge encodes the overland family and states the probable Persian relay in its confidence note.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/187","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/chay-urdu"},{"cursor":188,"id":188,"entryId":105,"entrySlug":"etymos","title":"Is *setu-mo- the certain ancestor of ἔτυμος?","position":"No. The analysis is serious and published, but the exact morphology and wider *set-u- family remain debated.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Beekes, Etygram, and the independent synthesis publish the analysis while retaining uncertainty.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The asterisked nodes and proposed confidence remain visible on every reused edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/188","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymos"},{"cursor":189,"id":189,"entryId":105,"entrySlug":"etymos","title":"Did ἔτυμος itself mean the modern discipline etymology?","position":"No. It meant true, real, or actual; only its substantivized neuter developed a technical true-sense meaning, and ἐτυμολογία is a later compound.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"LSJ separates the adjectival and substantivized senses and dates the latter to later writers.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier makes the semantic and morphological steps separately clickable.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/189","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymos"},{"cursor":190,"id":190,"entryId":106,"entrySlug":"eteos","title":"Does ἐτεός securely prove *set-u-?","position":"It supports the proposal, but the reconstructed preform, ablaut, and suffixation are not directly attested or unanimous.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Etygram says probably; Beekes and Gális publish analyses while preserving uncertainty.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The path ends at a boundary instead of treating the reconstruction as a fossil spelling.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/190","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/eteos"},{"cursor":191,"id":191,"entryId":106,"entrySlug":"eteos","title":"Did Lydian contact cause the loss of initial aspiration?","position":"Gális presents Lydian contact only as a theoretical possibility, not an established cause of Greek psilosis.","confidence":"speculative","sourceSummary":"The thesis distinguishes the phonological observation from the contact explanation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The contact hypothesis remains in the dispute layer and is not encoded as a factual ancestry edge.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/191","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/eteos"},{"cursor":192,"id":192,"entryId":107,"entrySlug":"stoyg","title":"Is Armenian ստոյգ an uncontested cognate of ἔτυμος and ἐτεός?","position":"It is a published comparison that strengthens the *set-u- analysis, but the exact Armenian preform and common-base morphology remain proposed.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Martirosyan, Beekes, Etygram, and Gális preserve the comparison at different levels of detail.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The graph connects the branches at proposed confidence and stops before a fabricated certainty.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/192","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/stoyg"},{"cursor":193,"id":193,"entryId":107,"entrySlug":"stoyg","title":"Is classical ստոյգ identical to the modern written form?","position":"The lexeme continues, but modern Eastern Armenian normally writes ստույգ; the dossier displays the classical form because that is the comparative form in the historical literature.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Calfa preserves the classical headword and the modern continuation is recorded separately.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Orthographic chronology is disclosed in the form note rather than erased.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/193","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/stoyg"},{"cursor":194,"id":194,"entryId":108,"entrySlug":"etymon","title":"Must an etymon be the deepest reconstructable root?","position":"No. Merriam-Webster defines it as an earlier same-language or ancestral form, a foreign loan source, or a word or morpheme used in composition or derivation.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The modern technical definition is broader than “ultimate root.”","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The truth claim uses the dictionary’s full definition rather than a simplified slogan.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/194","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymon"},{"cursor":195,"id":195,"entryId":108,"entrySlug":"etymon","title":"Are etyma and etymons both permitted plurals?","position":"Yes. Merriam-Webster records etyma and etymons, with etyma preserving the learned Greek-style plural.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Current lexicography records both forms.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Both variants remain visible as cited relatives.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/195","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymon"},{"cursor":196,"id":196,"entryId":109,"entrySlug":"etymologie-french","title":"Did the c. 1175 French witness already mean modern linguistic science?","position":"No. CNRTL treats the earliest records as a title reference and contextual wordplay distinct from the modern scientific sense.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The updated CNRTL history separates early witnesses from the 1529 filiation sense and the 1756 generalized research sense.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Journey stages and witness notes keep spelling attestation separate from semantic identity.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/196","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymologie-french"},{"cursor":197,"id":197,"entryId":109,"entrySlug":"etymologie-french","title":"When did French étymologie become the name of a science?","position":"CNRTL reports a generalized research sense from 1756 but notes that the word continued to be called an art; it reports an explicit science definition only in 1836.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical notice supplies separate dates for the research sense and science label.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier resists assigning one false birth date to a discipline that stabilized in stages.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/197","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymologie-french"},{"cursor":198,"id":198,"entryId":110,"entrySlug":"etetymos","title":"Is ἐτήτυμος a deeper ancestor of ἔτυμος?","position":"No. LSJ classifies it as a poetic reduplicated form for ἔτυμος, not an older proto-form from which ἔτυμος descends.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionary labels the morphological relation directly.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical edge points from the longer poetic form to the shorter base and keeps the separate reconstructed path below it.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/198","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etetymos"},{"cursor":199,"id":199,"entryId":110,"entrySlug":"etetymos","title":"Does the reduplicated form make *set-u- certain?","position":"No. ἐτήτυμος is attested, but the *setu-mo- and *set-u- stages beneath ἔτυμος remain reconstructed and disputed.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"LSJ secures the Greek relationship; Beekes and later synthesis supply the separately graded prehistoric analysis.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"Attested reduplication and proposed ancestry keep different confidence classes.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/199","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etetymos"},{"cursor":200,"id":200,"entryId":111,"entrySlug":"etymon-french","title":"Did French borrow étymon through Latin or directly from Greek?","position":"CNRTL names Latin etymon as the immediate donor; the Académie calls the French word a learned borrowing from Greek. The graph preserves the Latin route as probable, not certain.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Two institutional reference works describe the immediate borrowing route differently.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The competing source stance stays attached to the borrowing edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/200","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymon-french"},{"cursor":201,"id":201,"entryId":111,"entrySlug":"etymon-french","title":"Must a French étymon be directly attested?","position":"No. Both CNRTL and the Académie explicitly define the explanatory form as attested or reconstructed/hypothetical.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The two definitions independently preserve this core methodological distinction.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier can therefore point to a reconstructed form without presenting that form as attested.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/201","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymon-french"},{"cursor":202,"id":202,"entryId":112,"entrySlug":"etymologique-french","title":"Was French étymologique created from French étymologie?","position":"The transparent modern relationship does not describe the reported historical route. Both French references call étymologique a borrowing from Latin etymologicus.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"CNRTL and the Académie independently name the immediate Latin donor.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical lineage begins with a borrowing edge rather than an unsupported internal French derivation.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/202","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymologique-french"},{"cursor":203,"id":203,"entryId":112,"entrySlug":"etymologique-french","title":"Did the word first name modern historical linguistics?","position":"No. CNRTL’s earliest source-reported use around 1550 concerns compound names said to reveal their true sense; the current analytical sense is broader.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical notice separates the early phrase from the current definition.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic shift is exposed on the French borrowing edge and in the dated witness.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/203","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymologique-french"},{"cursor":204,"id":204,"entryId":112,"entrySlug":"etymologique-french","title":"Can the Greek-to-Latin adjective transfer be dated to one event?","position":"Not from the reviewed sources. Merriam-Webster establishes Greek etymologikos behind Latin etymologicus, while CNRTL documents late Latin use in Diomedes; neither identifies one precisely dated borrowing event.","confidence":"boundary","sourceSummary":"The donor chain is stronger than the event chronology.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The journey retains two unresolved stages instead of manufacturing a year or a map pin.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/204","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymologique-french"},{"cursor":205,"id":205,"entryId":113,"entrySlug":"etymological","title":"How was English etymological formed?","position":"Merriam-Webster analyzes etymologic from Latin etymologicus and etymological as etymologic + -al; Etymonline analyzes etymology + -ical.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Two reviewed historical dictionaries publish different segmentations.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The canonical dossier uses the explicit Latin-adjective route while the graph exposes the competing internal derivation.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/205","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymological"},{"cursor":206,"id":206,"entryId":113,"entrySlug":"etymological","title":"Does the English record begin in 1588 or the 1590s?","position":"The reports differ slightly: Merriam-Webster gives 1588 and Etymonline gives the 1590s. Neither date proves the word was coined then.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The earliest currently located written record can change as scholarship finds earlier evidence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"Both reports and the evidence limit remain visible pending direct witness inspection.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/206","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymological"},{"cursor":207,"id":207,"entryId":113,"entrySlug":"etymological","title":"Does etymological mean correct because of a word’s origin?","position":"No. Etymology is a word’s historical development, distinct from its current definition; origin does not legislate present meaning.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster’s methodological FAQ separates etymology from definition.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The contrarian truth rejects the etymological fallacy rather than treating a past sense as the real one.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/207","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymological"},{"cursor":208,"id":208,"entryId":114,"entrySlug":"etymologist","title":"Does the specialist title begin in 1604 or the 1630s?","position":"Merriam-Webster reports 1604; Etymonline reports the 1630s. These are different source horizons, not necessarily irreconcilable claims about the same underlying object.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Two reviewed references give different earliest-record labels.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The timeline spans both and discloses that no primary token was inspected.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/208","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymologist"},{"cursor":209,"id":209,"entryId":114,"entrySlug":"etymologist","title":"Is -ist part of the ancestry of etymology itself?","position":"No. -ist creates the English person-label etymologist; the base etymology has its own older French, Latin, and Greek ancestry.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The suffix reference defines the agent-forming function and the word entries identify the base formation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph branches at etymologist into a lexical-base trail and an affix trail.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/209","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymologist"},{"cursor":210,"id":210,"entryId":114,"entrySlug":"etymologist","title":"Was an etymologist an ancient Greek professional title?","position":"No. The English agent noun is reported only from the Early Modern period, though its base ultimately contains Greek material.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The English first-record sources and the Greek base history belong to different chronological layers.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier prevents component meaning from becoming a fabricated ancient occupation.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/210","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymologist"},{"cursor":211,"id":211,"entryId":115,"entrySlug":"etymologize","title":"Does etymologize begin in 1532 or the 1530s?","position":"The reports are compatible at different precision: Merriam-Webster gives 1532 and Etymonline gives the 1530s.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"An exact year falls inside the published decade range.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Both locators remain attached to the same derived English edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/211","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymologize"},{"cursor":212,"id":212,"entryId":115,"entrySlug":"etymologize","title":"Did the transitive and intransitive senses appear together?","position":"Not in the reviewed record. Transitive use is reported in the 1530s; Etymonline places the intransitive study-or-practice use in the 1650s.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical entry distinguishes the two grammatical histories.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Separate journey stages preserve the semantic chronology.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/212","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymologize"},{"cursor":213,"id":213,"entryId":115,"entrySlug":"etymologize","title":"Did English borrow etymologize directly from French or Medieval Latin?","position":"The reviewed entry forms English etymologize from etymology + -ize and merely compares French étymologiser and Medieval Latin etymologisare. Comparison alone does not prove direct borrowing.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The source’s grammar distinguishes its formation claim from its comparanda.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The comparanda are relatives, not parent nodes.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/213","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/etymologize"},{"cursor":214,"id":214,"entryId":116,"entrySlug":"word","title":"Was English word borrowed from Latin verbum?","position":"No. English word is inherited through Old English and Germanic; Latin verbum is an akin or cognate branch under the shared speaking root, not the donor.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage distinguish direct ancestry from the comparative Latin branch.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph joins word and verbum only at reconstruction and never draws a Latin-to-English borrowing edge.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/214","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/word"},{"cursor":215,"id":215,"entryId":116,"entrySlug":"word","title":"Is *werh1- an attested first human word?","position":"No. The asterisk marks a comparative reconstruction, and the reviewed source stops at the speaking root rather than identifying any spoken first word.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage explicitly presents the root and suffixed forms as reconstructed.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier ends at a knowledge boundary after the starred root.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/215","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/word"},{"cursor":216,"id":216,"entryId":117,"entrySlug":"verb","title":"Did verb always mean only the grammatical class?","position":"No. Latin verbum broadly meant word, utterance, expression, language, or discourse and also developed the specialized grammatical sense.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Lewis and Short publish the broad senses and a separately numbered grammatical use.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Two sense-specific Latin nodes preserve the specialization.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/216","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/verb"},{"cursor":217,"id":217,"entryId":117,"entrySlug":"verb","title":"Did English take verb directly from Latin?","position":"The reviewed route is Middle English from Anglo-French from Latin, not a one-hop direct Latin borrowing.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster explicitly names both donor stages.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier keeps the Anglo-French node instead of compressing it away.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/217","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/verb"},{"cursor":218,"id":218,"entryId":118,"entrySlug":"verbal","title":"Does verbal historically mean only spoken rather than written?","position":"No. The oldest structural center is Latin verbum plus -alis, of or relating to words; the spoken contrast is one later English sense among several.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster places word-related senses before and beside the spoken-language sense.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic-change record preserves plurality instead of choosing one supposedly true meaning.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/218","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/verbal"},{"cursor":219,"id":219,"entryId":118,"entrySlug":"verbal","title":"Is -al the lexical ancestor of verbal?","position":"No. Latin -alis is a derivational component of verbalis; the lexical base verbum and the suffix have separate graph branches.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The word history explicitly analyzes verbum plus -alis.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The main ancestry follows verbum while a canonical component edge exposes -alis.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/219","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/verbal"},{"cursor":220,"id":220,"entryId":119,"entrySlug":"adverb","title":"Does an adverb only modify a verb?","position":"No. Modern adverbs can modify verbs, adjectives, other adverbs, prepositions, phrases, clauses, or entire sentences.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster enumerates the wider modifier scope.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier rejects a definition inferred only from the visible name.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/220","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/adverb"},{"cursor":221,"id":221,"entryId":119,"entrySlug":"adverb","title":"Is adverb built from the English verb add?","position":"No. Latin adverbium contains the directional prefix ad-, from the Indo-European ad- base, plus verbum. English add is not a component.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster supplies the Latin compound and American Heritage supplies the deeper ad- base.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The component graph makes the historical prefix independently traversable.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/221","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/adverb"},{"cursor":222,"id":222,"entryId":120,"entrySlug":"proverb","title":"Are proverb and pro-verb the same historical word?","position":"No. Proverb, the traditional saying, is recorded from the fourteenth century through Latin proverbium; pro-verb, a grammatical substitute, is separately dated to 1907.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"One dictionary entry explicitly separates the three headword senses and their dates.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The hyphenated form remains a relative, not an ancestor node.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/222","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/proverb"},{"cursor":223,"id":223,"entryId":120,"entrySlug":"proverb","title":"What exactly did pro- contribute to Latin proverbium?","position":"The pro- plus verbum structure is secure, but the reviewed sources do not force one modern gloss for the prefix’s semantic contribution inside the inherited saying term.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster supplies the compound analysis; American Heritage publishes the unusually broad semantic field of per-1 and Latin pro-.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/223","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/proverb"},{"cursor":224,"id":224,"entryId":121,"entrySlug":"verbatim","title":"Did verbatim enter English as an adjective?","position":"No. Merriam-Webster reports the adverb in the fifteenth century and the adjective in 1613.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The entry separates parts of speech and first-known-use horizons.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier headword is modeled first as an adverb and retains the later adjective as semantic history.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/224","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/verbatim"},{"cursor":225,"id":225,"entryId":121,"entrySlug":"verbatim","title":"Does verbatim mean one isolated word?","position":"No. Its Medieval Latin formation and older Latin phrase family express distributive exactness: word by word.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster gives verbum plus -atim; Lewis and Short document ad verbum and verbum pro verbo.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph follows the word noun while the suffix branch explains the adverbial distribution.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/225","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/verbatim"},{"cursor":226,"id":226,"entryId":122,"entrySlug":"true","title":"Did true originally mean only factually correct?","position":"No. The reviewed English history foregrounds faithful, steadfast, loyal, and trustworthy senses before and beside modern factual accuracy.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster gives Old English trēowe “faithful,” and American Heritage explicitly traces the loyalty field.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier retains semantic plurality instead of declaring the current factual sense false.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/226","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/true"},{"cursor":227,"id":227,"entryId":122,"entrySlug":"true","title":"Does true descend from tree?","position":"No. True and tree are parallel descendants in different branches that meet at reconstructed *deru-; the modern tree noun is not a parent of true.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage explicitly says the words are joined at the root and publishes separate Germanic formations.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph shares only the deep root and draws no tree-to-true ancestry edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/227","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/true"},{"cursor":228,"id":228,"entryId":123,"entrySlug":"truth","title":"Was truth first only correspondence with fact?","position":"No. Merriam-Webster reports the earliest located English use under fidelity or constancy, while modern truth also covers factual correspondence.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionary separately identifies the archaic early sense and present definitions.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic record treats fidelity as history without using etymology to erase the current meaning.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/228","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/truth"},{"cursor":229,"id":229,"entryId":123,"entrySlug":"truth","title":"Is *deru- a written ancestral word?","position":"No. The asterisk marks a reconstructed comparative form rather than an attested token.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage publishes *deru-, *treuwaz, and *treuwithō as reconstructed forms.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The trail ends at a boundary after the starred root.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/229","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/truth"},{"cursor":230,"id":230,"entryId":124,"entrySlug":"trust","title":"Was the exact donor of trust Old Norse traust?","position":"Probably Scandinavian, perhaps Old Norse traust, but the reviewed authorities do not present the precise donor as certain.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster says probably Scandinavian; American Heritage says perhaps Old Norse.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/230","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/trust"},{"cursor":231,"id":231,"entryId":124,"entrySlug":"trust","title":"Did trust begin as a legal property arrangement?","position":"No. The historical noun centers on confidence and reliance; legal trust is one later semantic institution within the word’s wider range.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Both dictionaries place confidence and reliance in the inherited semantic core.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier does not mistake one prominent modern legal sense for the donor meaning.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/231","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/trust"},{"cursor":232,"id":232,"entryId":125,"entrySlug":"troth","title":"Is troth a poetic modern invention?","position":"No. Troth continues a Middle English and Old English fidelity noun and is reported in English from the twelfth century.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage both publish the inherited history.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The rare modern register does not make the word historically recent.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/232","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/troth"},{"cursor":233,"id":233,"entryId":125,"entrySlug":"troth","title":"Has troth always meant only a marriage promise?","position":"No. Its reported meanings include fidelity, loyalty, good faith, pledged word, and betrothal.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The reviewed definitions and etymology retain the broader truth-and-fidelity field.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The marriage sense is modeled as one specialization rather than the whole ancestry.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/233","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/troth"},{"cursor":234,"id":234,"entryId":126,"entrySlug":"betroth","title":"Is betroth built on truth or troth?","position":"The historical base is Middle English trouth or trouthe, where the modern truth and troth spellings were not yet cleanly separated; mapping it to only one modern headword overstates the evidence.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster glosses the base as truth or troth; American Heritage gives trouth and routes it through troth.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/234","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/betroth"},{"cursor":235,"id":235,"entryId":126,"entrySlug":"betroth","title":"Is the be- in betroth the verb be?","position":"No. It is the historical prefix bi- or be-, related to Old English bi- or be- and bī “by, near,” not the copular verb.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The betroth entries identify a prefix, and Merriam-Webster separately publishes the prefix history.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"A second graph branch exposes the prefix and prevents a false copular-be analysis.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/235","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/betroth"},{"cursor":236,"id":236,"entryId":127,"entrySlug":"truce","title":"Was truce borrowed from French?","position":"No. The reviewed history continues Middle English trewes from Old English trēow “fidelity” inside an inherited Germanic pledge branch.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage publish the English and Germanic route.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No French donor edge is drawn.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/236","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/truce"},{"cursor":237,"id":237,"entryId":127,"entrySlug":"truce","title":"Was truce historically singular all the way back?","position":"No. Modern singular truce continues Middle English trewes, explicitly analyzed as a plural of trewe “agreement.”","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Both reviewed dictionaries identify the plural form.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph records inflectional reanalysis instead of silently skipping from trewe to truce.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/237","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/truce"},{"cursor":238,"id":238,"entryId":128,"entrySlug":"tree","title":"Is tree the literal ancestor of true?","position":"No. Tree and true share the reconstructed *deru- family but travel through different Germanic formations and different senses.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage’s word history and root appendix publish the parallel branches.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins them at *deru- only.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/238","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/tree"},{"cursor":239,"id":239,"entryId":128,"entrySlug":"tree","title":"Did *deru- mean only tree or wood?","position":"No. The published reconstructed semantic range begins with being firm, solid, or steadfast and extends to wood and tree.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The American Heritage root heading explicitly supplies both semantic fields.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier preserves a semantic range rather than inventing one “literal true meaning.”","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/239","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/tree"},{"cursor":240,"id":240,"entryId":129,"entrySlug":"right","title":"Did right begin only as a moral judgment?","position":"No. The reviewed history joins straight, correct, just, proper, and directional senses inside one inherited family.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster compares Latin rectus, straight or right, and American Heritage preserves a concrete straight sense beside justice and correctness.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier records semantic plurality instead of replacing the modern moral sense with a geometric slogan.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/240","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/right"},{"cursor":241,"id":241,"entryId":129,"entrySlug":"right","title":"Is political right the prehistoric source of the word?","position":"No. American Heritage treats the political sense as a later seating-based development in legislative assemblies.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The headword etymology separately notes the historical seating explanation for the political noun.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The political branch is not projected into the reconstructed straight-and-direct root.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/241","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/right"},{"cursor":242,"id":242,"entryId":130,"entrySlug":"rule","title":"Was rule always only an abstract command?","position":"No. Latin rēgula meant a straightedge or ruler as well as a rule, and the physical measuring sense survives in English.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Both dictionaries publish the straightedge or rod history and current measuring senses.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The abstract and physical branches remain visible without claiming one modern sense is false.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/242","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/rule"},{"cursor":243,"id":243,"entryId":130,"entrySlug":"rule","title":"Does rule descend directly from English right?","position":"No. They are deep cousins: rule comes through French and Latin rēgula, while right follows Germanic *rehtaz.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage publishes separate *rēg-olā- and *reg-to- branches under the same root.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph joins the branches only at *h₃reg-.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/243","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/rule"},{"cursor":244,"id":244,"entryId":131,"entrySlug":"regular","title":"Did regular originally mean statistically normal?","position":"No. The reported medieval sense centers on living under or according to a rule; ordinary and standard are later extensions.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage glosses Middle English reguler as living under religious rule, and Merriam-Webster gives the rule lineage.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier retains modern normality while exposing the earlier rule-centered stage.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/244","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/regular"},{"cursor":245,"id":245,"entryId":131,"entrySlug":"regular","title":"Is regular unrelated to a physical ruler?","position":"No. Its Late Latin adjective descends from rēgula, whose older semantic range includes a bar, rod, or straightedge.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Both dictionaries route the adjective through Latin rēgula.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The connection is modeled through the historical noun, not as a folk resemblance.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/245","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/regular"},{"cursor":246,"id":246,"entryId":132,"entrySlug":"regulate","title":"Did regulate begin only as a legal-government word?","position":"No. The reported meanings include govern, direct, order, and adjust; legal control is one major branch.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster documents governance, ordering, rate adjustment, and control senses.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier does not reduce the word to modern administrative regulation.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/246","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/regulate"},{"cursor":247,"id":247,"entryId":132,"entrySlug":"regulate","title":"Does regulate jump directly from the root meaning rule?","position":"No. The reviewed route passes through Latin rēgula, Late Latin regulāre, and its participle regulātus.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster explicitly publishes the morphological chain.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every intermediate formation remains a clickable node.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/247","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/regulate"},{"cursor":248,"id":248,"entryId":133,"entrySlug":"royal","title":"Are royal and right unrelated lookalikes?","position":"No. They are not close derivatives of each other, but both occupy documented branches under the reconstructed straight-and-direct root.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster cross-references right from royal, and the root appendix publishes the king and right branches.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph shows deep cousinhood and no false royal-to-right edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/248","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/royal"},{"cursor":249,"id":249,"entryId":133,"entrySlug":"royal","title":"Did royal first mean magnificent rather than monarchical?","position":"No. The reported ancestry and first English sense are monarch-centered; magnificence is a semantic extension.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage define and derive the adjective from the king family.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The modern evaluative sense remains visible as an extension.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/249","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/royal"},{"cursor":250,"id":250,"entryId":134,"entrySlug":"regal","title":"Which medieval channel delivered regal into English?","position":"The Latin source is secure, but the immediate channel remains plural in the reviewed authorities: American Heritage gives Old French, while Merriam-Webster allows Anglo-French or Latin.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The two dictionaries publish different levels of specificity for the immediate borrowing route.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/250","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/regal"},{"cursor":251,"id":251,"entryId":134,"entrySlug":"regal","title":"Are regal and royal the same English borrowing?","position":"No. They are separate medieval English arrivals that converge on Latin rēgālis and rēx.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionaries give different English and French forms but the same Latin king adjective.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph keeps distinct headword paths and shared Latin nodes.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/251","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/regal"},{"cursor":252,"id":252,"entryId":135,"entrySlug":"realm","title":"Is realm simply a shortened form of royal?","position":"No. Realm descends through a government noun from Latin regimen, but its medieval form was altered under the influence of the royal adjective.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster supplies reiame and regimen; American Heritage explicitly identifies influence from Old French reial.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"An analogical side edge records influence without replacing the main lineage.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/252","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/realm"},{"cursor":253,"id":253,"entryId":135,"entrySlug":"realm","title":"Did realm always mean any abstract sphere?","position":"No. Its oldest reported English horizon is kingdom; sphere, domain, and biogeographic meanings are extensions.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster gives the thirteenth-century kingdom sense and current broader definitions.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic history proceeds from governed territory to generalized domain.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/253","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/realm"},{"cursor":254,"id":254,"entryId":136,"entrySlug":"rich","title":"Did rich reach Middle English only through Old English or only through French?","position":"The shared deep ancestry is secure, but the immediate medieval history is convergent: Merriam-Webster foregrounds Old English, while American Heritage explicitly gives both Old French and Old English.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The authorities differ in immediate-route emphasis while agreeing that the forms belong to the same Germanic/Celtic king-and-power family.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/254","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/rich"},{"cursor":255,"id":255,"entryId":136,"entrySlug":"rich","title":"Did rich originally mean only possessing money?","position":"No. Old English rīce is glossed strong or powerful, and the wider family centers on rule and kingship before the modern abundance field.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage supplies strong and powerful; Merriam-Webster connects the Germanic words with Celtic king vocabulary.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Older power does not invalidate modern wealth; it explains the semantic path.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/255","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/rich"},{"cursor":256,"id":256,"entryId":137,"entrySlug":"direct","title":"Did direct originally mean only immediate or unmediated?","position":"No. The recorded history foregrounds straightening, guiding, pointing, and directing; immediacy is one later semantic branch.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage preserve both straight-course and guidance senses alongside immediacy.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier keeps all major functions and does not declare the oldest meaning the only true one.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/256","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/direct"},{"cursor":257,"id":257,"entryId":137,"entrySlug":"direct","title":"Did every English function arrive through one identical medieval route?","position":"No. Merriam-Webster routes the verb and adverb through Anglo-French directer while giving the adjective from Latin directus.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionary separates the etymology by part of speech.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph preserves the main verb path and a separate adjective borrowing edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/257","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/direct"},{"cursor":258,"id":258,"entryId":138,"entrySlug":"ri","title":"Was Old Irish rí borrowed from Latin rēx?","position":"No. The comparative evidence derives Old Irish rí and Latin rēx as cognates in separate Celtic and Italic branches.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Cambridge derives Old Irish rí from Proto-Celtic *rīx-s; the Texas introduction compares the inherited Celtic vowel with Latin rēx.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No Latin-to-Irish borrowing edge is drawn.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/258","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/ri"},{"cursor":259,"id":259,"entryId":138,"entrySlug":"ri","title":"Did Old Irish rí directly become English rich?","position":"No. They are related through different Celtic formations: rí continues *rīx-s, while rich travels through the derivative *rīg-yo- borrowed into Germanic.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Cambridge supplies the rí branch; the American Heritage root appendix supplies the rich borrowing route.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The paths meet at the king grade without a false rí-to-rich edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/259","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/ri"},{"cursor":260,"id":260,"entryId":139,"entrySlug":"raja","title":"Did English royal descend from Sanskrit rājā?","position":"No. Sanskrit rājā and Latin rēx are cognates in separate Indo-Aryan and Italic branches under the same reconstructed king grade.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage explicitly places Sanskrit rājā, Latin rēx, and Celtic material under the wider root.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins the branches only at reconstructed ancestry.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/260","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/raja"},{"cursor":261,"id":261,"entryId":139,"entrySlug":"raja","title":"Is rājā the lexical stem of the Sanskrit noun?","position":"Not exactly. Rājā is the nominative singular; the consonant stem is rājan-, which appears across the paradigm and compounds.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Monier-Williams distinguishes rāja and rājan; Wiese lists rājan as the king noun.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier makes the inflectional step clickable instead of hiding it in prose.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/261","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/raja"},{"cursor":262,"id":262,"entryId":140,"entrySlug":"woman","title":"Does woman come from womb plus man?","position":"No. The historical form is Old English wīfman, built from wīf, woman or wife, and mann, human being or person.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage independently publish the two Old English components.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph exposes both real components and creates no womb edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/262","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/woman"},{"cursor":263,"id":263,"entryId":140,"entrySlug":"woman","title":"Did man inside wīfman already mean only an adult male?","position":"No. In this compound man carries its older human-being or person sense.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Both reviewed dictionaries gloss the second component as human being or person.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The woman and man dossiers share the exact Old English human-person node.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/263","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/woman"},{"cursor":264,"id":264,"entryId":141,"entrySlug":"man","title":"Did Old English man mean only an adult male?","position":"No. Its principal older sense was human being or person; wer and wīf could mark the sex distinction.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage gives the Old English semantic distribution and Merriam-Webster preserves human-being ancestry.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier retains both the generic and later male-specific senses.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/264","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/man"},{"cursor":265,"id":265,"entryId":141,"entrySlug":"man","title":"Is man derived from the Indo-European think root?","position":"Not in the reviewed American Heritage analysis. It publishes man-¹, human being, separately from men-¹, to think.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The root appendix separates the entries and their reflexes.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No graph edge merges the two roots merely because modern explanations sometimes associate humanity with thought.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/265","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/man"},{"cursor":266,"id":266,"entryId":142,"entrySlug":"female","title":"Was female formed by adding fe- to male?","position":"No. Female continues Latin fēmella through French; male only influenced its later English spelling.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Both dictionaries explicitly distinguish ancestry from analogical spelling influence.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The only female-to-male graph edge is typed analogical_influence, never inheritance.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/266","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/female"},{"cursor":267,"id":267,"entryId":142,"entrySlug":"female","title":"Does the suckle root give the true modern definition of female?","position":"No. It is a proposed comparative analysis of the Latin word’s deep formation, not a timeless or prescriptive definition of people.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The root appendix supplies reconstructed morphology, while the dictionaries document later lexical meanings.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The reveal states the historical formation without turning origin into essence.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/267","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/female"},{"cursor":268,"id":268,"entryId":143,"entrySlug":"male","title":"Does male come from mal-, bad?","position":"No. Male comes through French from Latin masculus and mās; mal- comes from a different Latin family headed by malus, bad.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster publishes the two independent histories.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph has no mal- ancestry edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/268","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/male"},{"cursor":269,"id":269,"entryId":143,"entrySlug":"male","title":"Do male and female share one historical root?","position":"No. They have different Latin ancestries. Their modern visual pairing comes partly from male reshaping female’s English spelling.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The male and female headword histories publish separate Latin sources and direct spelling influence.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"A cross-dossier influence edge preserves the contact without merging their families.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/269","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/male"},{"cursor":270,"id":270,"entryId":144,"entrySlug":"human","title":"Does human descend directly from Latin humus, soil?","position":"No. Latin homō and humus are sibling reflexes analyzed under the earth root; hūmānus belongs to the homō family.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster links hūmānus with homō; the root appendix separately lists homō and humus under dhghem-.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins human and humus only at reconstructed ancestry.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/270","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/human"},{"cursor":271,"id":271,"entryId":144,"entrySlug":"human","title":"Was earthling an attested original word for human?","position":"No. Earthling is a modern gloss for reconstructed *(dh)ghom-on-, not a surviving Proto-Indo-European inscription.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage marks the formation with an asterisk and derives Latin homō from it.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every reconstructed node remains visibly starred and the trail ends at an explicit boundary.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/271","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/human"},{"cursor":272,"id":272,"entryId":145,"entrySlug":"person","title":"Does persōna securely mean a mask through which sound passes?","position":"No secure reviewed etymology derives it as Latin per plus sonāre. The historical sources instead report a probable Etruscan connection and treat the origin as difficult.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The major dictionaries and classical reference favor or discuss phersu; the scholarly review keeps the problem open.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The product surfaces the familiar sound-through account only as a rejected or unsupported certainty claim.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/272","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/person"},{"cursor":273,"id":273,"entryId":145,"entrySlug":"person","title":"Is persona to phersu to prosōpon one certain chain?","position":"No. Latin persōna to Etruscan phersu is probable in major references, while the deeper Greek comparison is proposed and contested.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster prints the fuller route; Oxford supports the Etruscan candidate; Di Napoli reviews the unresolved evidence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The graph uses two uncertainty grades rather than flattening the route into fact.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/273","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/person"},{"cursor":274,"id":274,"entryId":146,"entrySlug":"lord","title":"Was lord originally a divine title?","position":"No. The recorded ancestry leads to Old English hlāford, a household compound of loaf and guardian.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage independently publish the compound and its components.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Later religious and aristocratic uses do not erase the household formation.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/274","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/lord"},{"cursor":275,"id":275,"entryId":146,"entrySlug":"lord","title":"Does loaf guardian prove that every hlāford literally distributed bread?","position":"No. The morphology is established; a literal social ritual for every speaker and use is not.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionaries publish the compound while the word history describes a household master.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface separates lexical morphology from an overconfident reconstruction of daily practice.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/275","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/lord"},{"cursor":276,"id":276,"entryId":147,"entrySlug":"lady","title":"Is lady simply the female form of lord?","position":"No. The histories share hlāf, loaf, but hlǣfdige has a kneading element where hlāford has guardian.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The two headword etymologies independently identify distinct second components.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The shared canonical loaf node joins the words without collapsing their formations.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/276","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/lady"},{"cursor":277,"id":277,"entryId":147,"entrySlug":"lady","title":"Does loaf kneader define the timeless nature of a lady?","position":"No. It is historical compound morphology, not a biological or prescriptive definition of women.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster describes the household title and warns against reducing it to a literal baker in every use.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier presents semantic history without turning etymology into essence.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/277","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/lady"},{"cursor":278,"id":278,"entryId":148,"entrySlug":"husband","title":"Is husband a native English kinship term built from house plus band?","position":"No. English borrowed a Norse householder compound: hūs plus bōndi or būandi. Band is not a component.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Both dictionaries publish the Norse borrowing and the actual two components.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph exposes house and householder and creates no band edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/278","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/husband"},{"cursor":279,"id":279,"entryId":148,"entrySlug":"husband","title":"Did husband originally mean only a married man?","position":"No. The earlier center was householder or master of a house; household and spouse senses overlapped before the modern specialization.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage explicitly explains the house-master and spouse overlap.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic-change fields preserve the narrowing rather than projecting the modern relation backward.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/279","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/husband"},{"cursor":280,"id":280,"entryId":149,"entrySlug":"wife","title":"Did wife always mean only a female spouse?","position":"No. Old English wīf and Middle English wif could mean woman as well as wife.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage publish the older forms; the woman compound independently preserves the woman sense.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The wife dossier shares its Old English node with the first component of woman.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/280","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/wife"},{"cursor":281,"id":281,"entryId":149,"entrySlug":"wife","title":"Is Tocharian B kwīpe the direct ancestor of wife?","position":"No direct ancestry is established. Merriam-Webster calls the comparison probable, while the secure reviewed line stops at Old English wīf.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"One dictionary reports the Tocharian comparison and another stops at the Old English horizon.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"Kwīpe is a side comparison with its own boundary, never the parent in the dossier spine.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/281","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/wife"},{"cursor":282,"id":282,"entryId":150,"entrySlug":"girl","title":"Did Middle English girl mean only a female child?","position":"No. Girle could denote a child or young person of either sex and could even be specified as a boy.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and the Middle English Dictionary independently document the broader medieval field.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic edge records narrowing without claiming a single instant of change.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/282","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/girl"},{"cursor":283,"id":283,"entryId":150,"entrySlug":"girl","title":"Does girl have a securely known Old English ancestor?","position":"No. American Heritage labels the origin unknown; the Middle English Dictionary marks *gyrela and a gierela garment comparison as uncertain.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The reviewed sources agree on the secure Middle English horizon but differ in how much tentative prehistory to display.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"Both proposals remain graph-only and end at separate evidence boundaries.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/283","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/girl"},{"cursor":284,"id":284,"entryId":151,"entrySlug":"boy","title":"Did boy begin as the ordinary word for a male child?","position":"Not exclusively. American Heritage records Middle English boi as male servant, churl, and young male.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The headword history documents a wider and more status-marked medieval semantic field.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier does not pretend one gloss exhausted the medieval word.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/284","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/boy"},{"cursor":285,"id":285,"entryId":151,"entrySlug":"boy","title":"Does boy securely descend from a word for ox hide?","position":"No. American Heritage offers a possible chain through a fettered person, fetter, Latin restraint collar, and Greek ox hide; Oxford labels the origin unknown.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The long internal route is published, but the first connection to Middle English boi remains disputed.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"Every later edge can be inspected without upgrading the initial proposed borrowing.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/285","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/boy"},{"cursor":286,"id":286,"entryId":152,"entrySlug":"loaf","title":"Does the bread noun loaf come from the verb meaning to idle?","position":"No. The inherited noun continues Middle English lof and Old English hlāf; the idle verb is a later probable back-formation from loafer.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage publish separate histories for the noun and verb.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier promotes only the inherited bread noun and keeps the homonymous verb in the dispute record.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/286","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/loaf"},{"cursor":287,"id":287,"entryId":152,"entrySlug":"loaf","title":"Does loaf have a securely established Indo-European root?","position":"Not in the reviewed evidence. *Hlaibaz is reconstructed as Proto-Germanic, while a shared European substrate source with Greek baking-vessel words is introduced only as perhaps.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"American Heritage distinguishes the Germanic reconstruction from a tentative substrate comparison.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The main spine ends at an explicit boundary; the Greek forms remain graph-only proposed comparisons.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/287","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/loaf"},{"cursor":288,"id":288,"entryId":153,"entrySlug":"wib-old-high-german","title":"Was Old High German wīb already the modern German insult?","position":"The sources do not license that projection. Duden marks modern Weib increasingly discriminatory, while Old High German records preserve wīb in ordinary old-woman and married-woman expressions.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Duden time-stamps the modern usage state; EWA preserves historical compounds and phrases with woman and wife senses.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier separates stages of semantic history instead of turning a current judgment into an ancient essence.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/288","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/wib-old-high-german"},{"cursor":289,"id":289,"entryId":153,"entrySlug":"wib-old-high-german","title":"Is the deeper origin of wīb securely known?","position":"No. Duden labels the origin unclear and offers a veiled bride or busy housewife interpretation only as possibilities.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The historical continuation is secure, but the two deeper explanations are explicitly tentative.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"Neither interpretation becomes a node or ancestry edge until stronger comparative evidence is promoted.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/289","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/wib-old-high-german"},{"cursor":290,"id":290,"entryId":154,"entrySlug":"humble","title":"Is humble historically connected with the ground?","position":"Yes. Merriam-Webster derives Latin humilis from humus, earth, and the comparative root appendix places the family under *dhghem-.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The headword history and root analysis converge on the ground-and-earth formation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph encodes each stage while keeping the modern ethical senses separate from ancestry.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/290","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/humble"},{"cursor":291,"id":291,"entryId":154,"entrySlug":"humble","title":"Does the etymology prove one exact moment when low became morally humble?","position":"No. The lexical formation is secure, but the sources do not date a single physical-to-social-to-moral transition.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Historical senses preserve overlapping physical, status, and character meanings rather than one instantaneous switch.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The dossier records the semantic field and withholds a fabricated event date.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/291","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/humble"},{"cursor":292,"id":292,"entryId":155,"entrySlug":"humus","title":"Are humus, soil, and hummus, chickpea paste, the same word?","position":"No. American Heritage separates Latin humus, soil, from the Arabic and possibly Aramaic food word hummus.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionary presents distinct numbered entries and unrelated language histories.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"This dossier promotes only the Latin soil noun.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/292","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/humus"},{"cursor":293,"id":293,"entryId":155,"entrySlug":"humus","title":"Does human descend from humus?","position":"No. Latin humus and homō are separate formations under *dhghem-; English human descends through hūmānus and homō.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The comparative root appendix lists humus and homō on distinct branches.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph joins the dossiers at the reconstructed root, never through a false direct edge.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/293","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/humus"},{"cursor":294,"id":294,"entryId":156,"entrySlug":"bridegroom","title":"Was the second element of bridegroom always groom?","position":"No. The inherited form had guma or gome, man; groom replaced the opaque element by folk etymology.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage independently publish the alteration.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The path preserves both the inherited compound and the later remodeling.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/294","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/bridegroom"},{"cursor":295,"id":295,"entryId":156,"entrySlug":"bridegroom","title":"Are bridegroom and human directly descended from one another?","position":"No. Germanic *gumōn- and Latin homō reflect different earthling formations that meet only at *dhghem-.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The root appendix distinguishes the zero-grade Germanic and o-grade Latin formations.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Separate nodes prevent a catchy earthling connection from becoming false direct ancestry.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/295","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/bridegroom"},{"cursor":296,"id":296,"entryId":157,"entrySlug":"dough","title":"Does dough descend from lady or lady from dough?","position":"Neither. The dough noun and lady’s kneading component follow separate Germanic formations that meet at *dheigh-.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The root appendix lists Germanic *daigaz and *dīg- on distinct branches under the same form-and-build root.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph reuses the root while preserving both formations.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/296","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/dough"},{"cursor":297,"id":297,"entryId":157,"entrySlug":"dough","title":"Is the asterisked dough trail a chain of written words?","position":"No. *daigaz, *dhoigh-o-, *dheigh-, and *dheig̑h- are comparative reconstructions, not manuscript spellings.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The root appendix explicitly prints reconstructed forms and the atlas marks each with an asterisk.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier crosses visibly from attested dāg into reconstructed nodes.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/297","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/dough"},{"cursor":298,"id":298,"entryId":158,"entrySlug":"figure","title":"Did figure begin as a word only for numbers?","position":"No. Its Latin and medieval fields include shape, form, likeness, symbol, and representation; numerical use is one branch of a wider history.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage publish broad form-and-representation inventories.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier does not project one modern sense backward as the whole word.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/298","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/figure"},{"cursor":299,"id":299,"entryId":158,"entrySlug":"figure","title":"Does figure descend from dough because both mean something shaped?","position":"No. Latin figūra and Germanic dough forms are separate root formations under *dheigh-.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The root appendix lists distinct zero-grade and o-grade derivations.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The surprising connection is cognate depth, not borrowing or direct descent.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/299","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/figure"},{"cursor":300,"id":300,"entryId":159,"entrySlug":"chthonic","title":"Did chthonic begin as a word for hell?","position":"No. The reviewed Greek history begins with khthōn, earth, and khthonios, of the earth; underworld reference is a specialization of what lies below.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage both anchor the word in Greek earth vocabulary.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier preserves earth and underworld senses without turning one into a false literal translation of the other.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/300","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/chthonic"},{"cursor":301,"id":301,"entryId":159,"entrySlug":"chthonic","title":"Does chthonic descend through Latin humus or English humble?","position":"No. Greek khthōn and Latin humus are separate daughter formations under *dhghem-.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The root appendix assigns distinct o-grade formations to the Greek and Latin branches.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins them only at the reconstructed earth root.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/301","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/chthonic"},{"cursor":302,"id":302,"entryId":160,"entrySlug":"exhume","title":"Is exhume literally structured as out of earth?","position":"Yes at the Medieval Latin level: exhumare is formed from ex, out of, and humus, earth.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster explicitly publishes both components.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Both components are preserved as separate graph parents.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/302","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/exhume"},{"cursor":303,"id":303,"entryId":160,"entrySlug":"exhume","title":"When did exhume acquire the archival recovery metaphor?","position":"The modern dictionary records the figurative sense, but the reviewed evidence does not date one secure semantic pivot.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster distinguishes disinterment from recovery out of neglect or obscurity without supplying a first figurative occurrence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The semantic change remains explicit while its chronology stays unresolved.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/303","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/exhume"},{"cursor":304,"id":304,"entryId":161,"entrySlug":"bride","title":"Is bride the same historical word as bird?","position":"No. Bosworth-Toller records brȳd, bride or spouse, separately from brid, the young of a bird; the reviewed bride path follows brȳd.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The Old English dictionary maintains separate headwords and meanings.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Surface resemblance is not allowed to create a homographic ancestry edge.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/304","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/bride"},{"cursor":305,"id":305,"entryId":161,"entrySlug":"bride","title":"What securely precedes Old English brȳd?","position":"The sources publish broad Germanic comparanda, including Old High German brūt, but this dossier does not yet have a reviewed source that warrants one reconstructed parent.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and Bosworth-Toller list relatives without printing a common proto-form in the located entries.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"The trail ends at an explicit cognate horizon rather than importing an uncited reconstruction.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/305","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/bride"},{"cursor":306,"id":306,"entryId":162,"entrySlug":"dairy","title":"Did dairy originally name milk as a substance?","position":"No. The earliest reviewed route names a milk-production place built on the woman responsible for the work.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster derives the place noun from deie, a woman in charge of milking and making butter and cheese.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Modern product senses are retained as later semantic expansion.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/306","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/dairy"},{"cursor":307,"id":307,"entryId":162,"entrySlug":"dairy","title":"Are *daigjōn-, *daiga-, and dough *daigaz one interchangeable reconstructed word?","position":"No. They are related formation, stem, and noun shapes with different grammatical and lexical roles.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster distinguishes the occupational derivative *daigjōn- from base *daiga-, while the root appendix prints dough from *daigaz.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Separate canonical nodes prevent convenient spelling similarity from erasing morphology.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/307","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/dairy"},{"cursor":308,"id":308,"entryId":163,"entrySlug":"fiction","title":"Did fiction originally mean only an invented story?","position":"No. Latin fictiō includes shaping or molding, feigning, pretense, and legal fiction; Middle English begins with invention of the mind.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster publishes the wide Latin and medieval semantic inventory.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Narrative is shown as one later center inside a larger inherited field.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/308","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiction"},{"cursor":309,"id":309,"entryId":163,"entrySlug":"fiction","title":"Does fiction descend from figure?","position":"No. Latin fictiō and figūra are sibling formations in the fingere and *dheigh- family; neither English word is the parent of the other.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster derives fictiō from the fig- stem of fingere, while the root appendix lists figure and fiction on distinct formations.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph meets at fingere or deeper, never through a fiction-to-figure edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/309","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiction"},{"cursor":310,"id":310,"entryId":164,"entrySlug":"feign","title":"Did feign originally mean only to lie?","position":"No. Its recorded Middle English field includes make, fabricate, make a likeness, dissemble, and pretend.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster publishes the wider medieval inventory.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The modern false-appearance center is a semantic narrowing, not the entire ancestry.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/310","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feign"},{"cursor":311,"id":311,"entryId":164,"entrySlug":"feign","title":"Does feign descend from faint or feint?","position":"No direct descent is established here. The root appendix groups them under the same nasalized shaping formation, while feign has its own documented French and Latin chain.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage supplies root-family membership; Merriam-Webster supplies the feign lineage.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Related words remain siblings unless a source warrants a directional edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/311","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feign"},{"cursor":312,"id":312,"entryId":165,"entrySlug":"humiliate","title":"Is the immediate Latin source a participle or a verb stem?","position":"Merriam-Webster names Late Latin humiliatus, the past participle of humiliare; American Heritage summarizes Late Latin humiliāre, humiliāt-. These are compatible levels of the same formation, not evidence for two unrelated ancestries.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The sources differ in entry granularity while agreeing on the Late Latin verb family.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier spine preserves the participle and the graph exposes the AHD verb-stem summary as a separately cited compatible route.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/312","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/humiliate"},{"cursor":313,"id":313,"entryId":165,"entrySlug":"humiliate","title":"Does English humiliate descend directly from dirt or English humus?","position":"No. English humiliate passes through Late Latin humiliatus and humiliare, then Latin humilis. Humilis is formed from Latin humus; the modern English soil word is a separate later borrowing.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster publishes the full Latin sequence, Logeion preserves the physical and social senses of humilis, and the root appendix places humiliate in the Latin earth branch.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph reuses the Latin humus node but draws no edge from English humus to English humiliate.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/313","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/humiliate"},{"cursor":314,"id":314,"entryId":166,"entrySlug":"humility","title":"Was humility originally a positive moral virtue?","position":"Not in every recorded Latin sense. Classical humilitās names physical lowness and low stature, then low rank, insignificance, meanness, or abjectness. Lewis and Short separately marks the good sense opposed to pride as ecclesiastical Latin.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Lewis and Short supplies the sense sequence; CNRTL independently distinguishes classical physical and social lowness from the Christian virtue sense.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph preserves classical and ecclesiastical sense nodes instead of projecting the later virtue backward onto every Latin occurrence.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/314","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/humility"},{"cursor":315,"id":315,"entryId":166,"entrySlug":"humility","title":"What is the earliest secure English humility witness?","position":"Merriam-Webster reports the fourteenth century broadly. The Middle English Dictionary supplies a circa-1390 Chaucer citation with humylitee, but this review did not inspect its underlying manuscript witness, and the located citation does not prove that no earlier English occurrence survives.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The sources support a fourteenth-century horizon and a specific reported occurrence, not one verified first object.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"Promote an exact earlier manuscript or edition witness only after direct facsimile inspection and textual-location verification.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/315","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/humility"},{"cursor":316,"id":316,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","title":"Did humiliation always center disgrace and shame?","position":"No. Christian Latin and historical French include lowering, abasement, mortifying discipline, and self-humbling. Chaucer’s Middle English occurrence appears within a treatment of humility, while current American Heritage definitions center degradation, disgrace, and shame.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"CNRTL supplies the Latin and French semantic record, Harvard supplies the Chaucer context, and American Heritage supplies the current center.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier preserves the earlier humbling field on separate nodes and edges instead of projecting modern shame backward.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/316","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/humiliation"},{"cursor":317,"id":317,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","title":"What is the earliest secure English humiliation witness?","position":"Merriam-Webster publishes the Middle English form humiliacioun, and Harvard’s Chaucer corpus indexes one occurrence. This review did not inspect an underlying manuscript, prove an exact composition year, or establish that no earlier English occurrence survives.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The evidence supports a late-fourteenth-century Middle English record, not a directly inspected first object.","status":"open","resolutionNote":"Promote a specific manuscript or early edition leaf only after facsimile inspection, textual-location verification, and a defensible date.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/317","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/humiliation"},{"cursor":318,"id":318,"entryId":167,"entrySlug":"humiliation","title":"Was English humiliation formed from the English verb humiliate?","position":"The documented chronology points the other way: Middle English humiliacioun is evidenced in Chaucer, whereas Merriam-Webster reports the English verb humiliate only circa 1534. Both English words descend through the Latin humilis family; the noun is not modeled as a modern English derivative of the later-attested verb.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster publishes both routes, Harvard supplies the earlier noun occurrence, and the reviewed humiliate dossier preserves the verb horizon.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph joins the two English words at Late Latin humiliātus and humiliāre rather than drawing a false English verb-to-noun ancestry edge.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/318","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/humiliation"},{"cursor":319,"id":319,"entryId":168,"entrySlug":"logy","title":"Does -logy simply mean “the study of”?","position":"No. Merriam-Webster gives oral or written expression as one sense and doctrine, theory, or science as another; American Heritage separately gives discourse or expression and science, theory, or study. “Study of” is a useful reading in many formations, not a universal historical definition.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage independently publish a multi-sense combining form.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier and truth ledger preserve the wider semantic range instead of substituting one classroom mnemonic.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/319","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/logy"},{"cursor":320,"id":320,"entryId":168,"entrySlug":"logy","title":"Was -logy a freestanding ancestral word?","position":"No evidence reviewed here supports that representation. Merriam-Webster calls -logy a noun combining form and explains that a hyphenated entry is a word element forming part of a compound; the historical forms are likewise evidenced within larger formations. The unrelated adjective logy “sluggish” has a different history.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster’s entry and explanatory notes distinguish the bound combining form from the unrelated adjective and from an autonomous word.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every stage retains the leading hyphen, and the attestation ledger identifies host-word evidence rather than inventing standalone tokens.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/320","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/logy"},{"cursor":321,"id":321,"entryId":168,"entrySlug":"logy","title":"Are -logy and -logue interchangeable endings?","position":"No. They are relatives in the Greek logos and legein family, but English -logy follows -logie, Latin -logia, and Greek -logiā, while prologue follows Greek prologos through Latin prologus and French prologue. Related ancestry does not erase distinct formations and transmission paths.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage publishes -logiā and -logos channels; the reviewed prologue dossier publishes the separate whole-word route.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph connects both paths at Greek logos without collapsing the English endings into one morpheme.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/321","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/logy"},{"cursor":322,"id":322,"entryId":168,"entrySlug":"logy","title":"Is the deepest root *leǵ- or *sleǵ-?","position":"The traditional *leǵ- reconstruction remains widely represented, while published scholarship argues that the gather or collect root began with *s. The graph preserves both analyses.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"UT Austin LRC and IE-CoR publish *leg-; Kaczyńska argues for initial *s.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/322","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/logy"},{"cursor":323,"id":323,"entryId":169,"entrySlug":"rix","title":"Was Gaulish -rīx an attested freestanding word?","position":"No freestanding token is established by the reviewed evidence. Cambridge calls it an onomastic element and Bolelli and Campanile call it the second member of compound personal names. The form is attested through those hosts, while Proto-Celtic *rīx-s is reconstructed.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Two scholarly sources describe the form in compounds; the digital Caesar witnesses confirm whole names rather than an autonomous token.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier retains a leading hyphen, identifies host witnesses, and keeps the asterisk on the reconstructed Proto-Celtic parent only.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/323","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/rix"},{"cursor":324,"id":324,"entryId":169,"entrySlug":"rix","title":"Did -rīx mean exactly “king” in every compound name?","position":"Not necessarily. The king or prince value is secure for the element, but scholarship distinguishes names where it is determinative from analyses in which it is semantically bleached or intensifying. Each host therefore requires its own compositional claim.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Bolelli and Campanile review Schmidt’s three-way semantic classification and the larger Gaulish personal-name evidence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/324","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/rix"},{"cursor":325,"id":325,"entryId":169,"entrySlug":"rix","title":"Is the historically meaningful Gaulish ending simply -ix?","position":"No. The linguistic sources segment -rīx or orthographic -rix as the onomastic element and align it with Proto-Celtic *rīx-s. Treating -ix alone as the inherited unit cuts through the initial r of the morpheme.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Cambridge prints -rix /-rīxs/ and Bolelli and Campanile print -rīx as the second member.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The headword and witnesses distinguish the evidence-bearing element from a modern visual stereotype about Gaulish names.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/325","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/rix"},{"cursor":326,"id":326,"entryId":169,"entrySlug":"rix","title":"Was Gaulish -rīx borrowed from Latin rēx?","position":"No borrowing is required by the reviewed comparative account. Celtic -rīx and Latin rēx are inherited cognates: Celtic raises Indo-European *ē to *ī, while Latin preserves ē.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Cambridge derives the Gaulish and Proto-Celtic form from PIE *(h₃)rēg̑-; the Texas Old Irish introduction explicitly compares Celtic ī with Latin ē.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins the branches at reconstructed ancestry and draws no Latin-to-Gaulish edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/326","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/rix"},{"cursor":327,"id":327,"entryId":170,"entrySlug":"rex","title":"Is the x of rēx an inherited single stem consonant?","position":"No. In the Latin nominative, stem rēg- combines with -s; g devoices to k before s and the /ks/ cluster is spelled x. The genitive rēgis preserves visible g.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"MIT’s slides and transcript explicitly lay out reg-s, reg-is, and the sound changes leading to x.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier reveals x as a surface cluster without calling g silent or treating spelling as the whole explanation.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/327","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/rex"},{"cursor":328,"id":328,"entryId":170,"entrySlug":"rex","title":"Did genitive rēgis historically produce nominative rēx?","position":"No. Rēx and rēgis are inflected forms in one paradigm. The graph uses the genitive to expose the stem, not as a chronological parent word.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Lewis and Short cite rēx, rēgis together; MIT explains both from the same rēg- stem.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The edge is typed inflection and its chronology note explicitly denies case-to-case ancestry.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/328","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/rex"},{"cursor":329,"id":329,"entryId":170,"entrySlug":"rex","title":"Did Latin rēx produce Old Irish rí or Gaulish -rīx?","position":"No. The reviewed comparative sources treat the Latin and Celtic forms as inherited cognates in separate Italic and Celtic branches; Celtic raises inherited *ē to *ī.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The Texas Old Irish introduction compares rí, ríg, Gaulish -rix, rēx, and rēgis; Cambridge reconstructs the Celtic branch.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins the forms at reconstructed ancestry and draws no Latin-to-Celtic borrowing edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/329","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/rex"},{"cursor":330,"id":330,"entryId":170,"entrySlug":"rex","title":"Did royal and regal enter English through one identical route?","position":"No. Both descend from Latin rēgālis, but royal crosses through Anglo-French roial or real while regal has Old French, Anglo-French, and direct-Latin transmission reported by different authorities.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The existing royal and regal dossiers preserve their distinct medieval channels and the documented uncertainty around regal.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The descendants remain separate dossiers even though they share the Latin king adjective and noun.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/330","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/rex"},{"cursor":331,"id":331,"entryId":171,"entrySlug":"king","title":"Is English king descended from Latin rēx?","position":"No. King is inherited through Old English cyning from a Germanic kin formation. Latin rēx belongs to the separate straight, direct, and rule family. Translation equivalence does not create ancestry.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"EWA and American Heritage publish the king-and-kin route; the existing rēx dossier publishes the independent Latin route.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossiers remain in separate lexical families and are joined only by a sourced historical-context link.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/331","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/king"},{"cursor":332,"id":332,"entryId":171,"entrySlug":"king","title":"What did Proto-Germanic *kuninga- originally designate?","position":"The kin-base derivation is secure in the reviewed sources, but its exact social interpretation is not. EWA gives a member of a noble lineage; Meli proposes one who brings distinction to his lineage. “Leader of the kin” is not a neutral translation of either analysis.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"EWA publishes the formation and one semantic reconstruction; Meli’s article abstract explicitly rejects that gloss and proposes another.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/332","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/king"},{"cursor":333,"id":333,"entryId":171,"entrySlug":"king","title":"Is Finnish kuningas an ancestor of English king?","position":"No. Finnish borrowed the word from Germanic. Its conservative shape is evidence for reconstruction, not a donor on the English lineage.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"EWA gives the Germanic-to-Finnic borrowing direction; Barber, Beal, and Shaw explain why the Finnish form preserves useful archaic structure.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Finnish is a cited descendant branch from the reconstructed node, never a parent of Old English.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/333","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/king"},{"cursor":334,"id":334,"entryId":171,"entrySlug":"king","title":"Do the chess, card, and supremacy senses reveal the original meaning of king?","position":"No. The inherited ruler title is older; the game-piece and preeminence senses are semantic extensions documented in the modern entry.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster separates the monarch, preeminence, chess, card, checkers, and verbal senses while tracing the word to Old English cyning.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier preserves later semantic branches without projecting them backward into Proto-Germanic social life.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/334","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/king"},{"cursor":335,"id":335,"entryId":172,"entrySlug":"kin","title":"Is kin a shortened form of king?","position":"No. Kin continues Old English cynn and Proto-Germanic *kunja-. The Germanic king title *kuninga- is morphologically derived from that lineage base plus a person-forming suffix; neither modern English word directly descends from the other.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"EWA publishes *kunja- as the kin base and *kuninga- as its suffixed title formation; American Heritage independently groups king and kin under the birth root.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossiers share the canonical *kunja- node. No king-to-kin ancestry edge is drawn.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/335","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kin"},{"cursor":336,"id":336,"entryId":172,"entrySlug":"kin","title":"Did kin always mean only blood relatives?","position":"No. Old and Middle English records include kind, race, people, tribe, nation, lineage, generation, progeny, gender, species, category, and family. The modern relatives sense is a semantic narrowing, not the whole ancestral meaning.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Bosworth–Toller and the Middle English Dictionary publish the broader historical inventories; Merriam-Webster documents the modern center.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic change remains visible on the Old-to-Middle and Middle-to-modern edges.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/336","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kin"},{"cursor":337,"id":337,"entryId":172,"entrySlug":"kin","title":"Are the family noun kin and diminutive suffix -kin the same morpheme?","position":"No. Merriam-Webster gives the family noun through Middle English from Old English cynn, but derives the diminutive suffix through Middle English from Middle Dutch -kin and Old High German -chīn.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster prints the noun and suffix as separate entries with separate etymologies.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The suffix is not attached to this family graph and the dossier labels the homography explicitly.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/337","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kin"},{"cursor":338,"id":338,"entryId":172,"entrySlug":"kin","title":"Can the exact date and phonological staging of cynn be treated as settled?","position":"The main sequence—gemination, umlaut, glide loss, and ending loss—is strongly evidenced, but the exact dating of West Germanic gemination and the analysis and chronology of Sievers’ Law remain debated.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Adamczyk prints the *kunjan > *kunnjan > *kynni > cynn sequence while describing Sievers’ Law as contentious; Fulk reports proposed dates from about 200 CE to the fourth century and favors the runic fourth- or fifth-century evidence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/338","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kin"},{"cursor":339,"id":339,"entryId":173,"entrySlug":"kind","title":"Is kind simply kin plus a final d?","position":"No. Kin continues Germanic *kunja- from a *-yo- formation, while kind continues noun *kundjaz and adjective *kundiz from a *-t- formation. They are deep cousins that meet at *ǵenh₁-, not one modern word built by adding d to the other.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage publishes the two separate zero-grade formations and their Germanic descendants; EWA’s kunni entry independently assigns kin to *kunja-.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph joins the dossiers only at the shared birth root and never draws a kin-to-kind derivation.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/339","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kind"},{"cursor":340,"id":340,"entryId":173,"entrySlug":"kind","title":"Did kind always mean benevolent or nice?","position":"No. Old English gecynde is natural, native, innate, fitting, proper, or inherited by birth. Middle English evidence adds affectionate and benevolent uses, making modern moral kindness a semantic development rather than the original whole meaning.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Bosworth–Toller documents the Old English adjective field; the Middle English Dictionary documents later loving and benevolent senses.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The adjective branch exposes the semantic change separately from the noun lineage.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/340","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kind"},{"cursor":341,"id":341,"entryId":173,"entrySlug":"kind","title":"Does kind of always mean a literal category or type?","position":"No. Alongside the compositional category construction, kind of has been reanalyzed as an approximator, hedge, downtoner, and pragmatic marker; reduced kinda represents that later constructional history.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Loureiro-Porto reviews the historical development and corpus evidence for category, hedge, and pragmatic-marker functions.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"A graph-only descendant edge records grammaticalization without making the pragmatic construction an ancestor of kind.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/341","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kind"},{"cursor":342,"id":342,"entryId":173,"entrySlug":"kind","title":"Is German Kind the source of English kind?","position":"No. German Kind belongs to the comparative Germanic birth family, but it is a cognate branch rather than a donor into English. Similar form and a child sense do not establish a borrowing route.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"American Heritage derives the English noun and adjective through Old English; EWA treats German Kind through its own Germanic comparative history.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"German Kind remains a cited relative and never appears on the English ancestry spine.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/342","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kind"},{"cursor":343,"id":343,"entryId":173,"entrySlug":"kind","title":"Is there one completely settled Proto-Germanic *kund- reconstruction?","position":"The English noun and adjective routes are well supported, but the exact prehistoric consonant, stem, and derivational analyses across the wider Germanic family are not reducible to one unqualified form. American Heritage prints *kundjaz and *kundiz; EWA discusses *kenþa-, *kunđa-, and *kunđi- plus unresolved voicing and borrowing questions.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The reviewed references agree on the birth-root family while preserving different reconstructed stem analyses and confidence limits.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/343","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kind"},{"cursor":344,"id":344,"entryId":174,"entrySlug":"kindred","title":"Does kindred descend from kind?","position":"No. The first component is kin, continuing Old English cynn. Kind follows a separate Germanic *kund- and Indo-European *gn̥ə-t- formation; the words meet only at the deeper birth root.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Traugott analyzes kindred as kin-reden; Merriam-Webster and American Heritage segment the Old English compound as cynn plus -ræden.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph connects kindred directly to cynn and reaches kind only by traversing the deeper shared *ǵenh₁- node.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/344","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kindred"},{"cursor":345,"id":345,"entryId":174,"entrySlug":"kindred","title":"Is the d in kindred inherited from the oldest compound?","position":"No. Traugott explicitly identifies an intrusive d between n and r. The late Old English compound is cynræden / cynrēde and Middle English records include both kinrede and kindrede.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The scholarly analysis, historical dictionaries, and form sequence agree that d is not an original component.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The modern-to-medieval edge labels the insertion; the Old English node contains no d.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/345","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kindred"},{"cursor":346,"id":346,"entryId":174,"entrySlug":"kindred","title":"Is the surviving -red element the color red?","position":"No. It is the reduced relic of Old English -ræden, a condition or state-forming element. The wider pattern once made social and abstract nouns and survives principally in kindred and hatred.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The Middle English Dictionary defines the suffix; Traugott reconstructs the productive X-RÆDEN schema and its decline.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The second compound edge descends through -ræden and never touches the color word red.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/346","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kindred"},{"cursor":347,"id":347,"entryId":174,"entrySlug":"kindred","title":"Did kindred begin as an adjective meaning similar in nature?","position":"No. The inherited noun names kinship, family, lineage, and related people. Merriam-Webster analyzes the adjective as attributive use of that noun and reports it later than the noun.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster separates the noun and adjective histories; American Heritage preserves both modern categories.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The similarity sense is recorded as semantic development on the whole-word continuation edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/347","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kindred"},{"cursor":348,"id":348,"entryId":174,"entrySlug":"kindred","title":"Is the exact history of -ræden reducible to either ready or read?","position":"The condition element is secure, and American Heritage assigns it through Germanic *rēdan to PIE *rē-dh-. But Merriam-Webster notes that Old English evidence can reflect a probable relationship to geræde “ready,” older analysis through rædan “advise,” and partial merger with ræding; Germanic *raidja- and *rēd- outcomes can be difficult to separate.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The sources agree on the inherited condition element but preserve different cautions about its immediate derivation and later formal convergence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/348","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kindred"},{"cursor":349,"id":349,"entryId":175,"entrySlug":"hatred","title":"Is the -red in hatred the color red?","position":"No. Middle English -rede / -reden continues Old English -ræden, a suffixal or affixoid element denoting state, condition, or quality.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and American Heritage segment the compound; Traugott documents the wider X-RÆDEN construction.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph gives the second component its own cited lineage and never connects it to the color word.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/349","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatred"},{"cursor":350,"id":350,"entryId":175,"entrySlug":"hatred","title":"Was hatred already a whole word in Old English?","position":"No reviewed source gives an Old English whole-word ancestor. The word is documented as a Middle English formation from hate plus -rede, with a 13th-century first-known-use horizon.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Both historical dictionaries identify the Middle English compound; Merriam-Webster dates the first known use to the 13th century.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The direct route begins with Middle English hatrede / hatreden and decomposes there.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/350","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatred"},{"cursor":351,"id":351,"entryId":175,"entrySlug":"hatred","title":"Did the noun hate directly continue Old English hete?","position":"The inherited noun is part of the history, but the immediate path is disputed. American Heritage presents Middle English hate from Old English hete; Merriam-Webster says the Middle English noun was probably derived from haten and replaced hete.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Two major historical dictionaries preserve materially different immediate analyses.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/351","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatred"},{"cursor":352,"id":352,"entryId":175,"entrySlug":"hatred","title":"Does the Germanic hate family securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only probably. Merriam-Webster publishes the proposal but says the semantic relations among grief, mourning, care, and hatred are far from transparent; Liberman questions whether all proposed non-Germanic cognates belong together.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The formal correspondence is plausible, but the semantic bridge and family membership remain contested.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/352","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatred"},{"cursor":353,"id":353,"entryId":175,"entrySlug":"hatred","title":"Did hate originally mean pursuit or persecution?","position":"Possibly, but not securely. Liberman points to Old English hatian in a pursuit context, German hetzen, Old English hettan, and the pursuer Hati; he presents pursuit as the most promising concrete history while leaving the rest murky.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The action-based account improves the Germanic semantic story but is not a uniquely demonstrated PIE origin.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/353","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatred"},{"cursor":354,"id":354,"entryId":175,"entrySlug":"hatred","title":"Does -red historically make hate more intense?","position":"No evidence reviewed identifies -red as an intensifier. It named a state or condition. Modern hatred can denote extreme animosity, but that lexical intensity is not the historical function of the suffix.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionaries gloss -rede as state, condition, or quality; Traugott reconstructs a condition-related-to-X schema.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic edge separates present intensity from historical word formation.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/354","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatred"},{"cursor":355,"id":355,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","title":"Did Middle English hate directly continue Old English hete?","position":"Possibly, but the immediate route is disputed. American Heritage gives direct noun descent; Merriam-Webster says the noun was probably derived from haten and replaced hete.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Two major historical dictionaries publish different immediate analyses.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/355","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hate"},{"cursor":356,"id":356,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","title":"Did hate originally mean pursuit or persecution?","position":"The Germanic action evidence makes pursuit or persecution a serious proposal, not a settled origin. Beowulf, hettan, German hetzen, and Hati support the comparison, but the full deep family remains murky.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Liberman develops the hypothesis while explicitly refusing a final solution.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/356","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hate"},{"cursor":357,"id":357,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","title":"Does hate securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only probably. The formal correspondence is widely published, but grief, care, mourning, love, and hatred do not form a transparent semantic chain, and some proposed cognates may not belong together.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the proposal; Liberman challenges semantic and membership assumptions.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/357","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hate"},{"cursor":358,"id":358,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","title":"Were English love and hate once the same word?","position":"No reviewed evidence connects English love directly to English hate. Middle Irish cais has an ambivalent love-and-hatred field inside a disputed comparison, but that is not a genealogical edge between the English words.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster and Liberman present the Celtic comparison with explicit semantic caution.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph keeps love in its *lewbʰ- family and hate in the Germanic *hatiz- family; their meeting remains contextual and disputed.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/358","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hate"},{"cursor":359,"id":359,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","title":"Has hate always meant extreme enmity?","position":"No. The current verb also covers strong dislike, distaste, and polite reluctance, while older English evidence includes hostile treatment and persecution. One gloss cannot be projected across every period and construction.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The modern dictionaries distinguish present senses; the historical sources preserve action-centered meanings.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Separate semantic claims on the edges and form notes preserve the range.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/359","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hate"},{"cursor":360,"id":360,"entryId":176,"entrySlug":"hate","title":"Is hatred the older or more original word?","position":"No. Hate is inherited from Old English noun and verb material; hatred is a Middle English formation first reported in the 13th century. Its suffix names a condition rather than linguistic originality.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster dates and analyzes both words; Traugott documents hatred as an X-RÆDEN relic.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The rabbit hole connects the two dossiers while keeping their distinct formation histories.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/360","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hate"},{"cursor":361,"id":361,"entryId":177,"entrySlug":"hete","title":"Did Middle English hate directly continue Old English hete?","position":"Possibly, but the immediate route is disputed. American Heritage gives direct descent; Merriam-Webster says the noun was probably derived from haten and replaced hete.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Two major historical dictionaries publish different analyses.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/361","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hete"},{"cursor":362,"id":362,"entryId":177,"entrySlug":"hete","title":"Did hete name only an inward feeling?","position":"No. Historical dictionaries include enmity, malignity, malice, spite, hostility, and persecution, and they document compounds for hostile speech, hostile blows, hostile designs, and other enacted or categorized hostility.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Bosworth–Toller and Clark Hall independently document the wider range.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier preserves the attested semantic field and compound evidence instead of projecting one modern gloss backward.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/362","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hete"},{"cursor":363,"id":363,"entryId":177,"entrySlug":"hete","title":"Was hete an isolated noun rather than a word-building base?","position":"No. Bosworth–Toller lists eleven derived first elements ending in -hete; Clark Hall separately records hetenīþ, heterūn, hetesprǣc, hetesweng, and heteðanc.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Two historical dictionaries expose a productive lexical neighborhood.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The relatives and leaderboard cite the compounds directly.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/363","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hete"},{"cursor":364,"id":364,"entryId":177,"entrySlug":"hete","title":"Does *hatiz- securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only probably. The formal comparison is published, but the grief, care, mourning, love, and hatred meanings do not form a transparent sequence and some proposed cognates may not belong together.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the proposal; Liberman challenges semantic and membership assumptions.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/364","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hete"},{"cursor":365,"id":365,"entryId":177,"entrySlug":"hete","title":"Does the Beowulf quotation establish the first use of hete?","position":"No. It is one located edited occurrence among many textual traditions listed by the dictionaries. Without a complete witness comparison and direct manuscript inspection, it cannot be promoted as the first surviving token.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Bosworth–Toller lists gospel, poetry, prose, homily, psalm, and biblical examples rather than one privileged first record.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The attestation is labeled source-reported and makes no earliest-use claim.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/365","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hete"},{"cursor":366,"id":366,"entryId":178,"entrySlug":"hatian","title":"Is the Germanic parent exactly *hatōjan-?","position":"The inherited weak verb is secure, but scholarly notation varies. Merriam-Webster prints *hatōjan-; Orel prints *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan and includes a second related *xatjanan formation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Two etymological sources agree on the family while differing in reconstruction detail.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/366","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatian"},{"cursor":367,"id":367,"entryId":178,"entrySlug":"hatian","title":"Did hatian mean only an inward feeling?","position":"No. Its grammatical objects include the world or people, a righteous person, subjects’ vices, former enemies, divine enemies, robbers, plunderers, and hostile deeds.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Bosworth–Toller supplies located textual examples; Clark Hall independently includes treating as an enemy.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier records object and context variation without replacing every occurrence with one modern psychological gloss.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/367","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatian"},{"cursor":368,"id":368,"entryId":178,"entrySlug":"hatian","title":"Are hatian “hate” and hátian “become hot” one word?","position":"No. Bosworth–Toller lists separate headwords with different vowel quantity, meanings, examples, and Germanic comparisons. Modern typography that drops macrons can hide the distinction.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionary explicitly separates the entries.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The quantity-marked homograph is a cited relative, never an ancestor or duplicate sense of the hate verb.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/368","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatian"},{"cursor":369,"id":369,"entryId":178,"entrySlug":"hatian","title":"Was pursuit the original meaning of hatian?","position":"Possibly relevant, not established. Beowulf, hettan, German hetzen, and the action contexts motivate a pursuit or persecution proposal, but the deeper semantic comparison remains unresolved.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Liberman develops the action hypothesis while refusing a final solution.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/369","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatian"},{"cursor":370,"id":370,"entryId":178,"entrySlug":"hatian","title":"Does the John 7:7 record establish the first use of hatian?","position":"No. It is one edited occurrence among many textual traditions. Without a complete witness comparison and direct manuscript inspection, it cannot be promoted as the earliest surviving token.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Bosworth–Toller lists gospel, psalm, prose, legal, and poetic records rather than one privileged first occurrence.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The attestation is labeled source-reported and makes no earliest-use claim.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/370","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatian"},{"cursor":371,"id":371,"entryId":179,"entrySlug":"hettan","title":"Is the infinitive hettan directly attested in the located corpus inventory?","position":"No. Tío Sáenz’s full-corpus weak-verb inventory lists the lemma as hettan but gives only hettende beneath it. The dossier therefore labels hettan a normalized lexicographic lemma rather than quoting an unattested infinitive token.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The 2019 corpus lemmatisation explicitly prints one form after the headword.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The form record and attestation distinguish lemma-level evidence from a directly surviving infinitive.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/371","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hettan"},{"cursor":372,"id":372,"entryId":179,"entrySlug":"hettan","title":"Is hettende a verbal participle or a lexical noun meaning enemy?","position":"The evidence supports both analyses in different editorial systems. Tío Sáenz lemmatizes hettende under hettan; Clark Hall calls it a participle of hatian; Bosworth–Toller lists hettende among the forms of the masculine noun hettend, “enemy.”","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Three lexical sources make incompatible or differently scoped assignments.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/372","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hettan"},{"cursor":373,"id":373,"entryId":179,"entrySlug":"hettan","title":"Are hettan and hatian the same Old English verb?","position":"Probably not historically, but the surviving forms are easy to merge. Orel assigns hettan to *xatjanan and hatian to a separate *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan formation; Clark Hall nevertheless sends hettende to hatian, and Bosworth–Toller cross-refers hettan to hatian.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Comparative morphology separates the formations while Old English lexicography exposes overlap.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/373","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hettan"},{"cursor":374,"id":374,"entryId":179,"entrySlug":"hettan","title":"Did hettan mean hate, pursue, attack, or persecute?","position":"No single gloss exhausts the record. Orel glosses Old English hettan “hate” but Middle High German hetzen “pursue”; the attested enemy forms encode an antagonist, and Liberman argues for pursuit or persecution as an older concrete history.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The formal family is stronger than a single recoverable semantic starting point.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/374","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hettan"},{"cursor":375,"id":375,"entryId":179,"entrySlug":"hettan","title":"Does the Phoenix hettende establish the first use of hettan?","position":"No. It is one edited poetic occurrence of an ambiguous form. Without a complete witness comparison and direct manuscript inspection, it cannot establish the first token of the lemma.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Bright locates the form in the Exeter Book poem; the wider dictionary record lists numerous hettend(e) occurrences.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The attestation is labeled source-reported and makes no earliest-use claim.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/375","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hettan"},{"cursor":376,"id":376,"entryId":179,"entrySlug":"hettan","title":"Does the Germanic family securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only probably. The formal comparison is published, but grief, care, mourning, love, pursuit, persecution, and hate do not form a transparent sequence, and some proposed cognates may not belong together.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the proposal; Liberman challenges semantic and membership assumptions.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/376","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hettan"},{"cursor":377,"id":377,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","title":"Did hetzen begin as a modern political hate-speech verb?","position":"No. The Middle High German dictionary centers the verb on driving dogs to hunt and already records transferred human conflict; Early New High German sources later make incitement explicit.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"MHDWB, FWB, and DRW preserve the older action-centered record.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic timeline separates hunting, transferred incitement, haste, and modern hostile agitation.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/377","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hetzen"},{"cursor":378,"id":378,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","title":"Is hetzen simply the German verb for hate?","position":"No as a synchronic definition, though the histories are related. Modern Duden distinguishes chase, hurry, and incitement senses; etymological sources connect the formation with Hass or hassen and the broader Germanic hate family.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Modern meaning structure and historical derivation answer different questions.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier links the family without replacing the verb’s attested action senses with a one-word gloss.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/378","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hetzen"},{"cursor":379,"id":379,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","title":"Is the Old High German form directly attested?","position":"Unresolved in the located sources. Bailey prints *hezzen with an asterisk and reconstructs it from Middle High German and cognates, while Duden and the older Kluge entry refer to an Old High German hetzen without visibly marking the form as hypothetical.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The sources expose different evidential presentation rather than a shared located OHG witness.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/379","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hetzen"},{"cursor":380,"id":380,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","title":"Was the formation a causative “make hate” or an action verb “make pursue”?","position":"Both descriptions occur, and their priority is not settled here. Duden analyzes a causative to hassen; Orel derives *xatjanan from the hate noun; Bailey and the medieval record foreground chase or persecution.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Morphological relationship is stronger than one uniquely recoverable original gloss.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/380","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hetzen"},{"cursor":381,"id":381,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","title":"Are the chase, hurry, and incitement senses separate homonyms?","position":"The reviewed dictionaries treat them as senses of one inherited verb. The semantic bridge from making quarry or people move under pressure to hurrying and inciting is historically plausible, though the dossier does not invent exact dates for every transition.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Duden supplies the modern polysemy and historical dictionaries document physical and transferred action.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"One dossier preserves distinct sense stages instead of duplicating unrelated headwords.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/381","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hetzen"},{"cursor":382,"id":382,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","title":"Is the noun Hetze older than the verb?","position":"No in the reviewed etymological account. Kluge describes Hetze as a Modern High German formation from the older verb, whose Middle High German history is independently attested.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The verb’s historical record predates the modern deverbal noun in the cited analysis.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The relation is modeled as derivation from the verb, not as the verb’s source.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/382","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hetzen"},{"cursor":383,"id":383,"entryId":180,"entrySlug":"hetzen","title":"Does hetzen securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only probably. The Germanic comparison is stronger than the deeper PIE proposal; the proposed grief, care, mourning, hatred, and pursuit meanings do not form one transparent sequence.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the comparison and Liberman challenges semantic and membership assumptions.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/383","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hetzen"},{"cursor":384,"id":384,"entryId":181,"entrySlug":"hatjan","title":"Is the infinitive hatjan itself written in the surviving manuscript?","position":"No. The directly inspected form is hatjandam, a weak masculine dative-plural present participle. Hatjan is the normalized lexical citation form assigned by Project Wulfila and the historical grammars.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The current corpus links its only verified occurrence to Codex Argenteus folio 3v and supplies the morphology.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier labels the lexeme attested through an inflected token and never quotes the infinitive as manuscript text.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/384","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatjan"},{"cursor":385,"id":385,"entryId":181,"entrySlug":"hatjan","title":"Are hatjan and hatan two Gothic verbs or one fluctuating paradigm?","position":"The located scholarship does not collapse to one answer. Project Wulfila gives separate class-I and class-III lemmas; Orel publishes distinct Germanic formations. Braune says hatan fluctuates between class III and class I, and Wright lists both under the same gloss.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Corpus lemmatization, historical grammar, and comparative reconstruction expose different analytical granularity.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":5,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/385","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatjan"},{"cursor":386,"id":386,"entryId":181,"entrySlug":"hatjan","title":"Does one surviving hatjan token prove the verb was rare in spoken Gothic?","position":"No. It proves only that the surviving and currently verified corpus contains one token assigned to this lemma. The fragmentary manuscript record cannot measure ordinary spoken frequency.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Project Wulfila’s occurrence inventory is exhaustive for its current corpus, while the manuscript edition documents the severe limits of Gothic textual survival.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface says one verified corpus occurrence, never one historical use or a frequency estimate for speech.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/386","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatjan"},{"cursor":387,"id":387,"entryId":181,"entrySlug":"hatjan","title":"Did Gothic hatjan mean pursue because German hetzen later did?","position":"Not in the surviving Gothic clause. Matthew 5:44 uses hatjandam for people who hate; Middle High German hetzen develops pursuit and hounding senses in a daughter branch. The formal comparison does not make every branch share every meaning.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Orel supplies the formal family while Project Wulfila anchors the Gothic context and Liberman argues for action history without erasing branch-specific evidence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/387","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatjan"},{"cursor":388,"id":388,"entryId":181,"entrySlug":"hatjan","title":"Was hatjan derived from the Germanic hate noun?","position":"Probably. Braune derives the class-I verb from the consonantal stem of hatis, and Orel derives *xatjanan from *xataz ~ *xatez. The exact reconstructed notation is editorial, but the noun-to-verb analysis is independently published.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Historical grammar and Germanic etymology agree on derivation while using different reconstruction levels.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph presents derivation rather than claiming that one attested Gothic noun token literally precedes the verb token.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/388","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatjan"},{"cursor":389,"id":389,"entryId":181,"entrySlug":"hatjan","title":"Does the codex’s route from Ravenna to Uppsala map the spread of spoken Gothic?","position":"No. It maps the custody of the evidence object. The manuscript traveled through Werden, Prague, Stockholm, Holland, and Uppsala long after Gothic ceased to be a living vernacular in those places.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Uppsala University documents the custody route; the scholarly edition identifies the manuscripts and repositories.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every post-Ravenna journey note explicitly labels manuscript custody rather than lexical diffusion.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/389","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatjan"},{"cursor":390,"id":390,"entryId":181,"entrySlug":"hatjan","title":"Does hatjan securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only probably. The Germanic family is stronger than the deeper proposal; grief, care, mourning, hatred, pursuit, and persecution do not form one transparent semantic sequence, and some proposed cognates may not belong together.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the proposal; Liberman challenges semantic and membership assumptions.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/390","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatjan"},{"cursor":391,"id":391,"entryId":182,"entrySlug":"hatis","title":"Does Gothic hatis simply mean the modern emotion hate?","position":"No. Hatred remains a legitimate dictionary gloss, but the surviving biblical tokens do different translation work: Streitberg maps the noun chiefly to Greek orgē, maps Galatians 5:20 to thumos, and flags Ephesians 4:31 because both Greek wrath nouns are adjacent.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The complete lemma inventory, verse alignments, and Streitberg’s case-and-equivalent list distinguish corpus semantics from a one-word modern gloss.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier leads with hatred, anger, or wrath and exposes each contextual alignment instead of selecting one timeless English equivalent.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/391","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatis"},{"cursor":392,"id":392,"entryId":182,"entrySlug":"hatis","title":"Does the corpus contain exactly fifteen historical uses of hatis?","position":"Project Wulfila currently reports exactly fifteen surviving corpus tokens assigned to the lemma. That is an inventory claim, not a total for spoken Gothic, lost manuscripts, spelling variants outside the corpus, or every historical use.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The lemma page lists all fifteen tokens and labels them unverified but unambiguous; the modern edition documents the fragmentary Gothic source base.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every count is explicitly bounded to the current reported corpus.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/392","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatis"},{"cursor":393,"id":393,"entryId":182,"entrySlug":"hatis","title":"Was hatis an inherited i-stem or a Gothic neuter a-stem?","position":"Both descriptions operate at different historical levels. Project Wulfila classifies the surviving Gothic paradigm as a neuter a-stem; Fulk treats hatis as an inherited i-stem transferred to the a-stems and compares Old English hete and Old Saxon heti.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Synchronic corpus morphology and diachronic comparative grammar answer different questions rather than contradicting each other.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The root trail states inherited i-stem and Gothic a-stem remodeling in the same cited edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/393","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatis"},{"cursor":394,"id":394,"entryId":182,"entrySlug":"hatis","title":"How should Ephesians 2:3 hatize and hatis be parsed?","position":"The witnesses disagree in form and the analytical layers disagree in labeling. Project Wulfila’s current morphology lists A hatize as genitive plural and B hatis as nominative or accusative singular; Braune calls B hatis a consonantal genitive beside A hatizē, while Streitberg’s later teaching glossary calls genitive hatis erroneous.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The A and B readings, automated morphology, historical grammar, and pedagogical grammar do not reduce to one uncontested paradigm explanation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/394","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatis"},{"cursor":395,"id":395,"entryId":182,"entrySlug":"hatis","title":"Does hatis underlie Gothic hatjan and hatizōn?","position":"Historical grammar derives class-I hatjan from the consonantal stem of hatis, and the University of Texas derivational table builds class-II hatizōn “be angry” directly on hatiz-. The separate class-III hatan remains a wider paradigm and reconstruction problem rather than a proved direct daughter of this noun.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Braune and the derivational grammar independently identify two noun-based formations while the corpus and Orel keep hatan analytically distinct.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The relatives and rabbit hole expose two documented denominatives and label the third verb separately.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/395","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatis"},{"cursor":396,"id":396,"entryId":182,"entrySlug":"hatis","title":"Does Galatians 5:20 prove hatis always meant explosive anger?","position":"No single verse can establish an invariant meaning. Galatians aligns plural hatiza with Greek thumoi, while other biblical contexts use orgē and Ephesians 4:31 does not permit a clean one-to-one choice. The exact semantic center of ordinary Gothic remains underdetermined by translation texts.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The Greek-Gothic alignment demonstrates contextual translation, not a complete monolingual semantic field.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/396","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatis"},{"cursor":397,"id":397,"entryId":182,"entrySlug":"hatis","title":"Do Celtic cais and cas make the deep Indo-European route secure?","position":"Not by themselves. Koch publishes Proto-Celtic *katsi- and a wider *kad- comparison, but Middle Irish cais itself carries both love and hatred, and Liberman challenges whether several non-Germanic comparisons form one transparent family.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"One modern comparative corpus supports the cross-branch set while a separate etymological analysis disputes its semantic unity.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/397","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatis"},{"cursor":398,"id":398,"entryId":182,"entrySlug":"hatis","title":"Do the surviving token counts measure spoken Gothic frequency?","position":"No. Fifteen reported corpus tokens measure a bounded textual survival, heavily shaped by biblical translation and manuscript loss. They cannot estimate how often Goths used the noun, its competing synonyms, or its everyday senses.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Project Wulfila supplies the occurrence inventory; the Gothic edition documents the limited manuscript source base.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface calls them corpus tokens and never historical uses or a speech-frequency sample.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/398","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatis"},{"cursor":399,"id":399,"entryId":182,"entrySlug":"hatis","title":"Does the Codex Argenteus custody route map the spread of hatis?","position":"No. It maps the custody of the directly inspected evidence object. The manuscript traveled through Werden, Prague, Stockholm, Holland, and Uppsala long after Gothic ceased to be a living vernacular in those places; the other hatis tokens survive in separate witnesses.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Uppsala University documents the custody route, while Project Wulfila identifies multiple manuscript sigla in the noun inventory.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every post-Ravenna journey note explicitly labels manuscript custody rather than lexical diffusion.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/399","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatis"},{"cursor":400,"id":400,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","title":"Is the infinitive hatan written in the surviving corpus?","position":"No. The two surviving forms are hatandane and hatandans, both present participles. Hatan is the normalized dictionary citation form assigned by Project Wulfila and the historical grammars.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The complete occurrence inventory and both verse analyses identify only participial forms.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier labels the lexeme attested through two inflected tokens and never quotes the infinitive as manuscript text.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/400","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatan"},{"cursor":401,"id":401,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","title":"Does Gothic preserve exactly two historical uses of hatan?","position":"Project Wulfila currently reports exactly two surviving corpus tokens assigned to the lemma. That count does not include lost manuscripts, spoken Gothic, unrecognized variants, or every use in history.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The lemma page supplies a complete current corpus inventory; the scholarly edition documents the fragmentary survival base.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every count is explicitly bounded to the currently reported surviving corpus.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/401","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatan"},{"cursor":402,"id":402,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","title":"Are hatan and hatjan two Gothic verbs or one fluctuating paradigm?","position":"The sources preserve different analytical levels. Project Wulfila gives separate class-III and class-I lemmas; Orel publishes distinct comparative formations. Braune says hatan fluctuates with class-I hatjan, while Sturtevant proposes a specifically Gothic secondary explanation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Corpus lemmatization, historical grammar, comparative reconstruction, and morphological argument do not collapse to one answer.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":5,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/402","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatan"},{"cursor":403,"id":403,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","title":"Do the written endings alone settle the participles’ case and gender?","position":"No. Project Wulfila gives masculine or neuter genitive plural for hatandane and masculine nominative or accusative plural for hatandans. The clauses resolve the contextual readings through syntax and Greek alignment, but the surface forms remain formally syncretic.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The verse analyses distinguish morphological possibilities from contextual interpretation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/403","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatan"},{"cursor":404,"id":404,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","title":"Does hatan map one-to-one to Greek miseō, hate?","position":"No. Luke 1:71 aligns hatandane with Greek misountōn, those hating, but Luke 6:27 aligns hatandans with echthrous, enemies. A dictionary gloss cannot replace verse-level lexical alignment.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The two complete verse analyses expose different Greek correspondences for the only two tokens.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier records contextual equivalents rather than assigning one timeless source-language gloss.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/404","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatan"},{"cursor":405,"id":405,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","title":"Are hatan and fijan perfect synonyms?","position":"They overlap in the Gothic hate field, but the surviving passages do not prove total synonymy. Luke 1 uses fijandam for enemies and hatandane for those hating; Luke 6 reverses those constructional roles. Sturtevant treats semantic association as relevant to formal association, not as proof that every sense and construction was identical.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The paired verses show controlled alternation while the historical article develops an analogical explanation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/405","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatan"},{"cursor":406,"id":406,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","title":"Was hatan inherited unchanged from Proto-Germanic?","position":"Possibly, not securely. Orel publishes *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan behind a Germanic cognate set. Sturtevant instead judges a specifically Gothic secondary origin more probable, and Braune records fluctuation with hatjan.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"A comparative etymology supports inheritance while two morphological analyses keep internal Gothic remodeling live.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/406","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatan"},{"cursor":407,"id":407,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","title":"Do two surviving tokens prove hatan was rare in spoken Gothic?","position":"No. They measure a bounded and fragmentary textual corpus, not ordinary speech, lost texts, genre distribution, or competition among Gothic hate verbs.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Project Wulfila supplies the current token inventory; the scholarly edition documents the limited surviving source base.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface says two reported corpus tokens, never two historical uses or a speech-frequency estimate.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/407","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatan"},{"cursor":408,"id":408,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","title":"Does the Codex Argenteus route map the spread of hatan?","position":"No. It maps custody of the two directly inspected evidence objects. The codex traveled through Werden, Prague, Stockholm, Holland, and Uppsala long after Gothic ceased to be a living vernacular in those places.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Uppsala University documents the custody route and both token records belong to the same codex.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every post-Ravenna journey note explicitly labels manuscript custody rather than lexical diffusion.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/408","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatan"},{"cursor":409,"id":409,"entryId":183,"entrySlug":"hatan","title":"Does hatan securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only probably. The Germanic family is stronger than the deeper proposal; grief, care, mourning, hatred, pursuit, and persecution do not form one transparent semantic sequence, and some proposed cognates may not belong together.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the proposal; Liberman challenges semantic and membership assumptions.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/409","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatan"},{"cursor":410,"id":410,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","title":"Does the surviving corpus contain 42 secure verb tokens?","position":"No. Project Wulfila exposes 42 candidates under fijan, but only 13 are verified, eight more are lexically unambiguous but unverified, and 21 are explicitly shared with the fijands noun inventory.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The complete lemma pages publish both inventories and their status partitions.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every total is labeled candidate inventory, and the 21-token overlap remains visible.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/410","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijan"},{"cursor":411,"id":411,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","title":"Is the infinitive fijan itself written?","position":"Yes, once in the current inventory: John 7:7 writes fijan. The other 41 candidates are inflected forms, and fian is a normalized variant redirect rather than a separately inventoried exact infinitive token.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Project Wulfila’s token page and the directly inspected folio 33r independently identify the written form.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier distinguishes the one written infinitive from the lemma and spelling variants.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/411","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijan"},{"cursor":412,"id":412,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","title":"Are fijan and fian separate Gothic verbs?","position":"No separate lexeme is supported, but the formal history remains analytical. Project Wulfila redirects fian to fijan, Streitberg groups j-bearing and j-less forms, and Sturtevant discusses loss of j in the sequence.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Corpus lemmatization and historical analysis agree on one lexeme while the precise phonological and orthographic development remains reconstructed.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/412","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijan"},{"cursor":413,"id":413,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","title":"Is fijands an ordinary participle or a lexical noun meaning enemy?","position":"Both categories exist historically and synchronically. Ayora Estevan derives the noun from a Proto-Germanic lexicalized present participle, then shows Gothic still using fi(j)ands as the productive participle one who hates. Token-level syntax and inflection sometimes distinguish them; many surface forms do not.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Historical word formation, Germanic parallels, and Gothic syntax expose two real analyses rather than one mistaken dictionary entry.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/413","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijan"},{"cursor":414,"id":414,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","title":"Can the nd-ending alone distinguish enemy from one who hates?","position":"No. Galatians 4:16 nominative fijands functions as the noun enemy, Romans 11:28 accusative fijandans is analyzed as a participle, and Romans 12:9 fiandans takes an accusative object. Twenty-one other corpus tokens remain explicitly lexically and morphosyntactically ambiguous.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The agent-noun study and Project Wulfila token statuses distinguish contextual disambiguation from surface-form certainty.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/414","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijan"},{"cursor":415,"id":415,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","title":"Does fijan map one-to-one to Greek miseō, hate?","position":"No. Verbal contexts commonly translate Greek miseō, but the shared fijand- formation also corresponds to Greek echthros, enemy. Luke 1:71 and Luke 6:27 even reverse the constructional work done by fijan and hatan.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Verse-level alignments and the overlapping lemma inventories defeat a timeless one-word translation arrow.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier records contextual equivalents and token ambiguity instead of a one-to-one lexicon.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/415","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijan"},{"cursor":416,"id":416,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","title":"Did fijan denote only an inward feeling?","position":"No. Ayora Estevan analyzes it as an experience verb whose Experiencer takes a Stimulus as accusative object. Surviving objects include people, one’s soul, one’s flesh, evils, and what one does, so the grammar encodes a relation toward an object rather than a free-floating feeling alone.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The study formalizes 23 preserved verbal testimonies and their argument structure.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic history records the predicate frame without claiming that every context shares one modern psychological model.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/416","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijan"},{"cursor":417,"id":417,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","title":"Was the enemy noun lexicalized only inside Gothic?","position":"No. Ayora Estevan argues for pre-Gothic, Proto-Germanic lexicalization because Old Norse, Faroese, Old English, Old Frisian, Old Dutch, and Old High German preserve parallel enemy nouns.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Cross-Germanic descendants support an inherited lexicalized nd-formation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph places *fi(j)and- at the Proto-Germanic level and keeps the Gothic noun as its descendant.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/417","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijan"},{"cursor":418,"id":418,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","title":"Do 42 candidate tokens measure spoken Gothic frequency?","position":"No. They measure a bounded, fragmentary textual corpus with duplicate manuscript witnesses, biblical translation effects, and unresolved lemma assignments.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The corpus statuses and manuscript inventory define what the count can and cannot measure.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface never calls the total all historical uses or a speech-frequency sample.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/418","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijan"},{"cursor":419,"id":419,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","title":"Does the Codex Argenteus route map the spread of fijan?","position":"No. Werden, Prague, Stockholm, Holland, and Uppsala trace custody of four inspected evidence objects long after Gothic ceased to be a living vernacular in those places.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Uppsala University documents manuscript custody; the four records all belong to the same codex.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every post-Ravenna journey stage is labeled object custody rather than lexical diffusion.","citationCount":5,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/419","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijan"},{"cursor":420,"id":420,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","title":"Does fijan securely descend from *peh₁-?","position":"Only as a proposal. The Germanic *fi(j)ēn- comparison is stronger than the deeper route; the exact intermediate morphology and semantic unity of harm, blame, suffering, and hate remain reconstructive.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Kroonen publishes the deeper analysis, but the evidence does not recover one directly attested PIE word or unique original scene.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/420","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijan"},{"cursor":421,"id":421,"entryId":184,"entrySlug":"fijan","title":"Are fijan and hatan perfect synonyms?","position":"They overlap, but the surviving corpus does not prove identity. In Luke 1 fijandam supplies enemies and hatandane those hating; in Luke 6 hatandans supplies enemies and fijandam those hating. Sturtevant uses their association in a formal argument without proving interchangeable semantics everywhere.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The paired verses show controlled overlap and a lexical swap, not complete synonymy.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/421","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijan"},{"cursor":422,"id":422,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","title":"Does the surviving corpus contain 26 secure noun tokens?","position":"No. Project Wulfila exposes 26 candidates under fijands: three verified, two further noun-only but unverified, and 21 explicitly shared with the fijan verb inventory.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The two lemma inventories publish the exact partition and overlap.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The site labels 26 as candidates, five as noun-only, and 21 as unresolved overlap.","citationCount":7,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/422","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijands"},{"cursor":423,"id":423,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","title":"Is fijands just an ordinary Gothic present participle?","position":"No single category covers the evidence. Ayora Estevan derives the enemy noun from a Proto-Germanic lexicalized participle while also showing that Gothic retained productive present-participial uses of the same formation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Diachronic word formation and synchronic syntax require both a noun and a live participle.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/423","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijands"},{"cursor":424,"id":424,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","title":"Did one who hates lexicalize as enemy only inside Gothic?","position":"No. Old Norse, Faroese, Old English, Old Frisian, Old Dutch, and Old High German enemy nouns require a pre-Gothic Germanic formation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Cross-branch descendants support Proto-Germanic lexicalization.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph places *fi(j)and- at the Proto-Germanic level and Gothic fijands below it.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/424","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijands"},{"cursor":425,"id":425,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","title":"Can the nd-ending alone distinguish enemy from one who hates?","position":"No. The noun and productive participle share surface inflection. Case, complementation, agreement, and context resolve some passages, but Project Wulfila leaves 21 candidates lexically and morphosyntactically ambiguous.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Ayora Estevan’s diagnostics resolve selected tokens without manufacturing certainty for the remainder.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/425","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijands"},{"cursor":426,"id":426,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","title":"Was fijands still transparently one who hates to Gothic speakers?","position":"The formal relationship was available because the verb and productive participle survived, but inherited lexicalization means ordinary noun use need not have been compositionally reanalyzed on every occasion.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The corpus shows coexistence, not speaker introspection or one uniform degree of transparency.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/426","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijands"},{"cursor":427,"id":427,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","title":"Did Gothic fijands mean devil or evil spirit?","position":"The reviewed Gothic noun inventory centers on enemy and regularly translates Greek echthros. Old English feónd developed or preserved devil senses, but that collateral history cannot be projected backward onto every Gothic occurrence.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Project Wulfila and Streitberg gloss the Gothic noun as enemy; Bosworth–Toller documents the Old English enemy, foe, and devil range.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph separates cognate branches and their semantic histories.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/427","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijands"},{"cursor":428,"id":428,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","title":"Is English fiend descended from Gothic fijands?","position":"No. English fiend continues Old English feónd; Gothic fijands is a collateral Germanic cousin from the same reconstructed formation, not the donor of the English word.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Bosworth–Toller supplies the Old and Middle English history, while Ayora Estevan supplies the common Germanic formation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph connects both branches at *fi(j)and- rather than drawing a Gothic-to-English arrow.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/428","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijands"},{"cursor":429,"id":429,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","title":"Does *fi(j)and- securely descend from *peh₁-?","position":"Only through the proposed deeper analysis of its Germanic verb base. The lexicalized participle-to-verb relation is stronger than the Indo-European route, whose intermediate morphology and semantic unity remain reconstructive.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Kroonen publishes the deeper comparison with the same uncertainty inherited by this noun trail.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/429","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijands"},{"cursor":430,"id":430,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","title":"Do 26 candidates measure spoken Gothic frequency?","position":"No. They measure a bounded fragmentary textual corpus with biblical translation effects, ambiguous lemma assignments, and duplicate manuscript witnesses.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Project Wulfila’s statuses and the Gothic manuscript inventory define what the count can measure.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface never calls the total all historical uses or a speech-frequency sample.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/430","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijands"},{"cursor":431,"id":431,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","title":"Does the Codex Argenteus route map the geographic spread of fijands?","position":"No. Werden, Prague, Stockholm, Holland, and Uppsala trace custody of evidence objects long after Gothic ceased to be a living vernacular in those places.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Uppsala University documents manuscript custody; the five inspected noun-only tokens belong to one codex.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Post-Ravenna journey stages are labeled object custody rather than lexical diffusion.","citationCount":5,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/431","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijands"},{"cursor":432,"id":432,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","title":"Are A, B, and Carolinus witnesses separate lexical usage events?","position":"They are separate surviving manuscript tokens, but duplicate witnesses of one passage cannot be counted as independent acts of historical usage.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The corpus inventory identifies sigla separately while verse identity exposes duplication.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Attestations preserve each physical witness and explicitly reject frequency inference.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/432","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijands"},{"cursor":433,"id":433,"entryId":185,"entrySlug":"fijands","title":"Does the Luke lexical swap resolve the remaining 21 noun-participle candidates?","position":"No. Luke 1:71 and 6:27 show that fijan and hatan can exchange the work of enemies and those hating, but those two contextual alignments do not determine every other fijand- token.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The paired verses demonstrate translation flexibility and preserve, rather than erase, the wider category problem.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/433","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fijands"},{"cursor":434,"id":434,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","title":"Did Old English fēond mean only the Devil?","position":"No. Bosworth–Toller gives enemy, foe, and Devil, while OED separates literal enemy, the Devil, demons, and malevolent-person uses already present in Old English.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Two historical dictionaries and multiple located Old English examples preserve a polysemous noun.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier keeps the senses distinct instead of retrojecting modern fiend onto every token.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/434","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feond"},{"cursor":435,"id":435,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","title":"Is English fiend descended from Gothic fijands?","position":"No. English fiend continues Old English fēond; Gothic fijands is a collateral Germanic cousin. Both meet at the reconstructed *fi(j)and- formation.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"OED and Bosworth–Toller document the direct English line, while Ayora Estevan documents the shared Germanic formation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No Gothic-to-English borrowing edge is drawn.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/435","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feond"},{"cursor":436,"id":436,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","title":"Was fēond still just an ordinary Old English present participle?","position":"No. OED classifies it as a strong masculine agent noun originally in the nd-class, and cross-Germanic evidence places lexicalization before Old English. Its participial origin remains historically visible without erasing noun status.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"OED morphology and Ayora Estevan’s Germanic analysis agree on a lexicalized agent noun.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph uses lexicalized_participle for historical formation and noun for the attested Old English category.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/436","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feond"},{"cursor":437,"id":437,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","title":"Do fēond, fīond, fīend, and fȳnd name separate words?","position":"No. OED explains unmutated dialect forms and i-mutated inflectional forms inside one inherited paradigm, with later analogical remodeling.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The revised forms and etymology sections publish dialect, case, number, and analogical distributions.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The variants remain relatives and witnesses of one dossier rather than duplicate headwords.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/437","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feond"},{"cursor":438,"id":438,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","title":"Did fiend originally mean demon?","position":"No. OED dates enemy or foe from Old English to 1450 and marks it obsolete; Devil was originally a specific use of enemy as the ultimate adversary.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"OED’s meaning history explicitly orders enemy before or alongside the specialized Devil use.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic route preserves specialization rather than replacing the early range with the modern one.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/438","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feond"},{"cursor":439,"id":439,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","title":"Why could enemy become the Devil?","position":"OED explains the Devil as the original or ultimate enemy, early translating Latin hostis and ultimately reflecting the literal adversary sense of Hebrew satan. This is a semantic and translation history, not proof of one coinage event.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"OED’s revised sense note supplies the adversary bridge and its evidentiary limit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The site states the bridge without inventing a unique first metaphor-maker.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/439","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feond"},{"cursor":440,"id":440,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","title":"Did Old English fēond have one regular plural?","position":"No. OED records endingless i-mutated and unmutated plurals, re-formed fēondas or fīondas, and occasional weak forms.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The revised Old English notes publish the competing inherited and remodeled patterns.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier treats inflectional variation as evidence, not noise.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/440","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feond"},{"cursor":441,"id":441,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","title":"Are fiend and friend the same root with opposite meanings?","position":"No. OED says friend is an antonym with a similar agent-noun formation. Similar morphology does not establish one lexical root or cognate pair.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The OED etymology explicitly compares the formations while keeping their bases distinct.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Friend is listed as a morphological parallel, not a parent, child, or cognate.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/441","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feond"},{"cursor":442,"id":442,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","title":"Is the deepest *peh₁- route established?","position":"No. The Germanic verb and lexicalized agent formation are firmer than the proposed Indo-European comparison, whose formal intermediates and semantic unity remain reconstructive.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Kroonen publishes the deeper route with analytical reconstruction rather than direct attestation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/442","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feond"},{"cursor":443,"id":443,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","title":"Does Beowulf 2289 show a demon sense?","position":"No. The directly inspected folio preserves feondes fotlast in a scene where the dragon finds the foe’s footprint. The pixels establish the form and local context, not the entire lexeme.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Electronic Beowulf aligns verse 2289 to Cotton MS Vitellius A XV folio 180v, whose image was directly inspected.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The witness record is limited to what the page visibly supports.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/443","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feond"},{"cursor":444,"id":444,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","title":"Do 188 Middle English quotations equal the complete history of fiend?","position":"No. They are the Middle English Dictionary’s current quotation set across eight senses, not a count of every historical utterance or surviving token.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The MED publishes its bounded quotation and sense counts.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The count is labeled as dictionary evidence rather than language-wide frequency.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/444","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feond"},{"cursor":445,"id":445,"entryId":186,"entrySlug":"feond","title":"Did every early fīend- form arise from inherited i-mutation?","position":"Not necessarily. OED notes that especially in early Mercian, some apparently mutated stems may instead have been re-formed after the present participle of fēon.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The revised etymology preserves inherited inflection and analogical re-formation as alternatives in part of the record.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/445","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feond"},{"cursor":446,"id":446,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","title":"Is fēogan a strong verb or a weak contracted verb?","position":"Bosworth–Toller labels the full FEÓGAN entry strong, but labels linked contracted feón weak and contracted. The displayed past forms in -de also require grammatical explanation. The dossier preserves the source-level tension rather than silently harmonizing it.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The two linked dictionary records use different class labels for the same hate-verb family.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/446","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feogan"},{"cursor":447,"id":447,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","title":"Are fēogan and feón separate hate verbs?","position":"No secure split is modeled. Bosworth–Toller links feón directly as a similar entry and the full paradigm lists feón among fēogan’s contracted variants.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The grammar and cross-links place both infinitives in one lexical dossier.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Feón remains a variant relative rather than a second ancestry node.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/447","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feogan"},{"cursor":448,"id":448,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","title":"Did fēogan mean only an inward emotion?","position":"No. The dictionary glosses hate and persecute, while examples take people, crimes, evil, unjust ways, law, peace, and a temple as objects.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The definition and ten located examples document both affective and hostile-action contexts.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier keeps the historical transitive range instead of substituting a single modern psychological gloss.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/448","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feogan"},{"cursor":449,"id":449,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","title":"Is fēogan the direct historical parent of English fiend?","position":"Not as a simple word-to-word descent. Fiend continues Old English fēond, the lexicalized Germanic one-who-hates formation; fēogan continues the related verb base.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"OED and the Germanic analysis separate the recorded English noun line from the cognate verb line.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins them at reconstructed word formation and draws no fēogan-to-fiend borrowing edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/449","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feogan"},{"cursor":450,"id":450,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","title":"Is feógende automatically the noun fēond?","position":"No. Feógende is the productive Old English participle listed in the verb paradigm. Fēond is a lexicalized nd-agent noun inherited from the prehistoric formation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Bosworth–Toller supplies both categories, while Ayora Estevan places noun lexicalization before the recorded branches.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Morphological ancestry is preserved without erasing lexical category.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/450","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feogan"},{"cursor":451,"id":451,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","title":"Is this hate verb the same word as feón meaning rejoice?","position":"No. Bosworth–Toller records a separate homographic feón meaning rejoice, be glad, or exult. Shared spelling after contraction does not establish shared sense or ancestry.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Dictionary search results and linked entries distinguish the hate and rejoice verbs.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The rejoice homograph is excluded from the ancestry trail.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/451","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feogan"},{"cursor":452,"id":452,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","title":"Was fēogan borrowed from Gothic fijan?","position":"No borrowing is established. Bosworth–Toller presents Gothic, Old High German, and Old Icelandic comparisons, while Kroonen reconstructs their Germanic verbal ancestor.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Comparative Germanic evidence supports collateral inheritance rather than a Gothic-to-English transfer.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph uses inheritance from *fi(j)ēn-, not borrowing from Gothic.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/452","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feogan"},{"cursor":453,"id":453,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","title":"Is the deepest *peh₁- route established?","position":"No. The Germanic verb comparison is firmer than the proposed Indo-European analysis, whose formal intermediates and semantic unity remain reconstructive.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Kroonen publishes the deeper route as analysis rather than direct attestation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/453","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feogan"},{"cursor":454,"id":454,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","title":"Do feógean, fiógan, feón, and fión prove separate lexemes?","position":"No. They are presented inside one paradigm or as linked contracted forms. Variation in vowel, spelling, and contraction is evidence about the verb, not a license to multiply headwords.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The FEÓGAN grammar lists the variants together and the feón entry links back to feógan.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The variants remain relatives attached to one canonical headword node.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/454","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feogan"},{"cursor":455,"id":455,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","title":"Are the ten Bosworth–Toller examples the complete fēogan corpus?","position":"No. They are the examples exposed by this dictionary entry, not a count of every surviving token, manuscript, lost text, or spoken use.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The source is a historical dictionary entry with an edited example list.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier labels every occurrence source-reported and makes no corpus-total claim.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/455","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feogan"},{"cursor":456,"id":456,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","title":"Does the fiógaþ manuscript variant establish exact Old English pronunciation?","position":"No. A spelling variant supports textual variation but does not by itself fix one phonetic value across dialects, periods, and inflections.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Bosworth–Toller reports Feógeaþ with fiógaþ in manuscript T.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The form is preserved without converting orthography into false acoustic certainty.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/456","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feogan"},{"cursor":457,"id":457,"entryId":187,"entrySlug":"feogan","title":"When did fēogan cease to be an ordinary verb?","position":"The reviewed evidence does not establish one last-use date or a complete Middle English continuation. The trail therefore stops at the Old English written record instead of inventing an extinction year.","confidence":"speculative","sourceSummary":"The current sources establish Old English use and the noun family’s later survival, but not a final verb occurrence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/457","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feogan"},{"cursor":458,"id":458,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","title":"Did fiend originally mean demon?","position":"No. OED records enemy or foe from Old English to 1450 and explains the Devil as a specific use of enemy as the ultimate adversary.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"OED’s revised meaning history and the MED’s first sense preserve the literal enemy record.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier begins with enemy and models Devil and demon as semantic specializations rather than original definitions.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/458","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiend"},{"cursor":459,"id":459,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","title":"Is English fiend descended from Gothic fijands?","position":"No. English fiend continues Old English fēond; Gothic fijands is a collateral Germanic cousin. Both meet at reconstructed *fi(j)and-.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"OED documents the English inheritance, while Ayora Estevan places Gothic and Old English on inherited Germanic branches.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No Gothic-to-English borrowing edge is drawn.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/459","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiend"},{"cursor":460,"id":460,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","title":"Was Middle English fẹ̄nd borrowed anew from another language?","position":"No borrowing is established. OED and the Middle English Dictionary both derive the medieval forms from Old English fēond or fīond.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Two independent historical-dictionary records publish direct English continuity.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph keeps one inherited English branch through medieval spelling variation.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/460","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiend"},{"cursor":461,"id":461,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","title":"Does the spelling fiend preserve one unchanged pronunciation?","position":"No. OED reports coexisting long and short vowels in Middle and early modern English and says the long vowel became dominant by the eighteenth century.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The revised later-development note explicitly documents pronunciation competition.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier does not read modern spelling backward as a single nine-century sound value.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/461","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiend"},{"cursor":462,"id":462,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","title":"Are fiend and friend the same root with opposite meanings?","position":"No. OED calls friend an antonym with a similar agent-noun formation. Similar morphology does not establish one lexical root.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The etymology compares parallel formations while keeping their verbal bases distinct.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Friend remains a morphological parallel, not a parent, child, or cognate.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/462","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiend"},{"cursor":463,"id":463,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","title":"Did the Devil sense immediately replace the enemy sense?","position":"No. Enemy or foe remains recorded into the fifteenth century while Devil, demon, monster, and other senses coexist through the Middle English record.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"OED dates and MED’s eight-sense inventory document semantic overlap rather than an instant switch.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The timeline models specialization and coexistence, not replacement at one moment.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/463","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiend"},{"cursor":464,"id":464,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","title":"Is Hebrew satan an ancestor node of English fiend?","position":"No. OED invokes Hebrew śāṭān, adversary, to explain the conceptual and translation background of the Devil-as-Enemy use; it does not derive the English word from Hebrew.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"OED’s sense note distinguishes the semantic bridge from the inherited Germanic etymology.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph records the Germanic ancestry and keeps Hebrew out of the lexical parent chain.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/464","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiend"},{"cursor":465,"id":465,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","title":"Did every early fīend- form arise from inherited i-mutation?","position":"Not necessarily. OED notes that especially in early Mercian, some apparently mutated stems may instead have been re-formed after the present participle of fēon.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The revised etymology preserves inherited inflection and analogical re-formation as alternatives in part of the record.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/465","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiend"},{"cursor":466,"id":466,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","title":"Is the deepest *peh₁- route established?","position":"No. The Germanic verb and lexicalized agent formation are firmer than the proposed Indo-European comparison, whose formal intermediates and semantic unity remain reconstructive.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Kroonen publishes the deeper route as analysis rather than direct attestation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/466","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiend"},{"cursor":467,"id":467,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","title":"Do 188 Middle English quotations equal the complete history of fiend?","position":"No. They are the Middle English Dictionary’s current quotation set across eight senses, not every historical utterance, lost witness, or surviving token.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The MED exposes a bounded lexicographic evidence set.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The count is labeled as dictionary evidence rather than total historical frequency.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/467","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiend"},{"cursor":468,"id":468,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","title":"Can one coinage event be named for enemy becoming the Devil?","position":"No unique event is established. OED explains a recurring ultimate-enemy use shaped by Latin hostis and the adversary meaning behind satan, but does not identify one inventor or first metaphorical moment.","confidence":"speculative","sourceSummary":"The semantic bridge is documented more securely than any single origin event.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/468","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiend"},{"cursor":469,"id":469,"entryId":188,"entrySlug":"fiend","title":"Is enemy still the ordinary modern meaning of fiend?","position":"No. OED marks the literal enemy or foe sense obsolete and dates that sense through 1450, while supernatural and hostile-person senses continue.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The revised sense chronology distinguishes obsolete and continuing uses.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The contrarian claim is historical, not a prescription for current usage.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/469","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiend"},{"cursor":470,"id":470,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","title":"Did German Feind originally mean demon?","position":"No. The High German record centers on enemy or adversary. DWB does document der böse Feind or der Feind for the Devil, but that is a historical specialization beside the ordinary enemy noun, not the original definition.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Duden and DWDS give enemy or opponent as the core; DWB separately records the Devil expression.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier preserves the secondary Devil use without rewriting the German headword as a demon noun.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/470","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feind"},{"cursor":471,"id":471,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","title":"Was Feind borrowed from English fiend?","position":"No borrowing is established. German Feind continues Old and Middle High German forms; English fiend independently continues Old English fēond. Both branches meet at reconstructed *fi(j)and-.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Duden, DWDS, DWB, and OED publish collateral inherited histories.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins the words at the Germanic formation and draws no English-to-German arrow.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/471","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feind"},{"cursor":472,"id":472,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","title":"Does every modern Feind literally mean one who hates?","position":"No. The participial source is historical morphology. Modern Duden senses include personal enemy, hostile power or force, and a determined opponent of something without requiring a recoverable emotion in every token.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Duden separates current lexical senses from the Herkunft statement.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The truth claim is diachronic, not a compositional definition imposed on modern speakers.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/472","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feind"},{"cursor":473,"id":473,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","title":"Can Feind refer only to a personal human enemy?","position":"No. Duden also records hostile powers, enemy soldiers or troops, threats to a group, figurative natural enemies, and opponents of practices or causes.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The modern sense inventory is explicitly broader than one interpersonal relation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The headword gloss and semantic journey retain the documented range.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/473","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feind"},{"cursor":474,"id":474,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","title":"Are fīant, fījant, vīant, vīent, and vīnt separate ancestry branches?","position":"Not in the reviewed sources. They are variants inside the Old and Middle High German continuation of one inherited enemy noun.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Duden, DWDS, and DWB group the forms in one etymological chain.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph chooses one representative node per historical stage and keeps the remaining spellings as cited relatives.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/474","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feind"},{"cursor":475,"id":475,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","title":"Are Feind and Freund the same root with opposite meanings?","position":"No. DWDS and DWB compare parallel fossilized participial morphology. The antonymy does not establish one verbal base or a single lexical root.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionaries invoke Freund as a morphological analogy, not Feind’s parent or cognate from the same verb.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Freund remains a parallel formation outside the ancestry trail.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/475","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feind"},{"cursor":476,"id":476,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","title":"Did every Germanic cognate preserve the same semantic history?","position":"No. German Feind remains an ordinary enemy noun, English fiend foregrounds demon and vicious-person senses, and Old Norse is glossed enemy or devil. Shared ancestry does not erase branch-specific semantics.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"DWDS supplies the cross-branch set and OED documents the English specialization.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The leaderboard reveal compares outcomes without treating one daughter language as the original meaning.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/476","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feind"},{"cursor":477,"id":477,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","title":"Did one who hates lexicalize as enemy only inside High German?","position":"No. Gothic, Old English, Old Frisian, Old Dutch, Old High German, and North Germanic parallels require an earlier Germanic formation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Ayora Estevan argues for pre-Gothic lexicalization and the dictionaries preserve the branch forms.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph places *fi(j)and- at the Proto-Germanic level.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/477","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feind"},{"cursor":478,"id":478,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","title":"Is the exact phonetic shape of *fi(j)and- directly known?","position":"No. The form is a comparative reconstruction. Optional j notation, branch vowels, and the relation of written historical variants require analysis rather than direct Proto-Germanic observation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Kroonen, Ayora Estevan, and Pfeifer publish compatible comparative forms with normalized notation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/478","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feind"},{"cursor":479,"id":479,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","title":"Is the deepest *peh₁- route established?","position":"No. The Germanic verb and lexicalized agent formation are firmer than the proposed Indo-European comparison, whose formal intermediates and semantic unity remain reconstructive.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Kroonen publishes the deeper route as analysis rather than direct attestation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/479","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feind"},{"cursor":480,"id":480,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","title":"Did Grimm establish a root meaning foam or fury?","position":"No. DWB speculates about foam and rage but immediately says the matter should remain undecided and requires confirmation. It is evidence of scholarly history, not a secure ancestry node.","confidence":"speculative","sourceSummary":"The qualification appears inside the historical dictionary’s own root discussion.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The foam proposal is preserved as a challenged hypothesis and excluded from the canonical route.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/480","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feind"},{"cursor":481,"id":481,"entryId":189,"entrySlug":"feind","title":"Can the lexicalization of one who hates as enemy be dated to one exact event?","position":"No unique event is known. Cross-branch evidence places it before the recorded daughter languages, but no text records the prehistoric lexicalization moment.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Comparative distribution establishes relative chronology more securely than an absolute date.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/481","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/feind"},{"cursor":482,"id":482,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","title":"Has Hass always meant only intense inner aversion?","position":"No. Modern Duden centers intense aversion and hostility, but DWB reports Middle High German hostile action, anger expressed in deeds, pursuit, and measured rivalry beside the familiar disposition sense.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The modern and historical dictionaries explicitly document different contextual ranges.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The semantic history preserves the rare side meanings without replacing the current definition.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/482","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hass"},{"cursor":483,"id":483,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","title":"Could medieval haʒ describe friendly competition?","position":"Yes in one cited Erec context. DWB quotes riders who friuntlîchen striten and calls their contest bescheiden haʒ, rivalry in pursuing a goal. This does not make every medieval use friendly.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"DWB gives the passage, work locator, and its rivalry interpretation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The leaderboard claim is limited to the cited contextual sense and source-reported status.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/483","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hass"},{"cursor":484,"id":484,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","title":"Did the 1996 reform create the word Hass?","position":"No. Duden reports a spelling change; the noun continues Old and Middle High German haʒ and centuries of New High German Haß or hasz.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Duden dates the orthographic change and all three dictionaries publish the older lineage.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph models spelling reform as an edge, not a lexical birth.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/484","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hass"},{"cursor":485,"id":485,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","title":"Was the original meaning hostile pursuit or suffering and sorrow?","position":"Unresolved. DWB argues for hostile pursuit or persecution as the original center; Duden glosses the origin as suffering, sorrow, and resentment; DWDS foregrounds hostile disposition, resentment, and enmity.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The reviewed dictionaries preserve competing semantic reconstructions.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/485","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hass"},{"cursor":486,"id":486,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","title":"Does the friendly-rivalry sense come from Old High German evidence?","position":"Not in the reviewed record. DWB says hostile disposition is exclusively attested in Old High German and places the friendly-rivalry passage in Middle High German Erec.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"DWB explicitly separates the historical evidence periods.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The route does not project the Erec sense backward into the eighth century.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/486","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hass"},{"cursor":487,"id":487,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","title":"Was German Hass borrowed from English hate?","position":"No borrowing is established. German Hass continues Old High German haʒ; English hate continues an Old English noun-and-verb history. The branches meet at reconstructed Germanic material.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"DWDS and DWB list collateral inherited forms across Germanic.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph joins the words at shared reconstruction and draws no English-to-German arrow.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/487","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hass"},{"cursor":488,"id":488,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","title":"Are Haß and Hass different etymological words?","position":"No. They are standard-spelling stages of the same noun. Duden explicitly flags the 1996 spelling change without a semantic or pronunciation split.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The spelling note and historical lineage resolve the distinction.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The forms remain separate route nodes only so the orthographic event is visible.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/488","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hass"},{"cursor":489,"id":489,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","title":"Is the exact Proto-Germanic noun *hatiz- or *hataz?","position":"The noun is reconstructed, and published notation reflects stem alternation and analytical choices. Koch prints *hataz ~ *hatiz- while Merriam-Webster foregrounds *hatiz-.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The descendants are attested but the Proto-Germanic paradigm is comparative.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/489","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hass"},{"cursor":490,"id":490,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","title":"Does Hass securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only as a qualified proposal. Formal correspondence is published, but the semantic chain through grief, care, pain, pursuit, and hatred is not transparent.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the comparison and Liberman challenges the wider semantic family.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/490","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hass"},{"cursor":491,"id":491,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","title":"Do Celtic cais and Greek κῆδος prove that love and hate share one root?","position":"No. They belong to a disputed wider comparison. Middle Irish cais carries a striking love-and-hatred field, but that does not make German Liebe an ancestor or cognate of Hass.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The comparison is published with explicit semantic and membership cautions.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/491","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hass"},{"cursor":492,"id":492,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","title":"Is Hass categorically incapable of a plural?","position":"No across history. DWDS marks current Hass as singular-only, while DWB calls historical plurals rare and quotes theological hasse and poetic die hasse.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The sources distinguish current grammar from rare historical usage.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier does not turn a current grammar label into an eternal ban.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/492","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hass"},{"cursor":493,"id":493,"entryId":190,"entrySlug":"hass","title":"Does modern Hass require a hostile action?","position":"No. Duden defines a strong feeling of rejection or hostility; DWB says New High German ordinarily preserves hostile disposition. Action-centered uses matter historically without becoming a requirement for every modern token.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Modern definitions and the historical semantic division agree on this distinction.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The current headword gloss remains feeling-centered while the ancestry edges preserve the action dispute.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/493","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hass"},{"cursor":494,"id":494,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","title":"Is the ordinary Old Norse noun hatr neuter?","position":"Yes in the dominant edited record. ONP’s main entry is ²hatr sb. n., gives genitive hatrs, and contains 54 citations; Cleasby and Vigfússon also label the noun neuter.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"A modern corpus dictionary and the historical dictionary independently classify the main noun.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The route labels the headword chiefly neuter while preserving the separate masculine anomaly.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/494","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatr"},{"cursor":495,"id":495,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","title":"Is there also a masculine hatr?","position":"ONP maintains a separate masculine analysis, but it rests on one citation and the editors flag it as possibly an elementary error. The possibility remains visible without being promoted to parity with the 54-citation neuter entry.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The source itself separates the entry and supplies both the count and warning.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/495","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatr"},{"cursor":496,"id":496,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","title":"Do the two ONP entries prove two equally secure Old Norse nouns?","position":"No. Editorial separation records an analytical problem; the 54-to-1 citation imbalance and explicit error warning make equal security unjustified.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The conclusion is limited to the public dictionary’s evidence counts and qualification.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface says grammar problem, not two established homonyms.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/496","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatr"},{"cursor":497,"id":497,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","title":"Could hatr mean mockery or scorn?","position":"Possibly in one context. ONP prints question marks before both the Danish and English glosses and compares Latin irrisio. One source-reported passage does not establish a broad independent sense.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The citation page preserves the passage, manuscript range, Latin comparison, and editorial question marks.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/497","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatr"},{"cursor":498,"id":498,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","title":"Did hatr mean only a private inner feeling?","position":"No. ONP’s principal gloss includes enmity and spite, and its citations include definitions involving desire to harm, opposition to love, and contextual persecution. That range does not make every token an action.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The main entry documents the corpus-wide range and located examples.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier retains hatred, enmity, and spite rather than reducing the noun to modern personal dislike.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/498","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatr"},{"cursor":499,"id":499,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","title":"Is the c.1150-1200 Hatr token the first known use?","position":"Not established. The inspected object proves a token in that codex; neither ONP nor the facsimile inspection licenses a global earliest-surviving-use claim.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The manuscript is dated and located, but firstness would require a separate exhaustive comparison.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The witness card says dated manuscript token, not first use.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/499","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatr"},{"cursor":500,"id":500,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","title":"Is the exact Proto-Germanic noun *hatiz- or *hataz?","position":"The noun is reconstructed, and published notation reflects stem alternation and analytical choices. Koch prints *hataz ~ *hatiz- while the atlas reuses the shared *hatiz- node.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The descendants are attested but the Proto-Germanic paradigm is comparative.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/500","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatr"},{"cursor":501,"id":501,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","title":"Does hatr securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only as a qualified proposal. Formal correspondence is published, but the semantic chain through grief, care, pain, pursuit, and hatred is not transparent.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the comparison and Liberman challenges the wider semantic family.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/501","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatr"},{"cursor":502,"id":502,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","title":"Was Old Norse hatr borrowed from English hate or German Hass?","position":"No such borrowing is established. The historical dictionaries list collateral Germanic forms, and Koch connects them through a reconstructed Germanic noun.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Independent branch forms and comparative reconstruction support inheritance rather than a modern-language donor.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins the dossiers at *hatiz- and draws no English-to-Norse or German-to-Norse arrow.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/502","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatr"},{"cursor":503,"id":503,"entryId":191,"entrySlug":"hatr","title":"Does textual opposition between love and hatr prove shared ancestry?","position":"No. The Time gráts ok látrs, time ælsko ok hatrs passage aligns love and hate semantically, but opposition inside a sentence is not a genealogical edge.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ONP supplies the text and Latin alignment; the reviewed graph keeps the ancestry separate.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The opposition remains an attestation and never becomes a false root link.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/503","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatr"},{"cursor":504,"id":504,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","title":"Does modern hassen apply only to people?","position":"No. Duden separates hatred toward a person from strong aversion toward a thing or action and gives clausal-object examples.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The contemporary dictionary explicitly publishes two related senses.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier keeps both current senses instead of forcing every object into personal hatred.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/504","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hassen"},{"cursor":505,"id":505,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","title":"Did hassen once express hostile action or pursuit?","position":"Yes in the reviewed historical accounts. Duden says the old forms also meant pursue; DWB labels hostile pursuit or persecution the original sense and cites Old and Middle High German alignments.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Two independent dictionaries publish the action history, and DWB supplies located examples.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The claim remains source-attributed and does not convert every historical token into persecution.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/505","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hassen"},{"cursor":506,"id":506,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","title":"Is hostile pursuit the securely recovered original meaning?","position":"Not beyond dispute. DWB calls it original and Duden independently notes pursue, but the surviving examples, the exact weak-verb reconstruction, and the deeper comparison do not recover one prehistoric scene with certainty.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The action hypothesis is strongly documented inside German history while the comparative semantic center remains unresolved.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/506","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hassen"},{"cursor":507,"id":507,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","title":"Was the verb formed directly from the noun Hass?","position":"The Germanic weak-verb family is grouped with the *hatiz- noun base, but the exact historical formation and direction are reconstructed rather than directly witnessed in German.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Orel and Merriam-Webster connect the formations while differing in reconstruction detail.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/507","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hassen"},{"cursor":508,"id":508,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","title":"Are haʒʒēn and haʒʒōn separate unrelated Old High German verbs?","position":"No such split is established. Duden prints both as historical forms of hassen, while the historical sources preserve variant weak-verb formations and spellings.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The dictionaries group the variants under one lineage without claiming one identical paradigm in every source.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The route displays both variants in one qualified stage and leaves exact morphology to the reconstruction dispute.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/508","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hassen"},{"cursor":509,"id":509,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","title":"Is the Proto-Germanic parent exactly *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan?","position":"The comparative verb family is secure, but its notation and subclass are not singular. Orel prints the alternatives; Merriam-Webster foregrounds *hatōjan- for the related inherited verb formation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Two etymological sources agree on the family while preserving different analytical forms.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/509","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hassen"},{"cursor":510,"id":510,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","title":"Does current hassen ordinarily mean physically persecute?","position":"No. Duden’s current meanings center hatred and strong aversion. Pursuit and persecution belong to the historical semantic account, not a requirement of the current standard verb.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The modern definition and historical dictionary division agree on the distinction.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The headword gloss remains current while the older action lane stays visible.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/510","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hassen"},{"cursor":511,"id":511,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","title":"Were the Behaim examples directly inspected in a manuscript?","position":"No. They are located reports in DWB. Browser permissions blocked the available digitized editions during this review, so neither a manuscript nor printed edition object is promoted as directly inspected.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The evidence ledger records the dictionary source and explicit inspection limit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Both attestations remain source-reported and have no facsimile or inspection record.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/511","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hassen"},{"cursor":512,"id":512,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","title":"Does the 1343 Behaim work establish the first use of hassen?","position":"No. It supplies two located historical contexts, not a complete comparison of all earlier witnesses or a token-level earliest-use proof.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"DWB also reports Old High German material and multiple Middle High German sources.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The date is a work horizon and the dossier makes no first-known-use claim.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/512","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hassen"},{"cursor":513,"id":513,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","title":"Was German hassen borrowed from English hate?","position":"No borrowing is established. German hassen continues Old and Middle High German forms; English hate follows its own Old English branch. They meet only in reconstructed Germanic material.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Duden, DWB, Orel, and the connected English dossiers document collateral inheritance.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph joins the branches at reconstruction and draws no English-to-German arrow.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/513","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hassen"},{"cursor":514,"id":514,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","title":"Is hetzen simply the same verb as hassen?","position":"No. Duden analyzes hetzen as a causative formation related to hassen—historically make hate or bring to hostile pursuit—while the modern verbs have distinct forms and ordinary meanings.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The etymological note connects the action histories without collapsing the lexemes.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/514","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hassen"},{"cursor":515,"id":515,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","title":"Does hassen securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only as a qualified proposal. Formal correspondence is published, but grief, pain, care, mourning, pursuit, and hatred do not form one transparent semantic sequence.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the comparison and Liberman challenges its wider semantic unity.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/515","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hassen"},{"cursor":516,"id":516,"entryId":192,"entrySlug":"hassen","title":"Did the shift from persecution to feeling happen in one dated event?","position":"No single event is established. DWB describes a contrast between hostile deeds and a more muted hostile disposition, while historical and modern examples show overlapping contextual ranges.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The dictionaries support a semantic development but do not date one universal switch.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/516","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hassen"},{"cursor":517,"id":517,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","title":"Does modern vijand refer only to one personally hated individual?","position":"No. Current and historical Dutch evidence covers persons, groups, political or military opponents, figurative threats, diseases, animals, and plant threats.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ANW, WNT, and EWN document broader grammar and usage.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The headword gloss keeps enemy or opponent broad and does not force every token into private hatred.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/517","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vijand"},{"cursor":518,"id":518,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","title":"Was vijand historically a present participle?","position":"Yes at the inherited formation level. EWN calls it an early independently used present participle, ONW calls it originally the present participle of the lost corresponding verb, and Kroonen reconstructs *fi(j)and-.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Independent Dutch and Proto-Germanic authorities converge on the analysis, while the parent form remains reconstructed.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier labels the parent with an asterisk and states literal one-who-hates as a word-formation analysis, not an attested Dutch sentence.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/518","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vijand"},{"cursor":519,"id":519,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","title":"Is modern vijand still a productive Dutch participle?","position":"No. ONW classifies the Old Dutch noun as synchronically unsegmented and says the corresponding verb is no longer known in Dutch; ANW classifies current vijand as a masculine noun.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical origin and modern grammatical category are explicitly distinct in the sources.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier uses fossilized or lexicalized participle, never a modern participial parse.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/519","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vijand"},{"cursor":520,"id":520,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","title":"Was vijand genuinely used for the Devil in medieval Dutch?","position":"Yes. VMNW has a dedicated Devil branch with multiple located thirteenth-century Lucifer and evil-spirit passages. ONW also lists a possible earlier Devil record.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The Middle Dutch record is repeated and explicit even though the earliest Old Dutch token is disputed.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Secure Middle Dutch Devil evidence is kept separate from the uncertain Old Dutch reading.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/520","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vijand"},{"cursor":521,"id":521,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","title":"Does Dfiunt / fiunt securely name the Devil in the earliest Old Dutch record?","position":"No. ONW reports that most editions read fiunt, Heyne proposed an error for diufil, both can render Latin diabolus, and the initial D has competing analyses.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionary itself publishes the textual dispute and alternative readings.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/521","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vijand"},{"cursor":522,"id":522,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","title":"Are the 901–1000 Wachtendonck Psalms forms directly inspected tenth-century manuscript tokens?","position":"No. ONW labels the records with much later copy dates, including 1595–1605 and circa 1598. This review inspected the lexical corpus record, not an original tenth-century object.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The corpus metadata separates linguistic dating from surviving-copy dating.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"All Wachtendonck Psalms attestations remain source-reported and receive no facsimile or witness-inspection record.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/522","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vijand"},{"cursor":523,"id":523,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","title":"Did the Devil preserve vijand’s full ending?","position":"Possibly, not certainly. Van Veen, De Vries, Van Haeringen, and EWN repeat variants of the proposal that medieval Devil usage made vijand a church or consecrated term whose full ending resisted the reduction seen in vriend. Their wording is maybe or probably.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Several etymologists publish the same causal hypothesis, but no source demonstrates a controlled historical mechanism or excludes alternatives.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/523","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vijand"},{"cursor":524,"id":524,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","title":"Did the Devil sense create the word vijand?","position":"No. The inherited enemy noun comes from the Germanic one-who-hates formation. Devil is an attested religious sense inside Dutch, not the origin of the agent noun.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The comparative derivation and ordinary enemy records are older and structurally independent of the preservation hypothesis.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The leaderboard reveal says may have preserved part of the form, never created the word.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/524","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vijand"},{"cursor":525,"id":525,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","title":"Did Dutch vijand undergo the same enemy-to-demon replacement as English fiend?","position":"No. Dutch retained ordinary enemy or opponent as the central modern sense. The Devil branch is historical; English fiend developed a different modern semantic center.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"EWN, WNT, ANW, and the reviewed fiend dossier show collateral inheritance followed by different daughter-language outcomes.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins the words at reconstructed ancestry and does not copy English semantic history into Dutch.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/525","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vijand"},{"cursor":526,"id":526,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","title":"Does Dutch still preserve the inherited hate verb behind vijand?","position":"Not as the corresponding inherited verb. ONW says the verb matching Old High German fīēn and Gothic fijan is no longer known in Dutch.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionary makes the lexical loss explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The verb is shown only as a starred Proto-Germanic node, while modern vijand remains a noun.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/526","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vijand"},{"cursor":527,"id":527,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","title":"Was Dutch vijand borrowed from German Feind or English fiend?","position":"No borrowing is established. Old Dutch fīunt / fīant, German Feind, English fiend, Gothic fijands, and the Nordic forms are collateral inherited descendants.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"EWN, ONW, WNT, and Kroonen publish the comparative descendant set.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph reuses the shared reconstructed nodes and draws no German-to-Dutch or English-to-Dutch arrow.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/527","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vijand"},{"cursor":528,"id":528,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","title":"Does vijand securely descend from exactly *peh₁-?","position":"Only as a qualified proposal. Kroonen and EWN publish deeper laryngeal-bearing analyses, but their notation and intermediate formation differ and the harm, blame, suffering, hostility, and hate path is not uniquely recoverable.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The Germanic noun and verb comparison is firmer than the displayed Proto-Indo-European route.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/528","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vijand"},{"cursor":529,"id":529,"entryId":193,"entrySlug":"vijand","title":"Does the 901–1000 corpus range prove when vijand was coined?","position":"No. It is the oldest attestation range published by ONW, not a birth certificate. The inherited formation must predate the daughter-language record, and the surviving sources are incomplete.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ONW distinguishes oldest attestation from etymology, and Kroonen places the formation at the reconstructed Germanic level.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The timeline labels first reviewed corpus evidence and never calls it coinage.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/529","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vijand"},{"cursor":530,"id":530,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Does modern fiende mean only a person who privately hates someone?","position":"No. SO and SAOB cover personal opponents, hostile states or forces, military collectives, natural enemies, and figurative nonhuman threats.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The current and historical Academy dictionaries publish a broader semantic range.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The literal one-who-hates belongs to historical word formation and is not imposed as the definition of every modern token.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/530","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":531,"id":531,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Was fiende historically a present participle?","position":"Yes at the inherited formation level. SO says originally hatande; SAOB says it is properly a present participle to a Germanic hate verb; Hellquist independently gives the same analysis.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Three Swedish dictionary authorities converge, while the parent form itself remains reconstructed.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier labels the parent with an asterisk and presents one-who-hates as a word-formation analysis, not an attested Proto-Germanic phrase.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/531","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":532,"id":532,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Is Swedish fiende formed from modern hata?","position":"No. The fi(j)- verb family behind fiende is distinct from the hat- family behind Swedish hata.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"SAOB publishes separate etymologies: fiende beside Gothic fijan and Old Norse fjá, hata beside Gothic hatan, Old Norse hata, Old English hatian, and German hassen.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph connects fiende through *fi(j)ēn- and treats hata as a cited collateral semantic comparison, never a parent node.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/532","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":533,"id":533,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Is modern fiende still a productive Swedish participle?","position":"No. SO and SAOB classify current fiende as a noun. The participial origin is historical and lexicalized.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The Academy dictionaries distinguish current word class from historical formation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface says frozen or lexicalized participle and does not give modern Swedish a fiende verb paradigm.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/533","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":534,"id":534,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Was Fienden genuinely used for the Devil in Swedish?","position":"Yes. Söderwall gives medieval Devil records, and SAOB gives multiple early-modern uses including the 1526 apposition fiende diefuulen.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Independent medieval and historical dictionaries preserve located evidence.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The demonic branch remains visible as attested Swedish semantic history.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/534","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":535,"id":535,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Is the Devil the central current meaning of fiende?","position":"No. SO defines an opponent prepared to harm a counterpart and supplies ordinary, military, figurative, and natural-enemy uses. SAOB marks the older Devil use as barely current by 1924.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Current and historical Academy labels distinguish the obsolete branch from modern usage.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The main gloss remains enemy or opponent, not demon.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/535","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":536,"id":536,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Does definite singular fienden always mean the Devil?","position":"No. Historical religious contexts can use Fienden that way, but SO also notes definite singular in ordinary military use. Grammar alone cannot choose the referent.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"SO and SAOB publish distinct definite-singular contexts.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Attestations retain their contexts instead of using capitalization or definiteness as an automatic semantic classifier.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/536","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":537,"id":537,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Does the beginning-of-the-1300s record date the coinage of fiende?","position":"No. It is the earliest use reported by SO, not a birth certificate. The inherited cross-Germanic formation predates the surviving Swedish record.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"SO separates first attestation from etymology, and comparative sources place the formation at the reconstructed Germanic level.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The timeline says first reviewed Swedish evidence, never invention date.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/537","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":538,"id":538,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Were the medieval and early-modern witness objects directly inspected?","position":"No. This review inspected dictionary records and a scanned etymological dictionary page, not the Skåne-Lagen manuscript, Söderwall’s underlying medieval objects, or the cited early-modern print pages.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The source surfaces provide lexicographic reports and edition locators but no completed object-level inspection for these rows.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every fiende attestation remains directly_inspected=0, and the dossier creates no witness-inspection record.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/538","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":539,"id":539,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Does fiende securely descend from exactly *peh₁-?","position":"Only as a qualified modern proposal. Kroonen publishes the route; Hellquist records a historically different deeper comparison, and neither recovers a written ancestral token or unique original semantic scene.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The Germanic noun-and-verb comparison is firmer than the displayed Proto-Indo-European route.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/539","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":540,"id":540,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Was Swedish fiende borrowed from Danish, German, Dutch, or English?","position":"No borrowing is established. Old Swedish fiande or fiände belongs to the inherited Germanic set alongside Danish fjende, German Feind, Dutch vijand, and English fiend.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"SO, SAOB, Hellquist, and Kroonen publish collateral comparative forms.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The canonical graph reuses the shared reconstructed formation and draws no daughter-language donor arrow into Swedish.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/540","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":541,"id":541,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Is Swedish frände a cognate from the same lexical root?","position":"Not on the cited evidence. SAOB and Hellquist compare fiende with frände with respect to formation; that morphological parallel does not make the two words descendants of one lexical root.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Both dictionaries explicitly frame frände as a comparison of formation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Frände is not inserted as an ancestor or root cognate.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/541","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":542,"id":542,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Can the exact Proto-Germanic pronunciation and lexicalization moment be recovered?","position":"No. *fi(j)and- and *fi(j)ēn- are normalized comparative reconstructions; optional j, branch vowels, and the timing of lexicalization remain analytical.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Kroonen and Ayora Estevan publish compatible forms and pre-Gothic lexicalization without one directly observed event.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/542","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":543,"id":543,"entryId":194,"entrySlug":"fiende","title":"Does the root reveal that every enemy is truly a hater?","position":"No. Etymology records historical formation, not an immutable present-day essence. Modern fiende covers people, states, armies, forces, and figurative threats whether or not literal hatred is evidenced.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"SO and SAOB supply current semantics; the participial analysis belongs to historical sources.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The leaderboard reveal exposes hidden morphology while the dossier explicitly rejects the etymological fallacy.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/543","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiende"},{"cursor":544,"id":544,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Was Old High German fīant a noun?","position":"Yes. AWB classifies fîant / fîjant as a strong masculine noun and supplies a large nominal inflectional inventory.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The official historical dictionary's headword grammar and paradigm are explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier never relabels attested fīant as a productive present participle.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/544","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":545,"id":545,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Was fīant still a productive participle?","position":"Not on the cited evidence. AWB calls it a noun, but says its old participial character can shine through in fixed formulas. Residual transparency is not productive category identity.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The noun classification and the cautious formula note occur in the same official article.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface distinguishes attested noun, formulaic afterglow, and reconstructed participial formation.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/545","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":546,"id":546,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Do the fixed formulas prove the entire prehistoric derivation by themselves?","position":"No. They are daughter-language evidence compatible with participial history; the Proto-Germanic formation is established comparatively across branches.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"AWB supplies the formula analysis, while Kroonen and Ayora Estevan supply the cross-Germanic reconstruction and lexicalization argument.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No single Old High German phrase is treated as a direct recording of Proto-Germanic grammar.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/546","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":547,"id":547,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Could fîant uuesan actually mean hate or wish someone ill?","position":"Yes. AWB glosses the fixed formula as be hostile, hate someone, or wish someone ill and supplies multiple located examples.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionary states the semantic range and prints examples including fient ist, demo drachen fient, and sie sint mir fient.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier reports the range without forcing the strongest hate reading onto every occurrence.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/547","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":548,"id":548,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Was the Devil the central meaning of fīant?","position":"No. AWB separates personal, public or military, spiritual, and specifically Devil senses. The demonic branch is real but not the whole noun.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionary's meaning architecture explicitly distinguishes the groups.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The main gloss remains enemy, opponent, or adversary.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/548","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":549,"id":549,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Is Habakkuk-gloss dfiunt a secure Devil token?","position":"No. AWB says the d likely begins diuuil and treats dfiunt as probably corrupt; the Epinal form dfiant does not remove the uncertainty.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The official article flags the reading under probable scribal error.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/549","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":550,"id":550,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Were the underlying manuscript objects directly inspected?","position":"No. This review inspected AWB records and Sievers's digitized text-edition page, not the Tatian, Ludwigslied, Otfrid, or Notker manuscript objects.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Every attestation row identifies a lexicographic or edited-text surface and lacks object-level manuscript inspection.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"All fīant attestations remain directly_inspected=0 and no witness-inspection record is created.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/550","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":551,"id":551,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Does the eighth-century report date the word's coinage?","position":"No. It is a lexicographic attestation horizon. Inherited cross-Germanic evidence places the formation earlier than the surviving High German record.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Pfeifer supplies the century; comparative sources supply the pre-branch ancestry.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The timeline uses a century range and leaves the exact token year null.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/551","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":552,"id":552,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Was fīant borrowed from Gothic, Old English, Dutch, or Norse?","position":"No borrowing is established. The daughter forms are collateral inherited continuations of the reconstructed Germanic enemy formation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"AWB, Kroonen, Pfeifer, and Ayora Estevan publish the cross-branch set.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins the words at *fi(j)and- and draws no daughter-to-daughter donor arrow.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/552","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":553,"id":553,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Are fiiant, fîjant, fiunt, fient, fiand, fiund, and fiend separate ancestry branches?","position":"Not in AWB's article. They are form, spelling, dialectal, and inflectional records inside one headword history, with a few individual corrupt or ambiguous tokens separately flagged.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"AWB inventories the variants beneath one strong masculine lemma.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph uses one canonical attested node and preserves the variants in evidence notes and attestations.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/553","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":554,"id":554,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Does fīant securely descend from exactly *peh₁-?","position":"Only as a qualified modern proposal. The Germanic noun-and-verb relation is firmer than the displayed Indo-European route.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Kroonen publishes the comparison but no written intermediate or unique original semantic scene.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/554","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":555,"id":555,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Can the exact Proto-Germanic pronunciation and lexicalization moment be recovered?","position":"No. *fi(j)and- and *fi(j)ēn- are normalized comparative reconstructions; optional j, branch vowels, and the moment the agent became an ordinary noun remain analytical.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Kroonen and Ayora Estevan publish compatible forms and pre-branch lexicalization without a directly observed event.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/555","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":556,"id":556,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Did one who hates lexicalize as enemy only inside Old High German?","position":"No. Gothic, Old English, Old Frisian, Old Dutch, Old Saxon, and North Germanic parallels require an earlier shared formation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"AWB's comparative header and the modern comparative studies span the daughter branches.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The lexicalized parent is placed at the Proto-Germanic level.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/556","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":557,"id":557,"entryId":195,"entrySlug":"fiant","title":"Does the root reveal that every enemy truly hates?","position":"No. Historical word formation does not dictate the psychology of every referent. AWB includes military collectives, opponents, spiritual enemies, the Devil, and fixed constructions with context-dependent force.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The attested semantic architecture is broader than a universal claim of inner hatred.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The leaderboard exposes grammatical history while explicitly rejecting the etymological fallacy.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/557","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiant"},{"cursor":558,"id":558,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"Was fjándi an Old Norse participle or a noun?","position":"In the attested entry it is a masculine noun. The participial analysis belongs to its inherited formation, not to a relabeling of every Old Norse token.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ONP classifies the lemma as sb. m.; Cleasby and Vigfússon explain the historical -nd- formation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph separates the attested noun from the reconstructed lexicalized participle.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/558","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":559,"id":559,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"Did fjándi originally mean the Devil?","position":"Not in the reviewed historical account. The ordinary enemy sense is older, and Cleasby and Vigfússon place the fiend development after Christianity.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionary states the relative chronology; ONP preserves both ordinary and supernatural branches.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier says enemy before Devil without assigning a fake first year to either innovation.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/559","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":560,"id":560,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"Does properly a hater define every fjándi referent?","position":"No. It is a historical word-formation gloss, not a psychological claim about every enemy, demon, god, animal, object, or insult target.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The 222-citation ONP topology is far broader than a literal agent gloss.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The leaderboard exposes morphology while rejecting the etymological fallacy.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/560","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":561,"id":561,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"How many meanings does the ONP entry distinguish?","position":"Six numbered zones, with additional formulas: enemy or opponent; devil, monster, or demon; evil spirit; pagan god; the Devil or Satan; and a derogatory hated or bewitched being or thing.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ONP’s structured entry explicitly labels senses 1–6.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface preserves the branches rather than flattening them into demon.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/561","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":562,"id":562,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"Are the 222 ONP citations a complete Old Norse corpus?","position":"No completeness claim is made. They are the public entry’s current citation set, valuable evidence rather than the set of every surviving occurrence.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ONP exposes the count and entry status but does not license universal corpus completeness.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier says 222 citations in ONP, not 222 total historical tokens.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/562","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":563,"id":563,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"Are the Lexicon Poeticum dates definitive?","position":"No. The project explicitly says its concordance is unreviewed and dates may come from earlier editions and should be checked.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The warning appears directly above the 49 poetic citations.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The 960, 961, and 1190 records remain source-reported and probable, not directly dated witnesses.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/563","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":564,"id":564,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"Does the 960 poetic date identify the oldest manuscript token?","position":"No. It is a source-reported composition date. Surviving manuscript copies may be later, and none is directly inspected here.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Lexicon Poeticum separates citation dates from its manuscript list and warns that dates require checking.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The attestation type is lexical_corpus_record and directly_inspected remains false.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/564","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":565,"id":565,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"Was the ÁKr fiandanom variant directly read from GKS 3270 4°?","position":"No. ONP’s citation record and linked image index were inspected, but the exact manuscript token was not located and verified on the folio image.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The ONP citation identifies the variant, manuscript, c.1350 date, and image collection.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No facsimile URL or witness-inspection row is created.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/565","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":566,"id":566,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"Are fjándi and frændi cognates because they form a memorable pair?","position":"No evidence here establishes that. ONP documents a rhetorical and semantic opposition, while the ancestry graph routes fjándi through *fi(j)and-.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The formula is a collocation; the comparative sources provide a different ancestry route.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"frændi is labeled a non-cognate contrastive relative, not a parent or cousin.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/566","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":567,"id":567,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"Was fjándi borrowed from English fiend or German Feind?","position":"No. The words are collateral inherited continuations of the Proto-Germanic lexicalized enemy formation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Cleasby and Vigfússon, Kroonen, and Ayora Estevan publish the cross-branch set.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins the words at *fi(j)and- and draws no daughter-to-daughter donor arrow.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/567","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":568,"id":568,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"Did every Germanic daughter develop a dominant demon sense?","position":"No. Old Norse retains ordinary enemy and multiple supernatural branches, English foregrounds fiend, while German Feind and Swedish fiende remain ordinary enemy nouns.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The cited dictionaries document different daughter-language semantic centers.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Shared ancestry does not erase branch-specific semantic history.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/568","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":569,"id":569,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"Does fjándi securely descend from exactly *peh₁-?","position":"Only as a qualified modern proposal. The Germanic noun-and-verb relation is firmer than the displayed Indo-European route.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Kroonen publishes the comparison but no written intermediate or unique original semantic scene.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/569","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":570,"id":570,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"Can the exact Proto-Germanic pronunciation and lexicalization moment be recovered?","position":"No. *fi(j)and- and *fi(j)ēn- are normalized comparative reconstructions; optional j, branch vowels, and the moment the agent became an ordinary noun remain analytical.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Kroonen and Ayora Estevan publish compatible forms and pre-branch lexicalization without a directly observed event.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/570","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":571,"id":571,"entryId":196,"entrySlug":"fjandi","title":"Can one date the shift from enemy to fiend to one event?","position":"No. The historical dictionary gives a relative post-Christian chronology, while ONP and the poetic corpus show overlapping ordinary and supernatural uses rather than one recoverable coinage moment.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The sources establish semantic branching but not a uniquely dated innovation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/571","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjandi"},{"cursor":572,"id":572,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Does fjende literally mean hater today?","position":"No. One-who-hates describes the inherited formation. Current Danish defines an enemy by opposition or harm, not by a required inner emotion.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"DDO separates current senses from its origin note.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier exposes morphology without committing the etymological fallacy.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/572","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":573,"id":573,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Was Danish fjende borrowed from German Feind?","position":"No borrowing route is established here. DDO compares both with Old Norse fjándi, and comparative research places them under the inherited Germanic formation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"DDO, Kroonen, and Ayora Estevan support collateral inheritance.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins the words at a reconstructed ancestor and draws no German-to-Danish arrow.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/573","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":574,"id":574,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"What is the exact earliest surviving Danish fjende token?","position":"Not established by the inspected public evidence. Gammeldansk Ordbog reports fiende as known since 1100–1300 but exposes no exact first token on the entry page.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The public headword gives a range; the linked citation-card collection did not yield an inspected object.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/574","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":575,"id":575,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Was historical Fiende pronounced with two syllables or three?","position":"Both patterns are source-reported. Holbergordbog separates three-syllable and two-syllable scans and links the latter with Finde and Fînde forms.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The headword article supplies multiple metrical examples in each group.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Variation remains visible rather than being normalized into one timeless pronunciation.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/575","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":576,"id":576,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Are Fiende, Fiænde, Finde, Fînde, and Fiend separate words?","position":"Not in the reviewed articles. They are treated as surface and scansion variants of the same lexical family.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ODS and Holbergordbog organize them under Fjende or Fiende.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The forms remain relatives and attestations, not false ancestry nodes.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/576","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":577,"id":577,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Did Danish fjende ever mean the Devil?","position":"Yes in a bounded religious branch. ODS identifies den gamle Fjende and related uses as the Devil, while ordinary enemy remains the general sense.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ODS sense 1.1 and its supplement label the religious use.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The Devil is neither erased nor promoted into the word’s sole original meaning.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/577","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":578,"id":578,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Was the Devil meaning the original Danish sense?","position":"No source inspected establishes that. Old Danish is glossed simply enemy, and the historical dictionaries present Devil as a special development inside the broader enemy field.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Gammeldansk Ordbog, ODS, and the comparative formation support ordinary enemy as the lexicalized category.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph separates inherited formation from later contextual specialization.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/578","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":579,"id":579,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Can fjende refer only to people?","position":"No. Historical and current records apply it to states, military forces, animals, ideologies, weather, sleep, passions, and other harmful abstractions.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ODS, Holbergordbog, and DDO publish the extensions.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier models extensions without turning them into separate ancestors.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/579","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":580,"id":580,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Does DDO preserve the lost verbal meaning?","position":"It preserves the historical analysis, not a productive modern Danish verb: the noun was originally a present participle of a verb corresponding to Old Norse fjá, hate or persecute.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"DDO states the formation directly in its origin field.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Modern meaning and historical grammar remain separate fields.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/580","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":581,"id":581,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Does the ODS Sanskrit comparison prove a direct Sanskrit-to-Danish line?","position":"No. ODS preserves an older comparison with Sanskrit pīyati, while modern comparative work gives a reconstructed route. Neither source licenses a historical borrowing or direct line.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ODS and Kroonen represent different analytical layers.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/581","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":582,"id":582,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Can the exact change from fiende to fjende be dated to one event?","position":"No. The records show overlapping spellings, syllable patterns, and editorial judgments rather than one recoverable switch.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"ODS and Holbergordbog document coexistence and commentary across editions.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/582","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":583,"id":583,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Does known since 1100–1300 mean the word was coined then?","position":"No. It bounds surviving Old Danish evidence and does not date the prehistoric lexicalization or first spoken Danish use.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical entry supplies an evidence range, while comparative sources place formation earlier.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Corpus onset and word creation are not conflated.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/583","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":584,"id":584,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Does Holberg scansion reproduce ordinary speech exactly?","position":"Not necessarily. It is evidence for metrical realization and variation, not audio or a complete social map of pronunciation.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Holbergordbog explicitly analyzes scanning and spellings; ODS also preserves prescriptive disagreement.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The pronunciation history is evidence-bounded.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/584","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":585,"id":585,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Was English fiend borrowed from Danish fjende?","position":"No. They are collateral inherited continuations; English specialized the demonic branch much more strongly.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Kroonen and the reviewed English and Danish dictionaries support shared ancestry and separate semantic histories.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The rabbit hole compares siblings without inventing transmission.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/585","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":586,"id":586,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Is *fi(j)and- an attested Danish word?","position":"No. It is a normalized Proto-Germanic reconstruction used to explain cross-branch evidence.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Kroonen marks the form as reconstructed; Danish sources provide later attested forms.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The asterisk remains structural and visible.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/586","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":587,"id":587,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Does fjende securely descend from exactly *peh₁-?","position":"Only as a qualified modern proposal. The Germanic noun-and-verb relationship is firmer than the displayed Indo-European route.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Kroonen publishes the comparison but no written intermediate or unique semantic scene.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/587","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":588,"id":588,"entryId":197,"entrySlug":"fjende","title":"Does DDO listing hater nearby prove fjende still means hater?","position":"No. A near-word list is lexical navigation, not identity. DDO’s definition centers active opposition, harm, or destruction and its origin field separately explains the old participle.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The current entry exposes both fields independently.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Interface adjacency is not converted into an etymological claim.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/588","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fjende"},{"cursor":589,"id":589,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Was Old High German fīēn a verb?","position":"Yes. AWB classifies fîên as a weak verb and supplies infinitive, present-participle, preterite, and past-participle forms.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The official historical dictionary’s headword grammar and paradigm are explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier keeps the attested verb distinct from the enemy noun fīant.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/589","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":590,"id":590,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Was the verb recorded throughout the Old High German world?","position":"Not on the reviewed evidence. AWB says it is attested only in Alemannic manuscripts of the eighth and ninth centuries.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The official entry gives both the regional and chronological limit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The map uses a broad manuscript region and no invented point coordinate.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/590","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":591,"id":591,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"What is the exact earliest surviving fīēn token?","position":"Not established here. AWB supplies a bounded manuscript horizon and edition locators but no single inspected first object or exact year.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The records are dictionary-reported and the manuscripts were not directly inspected.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/591","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":592,"id":592,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Were the underlying manuscript objects directly inspected?","position":"No. This review inspected the official dictionary article, not the manuscripts behind its gloss and rule-text references.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"All six attestation rows identify a lexicographic surface and set directly_inspected to false.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No witness-inspection record or facsimile claim is created.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/592","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":593,"id":593,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Do fien, fiendi, fietos, and fieta represent four unrelated words?","position":"No. AWB inventories them inside one weak-verb paradigm as infinitive, present participle, second-person singular preterite, and past participle.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The headword’s form section explicitly assigns the categories.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Surface forms remain relatives and attestations rather than false ancestry nodes.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/593","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":594,"id":594,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Is the separate twelfth-century fien [sic] ubere record this hate verb?","position":"Unknown, and it is not merged here. AWB places it in a separate article and says it is not interpreted.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The adjacent official headword explicitly marks the isolated record as uninterpreted.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/594","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":595,"id":595,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Is fiendi simply the same lexical item as the noun fīant?","position":"Not in the reviewed grammar. AWB analyzes fiendi as the present participle of fîên, while fîant / fîjant is a separate strong masculine noun; one gloss alignment remains textually ambiguous.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The two official articles classify the forms separately and cross-reference their historical relation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Productive participle, lexicalized noun, and ambiguous gloss alignment remain separate claims.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/595","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":596,"id":596,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Did fīēn have one perfectly identical meaning in every record?","position":"No. AWB separates hate, not love, or be hostile from abhor or reject, and the Latin alignments vary among odire, exosus, and detestari.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The official article has two meaning groups and prints the bilingual records.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph models a bounded semantic field rather than one timeless English gloss.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/596","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":597,"id":597,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Does Latin odire or detestari reveal the exact Old High German nuance by itself?","position":"No. A bilingual alignment is evidence, but translation and gloss practice do not erase contextual or grammatical differences.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"AWB preserves multiple Latin alignments and distinguishes their source records.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Each attestation retains its own locator and editorial note.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/597","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":598,"id":598,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Does not love mean that fīēn was merely mild dislike?","position":"Not necessarily. AWB groups not love with hate and be hostile, while other records align the verb with odire and detestari.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The source’s own meaning architecture gives a range rather than a modern intensity scale.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No single English emotion word is forced onto the whole dossier.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/598","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":599,"id":599,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Was fīēn borrowed from Gothic fijan, Old English feon, Middle Low German vîen, or Old Norse fjá?","position":"No daughter-to-daughter borrowing is established. AWB compares the forms, and Kroonen places them under a reconstructed Germanic verb.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionary and comparative study support collateral inheritance.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins them at *fi(j)ēn- and draws no donor arrow among daughter languages.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/599","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":600,"id":600,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Is *fi(j)ēn- an attested Old High German spelling?","position":"No. It is a normalized Proto-Germanic reconstruction used to explain the daughter-language set.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Kroonen marks the comparative form as reconstructed; AWB supplies later attested forms.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The asterisk remains structural and visible.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/600","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":601,"id":601,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Can the exact Proto-Germanic pronunciation and path into fīēn be recovered?","position":"Not completely. Optional j, vowel quantity, stem remodeling, and daughter inflection belong to comparative analysis rather than a recorded transition.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Kroonen publishes a normalized reconstruction, while AWB supplies daughter forms.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/601","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":602,"id":602,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Does fīēn securely descend from exactly *peh₁-?","position":"Only as a qualified modern proposal. The Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed Indo-European route.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Kroonen publishes the comparison but no written intermediate or uniquely recoverable original semantic scene.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/602","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":603,"id":603,"entryId":198,"entrySlug":"fien","title":"Does the end of the ninth-century record prove the verb died in 900?","position":"No. The dictionary bounds surviving evidence; it does not identify one extinction event, last speaker, or exact loss date.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The official source reports where and when the verb is attested, not when every spoken continuation ceased.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/603","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fien"},{"cursor":604,"id":604,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Was Old Norse fjá a verb?","position":"Yes. ONP classifies it as a poetic verb; Cleasby, Zoëga, and Fritzner all gloss it as hate and document finite or reflexive grammar.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The independent dictionary records agree on lexical category and core gloss.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier keeps the verb distinct from the lexicalized noun fjándi.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/604","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":605,"id":605,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Does ONP contain prose citations for fjá?","position":"No. The public ONP lemma marks the word poetic and displays zero citations across every expected prose genre.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The official prose dictionary's entry exposes the absence directly.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier does not fabricate prose attestations.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/605","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":606,"id":606,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Are there exactly three surviving Old Norse uses?","position":"Three is the count in the reviewed public Lexicon Poeticum surface and matches the three locations in Cleasby and Fritzner, but it is not presented as a census of every lost or surviving utterance.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The concordance itself warns that it has not been reviewed.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/606","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":607,"id":607,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"What is the exact earliest surviving fjá token?","position":"Not established here. The reviewed sources supply poem and stanza locations but no directly inspected manuscript object, exact composition date, or uncontested first-use year.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"All three attestation rows are source-reported normalized editions.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/607","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":608,"id":608,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Were the underlying manuscript objects directly inspected?","position":"No. This review inspected dictionaries, concordance metadata, and normalized text surfaces, not the manuscripts behind the three poems.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Every attestation sets directly_inspected to false and no witness-inspection record is created.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No facsimile or manuscript-verification claim is attached.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/608","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":609,"id":609,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Does Hýmiskviða 22 preserve the active form fjá?","position":"Yes in the reviewed normalized teaching text: sú er goð fjá. Cleasby and Fritzner independently locate the verb there.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The edited line and two lexicographic references converge.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The claim is about the normalized textual record, not manuscript pixels.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/609","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":610,"id":610,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Is fíár in Lokasenna 35 a form of this verb?","position":"Yes in the reviewed normalized text and historical dictionaries: þann er mangi fíár means the one whom no one hates.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Cleasby and Fritzner locate fjá at Lokasenna 35, while the normalized text exposes the finite form.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The surface form remains an inflectional relative, not a false ancestor node.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/610","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":611,"id":611,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Is fiásk in Skírnismál 33 a separate verb?","position":"No on the reviewed evidence. Cleasby, Zoëga, and Fritzner classify the reflexive under fjá, and the teaching text preserves þik skal Freyr fiásk.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The grammatical descriptions and verse context agree.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The reflexive form remains evidence inside the same dossier.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/611","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":612,"id":612,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Did fía become fjá at one exactly recoverable moment?","position":"No exact date or complete phonetic sequence is established. Zoëga calls fía the early form and ONP cross-references it, which supports a historical surface relation but not a point event.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The lexicographic relation is clear while chronology and intermediate written forms remain missing.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/612","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":613,"id":613,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Was fjá obsolete at one exact medieval date?","position":"No. Cleasby calls the word obsolete from a nineteenth-century lexicographic perspective, but the reviewed record does not identify a last speaker or extinction year.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Lexicographic obsolescence and a dated loss event are different claims.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/613","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":614,"id":614,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Is fjándi simply another finite form of fjá?","position":"No. Cleasby identifies fjándi as the surviving participial relative, and the separate ONP dossier classifies it as a masculine noun with 222 prose citations.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The sources preserve both historical relationship and lexical-category separation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins the words through the reconstructed verb family rather than collapsing their entries.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/614","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":615,"id":615,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Do the three poetic verb records and 222 fjándi prose citations form a direct frequency comparison?","position":"No. They come from different public corpora with different genres, coverage, editorial states, and counting rules.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ONP is a prose dictionary; Lexicon Poeticum is a separately warned poetic concordance.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The rabbit hole presents the contrast as corpus architecture, not a statistical ratio.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/615","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":616,"id":616,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Was fjá borrowed from Gothic fijan, Old English feon, or Old High German fīēn?","position":"No daughter-to-daughter borrowing is established. The dictionaries compare them, and Kroonen places them under a reconstructed Germanic verb.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionaries and comparative study support collateral inheritance.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins them at *fi(j)ēn- and draws no donor arrow among daughters.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/616","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":617,"id":617,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Is *fi(j)ēn- an attested Old Norse spelling?","position":"No. It is a normalized Proto-Germanic reconstruction used to explain the daughter-language set.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Kroonen marks the form as reconstructed, while ONP explicitly cites EDPG *fi(j)ēn-.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The asterisk remains structural and visible.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/617","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":618,"id":618,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Can the exact pronunciation and path into fjá be recovered?","position":"Not completely. Vowel quantity, optional glide, contraction, surface variation, and poetic normalization belong to historical analysis rather than recorded audio.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The dictionaries publish forms and comparisons, not a historical sound recording or complete transition series.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/618","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":619,"id":619,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Does fjá securely descend from exactly *peh₁-?","position":"Only as a qualified modern proposal. The Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed Indo-European route.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Kroonen publishes the comparison but no written intermediate or uniquely recoverable original semantic scene.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/619","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":620,"id":620,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Is the possible runic inscription shown on modern dictionary pages a historical attestation?","position":"No. It is a generated transliteration widget, not a cited inscription, object, shelfmark, or manuscript record.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The modern Cleasby and Zoëga transcription pages label it possible and generate the runes from the headword.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The runes are excluded from attestations and witness counts.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/620","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":621,"id":621,"entryId":199,"entrySlug":"fja","title":"Are Lexicon Poeticum dates and counts definitive without review?","position":"No. The project explicitly says the concordance has not been reviewed and that dates, especially, should be checked.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The source publishes its own limitations.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier preserves count three with probable confidence and assigns no point dates.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/621","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fja"},{"cursor":622,"id":622,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Was Old Norse hata a verb?","position":"Yes. ONP marks hata vb. with the weak stem [-að-], and Cleasby, Zoëga, and Fritzner independently classify the lemma as a verb.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Four historical dictionaries agree on lexical category and expose finite, participial, or middle-voice grammar.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier keeps the verb distinct from the noun hatr and from the different verb fjá.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/622","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":623,"id":623,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Does ONP expose 101 prose citations?","position":"Yes on the reviewed public entry. The number is a current dictionary-citation count, not a census of every surviving token, lost text, or spoken use.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ONP labels the search box Search/filter 101 citations.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every public count remains bounded to the named research surface.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/623","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":624,"id":624,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Did hata mean only an inward feeling?","position":"No. ONP structures persecution, rejection, humiliation, ordinary hate, participles, and hostile middle-voice constructions; Fritzner independently preserves persecution and damage or destruction.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The semantic branches contain located examples rather than modern paraphrase alone.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The contrarian reveal states range, not one first meaning.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/624","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":625,"id":625,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Could hata mean persecute?","position":"Yes. ONP's first sense is persecute, and its Páls saga citation aligns er þu hatar with Latin quem tu persequeris. Fritzner gives the same passage under pursue.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionary structure, exact citation, and Latin alignment converge.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The persecution sense is kept distinct from ordinary feeling.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/625","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":626,"id":626,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Could hata mean reject or despise?","position":"Yes. ONP's second sense includes despise, reject, and cast aside; Ragnars saga uses hata gullinu in that prose structure.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The exact citation page assigns the clause to sense two.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"This prose record is not collapsed into the disputed poetic gold-spending formula.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/626","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":627,"id":627,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Could hata mean mock or humiliate?","position":"Yes. ONP's third sense is mock or humiliate and locates a 1479 confession in which the speaker hatadi God's poor with many insults.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The structured sense and source-reported line agree.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier records the social action without treating it as every token's meaning.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/627","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":628,"id":628,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Could poetic hata mean damage or destroy?","position":"Probably. Zoëga states damage or destroy; Fritzner supplies poetic examples under damage, spoil, or destroy; the poetic concordance translates records with damage and destruction.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Three lexical surfaces converge, but the public poetic concordance warns that it is unreviewed.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/628","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":629,"id":629,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Was shun the original meaning of hata?","position":"Not established. Cleasby and Vigfússon propose that the poetic dative shun sense was probably original, then immediately say hatta with double t may be the better reading.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The same source both advances and destabilizes the claim.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/629","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":630,"id":630,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Does hata gulli simply mean hate gold?","position":"Not securely. Cleasby treats the dative phrase as spend gold, ONP has a separate prose contempt-for-gold record, and the poetic reading itself is questioned.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Grammar, genre, metaphor, and textual reading prevent a single literal gloss.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/630","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":631,"id":631,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Was any underlying manuscript object directly inspected?","position":"Yes, exactly one in this dossier: Holm perg 15 4° folio 89v. All other prose and poetic records remain source-reported.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The scan visibly preserves hata and has one structured witness-inspection record.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Direct inspection is never generalized from one leaf to the whole corpus.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/631","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":632,"id":632,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Is the c1200 homily token the earliest surviving use?","position":"Not established. It is an early directly inspected object, but the review did not compare every manuscript witness, poetic attribution, variant, or dating claim.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ONP and Lexicon Poeticum expose broader records with different dating models.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/632","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":633,"id":633,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Is the Proto-Germanic parent exactly *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan?","position":"The inherited verb family is secure enough for comparison, but reconstruction notation and the relationship among class-III and related weak formations vary.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Orel publishes an alternation; other reviewed dossiers use *hatōjan- or discuss class fluctuation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/633","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":634,"id":634,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Was the verb mechanically derived from *hatiz- in one recoverable step?","position":"The noun and verb formations belong together, but the exact formation, chronology, and semantic direction are reconstructed rather than witnessed.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Orel and Merriam-Webster connect the formations at different levels of specificity.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/634","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":635,"id":635,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Does hata securely descend from exactly *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only as a qualified proposal. The Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed Indo-European route, whose semantic members are far from transparent.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the route and Liberman challenges parts of the comparison.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/635","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":636,"id":636,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Can one exact Old Norse pronunciation be recovered?","position":"No. Orthographic forms and comparative analysis constrain the history, but no sound recording or complete transition series exists.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The reviewed sources publish spellings, grammar, and comparison rather than audio.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/636","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":637,"id":637,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Are the possible runic inscriptions on modern dictionary pages historical attestations?","position":"No. They are generated transliteration widgets without an object, inscription identifier, shelfmark, or historical locator.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The Cleasby, Zoëga, and Fritzner transcription pages generate forms from the headword.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Generated runes are excluded from attestations and witness counts.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/637","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":638,"id":638,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Does Lexicon Poeticum establish exactly ten or eleven poetic tokens?","position":"No definitive total is promoted. The h-word list reports ten, while the headword page exposes eleven linked rows including variants; the project warns that the concordance is unreviewed.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The public interfaces and warning are internally sufficient to reject a false definitive total.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/638","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":639,"id":639,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Does ONP's sense order prove a chronological semantic sequence?","position":"No. A structured dictionary article groups meanings for analysis; it does not by itself prove that persecution came before rejection, humiliation, or ordinary hate in speech.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"No dated continuous transition series is published in the entry.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The leaderboard says sense order and semantic range, never a proven chronology.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/639","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":640,"id":640,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Are hata and fjá forms of one Old Norse verb?","position":"No. Both can be glossed hate, but hata belongs to the Germanic hat- family while fjá continues the different fi(j)- verb family.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Orel places hata in the hat- set; ONP and Kroonen place fjá under *fi(j)ēn-.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph keeps two entries and joins each to its own reconstructed family.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/640","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":641,"id":641,"entryId":200,"entrySlug":"hata","title":"Is hatask a separate unrelated verb?","position":"No on the reviewed evidence. ONP and Cleasby treat the middle-voice, reflexive, and reciprocal constructions inside the hata paradigm.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The sources document hatask with particles and reciprocal hostility under the same headword.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Inflectional and constructional variation remains visible without creating a false ancestor.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/641","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hata"},{"cursor":642,"id":642,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Was Old Frisian hatia a weak verb?","position":"Yes. Hofmann and Popkema classify hatia, hetia, and hātia as a weak verb; Köbler independently classifies the family as a weak verb.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Two Old Frisian dictionaries agree on lexical category and core hate or harm meanings.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier keeps the verb distinct from the noun hāt and from Brokmer atia \"rear\".","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/642","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":643,"id":643,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Does the current Corpus Oudfries search return six hits?","position":"Yes for the reviewed May 2026 word-or-lemma query. The number is a current corpus result, not a census of all lost, surviving, or spoken Old Frisian.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The public search reports six hits in a 235,462-token corpus; the about page defines the version and scope.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every displayed count names the corpus and review date.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/643","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":644,"id":644,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Are all six search hits instances of the hate or harm verb?","position":"No. Buma identifies the Brokmer B 101 hatia as atia \"rear\" with prothetic h, and Nijdam's translation concerns a mother unable to feed her children.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"A critical edition's explicit philological note and an independent dissertation translation converge against the corpus lemma assignment.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The Brokmer token is excluded from the main form's attestation ledger and shown only as a corrected homograph.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/644","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":645,"id":645,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Does the Brokmer B 101 passage mean a mother cannot hate her children?","position":"No. In context it says that if the mother is so poor that she cannot otherwise feed or rear her children, she may take something from the wergeld.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Nijdam translates the clause with feeding the children; Buma explains the written form as prothetic atia \"rear\".","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The family-law context is not reverse-engineered into an emotional sense.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/645","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":646,"id":646,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Did hatia mean only inward hatred?","position":"No. Hofmann and Popkema give hate or reject, damage, and a feud-language expression for harming or pursuing someone as an enemy. The corpus records include road and legal-adversity contexts beside theological hate.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Lexicographic sense divisions and located corpus passages independently show active harm and obstruction.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The leaderboard claims documented range, not a proven chronological sequence.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/646","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":647,"id":647,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Could hatia concern damaging or hindering a road?","position":"Yes in the reviewed legal records. The Register to Jus Municipale Frisonum pairs hatijen with hindrien on the army road, and the Book of Rudolf places hatie in a ban concerning that road.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Two separate corpus documents supply related legal-road constructions.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The exact modern translation remains cautious, but the action context is explicit.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/647","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":648,"id":648,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Could hatia express theological hate?","position":"Yes. Jurisprudentia Frisica says God especially hatien the perjurer, lying tongue, and false witnesses, as Solomon describes.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The located corpus transcription supplies an overt theological subject and condemned objects.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The theological record remains one sense context, not the verb's universal essence.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/648","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":649,"id":649,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Are the remaining five records all semantically identical?","position":"No. They range across road harm or obstruction, writing or events going against a person, family-law adversity, and divine hatred; two Jurisprudentia Frisica passages remain only cautiously glossed.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The corpus surface and Popkema's sense inventory support a range, while full translations were not available for every passage.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The ledger preserves probable contextual glosses instead of forcing one English definition.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/649","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":650,"id":650,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Is the Proto-Germanic parent exactly *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan?","position":"The inherited Germanic verb family is probable, but reconstruction notation and the relationship among weak formations vary across references.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Orel publishes the alternation; Köbler prints *hatōn, *hatēn, and *hatǣn; other reviewed dossiers use different levels of reconstruction.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/650","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":651,"id":651,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Why does Köbler print hatia with an asterisk while corpus forms are visible?","position":"Köbler's sigla mark inferred or unattested representations inside his lexicographic system, while the later corpus surfaces inflected forms hatijen, hatie, hata, and hatien and one misleading hatia homograph. The exact source-base difference remains to be reconciled.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The dictionary's method page defines its asterisk conventions; the live corpus exposes later searchable forms.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/651","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":652,"id":652,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Is hatia specifically East Old Frisian, West Old Frisian, or both?","position":"The reviewed sources do not flatten the dialect evidence. Popkema marks hetia as West Lauwers, Corpus Oudfries places relevant records in West Old Frisian texts, while StarLing labels hatia East Frisian.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The references organize dialect labels and variants differently.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/652","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":653,"id":653,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Is damage a late semantic extension or an old legal and feud specialization?","position":"Not established. The dictionaries document damage and enemy-pursuit senses, but the reviewed records do not supply a continuous dated semantic transition series.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Sense range is better evidenced than sequence or direction.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/653","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":654,"id":654,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Is any one reviewed token the earliest surviving use of the verb?","position":"Not established. The Book of Rudolf has an older text-date range but a later manuscript, and this review did not compare every witness, edition, or dating claim.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Corpus metadata separates text and manuscript dates and does not label one hit the global first use.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/654","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":655,"id":655,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Can the six-hit result measure ordinary medieval speech?","position":"No. Corpus Oudfries is a surviving-text corpus dominated by legal and related manuscripts, not a random sample or recording of spoken frequency.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The about page defines 177 text witnesses from 11 manuscripts and a bounded 235,462-token surface.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Counts are reported as corpus architecture, never as population frequency.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/655","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":656,"id":656,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Can one exact Old Frisian pronunciation or vowel length be recovered?","position":"No. Lexicographic forms include hatia, hetia, and hātia, but the reviewed sources do not provide audio or a complete dated phonetic transition series.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionaries publish spelling and quantity notation rather than a recorded historical voice.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/656","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":657,"id":657,"entryId":201,"entrySlug":"hatia","title":"Does hatia securely descend from exactly *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only as a qualified proposal. The Germanic comparison is firmer than the displayed Indo-European route, whose semantic members are far from transparent.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the route and Liberman challenges parts of the comparison.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/657","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatia"},{"cursor":658,"id":658,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Did cais mean only hatred?","position":"No. eDIL explicitly says the noun is explained both as love and hate, gives love glosses such as serc and grádh, and cites passages translated with love or beloved.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The entry heading, glossary equations, and located positive citations converge.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier displays both semantic poles and cites each separately.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/658","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":659,"id":659,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Did cais mean only love?","position":"No. eDIL also gives miscais and mioscais hatred glosses and cites passages translated with hatred.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The same entry supplies explicit negative glosses and located negative contexts.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Love is not promoted over hate as the noun's sole value.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/659","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":660,"id":660,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Are love and hate merely two modern search results rather than one lexicographic headword?","position":"No. eDIL places both explanations, glossary equations, and citations inside headword 1 cais, also caise.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The headword structure directly groups the evidence.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph models one lexicographic entry while leaving deeper historical sense structure open.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/660","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":661,"id":661,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Can context assign a reading in every cited passage?","position":"Context can support many readings, as eDIL's translations show, but the entry expressly says texts may be capable of either meaning according to context and some records remain un-translated or tentative.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Located positive and negative translations coexist with unresolved citations.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Each attestation preserves its source confidence instead of inheriting one global gloss.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/661","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":662,"id":662,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Does the Éigse line certainly use cais once for love and once for hatred?","position":"Not certainly. eDIL tentatively translates \"mo chais is cais 'na agaid\" as \"my love ... is met by hatred(?)\" and prints a question mark on the second reading.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The source preserves the tantalizing opposition and its uncertainty together.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/662","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":663,"id":663,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Are the opposite readings one polysemous word, merged historical homonyms, or a lexicographic convenience?","position":"eDIL groups them in one headword but does not, by that editorial act alone, settle the full historical relationship among every love and hate occurrence.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The entry structure supports shared treatment; the semantic scholarship warns against using opposition as a universal key.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/663","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":664,"id":664,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Does the cais meaning eye belong to the love–hate lineage?","position":"No. eDIL assigns eye to a separate numbered headword, 2 cais, with its own eye gloss and citation.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionary's numbered homograph structure is explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The eye word is recorded as an excluded homograph and never used as ancestry evidence.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/664","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":665,"id":665,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Does eDIL make the deep etymology settled?","position":"No. eDIL says it is generally not an etymological dictionary and supplies etymologies selectively. The deeper graph route therefore rests on separately cited comparative scholarship.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The project's own method statement defines the evidence boundary.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Lexicographic meaning evidence and comparative ancestry evidence are kept distinct.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/665","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":666,"id":666,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Does the contrast miscais prove that bare cais originally meant love?","position":"No. The contrast is evidence that some contexts oppose the forms, but prefixal morphology and a translated contrast do not by themselves recover the oldest sense of bare cais.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"eDIL supplies the paired forms without a dated semantic derivation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph records the contrast and leaves chronological priority unknown.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/666","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":667,"id":667,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Does negative caisgen reveal the timeless core of cais?","position":"No. The compound supplies one negative formation, not a license to reinterpret every positive citation as concealed hatred.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The compound occurs inside the same lexicographic evidence surface as explicit love glosses.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Derived forms remain contextual relatives rather than universal semantic definitions.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/667","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":668,"id":668,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Did love develop into hate, hate into love, or both from another meaning?","position":"No reviewed source establishes one direction. The citations show an opposition; they do not date a semantic transition.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The lexicographic record lacks a secure chronological series, and comparative cautions reject an easy semantic skeleton key.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/668","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":669,"id":669,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Is Proto-Celtic *katsi- the secure direct parent of cais?","position":"Koch publishes the comparison, but the reviewed materials do not expose a complete dated Goidelic derivation or independent consensus sufficient to mark the edge established.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"One located comparative treatment supports the reconstruction while the lexicographic source does not adjudicate it.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/669","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":670,"id":670,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Is *kad-t/si- from *kad- the only defensible deeper analysis?","position":"No. It is a published proposal, not an attested sequence, and the wider cross-branch set remains semantically disputed.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Koch supports the derivation; Liberman challenges transparent unity among the proposed comparisons.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/670","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":671,"id":671,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Does cais securely prove cognacy with the Germanic hate family?","position":"No. The Celtic–Germanic comparison is serious enough to display, but the graph keeps it as a context link rather than a genealogical edge because formal and semantic acceptance remain unsettled.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Affirmative comparative scholarship and a direct skeptical treatment are both cited.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/671","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":672,"id":672,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"What is the earliest surviving use of cais in either sense?","position":"Not established here. eDIL supplies located citations but the underlying objects and dates were not normalized or directly inspected for an earliest-use audit.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The dictionary's headword and citation policies do not turn the first visible web citation into a first-use record.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/672","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":673,"id":673,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"How was historical cais pronounced in each cited period and region?","position":"Not directly recoverable from the reviewed evidence. Written forms and variants do not constitute recorded audio or a complete phonological reconstruction.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"eDIL exposes orthography and variants; it does not provide one securely dated pronunciation for all citations.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/673","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":674,"id":674,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Do the displayed citations measure how often speakers used love versus hate?","position":"No. They are a selected historical-dictionary evidence surface, not a balanced corpus or a sample of medieval speech.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"eDIL documents its selection, revision, and citation practices.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No frequency ratio or prevalence claim is calculated from the entry.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/674","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":675,"id":675,"entryId":202,"entrySlug":"cais","title":"Does one revised eDIL entry imply every line has been uniformly re-edited?","position":"No. eDIL says revisions were targeted and that a revised component does not mean an entire entry received uniform revision.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The About page explicitly bounds the revision project.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Source records identify the current web surface without claiming total editorial uniformity.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/675","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/cais"},{"cursor":676,"id":676,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","title":"Is the normalized infinitive hatizōn written in the surviving manuscript?","position":"No. The manuscript token is hatizoþ. Hatizōn is the lexicographic citation form reconstructed from the inflectional paradigm and printed by the historical grammars.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Project Wulfila links the one written form to its lemma; the directly inspected page verifies the token rather than the infinitive.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface labels the lemma attested through an inflected token and never quotes the infinitive as manuscript text.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/676","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatizon"},{"cursor":677,"id":677,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","title":"Does the current Project Wulfila corpus contain exactly one verified occurrence?","position":"Yes. The lemma page lists only John 7:23 hatizoþ. This is a bounded statement about the current surviving corpus, not all historical Gothic.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The current lemma record exposes a one-item verified occurrence inventory.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every count names the corpus and does not become a speech-frequency claim.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/677","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatizon"},{"cursor":678,"id":678,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","title":"What does the surviving token mean in context?","position":"It asks whether the audience is angry at Jesus. Project Wulfila aligns hatizoþ with Greek χολᾶτε and English “are ye angry at me”; Streitberg and Wright gloss the verb with anger rather than a general act of hating.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The verse alignment and two historical lexical sources converge on the anger reading.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier says be angry with or at someone and leaves any unattested broader range open.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/678","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatizon"},{"cursor":679,"id":679,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","title":"Was hatizōn formed from hatis?","position":"Yes as the reviewed grammatical analysis. The University of Texas table explicitly gives hatis, stem hatiz-, and hatizōn; Wright independently classifies the verb as weak class II.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Two grammatical sources and the corpus inflection class support a denominative formation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph models derivation from the noun without pretending one surviving noun token chronologically caused the verb token.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/679","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatizon"},{"cursor":680,"id":680,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","title":"Does the manuscript write the macron in hatizōn?","position":"No. Gothic spelling on the inspected folio writes hatizoþ without a macron. The macron in the scholarly citation form represents analyzed vowel length.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The inspected object and corpus transcription agree on the written token; Wright and the derivational grammar supply the macronized headword.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Display typography keeps editorial length notation distinct from manuscript characters.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/680","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatizon"},{"cursor":681,"id":681,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","title":"Is hatizoþ second-person plural present indicative?","position":"Project Wulfila analyzes it as active indicative present second-person plural. The pixels verify the form, while the grammatical label remains an editorial morphological analysis.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The word-analysis page explicitly supplies voice, mood, tense, person, and number.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The witness note separates visible letters from grammatical interpretation.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/681","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatizon"},{"cursor":682,"id":682,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","title":"Is Greek χολᾶτε an ancestor of Gothic hatizōn?","position":"No. It is the Greek source-text form translated by the Gothic verb in John 7:23. Translation equivalence is contextual evidence, not lexical descent or borrowing.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The aligned verse shows a Greek-to-Gothic translation relation while the grammatical derivation independently starts from Gothic hatis.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The Greek form appears as a relative/context record and never as a canonical parent edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/682","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatizon"},{"cursor":683,"id":683,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","title":"Does one surviving token prove the verb was rare in spoken Gothic?","position":"No. It proves only that the current surviving and verified corpus contains one assigned token. The fragmentary manuscript record cannot measure ordinary speech.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Project Wulfila provides a complete current corpus inventory; the scholarly manuscript record documents severe survival limits.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The leaderboard says one surviving corpus token, never one historical utterance.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/683","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatizon"},{"cursor":684,"id":684,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","title":"Is John 7:23 the first Gothic use of the verb?","position":"Not established. The translation belongs to a fourth-century tradition, the surviving codex is early sixth century, and no complete lost-text or spoken-language archive exists.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The corpus locates the extant token while manuscript history separates translation and object dates.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/684","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatizon"},{"cursor":685,"id":685,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","title":"Can one exact spoken pronunciation be recovered?","position":"No recorded voice survives. The macron and grammatical spelling support a historical phonological analysis, but they do not license an audio-like exact realization.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Written and grammatical sources provide form and quantity notation without direct acoustic evidence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/685","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatizon"},{"cursor":686,"id":686,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","title":"How does hatizōn relate to Gothic hatjan and hatan?","position":"The reviewed sources distinguish class-II hatizōn, class-I hatjan, and class-III hatan. Hatis clearly supports two denominatives, while the precise historical relationship among all three verb systems remains disputed.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Project Wulfila and Wright separate the lemmas; historical and comparative analyses differ in how tightly the paradigms are grouped.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/686","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatizon"},{"cursor":687,"id":687,"entryId":203,"entrySlug":"hatizon","title":"Does hatizōn securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only through the noun family’s qualified proposal. The Germanic derivation from hatis is firmer than the deeper comparison, whose grief, care, mourning, love, hatred, and anger fields do not form one transparent sequence.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the proposal; Liberman challenges semantic and membership assumptions.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/687","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hatizon"},{"cursor":688,"id":688,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Is hazzōn itself a directly inspected manuscript token?","position":"No. The current dossier verifies dictionary and research-database records plus three source-reported lexical alignments; it does not claim a manuscript object for the normalized infinitive.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The evidence ledger marks all three attestations uninspected and separates them from the citation headword.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The headword remains an attested-language citation form, while direct-object inspection stays at zero.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/688","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":689,"id":689,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Did Old High German preserve only the ōn form?","position":"No. Duden prints haʒʒēn and haʒʒōn, Starling prints hazzēn and hazzōn, and the UT index adds hazēn and hazōn spellings.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Three independent reference systems expose both vowel-class forms.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The route uses a combined historical-variant node rather than erasing the ēn evidence.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/689","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":690,"id":690,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Were hazzēn and hazzōn separate unrelated verbs?","position":"That is not established. Dictionaries group both forms under the history of hassen, while corpus-wide scholarship shows that ēn verbs can acquire ōn double forms. The exact relationship for this lexeme still requires token-level paradigm study.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The grouping is secure at dictionary level, but the accessible journal abstract does not identify hazzōn among its twenty repeated double forms.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/690","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":691,"id":691,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Does the ninth-century label prove the first use of hazzōn?","position":"No. It is the century attached to the form in one comparative database, not a demonstrated search of every earlier manuscript, gloss, and edition.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Starling supplies the label but makes no token-level earliest-use proof on the reviewed record.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The date remains source-reported and the dossier makes no first-known-use claim.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/691","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":692,"id":692,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Could the Old High German verb express following or hostile pursuit?","position":"Yes in the reviewed lexical reports. DWB aligns haʒôn with aemulari and hatamas and hatent with forms of insequi; Duden independently says the older verb also meant pursue.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Two independent dictionaries preserve the action range, with DWB providing located Graff references.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The action evidence is included without assigning pursuit to every historical token.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/692","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":693,"id":693,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Was pursue the securely recovered basic meaning of the root?","position":"No consensus is established. DWB calls hostile pursuit or persecution original inside the German history, while Pokorny’s account explicitly says the Germanic facts do not establish pursue as the root’s basic meaning.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The reviewed scholarship contains a direct branch-level claim and a direct comparative caution.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/693","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":694,"id":694,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Is hazzōn straightforwardly one class-II verb?","position":"The ōn citation form has class-II morphology, but the historical record also preserves ēn forms associated with class III. Corpus-wide scholarship treats such double forms as a real Old High German problem rather than a typographic nuisance.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The form sets and the general double-paradigm phenomenon are documented; exact token distribution for hazzōn remains unverified here.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/694","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":695,"id":695,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Is the Proto-Germanic parent exactly *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan?","position":"The comparative verb family is secure, but its notation and subclass are not singular. Orel prints *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan, while Starling prints *xatōn-, -ēn- beside other related formations.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Two etymological sources agree on the family while preserving different analytical representations.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/695","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":696,"id":696,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Was the weak verb formed directly from *hatiz-?","position":"The weak-verb reconstructions are grouped with the *hatiz- noun family, but the exact formation, chronological direction, and relation among the ēn, ōn, and jan verbs are reconstructed rather than witnessed.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Orel and the wider reviewed Germanic evidence connect the formations without producing a dated derivational event.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/696","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":697,"id":697,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Is Old High German hazzōn the same formation as Gothic hatizōn?","position":"No such identity is established. Gothic hatizōn is explicitly analyzed as a class-II denominative from hatis through the stem hatiz-, while Orel places Old High German hazzōn under the *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan alternatives. Similar normalized endings do not erase distinct immediate analyses.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Independent grammatical and comparative routes converge only deeper in the shared hate family.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The rabbit hole connects the dossiers through their evidence-backed graph path without flattening their immediate parents.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/697","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":698,"id":698,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Is hazzōn the only correct historical spelling?","position":"No. The reviewed references print hazēn, hazōn, hazzēn, hazzōn, haʒʒēn, haʒʒōn, and haʒôn according to their editorial systems and source conventions.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The UT index, Starling, Duden, and DWB visibly use different but overlapping representations.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The entry treats hazzōn as a navigable citation form rather than a unique manuscript spelling.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/698","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":699,"id":699,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Can the exact Old High German pronunciation be recovered from the citation forms?","position":"Not from the reviewed records alone. Quantity marks and consonant spellings encode scholarly analyses, but no audio exists and the dossier does not infer one dialect-neutral phonetic realization.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The references provide written forms and morphological categories, not a directly recorded pronunciation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The pronunciation field remains explicitly not directly recoverable.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/699","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":700,"id":700,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Can the hazzōn record be pinned to one exact place?","position":"No. The sources identify Old High German forms and a corpus-wide Franconian transition-zone finding, but the accessible evidence does not locate this headword’s reviewed records to a single manuscript place.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The journal abstract gives a general dialect-geographic result while the dictionaries do not supply a directly inspected object location for this form.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The journey uses broad linguistic horizons and no invented map coordinates.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/700","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":701,"id":701,"entryId":204,"entrySlug":"hazzon","title":"Does hazzōn securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only as a qualified proposal. Formal correspondence is published, but grief, pain, care, mourning, pursuit, and hatred do not form one transparent semantic sequence.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the comparison and Liberman challenges its wider semantic unity.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/701","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hazzon"},{"cursor":702,"id":702,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Was Old Dutch fīunt a noun?","position":"Yes. ONW classifies it as a masculine noun, calls all twenty-six occurrences appellative, and supplies a nominal inflection table.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The official historical dictionary provides explicit word class, frequency, and case-number data.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier labels the attested form a masculine noun.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/702","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":703,"id":703,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Was fīunt still a productive present participle in Old Dutch?","position":"No on the reviewed evidence. ONW calls it synchronically unsegmented while explaining that it was originally the present participle of the corresponding hate verb.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The same morphology note separates historical formation from synchronic Old Dutch structure.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Attested fīunt is never relabeled as a productive Old Dutch participle.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/703","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":704,"id":704,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Did the corresponding hate verb survive in Dutch?","position":"Not as a known Dutch continuation. ONW says the verb corresponding to Old High German fīēn and Gothic fijan is no longer known in Dutch.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The lexical-loss statement is explicit in the historical dictionary.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The Dutch trail displays the verb only at the reconstructed Germanic level while linking sideways to attested daughter verbs.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/704","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":705,"id":705,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Does frequency twenty-six mean twenty-six surviving manuscripts?","position":"No. It is an occurrence frequency inside the dictionary corpus. The semantic profile currently displays twenty representative location blocks and explicitly warns that locations have been reduced.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ONW separately gives total frequency, source records, and a reduction warning.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface says occurrences, never manuscripts or independently preserved objects.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/705","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":706,"id":706,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Do the 901–1000 labels identify surviving tenth-century manuscript objects?","position":"No. ONW pairs those language-period dates with much later copy labels, including 1595–1605, circa 1598, and 1701–1800.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The source metadata publishes both dating layers.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Every WPs attestation remains directly_inspected=0 and preserves its later-copy label.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/706","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":707,"id":707,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Does the six-cell table preserve the complete Old Dutch paradigm?","position":"No. It attests nominative and genitive singular plus nominative, genitive, dative, and accusative plural. Unrecorded cells must not be invented.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The ONW inflection table contains exactly those six case-number rows and no complete paradigm claim.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The truth claim says six attested cells, not complete declension.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/707","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":708,"id":708,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Does dfiunt or fiunt securely name the Devil?","position":"No. ONW reports that most editions read fiunt, Heyne proposed an error for diufil, both can render Latin diabolus, and the initial D has competing analyses.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionary publishes the textual alternatives in its second sense.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/708","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":709,"id":709,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Was Devil the ordinary meaning of fīunt?","position":"No. ONW defines the main sense as enemy or opponent and says other WPs occurrences translate Latin inimicus; the Devil branch depends on the disputed diabolus gloss.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The semantic profile separates the broad first sense from one disputed second-sense record.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The main gloss remains enemy or opponent.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/709","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":710,"id":710,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Is the Groningen fiundum record straightforward Old Dutch evidence?","position":"No. ONW displays it but explicitly says the Groningen psalm glosses are counted as Old Frisian.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The source itself states the language assignment.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The record is retained as a documented boundary with probable confidence, not counted as uncomplicated Old Dutch proof.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/710","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":711,"id":711,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Do all printed spellings represent separate lexemes?","position":"No. ONW groups fiunt, dfiunt, fiundis, fiundes, fiunda, uiande, uiende, fiundo, fiundun, fiundum, uiandan, and viannden inside one lemma and inflection table, while flagging individual readings.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The complete frequency table organizes the surfaces by case and number under one headword.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"One canonical attested node preserves variants in evidence rows instead of creating false ancestry branches.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/711","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":712,"id":712,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Was fīunt borrowed from German, Gothic, English, Frisian, or Norse?","position":"No borrowing is established. The daughter nouns are collateral inherited descendants of the reconstructed Germanic formation.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"ONW, EWN, Kroonen, and Ayora Estevan publish the cross-Germanic family.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph joins the branches at *fi(j)and- and draws no daughter-to-daughter donor edge.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/712","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":713,"id":713,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Does fīunt securely descend from exactly *peh₁-?","position":"Only as a qualified proposal. The Germanic noun-and-verb relationship is firmer than the displayed Indo-European route, whose notation and semantic framing vary.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Kroonen and EWN publish related but not identical deeper analyses.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/713","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":714,"id":714,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Does the etymology prove that every enemy truly hates?","position":"No. Historical word formation does not determine the psychology of every referent. The corpus includes singular, plural, religious, military, and collective opponents.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The ONW contexts and comparative formation support lexical history, not a universal claim about real enemies.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The leaderboard reveals the fossilized formation while rejecting the etymological fallacy.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/714","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":715,"id":715,"entryId":205,"entrySlug":"fiunt","title":"Were any underlying manuscript objects directly inspected for this dossier?","position":"No. This review inspected the ONW article and its expanded source-reported records, not the Wachtendonck Psalms copies, Leiden Willeram codex, Groningen gloss object, or rhymed-text witnesses.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"All attestation evidence comes from the historical-dictionary surface and carries no object-level facsimile verification.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"All sixteen attestation rows remain directly_inspected=0 and no witness-inspection row is created.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/715","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fiunt"},{"cursor":716,"id":716,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Is hatan the normalized Old Saxon headword?","position":"No. It is the exact manuscript-M infinitive at Heliand 1451. Köbler normalizes the lexeme as hatōn and reports manuscript C haton at the same locus.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionary entry and direct Munich image separate lemma normalization from written surface.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier headword is hatōn; the queue candidate hatan resolves to its own represented variant node.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/716","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":717,"id":717,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Does Köbler’s count four mean four manuscripts?","position":"No. The entry exposes four cited loci: Heliand 1451, Heliand 4915, Heliand 5423, and one GlG gloss. Manuscript variation yields six displayed witness readings across those loci.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The Belegzahl, B field, source sigla, and line numbers are explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface says four loci and six readings, never four manuscripts.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/717","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":718,"id":718,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Is Heliand 4915 unambiguously a productive present participle?","position":"No. Köbler lists hatandiero or hettendero under the verb hatōn as present participial forms and also under hėttiand, a lexicalized agent noun meaning enemy.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The same dictionary and line references preserve both analyses.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/718","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":719,"id":719,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Is Heliand 4915 unambiguously an enemy noun?","position":"No. The separate hėttiand entry establishes the lexicalized noun analysis, while the verb entry retains the same readings as participial evidence. The surviving phrase alone does not erase the overlap.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Lexicographic double-indexing and the directly inspected hatandiero hop phrase define a genuine category boundary.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/719","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":720,"id":720,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Were the Munich hatan and hatandiero readings directly inspected?","position":"Yes. Full-resolution MDZ images of Cgm 25 scans 45 and 142 were visually checked against the line-level transcription and dictionary inventory.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Two structured inspection records preserve the observed forms, contexts, artifacts, and claim limits.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Only those two Munich readings are marked directly inspected.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/720","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":721,"id":721,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Were the Cotton haton, hettendero, and hatoda readings directly inspected?","position":"No. Köbler reports the C readings and Biblissima supplies manuscript identity and dating, but their exact folio pixels were not located and inspected in this review.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The attestation rows remain source-reported and carry no inspection records.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Catalog access is not misrepresented as token-level visual verification.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/721","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":722,"id":722,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Does the Munich manuscript date prove an 875 first use?","position":"No. The manuscript is cataloged to the second half of the ninth century, while the Heliand work is dated circa 830–840. The numeric 875 is only a representative object date for timeline placement.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"MDZ separates work creation from manuscript date.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No first-known-use claim is made.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/722","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":723,"id":723,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Does the Cotton manuscript date equal the Heliand composition date?","position":"No. Biblissima dates the copy to the middle or second half of the tenth century; the Heliand work itself is earlier.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The manuscript catalog and MDZ item description provide two different chronological layers.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Journey and witness records keep text and object clocks separate.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/723","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":724,"id":724,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Does haton aligned with Latin odisse define the entire verb?","position":"No. It is one bilingual gloss locus. The Heliand supplies distinct syntactic contexts, and a translation equivalent does not recover every sense, construction, or historical stage.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Köbler labels the gloss source separately from the Heliand records.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The gloss remains one source-reported witness, not a universal definition.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/724","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":725,"id":725,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Did Old Saxon hatōn mean pursue as well as hate?","position":"Köbler lexicographically gives both hassen and verfolgen, so the action range belongs in the record. The four-locus inventory does not by itself assign both readings to every token or establish their chronology.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The dictionary prints the gloss range without a token-by-token semantic distribution.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/725","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":726,"id":726,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Was pursue the securely recovered basic meaning of the root?","position":"No. A daughter-language gloss range cannot establish one Proto-Germanic or Proto-Indo-European basic meaning, and the broader reviewed comparison explicitly remains semantically opaque.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Comparative sources distinguish branch evidence from root reconstruction.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The contrarian claim centers the category boundary, not an origin slogan.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/726","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":727,"id":727,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Is the Proto-Germanic parent exactly *xatēnan ~ *xatōjanan?","position":"The comparative family is secure, but notation is not singular. Orel prints the alternation while Köbler prints Germanic *hatōn.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Two etymological sources agree on the family but preserve different morphological analyses.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/727","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":728,"id":728,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Was the weak verb formed directly from *hatiz-?","position":"The weak verb and Old Saxon heti belong to the same inherited family, but the exact formation direction and chronology among noun, weak-verb paradigms, and agent noun remain reconstructed.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Orel, Merriam-Webster, and Köbler connect the formations without a dated derivational event.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/728","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":729,"id":729,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Does the hėttiand overlap prove that every enemy is literally a hater?","position":"No. Historical lexicalization explains a word formation, not the psychology of every person denoted by the noun.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The agent-noun analysis is linguistic evidence, not an etymological-fallacy license.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The reveal names the grammatical fossil while rejecting a universal claim about referents.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/729","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":730,"id":730,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Can hatōn be pinned to one exact birthplace?","position":"No. The Heliand’s poetic place of origin is unknown, the Munich manuscript is cataloged with Corvey, the Cotton witness was copied in England, and the gloss object remains unresolved.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The manuscript and edition records preserve distinct production and transmission layers.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Only the Corvey catalog attribution receives an approximate point.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/730","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":731,"id":731,"entryId":206,"entrySlug":"haton","title":"Does hatōn securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only as a qualified proposal. Formal correspondence is published, but grief, pain, care, mourning, pursuit, hostile action, and hatred do not form one transparent semantic sequence.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the comparison and Liberman challenges its wider semantic unity.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/731","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/haton"},{"cursor":732,"id":732,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Is Old Saxon heti itself attested?","position":"Yes. Köbler reports accusative and dative singular heti, and the exact Munich Heliand 1322 token is visible in Cgm 25 folio 20r.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionary inventory, scholarly transcription, and directly inspected primary object converge on the written surface.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier headword is the attested surface heti, not the dotted normalized citation form or a Proto-Germanic reconstruction.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/732","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":733,"id":733,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Is Köbler's hėti* a prehistoric proto-form?","position":"No. It is the starred normalized headword of an Old Saxon dictionary entry whose own B field lists written Old Saxon heti and hetias; the entry separately labels Germanic *hati-, *hatiz as its etymology.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The source keeps its Old Saxon headword layer and Germanic reconstruction layer distinct.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"SET-U does not move a source's trailing headword star backward in time.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/733","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":734,"id":734,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Does the trailing star specifically mean that the nominative singular is unattested?","position":"That is a plausible reading because Köbler lists only accusative, dative, and genitive evidence, but no explicit legend defining this exact trailing star was located in the reviewed source.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The inflectional inventory is explicit; the full typographic convention remains unstated in the located material.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/734","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":735,"id":735,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Does Köbler's count three mean three manuscripts?","position":"No. It denotes three lexical loci: Heliand 1322, Genesis 60, and the Saxon Confession. The Heliand locus alone has M, C, and V readings, producing five reported witness readings overall.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The Belegzahl, source sigla, line numbers, cases, and manuscript letters are explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface says three loci and five readings, never three manuscripts.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/735","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":736,"id":736,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Do manuscripts M, C, and V represent three separate Heliand occurrences?","position":"No. Köbler assigns all three readings to the same Heliand 1322 locus. They are separate witnesses to one textual occurrence, not three line-level uses.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"One verse number is followed by the three manuscript sigla M, C, and V.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Witness count and lexical-locus count remain separate.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/736","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":737,"id":737,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Was the Munich heti token directly inspected?","position":"Yes. The full-resolution MDZ image of Cgm 25 scan 41 was visually checked against the dictionary and LWL transcription.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"A structured inspection record preserves the form, context, locator, artifact, and claim limits.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Only the Munich Heliand reading is marked directly inspected.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/737","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":738,"id":738,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Were the Cotton, Vatican, Genesis, and Saxon Confession objects directly inspected?","position":"No. Their readings are source-reported through Köbler or the Academy dictionary; no exact primary-object pixels were inspected for those four rows.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The attestation ledger carries no inspection record for any of those witnesses.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"A digital dictionary page is not misrepresented as manuscript inspection.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/738","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":739,"id":739,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Does the representative year 875 prove a first use of heti?","position":"No. The Heliand work is earlier than the Munich copy, and other witnesses have distinct or unresolved object dates. The numeric year only positions a second-half ninth-century manuscript.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Work chronology, object chronology, and lexical first use are different claims.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No first-known-use claim is made.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/739","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":740,"id":740,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Does Heliand 1322 use heti only for a private feeling?","position":"No. Köbler gives Latin persecutio for the Heliand use, and the visible clause says righteous people endure powerful men's heti and harmquidi. The noun functions in an external hostility or persecution setting.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionary translation tag, direct image, and line transcription converge on the contextual action field.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier exposes contextual hostility without claiming that every use means persecution.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/740","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":741,"id":741,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Does the Heliand persecution context define every use of the noun?","position":"No. Genesis supplies a different grammatical environment, and the Saxon Confession places hetias among confessed wrongs beside malice, envy, and slander. One line cannot define the whole lexeme.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Three textual loci preserve distinct constructions and discourse settings.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The summary states a range and leaves token-by-token translation limits explicit.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/741","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":742,"id":742,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Does the Saxon Confession really contain genitive singular hetias?","position":"Yes. The Academy dictionary prints hetias as genitive singular at S 318,8 = Wa 16,11 and quotes the full sequence ik iuhu nithas endi auunstes, hetias endi bisprakias.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The lemma record and source key independently expose grammar, locator, context, and tenth-century dating.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The edited record remains source-reported because the underlying manuscript was not inspected.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/742","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":743,"id":743,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Was Old Saxon heti an i-stem noun?","position":"Köbler classifies it as masculine strong i-stem, and Fulk directly calls Old Saxon heti an i-stem in comparison with Gothic hatis.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"A historical dictionary and comparative grammar agree on the Old Saxon branch analysis.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The branch classification is retained even though wider Germanic stem history remains disputed.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/743","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":744,"id":744,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Is there one uncontested inherited stem-class analysis for the wider noun?","position":"No. Fulk compares Old Saxon heti and Old English hete as i-stems and says Gothic hatis transferred to the a-stems; Pfeifer calls the wider noun an old es/os-stem.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The sources agree on the family but frame its prehistoric morphology differently.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/744","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":745,"id":745,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Is *hatiz- the one exact spoken Proto-Germanic parent?","position":"It is the atlas's reviewed cross-source representation, not a recording. Köbler prints *hati-, *hatiz, Koch gives *hataz ~ *hatiz-, and Pfeifer's stem-class description differs.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Comparative notations converge on a family while preserving formal alternatives.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/745","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":746,"id":746,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Was persecution the securely recovered original meaning?","position":"No. The Heliand context supports persecution or endured hostility at one branch locus, but a daughter-language context cannot by itself establish semantic priority in Proto-Germanic or Proto-Indo-European.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Contextual evidence and comparative reconstruction operate at different historical levels.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/746","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":747,"id":747,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Can one exact Old Saxon pronunciation of heti be recovered?","position":"No. The reviewed sources supply spellings, editorial vowel notation, grammar, and comparison, but no recorded voice or fully dated phonetic sequence.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Written forms and normalized symbols are not audio evidence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/747","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":748,"id":748,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Can heti be pinned to one exact birthplace?","position":"No. The Heliand poetic origin is unresolved, its witnesses traveled through distinct manuscript contexts, and the Genesis and confession records are not one production event.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Textual and object layers do not support one coordinate for the lexeme's origin.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Only the Corvey catalog attribution receives an approximate point.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/748","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":749,"id":749,"entryId":207,"entrySlug":"heti","title":"Does heti securely descend from *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"Only as a qualified proposal. Formal correspondence is published, but grief, pain, care, battle, hostility, persecution, and hatred do not form one transparent semantic sequence.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the comparison, Liberman challenges its wider unity, and the UT database labels its reflex pages under active construction.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/749","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/heti"},{"cursor":750,"id":750,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Is Old Saxon hōti supported by attested forms?","position":"Yes. Köbler reports five written inflectional readings at three Heliand loci, and Munich hotie and hotean are directly visible.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Dictionary inventory, scholarly transcription, and two primary-object inspections converge on the lexical record.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier uses normalized hōti while preserving every reported surface form.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/750","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":751,"id":751,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Is Köbler's hōti* a Proto-Germanic reconstruction?","position":"No. It is the starred headword of an Old Saxon entry whose B field lists Heliand forms; the entry separately labels Germanic *hwōtja- as etymology.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The source keeps the Old Saxon entry layer and the older Germanic reconstruction layer distinct.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface does not move the trailing star backward in time.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/751","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":752,"id":752,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Does the trailing star mean that no nominative form is attested?","position":"No simple rule of that kind fits this entry: Köbler explicitly reports nominative plural hotie and huotia plus nominative singular huoti beneath hōti*. The exact convention remains unstated in the located material.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The cases are explicit even though a full typographic legend was not located.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/752","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":753,"id":753,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Does Köbler's count three mean three manuscripts or five occurrences?","position":"Neither. It denotes three Heliand line loci; two loci have M and C readings, while one has C only, producing five witness readings.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Line numbers, cases, and manuscript sigla are explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The interface separates three loci from five readings.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/753","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":754,"id":754,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Are hotie and huotia two separate Heliand uses?","position":"No. They are manuscript M and C readings at the same Heliand 5183 locus. The same distinction applies to hotean and huotian at 5246.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Köbler assigns each pair to one line number with distinct witness sigla.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Witness variation is not inflated into extra lexical occurrences.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/754","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":755,"id":755,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Was Munich hotie directly inspected?","position":"Yes. Cgm 25 scan 150 visibly preserves hotie in the phrase an iuuuomu hugea hotie.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The facsimile, dictionary locator, and LWL transcription align.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Only the observed form and bounded immediate context are marked inspected.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/755","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":756,"id":756,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Was Munich hotean directly inspected?","position":"Yes. Cgm 25 scan 152 visibly preserves hotean in the phrase thurh hotean hugi.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The facsimile, dictionary locator, and LWL transcription align.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The inspection does not select one ancestry hypothesis.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/756","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":757,"id":757,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Were Cotton huotia, huotian, and huoti directly inspected?","position":"No. All three are source-reported through Köbler; the Cotton manuscript is cataloged separately, but no exact page pixels were inspected for these tokens.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"No witness-inspection record is attached to the three Cotton attestations.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"A catalog record is not misrepresented as token inspection.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/757","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":758,"id":758,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Do the manuscript dates prove a first known use?","position":"No. The Heliand work predates both copies, and the surviving witnesses are transmission objects rather than the adjective's origin event.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Work chronology, manuscript chronology, and lexical first use are different claims.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No first-known-use claim is made.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/758","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":759,"id":759,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Is exact surface hōti written in one of the five reported readings?","position":"No. The reported forms are hotie, huotia, hotean, huotian, and huoti. The macronized citation form hōti is an editorial normalization.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The complete B field exposes the distinction.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Search uses the normalized lemma while witness cards show exact surfaces.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/759","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":760,"id":760,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Does every Heliand context simply mean hate?","position":"No. The located contexts concern hostile minds, hostile intent, and a ruler becoming hostile or enraged in mind. Those are compatible with hostility but do not force the modern noun hate into every token.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Two line contexts were checked against the manuscript and transcription; Köbler quotes the third.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Token context and reconstructed family classification remain separate.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/760","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":761,"id":761,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Do ho- and huo- spellings prove one precisely dated sound change?","position":"No. They establish witness variation across M and C. The available spellings, manuscript dates, and editorial macrons do not by themselves recover one exact phonetic sequence.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The paired readings are explicit, but written variation is not audio.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/761","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":762,"id":762,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Does hōti belong to the hate family or the threat-whet-incite family?","position":"The reviewed sources disagree. UT files hōti under k̑ād- with hate reflexes; Köbler reconstructs *hwōtja- beside *hwōtō and the *kʷē̆d- / *kʷō̆d- complex.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Both analyses are published and address the exact Old Saxon form, but neither source resolves the conflict against the other.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/762","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":763,"id":763,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Does Köbler's headword cross-reference to hatōn settle the ancestry?","position":"No. “See hatōn” is a lexical cross-reference; the same entry's E field supplies the distinct *hwōtja- etymology. Cross-reference, semantic neighborhood, and parent edge are separate claim types.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The Hw and E fields coexist on the same entry.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/763","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":764,"id":764,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Is *hwōtja- securely derived from *hwōtō in that direction?","position":"Not from the located evidence. Köbler says compare the noun *hwōtō “threat,” which establishes a proposed relationship but not a fully demonstrated direction of formation.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Only one located source explicitly joins the reconstructed forms.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/764","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":765,"id":765,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Does English whet descend from Old Saxon hōti?","position":"No such direct descent is claimed. UT places whet and other Germanic sharpen or incite reflexes under *kʷē̆d- / *kʷō̆d-; Köbler uses that etymon for hōti, making them proposed deeper relatives if his route is right.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The comparative pages distinguish daughter reflexes from direct word-to-word ancestry.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The rabbit hole follows a shared proposed root, never an Old-Saxon-to-English arrow.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/765","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":766,"id":766,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Is *kʷē̆d- / *kʷō̆d- a securely attested prehistoric word?","position":"No. It is a Pokorny etymon adapted in a comparative database whose pages are explicitly under active construction. Its link to hōti is a published proposal.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The source labels the record as an etymon and describes its own revisability.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/766","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":767,"id":767,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Can one exact Old Saxon pronunciation of hōti be recovered?","position":"No. Spellings, cases, manuscript variation, and editorial vowel length do not supply recorded speech or one completely dated phonetic reconstruction.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"No reviewed source provides audio or a uniquely recoverable pronunciation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/767","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":768,"id":768,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Can hōti be pinned to one exact birthplace?","position":"No. Heliand's place of poetic origin is unresolved, and the Munich and Cotton objects belong to different transmission settings.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Text creation and manuscript production are distinct evidence layers.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Only the Corvey catalog attribution receives an approximate point.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/768","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":769,"id":769,"entryId":208,"entrySlug":"hoti","title":"Does the threat-whet route unveil the word's one true nature as sharpened hostility?","position":"No. That is an evocative modern paraphrase, not an attested ancient definition. The route itself is disputed, and the visible contexts establish hostile disposition or intent without recovering prehistoric consciousness.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The source disagreement and semantic limits block essence-language.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/769","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/hoti"},{"cursor":770,"id":770,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Is κῆδος an attested Ancient Greek noun?","position":"Yes. LSJ supplies a full neuter-noun entry, Doric κᾶδος, and citations from Homer onward; Scaife independently exposes the Iliad 1.445 line.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"A historical lexicon and digital critical text converge on the exact Greek record.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier distinguishes the lexeme from reconstructed ancestors and modern transliterations.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/770","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":771,"id":771,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Does κῆδος have one simple English definition?","position":"No. LSJ separates care or concern, anxiety and grief, troubles, funeral rites and mourning, an object of care, and connection by marriage.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionary's numbered sense structure and citations are explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The headword summary preserves the semantic network instead of choosing one slogan.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/771","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":772,"id":772,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Did κῆδος itself mean Germanic-style hate?","position":"Not in the reviewed Greek lexical record. Its central cited meanings concern care, grief, trouble, mourning, funeral obligation, and affinity.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"LSJ's sense inventory does not make hate the Greek headword gloss.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Germanic hate appears only through a qualified deeper comparison.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/772","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":773,"id":773,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Does the proposed cognacy prove that hate originally meant care?","position":"No. Formal comparison does not recover one original semantic scene, and the reviewed sources explicitly call the semantic relations opaque or disputed.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster qualifies the comparison and Liberman challenges broad semantic unification.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/773","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":774,"id":774,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Could κῆδος mean connection by marriage?","position":"Yes. LSJ cites Herodotus, Aeschylus, Euripides, Sophocles, Philo, and Thucydides for affinity or contracting marriage.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The numbered second sense and multiple citations are explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph treats affinity as an attested sense, not the noun's only meaning.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/774","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":775,"id":775,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Is the marriage sense simply the original meaning of every Homeric token?","position":"No. LSJ says some marriage-based explanations of Iliad 13.464 and related passages are wrong and directs those uses back to anxiety or grief.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The lexicon explicitly marks a historical interpretive error, while the full scholarly debate is not reproduced here.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/775","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":776,"id":776,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Could κῆδος name funeral rites or mourning?","position":"Yes. LSJ supplies a dedicated sub-sense with Homeric, lyric, tragic, historical, oratorical, philosophical, and inscriptional evidence.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The lexical record includes exact citations and excerpts.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Mourning is one attested branch beside care and affinity.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/776","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":777,"id":777,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Does Aeschylus play on more than one κῆδος sense?","position":"Yes according to LSJ: Helen is an object of care in Agamemnon 699 with a play on the marriage-connection sense.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"LSJ states the wordplay directly.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The record remains source-reported because no manuscript object was inspected.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/777","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":778,"id":778,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Are κῆδος and kêdos separate Ancient Greek lexemes?","position":"No. Merriam-Webster uses the Latin-script transliteration kêdos for the same Greek noun that LSJ indexes as κῆδος.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The two sources expose complementary source encodings of one headword.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"A source-cited candidate resolution prevents a duplicate dossier.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/778","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":779,"id":779,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Is Doric κᾶδος a different etymological word?","position":"No separate lexeme is established. LSJ prints it as the Doric form of κῆδος and cites it in Pindar.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dialect label and citation are explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"A graph-only dialect-variant edge preserves the form without inflating the dossier count.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/779","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":780,"id":780,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Is κῆδος derived from κήδω, or is the verb derived from the noun?","position":"LSJ parenthetically links κῆδος with κήδω, whose active and middle-passive senses span distress and care, but the located entry does not fully argue one diachronic direction.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The lexical relationship is clear; exact derivational direction is not.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/780","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":781,"id":781,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Does κῆδος securely continue *ḱh₂d-es-?","position":"It is a published comparison, not an uncontested fact. Multiple sources place the Greek noun in the family, while the semantic and membership cautions require proposed confidence.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Formal comparison is published, but the deeper family remains disputed.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/781","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":782,"id":782,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Does the Ionic-Attic η beside Doric ā prove the whole Indo-European route?","position":"No. The dialectal vowel pattern supports Greek-internal history, but it does not by itself establish the proposed root, suffix, or non-Greek cognates.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"LSJ supplies the dialect forms; comparative sources supply the deeper hypothesis separately.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Sound history and family membership remain separate claim layers.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/782","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":783,"id":783,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Are Celtic cais or cás unquestionably cognate with κῆδος?","position":"No. They occur in a published wider comparison, but semantic breadth and branch membership remain debated.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Koch supports the larger family while Liberman questions semantic skeleton-key arguments.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/783","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":784,"id":784,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Are Germanic hate words unquestionably cognate with κῆδος?","position":"No. The formal comparison is prominent enough to traverse, but the sources explicitly qualify the semantic path and do not recover one shared original sense.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"Merriam-Webster, Koch, UT, and Liberman preserve different levels of confidence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/784","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":785,"id":785,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Can care, grief, mourning, affinity, and hate be ordered as one proven semantic chain?","position":"No. The Greek senses are attested, but their internal chronology and the cross-branch prehistoric sequence are not recoverable as one linear ladder.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The lexical record supplies coexistence and contexts, not a complete innovation chronology.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/785","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":786,"id":786,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Is /kɛ̂ː.dos/ recorded ancient pronunciation?","position":"No. It is a normalized scholarly approximation based on the written form and historical phonology, not audio from an Ancient Greek speaker.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"No reviewed source supplies recorded ancient speech.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The pronunciation field states its evidentiary status.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/786","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":787,"id":787,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Does Iliad 1.445 prove the first use of κῆδος?","position":"No. It proves a line in a modern digital critical text and an ancient textual tradition, not the earliest surviving physical token or the word's invention.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Text composition, edition, manuscript transmission, and lexical origin are distinct evidence layers.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The attestation is a corpus record rather than a directly inspected primary object.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/787","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":788,"id":788,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Can κῆδος be pinned to one exact birthplace?","position":"No. The word spans dialects, genres, authors, and a long manuscript tradition. No reviewed evidence identifies one innovation point.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The sources support a distributed Greek record rather than one location.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No map coordinate is fabricated.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/788","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":789,"id":789,"entryId":209,"entrySlug":"kedos","title":"Is one older ancestor securely known beyond *ḱeh₂d-?","position":"No. The displayed root is already a disputed reconstruction and no still-deeper form clears the review boundary.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The disagreement at the proposed family requires an explicit stopping point.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The route ends at UNKNOWN rather than manufacturing deeper certainty.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/789","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/kedos"},{"cursor":790,"id":790,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Was friend historically an agent noun meaning one who loves?","position":"Yes at the word-formation level. OED, Bosworth–Toller, and American Heritage independently identify a present-participial formation on the love or favor base.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Three dictionary traditions converge on the grammatical analysis.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier states this as historical morphology, not a mandatory modern definition.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/790","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":791,"id":791,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Are friend and free historically related?","position":"Yes. OED places friend on the Germanic base of free, Bosworth–Toller glosses freón as free or love, and American Heritage traces both through Germanic *frī-.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Independent sources explicitly connect the families.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The relation is represented through the shared reconstructed base.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/791","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":792,"id":792,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Does friend literally mean free in modern English?","position":"No. Historical relationship is not synchronic definition. OED gives friend its own extensive noun senses, while the Germanic base links the histories.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The same sources separate headword meaning from ancestry.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph rejects an etymological-fallacy slogan.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/792","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":793,"id":793,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Are friend and fiend the same root with opposite meanings?","position":"No. OED says fiend shows a similar formation, but the two agent nouns are built on different verb bases. Parallel morphology does not establish cognacy.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Both OED etymologies explicitly compare the formations without merging the roots.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"A cited context link and rabbit hole connect them without an ancestry edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/793","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":794,"id":794,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Does Modern English friend descend through Middle English and Old English?","position":"Yes. MED derives frẹ̄nd from Old English frēond, and OED supplies the continuous form history into modern English.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The route is directly documented by historical dictionaries.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Attested stages remain separate nodes with their own dates and forms.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/794","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":795,"id":795,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Was friend always spelled friend?","position":"No. OED and MED inventory friand, freond, frend, frind, vrend, freynd, frynd, and many further forms.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Both form inventories are extensive and explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Variant spellings are evidence, not duplicate word origins.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/795","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":796,"id":796,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Was Old English frēond still transparently a productive participle in every use?","position":"Not demonstrably. Its history is participial, but OED says it inflects as a strong masculine agent noun and the textual record uses it as an ordinary noun.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Historical derivation and synchronic lexical category are different questions.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/796","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":797,"id":797,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Is *frijōnd- an attested Proto-Germanic spelling?","position":"No. It is a normalized reconstruction used to represent the common participial formation behind the daughter-language set.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"OED and American Heritage publish the comparative analysis, not a written Proto-Germanic object.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The asterisk remains structural and visible.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/797","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":798,"id":798,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Can the exact Proto-Germanic pronunciation and inflection be recovered?","position":"Not completely. OED reconstructs vowel contraction and formal variation, but no recording or written Proto-Germanic paradigm survives.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Comparative grammar explains the forms without reproducing a historical audio event.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/798","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":799,"id":799,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Does friend securely descend from exactly *prī-?","position":"It is a published Indo-European comparison, not direct attestation. The Germanic and Old English stages are firmer than the deepest displayed root.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"American Heritage supplies the root cross-reference; no proto-language token survives.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/799","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":800,"id":800,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Did friend always mean only an intimate non-relative companion?","position":"No. OED and MED document ally, supporter, patron, relation, lover, address, and other uses beside close companion.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The numbered senses and historical quotations are explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The summary preserves semantic plurality rather than a single definition.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/800","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":801,"id":801,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Can the exact moment when a loving one became the noun friend be dated?","position":"No. The formation predates the daughter-language records, while lexicalization is inferred from already-established nouns in those languages.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Comparative evidence gives relative chronology, not a coinage event.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/801","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":802,"id":802,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Does the friend-free relationship prove that early friends were legally free group members?","position":"No. The reviewed sources establish a lexical base spanning love, favor, and freeing; they do not recover one legal or sociological institution behind the word.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"No cited source licenses that social-history leap.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier keeps semantic reconstruction separate from institutional speculation.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/802","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":803,"id":803,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Are Dutch vriend and German Freund cognates of English friend?","position":"Yes. OED lists the Old and modern West Germanic forms in the inherited cognate set.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The cross-Germanic inventory is explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"They are relatives, not daughter-to-daughter borrowings.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/803","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":804,"id":804,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Did the Scandinavian cognates preserve exactly the English companion sense?","position":"No. OED says the Scandinavian words center the sense relative, while their ordinary friend sense is expressed by another word family.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"OED explicitly distinguishes the Scandinavian semantic outcome.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Cognacy does not require identical later meanings.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/804","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":805,"id":805,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Does the Beowulf quotation prove the first use of friend?","position":"No. It is one source-reported Old English textual witness, not a birth certificate for the word or its earliest surviving physical token.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"OED supplies the quotation but does not make the dossier's inspected-object claim.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The attestation remains source-reported.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/805","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":806,"id":806,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Does the spelling friend preserve one stable medieval vowel?","position":"No. OED describes Old English ēo and īo, late monophthongization, and Middle English long and short vowel variants.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The form-history note expressly records competing vowel outcomes.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Spelling continuity is not phonetic stasis.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/806","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":807,"id":807,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Can the pronunciation of Old English frēond and Proto-Germanic *frijōnd- be heard exactly?","position":"No. Historical phonology supports normalized approximations, not audio recordings or one recoverable dialect realization.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The sources are written and comparative records.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Only the modern headword receives a current phonemic transcription.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/807","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":808,"id":808,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Are Latin amīcus and Greek philos cognates of friend because all mean friend?","position":"No such cognacy is established here. American Heritage uses them as transparent love-to-friend analogies, not as ancestors of English friend.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The Word History separates analogy from the Germanic ancestry it then explains.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No ancestry edge is drawn to Latin or Greek.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/808","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":809,"id":809,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Do Frigg, Friday, Frederick, and Siegfried descend from the noun friend?","position":"No. American Heritage places them in related Germanic formations under the wider *frī- family; they are collateral relatives, not descendants of English friend.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The source describes the root and peace-noun connections separately.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"They appear as relatives, never children of the English headword.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/809","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":810,"id":810,"entryId":210,"entrySlug":"friend","title":"Is one still older ancestor securely known beyond *prī-?","position":"No. The displayed form is already a proposed reconstruction, and no deeper node clears the reviewed evidence boundary.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The accessible source trail ends at the Indo-European root cross-reference.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The route ends at UNKNOWN.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/810","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/friend"},{"cursor":811,"id":811,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","title":"Was Freund historically a loving-agent noun?","position":"Yes at the word-formation level. Pfeifer and Grimm identify a substantivized present participle of the Germanic love verb; Duden paraphrases the original sense as the loving one.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Three German dictionary treatments converge on the analysis.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier states historical morphology, not a mandatory modern definition.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/811","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freund"},{"cursor":812,"id":812,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","title":"Does Freund derive from modern Freude?","position":"No. The reviewed ancestry runs through vriunt and friunt to the Germanic love or favor verb family. Modern Freude is not inserted as its parent.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Pfeifer, Duden, and Grimm give the historical stages and participial derivation.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Collateral family resemblance is not direct derivation.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/812","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freund"},{"cursor":813,"id":813,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","title":"Are Freund and Feind the same root with opposite meanings?","position":"No. Grimm explicitly contrasts the love verb behind Freund with the different hate verb behind Feind. Parallel agent morphology and antonymy do not establish cognacy.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The DWB discussion distinguishes the lexical bases.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"A context link connects the grammatical mirror without an ancestry edge.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/813","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freund"},{"cursor":814,"id":814,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","title":"Did Freund always mean only a close non-relative companion?","position":"No. Pfeifer and Grimm document neighbor, lover, blood relative, ally, supporter, patron, and address uses.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical sense inventories are explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier preserves semantic plurality.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/814","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freund"},{"cursor":815,"id":815,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","title":"Can Freund historically refer to a woman?","position":"Yes. Grimm records older and contextual uses of the masculine noun for female referents. Grammatical gender and referent sex are not identical.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionary explicitly discusses feminine reference.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Modern stylistic expectations are not projected backward.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/815","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freund"},{"cursor":816,"id":816,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","title":"Is *frijōnd- an attested Proto-Germanic spelling?","position":"No. It is a normalized comparative reconstruction behind the daughter-language cognates.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The sources publish a reconstructed formation and written daughter forms.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The asterisk remains visible.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/816","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freund"},{"cursor":817,"id":817,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","title":"Can the exact Proto-Germanic pronunciation and paradigm be recovered?","position":"Not completely. Comparative forms support the morphology, but no recording or written Proto-Germanic paradigm survives.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The evidence is reconstructive.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/817","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freund"},{"cursor":818,"id":818,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","title":"Can the exact lexicalization date of the loving participle be known?","position":"No. The formation predates the daughter-language records and is already nominal in the earliest High German evidence.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Relative chronology does not supply a coinage year.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/818","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freund"},{"cursor":819,"id":819,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","title":"Does Freund securely descend from exactly *prī-?","position":"The comparison is published on the shared friend-family route but remains proposed and less secure than the Germanic formation.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"No Proto-Indo-European token survives.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/819","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freund"},{"cursor":820,"id":820,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","title":"Was the relative sense inherited or independently strengthened in Germanic branches?","position":"The sources establish the sense across German and Nordic evidence but do not recover one complete prehistoric semantic tree.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Later daughter-language distributions do not uniquely date the kinship branch.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/820","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freund"},{"cursor":821,"id":821,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","title":"Does modern Freund literally mean someone currently loving?","position":"No. The participial source is diachronic morphology; contemporary dictionaries give lexical friend, partner, supporter, and ally senses.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Modern sense inventories are separate from the etymological analysis.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The leaderboard avoids the etymological fallacy.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/821","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freund"},{"cursor":822,"id":822,"entryId":211,"entrySlug":"freund","title":"Is one older ancestor securely known beyond proposed *prī-?","position":"No reviewed earlier node clears the evidence boundary.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The accessible cited trail ends at the proposed comparison.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The route ends at UNKNOWN.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/822","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freund"},{"cursor":823,"id":823,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","title":"Was vriend historically a loving-agent noun?","position":"Yes at the word-formation level. EWN, WNT, and MNW independently analyze the noun as an old present participle of the Germanic love verb.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Three Dutch lexicographic traditions converge.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Historical morphology does not impose a compositional modern definition.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/823","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vriend"},{"cursor":824,"id":824,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","title":"Are vriend and vijand cognates?","position":"No. EWN compares their parallel participial formation, but the reviewed vijand dossier follows a different hate verb base.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The grammatical analogy is explicit and the canonical roots remain separate.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"A context link records the mirror without merging families.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/824","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vriend"},{"cursor":825,"id":825,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","title":"Was vriend always pronounced as its spelling might suggest?","position":"No single unchanged pronunciation is established. WNT discusses reduced vrind and vrund variants, while the current reference gives one-syllable /vrint/.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Historical form inventories and the current pronunciation record are distinct evidence layers.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Spelling continuity is not phonetic stasis.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/825","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vriend"},{"cursor":826,"id":826,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","title":"Is current /vrint/ evidence for Old Dutch pronunciation?","position":"No. It is a present-day pronunciation record only. Historical sound values are reconstructed from written and comparative evidence.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"WikiWoordenboek supplies only the current IPA.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"No current audio is projected backward.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/826","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vriend"},{"cursor":827,"id":827,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","title":"Did vriend always mean only a non-relative companion?","position":"No. WNT and MNW document relation, lover, ally, patron, address, mediator, and supporter senses.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The numbered historical senses are explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The modern core does not erase older branches.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/827","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vriend"},{"cursor":828,"id":828,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","title":"Did ritual blood relationship create the kin sense?","position":"De Vries proposes a ritual social explanation, but the accessible evidence does not establish it as the unique historical path.","confidence":"speculative","sourceSummary":"Etymologiebank reports the hypothesis as an etymological proposal.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/828","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vriend"},{"cursor":829,"id":829,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","title":"Can the relative sense be proved older than the friend sense?","position":"No. The early records and comparative languages show both social fields, but the reviewed sources do not recover a single semantic priority event.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Polysemy and uneven textual survival block a clean sequence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/829","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vriend"},{"cursor":830,"id":830,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","title":"Is modern vriend merely an etymologizing spelling of vrind?","position":"WNT raises the historical spelling issue, but the route preserves both written and spoken evidence rather than reducing the standard word to one editorial intervention.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The historical dictionary discusses reduction and spelling, not one universally dated respelling event.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/830","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vriend"},{"cursor":831,"id":831,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","title":"Can the exact Proto-Germanic pronunciation and paradigm be recovered?","position":"Not completely. The participial reconstruction is well supported, but no recorded Proto-Germanic token or full paradigm survives.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Comparative reconstruction has real but bounded force.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/831","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vriend"},{"cursor":832,"id":832,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","title":"Does vriend securely descend from exactly *prī-?","position":"The shared deep comparison is published but remains proposed and less secure than Old Dutch and Germanic *frijōnd-.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"The proto-root is not directly attested.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/832","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vriend"},{"cursor":833,"id":833,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","title":"Does modern vriend literally mean someone currently loving?","position":"No. Historical morphology and current lexical meaning are different layers.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"ANW gives the current noun category while the historical dictionaries give etymology.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The graph prevents an etymological-fallacy slogan.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/833","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vriend"},{"cursor":834,"id":834,"entryId":212,"entrySlug":"vriend","title":"Is one older ancestor securely known beyond proposed *prī-?","position":"No reviewed earlier node clears the evidence boundary.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The cited route stops after the proposed comparison.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The route ends at UNKNOWN.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/834","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/vriend"},{"cursor":835,"id":835,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Was frændi historically a loving-agent formation?","position":"Yes at the comparative word-formation level. OED places the Old Icelandic form in the inherited participial cognate set, while Cleasby–Vigfússon and Fritzner derive it as a participle of frjá.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Three lexicographic traditions converge on the inherited participial analysis.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The claim concerns historical morphology, not a mandatory contextual meaning in every Old Norse occurrence.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/835","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":836,"id":836,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Did frændi have only one Old Norse meaning?","position":"No. ONP structures friend, foster brother or companion, kinsman or son, parents, and ancestor senses and says the boundary between friend and kin is not sharp.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The 225-citation entry explicitly separates five semantic zones.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier preserves the structured polysemy.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/836","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":837,"id":837,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Was kinship the recorded Scandinavian center?","position":"Yes, but not the exclusive sense. Cleasby–Vigfússon and Zoëga center kinsman, while ONP preserves narrower friend and companion groups beside the much broader relative record.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Independent historical dictionaries agree on the kinship center without erasing ONP’s friend citations.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The leaderboard says semantic center, not only meaning.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/837","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":838,"id":838,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Why did kinship become central in Scandinavian?","position":"Cleasby–Vigfússon and Fritzner propose social explanations involving strong family bonds and mutual obligation, but the textual distribution does not uniquely prove one causal event.","confidence":"speculative","sourceSummary":"The explanations are published historical interpretations rather than recoverable semantic events.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/838","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":839,"id":839,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Does sem frændr en eigi sem fiandr prove the ordinary friend sense?","position":"ONP files the phrase under friend but flags possible kin sense 3; Cleasby–Vigfússon treats it as a possible alliterative exception. The citation does not force one clean answer.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The sources explicitly preserve competing classifications of the same phrase.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/839","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":840,"id":840,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Are frændi and fjándi cognates because they are paired and rhyme?","position":"No. They descend from different Germanic verb families. Their Old Norse pairing is rhetorical and semantic, not genealogical.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The reviewed friend and enemy dossiers keep distinct reconstructed parents.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"A cited context link preserves the genuine formula without drawing a false ancestry edge.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/840","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":841,"id":841,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Are frǽndi and frændi different ancestral words?","position":"No distinction is established here. ONP uses frǽndi as an editorial headword, while Cleasby–Vigfússon and Zoëga print frændi for the same masculine noun.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionaries align the spellings to one lexical entry.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Orthographic and vowel-length notation remain documented in notes rather than split into fake ancestors.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/841","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":842,"id":842,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Can the exact Old Norse pronunciation be heard or uniquely recovered?","position":"No. The displayed IPA is a normalized scholarly approximation; manuscript spelling and comparative phonology cannot reproduce one recorded medieval voice.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The sources are written lexical and manuscript records, not audio.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/842","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":843,"id":843,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Is *frijōnd- an attested Proto-Germanic spelling?","position":"No. It is a normalized reconstruction behind the daughter-language cognates.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The sources publish comparative forms and a reconstructed formation, not a Proto-Germanic document.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The asterisk remains visible.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/843","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":844,"id":844,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Can the exact Proto-Germanic pronunciation and full paradigm be recovered?","position":"Not completely. Comparative evidence supports the nd-participial morphology, but no written paradigm or recording survives.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The parent form is reconstructed from daughter evidence.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/844","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":845,"id":845,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Did friend or kin come first semantically?","position":"The inherited agent formation and daughter-language distributions do not recover one securely dated semantic split. Old Norse evidence preserves overlap rather than a single transition record.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Textual survival and later lexical centers do not uniquely establish semantic priority.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/845","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":846,"id":846,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Does English friend define what Old Norse frændi must mean?","position":"No. Cognates can diverge semantically. OED explicitly contrasts West Germanic friend with Scandinavian relative, and ONP documents the Old Norse distribution directly.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Comparative ancestry and language-specific senses are separate evidence layers.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The shared graph node does not collapse the daughter-language glosses.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/846","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":847,"id":847,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Does frændi securely descend from exactly *prī-?","position":"The comparison is published through the shared friend-family route but remains proposed and less secure than the Germanic participial formation.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"No Proto-Indo-European token survives.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/847","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":848,"id":848,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Is one older ancestor securely known beyond proposed *prī-?","position":"No reviewed earlier node clears the evidence boundary.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The accessible cited trail ends at the proposed comparison.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The route ends at UNKNOWN.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/848","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":849,"id":849,"entryId":213,"entrySlug":"fraendi","title":"Was the ordinary friend sense completely absent in Old Norse?","position":"No. ONP explicitly structures a friend sense and a foster-brother or companion sense, even though historical dictionaries emphasize the dominance of kinsman.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The structured citation record prevents an absolute absence claim.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Semantic specialization is represented as a shift in center, not total erasure.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/849","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/fraendi"},{"cursor":850,"id":850,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Was frēond historically a loving-agent formation?","position":"Yes at the comparative word-formation level. OED identifies a noun use of the Germanic present participle, Bosworth–Toller calls freónde loving the participle of freón, and American Heritage independently gives one who loves.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Three dictionary traditions converge on the inherited participial analysis.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Historical morphology does not dictate one literal interpretation for every written noun token.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/850","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":851,"id":851,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Was every Old English frēond token still a productive participle?","position":"Not demonstrably. OED classifies the word as a strong masculine nd-agent noun, and Bosworth–Toller labels the headword a masculine noun even while preserving its participial history.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"Synchronic lexical category and diachronic formation are distinct.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/851","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":852,"id":852,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Did frēond literally mean one who loves in every context?","position":"No. The formation motivates the inherited noun, but attested uses include companion, ally, relation, religious epithet, and legal arbitrator.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The dictionaries publish a contextual range that cannot be collapsed into one ongoing action.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The loving-agent reveal is presented as word formation, not an exhaustive token gloss.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/852","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":853,"id":853,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Did Old English frēond mean only a close private companion?","position":"No. OED separates close acquaintance, non-enemy or ally, and relation senses already in Old English; Bosworth–Toller adds patronal, religious, and arbitration contexts.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"Independent sense and citation records show social breadth.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The dossier refuses to project one modern friendship norm backward.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/853","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":854,"id":854,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Was the relation or kinsman sense absent from Old English?","position":"No. OED cites the Rushworth Gospels and Laws of Cnut under close relation or kinsman. The sense later becomes regionally restricted in English but is attested in Old English.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The historical sense entry directly documents Old English kinship uses.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Scandinavian semantic specialization does not make the English kin sense imaginary.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/854","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":855,"id":855,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Could frēond mean political ally or non-enemy?","position":"Yes. OED cites the early Old English Orosius translation for Hannibal never becoming a friend of the Romans and separates ally from intimate-companion use.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The located early record directly supports an alliance reading.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Ally remains distinct from etymological ancestry.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/855","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":856,"id":856,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Are frēond and fēond cognates because Old English pairs them?","position":"No. OED calls fiend an antonym with a similar formation, while the reviewed graph traces the nouns to different love and hate bases. Bosworth–Toller’s pair is rhetorical evidence, not genealogy.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The formational parallel and distinct roots are independently documented.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"A context link preserves the historical pair without a false ancestry edge.","citationCount":3,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/856","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":857,"id":857,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Are frēond, frīond, and frīand separate ancestral words?","position":"No separate lexemes are established here. OED treats them as dialectal reflexes: ēo chiefly West Saxon and Mercian, īo chiefly Northumbrian and Kentish, and īa Kentish unrounding.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The form history explicitly explains the vowel geography.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Dialect evidence remains visible without duplicating the headword.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/857","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":858,"id":858,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Are frīend and frȳnd separate friend words?","position":"No. OED explains them as inherited i-mutated inflectional forms, with some analogical re-formation possible elsewhere in the paradigm.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The nd-stem inflection supplies the morphological account.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Inflected forms remain evidence rather than fake lexeme dossiers.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/858","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":859,"id":859,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Did Old English frēond have one regular plural?","position":"No. OED records endingless mutated and unmutated plurals, re-formed frēondas or frīondas, and rare vowel-final analogical forms.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The published paradigm contains inherited and remodeled plural strategies.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Variation is a feature of the evidence, not noise to erase.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/859","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":860,"id":860,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Can the exact pronunciation of frēond be heard or uniquely recovered?","position":"No. The displayed IPA is a normalized scholarly approximation across written dialect evidence, not one recorded Old English voice.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"OED documents competing ēo, īo, īa, and late monophthongal spellings rather than audio.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/860","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":861,"id":861,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Is *frijōnd- an attested Proto-Germanic spelling?","position":"No. It is a normalized reconstruction behind a published cross-Germanic cognate set.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"No Proto-Germanic manuscript preserves the asterisked form.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The reconstruction remains visibly starred.","citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/861","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":862,"id":862,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Does frēond securely descend from exactly *prī-?","position":"The deep comparison is published by American Heritage but remains proposed and less secure than the Germanic participial formation.","confidence":"proposed","sourceSummary":"No Proto-Indo-European token or complete intermediate record survives.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":1,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/862","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":863,"id":863,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Does folio 152r prove the earliest use of frēond?","position":"No. The directly inspected object proves one inflected form in one manuscript witness. It is not a birth certificate for the lexeme or the poem.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"The image, shelfmark, folio, and verse alignment are repeatable; the claim limit is explicit.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"The witness is strong object evidence with deliberately narrow scope.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/863","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":864,"id":864,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Does freondum at Beowulf 1018 identify every person as a modern intimate friend?","position":"No. The local text says Heorot was filled with freondum, but the manuscript alone does not recover each referent’s exact social relationship or a modern intimacy category.","confidence":"probable","sourceSummary":"The pixels establish form and immediate context, while semantic precision depends on edition and historical interpretation.","status":"open","resolutionNote":null,"citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/864","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"},{"cursor":865,"id":865,"entryId":214,"entrySlug":"freond","title":"Did frēond become polysemous only after Old English?","position":"No. Companion, ally or non-enemy, relation, religious friend, and social-legal helper uses are already represented in the Old English citation record.","confidence":"established","sourceSummary":"OED and Bosworth–Toller independently locate the range before Middle English.","status":"resolved","resolutionNote":"Later English expands the word further, but it does not create all semantic breadth from nothing.","citationCount":2,"canonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/dispute/865","dossierCanonicalUrl":"https://set-u.org/word/freond"}]}
